A Geographical Concern

Pre-Release Archive

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

Spoiler:
Stendarr wrote: No [&@%!] Sherlock, did I seriously need to spell it out to you that this was including horse travel? Plus, my wood elf runs faster than any horse right now.
So, dear Watson, where's the problem?
My point was about fast travel and not wanting to do all the distances all the time, by foot or with an horse.
Stupid and time consuming, exactly like Morrowind's travel system. Consistency, man, consistency! You can't praise a feature of Morrowind and then turn around and claim the exact same setup is stupid in a different game.
Did you ignore what I just said on purpose? I said that using my head rather than in game elements is not immersive. Putting money in a crate and then using fast travel from a point to another is not using a travel system. Plus, I'd have to elaborate the whole thing myself, what is immersive, is using EXISTING systems in-game. Morrowind's system stupid? Realist maybe?
Yes?
Yes.
Then tell me how.
Ah, but you admit that the environments are bleak. I'm perfectly willing to concede that preferring good graphics and nice environments is an aesthetic choice; I'm only pointing out that the simple fact that Morrowind is cramped and ugly, Oblivion is not. You're free to interpret that as you will.
Thing is we aren't talking about preferring x or y.
There's not any real imperial city in Oblivion! They're all based on other cultures, the imperial city itself is Aldmeri.
Well, I'm sorry Cyrodiil is multicultural. I'd say it's inevitable given the highly cosmopolitan nature of Tamriel's central province, and I for one like diversity and variety, but if you'd rather have a dozen interchangeable settlements with bland textures and nothing to do in them save look at the same three generic Dunmer faces over and over again, then I guess that's your choice.
I know Cyrodiil was going to be obviously multicultural, but that doesn't excuse the lack of an imperial culture and how most of them are just guards.

Morrowind's cities are not interchangeable. Balmora is quite different than Ald'ruhn, Sadrith Mora, Ebonheart, Vivec, Gnisis, Khuul, Seyda Neen, Vos, Hla Oad, Caldera as they are to each other. Sure some are similar, but that's because they're part of the same culture which is just realism. Plus, Ald'ruhn is still pretty different from Mar Gaan despite the same architecture.

And what does textures have ANYTHING to do with this? Same 3 dunmer faces? What does this have to do with the settlements themselves? I could say that all male dunmer in Oblivion have the same damn voice, how is that relevant? As for bland textures, why would you compare textures from two games released 4 years apart? That's beside the point. Ald'ruhn and Mar Gaan's textures has nothing to do with Oblivion's lack of towns.
Morrowind had tons of unique dungeons, and caverns.
As Oblivion did. So many, in fact, that I STILL haven't explored them all. And just a minute ago you were complaining about the diversity of Oblivion's cities! It's OK for dungeons to be unique, but not towns and cities?
I didn't meant unique by the number of dungeons, but how different they were. There's 8 cities in Oblivion, how many dungeons? 300 maybe? 4 different types? I never complained about Oblivion's diversity of cities, you missed my point. I complained about the LACK of imperial influenced cities and forts. Oblivion's dungeons, how numerous they are, are all the same except for a couple of unique ones. 4 types, Morrowind has 9! Why explore all dungeons if they all look alike?
Morrowind had 62 (!) unique artifacts which a big portion of them were found (via quests or not) in a unique dungeon - often, VERY cool - and the game had a lot of cooler places than in Oblivion.
"Cooler" is a matter of opinion. Frankly, I can't recall any locations in Morrowind that really stood out, save for the oh-so tiny ships, and even those were nothing compared to the ships present in Oblivion. Nor can I recall any artifacts offhand, except for the ones which were ALSO in Oblivion, and the Boots of Blinding Speed... which I only remember because they were rubbish.
That's because you probably missed all the interesting places. There was Egyptian-style trapped tomb with loads of jewels and interesting items, there was a dwemer ruin so unique that I tried for a couple of hours to see if something could be unlocked, there was a dwemer ruin with an observatory, there was a nord tomb with a boat in the middle, there was a dwemer ruin only accessible through a grotto hidden underwater, and dangerous to access because of lava inside the ruin itself. There was a daedric shrine whose door was blocked and you had to access it through a cavern which made you go through really different areas. Molag Bal's shrine was hidden inside a huge cavern filled with lava, it actually looked like a real shrine. There was an underwater daedric shrine. And that's only what I can remember. There were tons of dungeons with unique areas, designs and all. I have Oblivion's guide, and there is a short section about unique dungeons, not nearly as much as Morrowind. Cooler is a matter of opinion, but when everywhere looks like everywhere else, it's not so cool.

As for these artifacts, I can understand why you'd only remember those which were also in Oblivion for obvious reasons... But it's normal when there's so many of them too. Plus, I love getting those artifacts I was hunting in Morrowind, better looking and to see how you can access them. Thing is, Oblivion replaced cool dungeons with finishing a quest for a daedra lord. Morrowind asked you this, but not ONLY this. And UESP's definition of Oblivion artifacts is them being unique items, Morrowind's definition is actual artifacts, related to lore, there was plenty more unimportant unique items.
Pre-determined stuff, yeah, but I'd be surprised you'd remember how each caves and ruins looked like and what you found there by your second playthrough.
Each, nothing. Find one cave with some Orc or Glass armor and hey! Every single game. Oh, look what I found, it's that SAME glass pauldron I found the last fifty times I played.
Go to a different place and you'll find something else. Unlike Oblivion where when you go somewhere else, you find the exact same items. Glass armor in Morrowind was actually quite rare, just wait level 20 in Oblivion and you'll easily have one, boring, looses all its value. Why buy armor in a store when you can just wait to level up and find ebony armor like it's the most common thing out there? Plus, there's plenty of caves in Morrowind, go explore some others. After 200 hours, I would have guessed you kind of forgot about every places you visited, and either not immediately replay, but do the same exact thing.
Oh, and how does ugly landscapes have anything to do with quality? I doubt you found Fallout 3's landscapes beautiful.
I didn't, and it bothered me to no end; in fact, the monotony of the Wasteland is my biggest Fallout petpeeve. New Vegas was slightly better, but it's still not as much fun to simply wander around aimlessly as it was in Oblivion.
Opinion dude, has nothing to do with quality as I said.
That's hardly a contradiction. First moving faster was in relation with how Oblivion seems smaller (logic), but it's also unrealistic. It's not because I want to walk less that I want to walk faster, I still walk the same damn road all the friggin time because the game is constructed around the fast travel feature, so they decide they can make you cross the whole province often.
So, what are you proposing? That they make the roads BIGGER, so it takes more time to walk them?

I really don't follow, you'll have to explain what you're upset about a bit more clearly. It sounds to me like you're either frustrated by all the walking, but don't want to go faster, or you simply find yourself walking down the same paths over and over, which is a problem that was MUCH worse in Morrowind owing to the level design and the fact that you didn't have as much lateral movement. If I want to go from Skingrad to Chorrol, I can pick any direction and blaze a trail. If I wanted to go from Vivec to Balmora, I basically had no choice but to walk through the same miserable valley as I always did. Or awkwardly fast travel via a travel station which we've already agreed is a terrible idea.
I didn't say I don't want to walk faster, that only it made the world feel smaller and that it wasn't really realistic, but we're getting beside the point.

The problem of walking the same paths wasn't worse in Morrowind. If I wanted to go from Vivec to Balmora, I could use the convenient mages guild teleportation. Most of my walking was to go to areas out of the transport grid for quests, and those quests didn't ask me to go to the cave of the Incarnate 50 times, they asked you to go to different places in the wilderness. Oblivion asked me to go to the same cities over, and over again without a real transportation system to get me there. And blazing a trail doesn't fix the fact that there is no real transport system and that I have to get from the same cities. I shouldn't have to blaze a trail because I'm tired of walking the same road to one of the province's big cities, I'd be far more forgiving for going somewhere off civilization.
The fog can be taken out via mods. Textures can be way better via mods (in fact there's a Morroblivion mod out there which makes Morrowind run with Oblivion's engine), even then, there's the MGE mod which still makes a big difference.
Oh, yes, sure, and you can get dozens more villages in Oblivion via mods. You can get wizards guild teleporter pads via mods. You can get guns, jetpacks, a Japanese island, and anything else you can think of. Because they're mods. If Morowind needs mods to bring it on par with vanilla Oblivion- and I agree with you, it does!- then what does that tell us about Morrowind?
It tells Morrowind is an older game. Seriously, why compare technologies? Morrowind is obviously inferior, the game is 4 years older! You shouldn't use Morrowind's age to defend Oblivion. I talked about those mods because it rejuvenates the game, you can't blame a game for being old, so you can't blame me to talk about mods to do this, you shouldn't have brought Morrowind's age in the first place.
Oblivion is bigger, but is more empty,
Not so much. It's more spread out. More immersive. Taken all together, Oblivion has more content than Morrowind, and I'm sure if you sunk it down to Morrowind's size you wouldn't be able to go two feet without stumbling on something fantastic goody. But Bethseda had the right idea, they knew that large areas with lots of variety, where you could go for ten minutes without running into dozens of generic, dusty, elven mud huts, was the way to go. Frankly, if I had my way, they'd make Oblivion four times larger with the same amount of content...[/quote]

More immersive? I mean, it has to be scaled down at some point for the game to be fun. You want real immersion? Put 50 cities, some of them with 50 pubs, 20 inns, put 20 kilometers between them, etc... But then with Oblivion, what have you got? A huge chunk of land, few different kind of geography across the whole province, a few cities and nothing in between but countless of forts and ayleid ruins. I don't see Oblivion's "lots of variety" when most of it is a giant forest with little change. Bruma area is wintery, Chorrol's mountainous, Bravil's swampy, it changes, but not that much, most of it is just a forest. Morrowind has the Bitter Coast, ashlands, grazelands, west gash, ascadian isles, sheogorad and some others less different than these. Morrowind IS more varied terrain and dungeon wise. Do I need to remind you TES III has two times more the types of dungeons than IV has?

And yeah, while in Oblivion you can go for ten minutes without running into dozens of "generic" dusty elven mud huts (what, you expect for the ashlanders to have drastically different huts? This is no fashion contest, it's just realism), but you do fun into dozens of generic ruined forts and ayleid ruins.

More raw content =/= better. While Oblivion may have more raw content, Morrowind has more of EVERYTHING. Do I need to retype all I previously wrote? How many different kinds of everything there is, more quests, more types of dungeons, etc? You can argue Morrowind was small for the content it had, and I wouldn't have minded much for it to be bigger, but it still has more of everything. And I think you ignored all the bits I talked about how Oblivion's villages were pathetically small and how Morrowind had more of those types of things and bigger ones. :lol:

...and that's exactly what's going to happen with Skyrim. Don't forget, Skyrim will not be Morrowind. I hate speculating on motives, but as I've said in other threads (and as seems to be supported by your sometimes contradictory stances on Morrowind's key features), much of this "Morrowind nostalgia" that grips the boards from time to time is due not to any real, sober, objective analysis of Morrowind's merits as a game, but to emotional baggage and a text-book myth of a "Golden Age". Morowind is clearly an inferior package, when viewed objectively, but some people still insist on loving it, and reject anything that isn't their memory of what the game SHOULD be. That won't change with Skyrim, and I expect there to be building discontent from the Morrowind crowd as Skyrim approaches.
I call [&@%!]. Who are you to say we are drenched in "Morrowind nostalgia"? I say you are drenched in "Oblivion nostalgia". I wrote to you why I prefer Morrowind by far, you can't argue Morrowind has more of everything despited its smaller size (which is mostly due to time constraints). Oblivion may have more raw content, but it's all the same damn thing. Morrowind offers a much more complete package from that perspective, Oblivion only offers sheer size rather than variety and types of content.
Skyrim is building on Oblivion, and will be to Oblivion what Oblivion is to Morrowind. Bigger areas, broader biomes, more spread between settlements, and fast travel to compensate! I'm looking forward to this, and I hope, Azura willing, that you'll come to your senses as the day draws nearer! :mrgreen:
You're mistaken. Beth always stated each and every ES game will be a different beast than the predecessor. I obviously didn't expect Morrowind pt. 2 with Oblivion, but was sorely disappointed with how downgraded it was compared to Morrowind (nostalgia my ass), again do I need to pull off the factions numbers and other miscellaneous ones? But if you are expecting Skyrim to be Oblivion part 2, you will be disappointed. Like Todd Howard said in an interview available here, many people will scream. I didn't scream because it was not like Morrowind per se, but because of how wrong some things were and compare them to Morrowind because it's an ES game and these things are superior; ie. more factions, more cities, more dungeon types, more unique dungeons, more artifacts, etc... By your logic, I could've said Morrowind would be to Daggerfall what Arena was to it, but that's obviously not what happened as it got less of everything instead of the contrary. Considering I'm far from being alone in this case on the beth forums, and that they do listen to their fans to some extent, I'm confident they'll get some things better. Todd did say in an interview how some things didn't end up as he wanted in Oblivion, or wasn't the right answer as he put it.

Otherwise I don't think our discussion is so OT, the thread is about a geographical concern which part of our discussion is about.

Ok then, I guess we can take this elsewhere if it doesn't fit. Or just stop it.
Image
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Dean »

I was talking about the swearing and the whole 'Why Morrowind is better then Oblivion' and vice-versa. Feel free to talk about the land but I really hate the TES battles as they lead nowhere and then you get random people chiming in over it all.
User avatar
DorostheConqueror
Champion
Champion
Posts: 833
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 8:20 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by DorostheConqueror »

Spoiler:
My point was about fast travel and not wanting to do all the distances all the time, by foot or with an horse.
Then don't! Use the fast travel.
Did you ignore what I just said on purpose? I said that using my head rather than in game elements is not immersive. Putting money in a crate and then using fast travel from a point to another is not using a travel system. Plus, I'd have to elaborate the whole thing myself, what is immersive, is using EXISTING systems in-game. Morrowind's system stupid? Realist maybe?
It's the same thing, though! There's absolutely no difference between what I suggested and the system in place in Morrowind. And it IS using an existing system in-game; no mods required! I swear, try it out in the vanilla game, and it should work.
Then tell me how.
I already did! The bulk of the post was devoted to showing how the volcanic valleys in Morrowind are utter rubbish and one of the root problems in Morrowind's flawed world design. That was what STARTED the discussion in the first place!
Thing is we aren't talking about preferring x or y.
Yes we are! Well, I'm more interested in facts, but ultimately it all boils down to whether you prefer the cramped confines of Morrowind or the superior environments of Oblivion.
I know Cyrodiil was going to be obviously multicultural, but that doesn't excuse the lack of an imperial culture and how most of them are just guards.
There is too plenty of Imperial cultural influences! The whole PLACE is Imperial. It's like saying New York City isn't American because there are Chinese restaurants and no picket fences anywhere.

I'm guessing that you think the monotone "Imperial" architecture present in Morrowind is THE archetypical Imperial architecture, is this correct? And anything that deviates from that pattern is somehow "inauthentic" or not culturally Imperial?
Oblivion's dungeons, how numerous they are, are all the same except for a couple of unique ones. 4 types, Morrowind has 9! Why explore all dungeons if they all look alike?
4 broad resource sets, you mean. It's true that Oblivion has fewer such sets, but each set is far better developed than the sets present in Morrowind, to the point where there might as well have been well over a dozen sets had they decided to keep dungeons in a simplified Morrowind-like state. Bethesda opted for quality over quanity on this point, and clearly they made a good choice! What's more, you have to remember that there's a big difference between a dungeon "looking the same" and a dungeon utilizing similar resources. NO two dungeons in Oblivion look the same, and any opinion otherwise is demonstrably false.
That's because you probably missed all the interesting places.
No, I saw all those. Unfortunately, they weren't as good as you make them out to be; the Observatory, for example, became my personal Lair, but only after I ran it through the CS for a few hours to tidy it up and make it look less bleak and depressing.
Go to a different place and you'll find something else.
Yes. I'll find the same spear I found last playthrough. Or the same pair of pants. Or the same generic clutter item.
Opinion dude, has nothing to do with quality as I said.
I never said it did! The "fact" is that Fallout's Wastelands are bleak and monotonous. My "opinion" is that this state of affairs sucks. Maybe you like bleak monotony, and if so, that's totally fine!
The problem of walking the same paths wasn't worse in Morrowind. If I wanted to go from Vivec to Balmora, I could use the convenient mages guild teleportation.
Right. So rather than walking, you just fast travel. Where have I heard that before? :)
Morrowind is obviously inferior,
Right, that's my point.
I say you are drenched in "Oblivion nostalgia"
Not at all! Or at not yet, at any rate, although if I fail to hold Oblivion to the same standards of critical analysis that I currently hold Morrowind (which, despite what you may think, IS my nostalgia game for TES), please call me on it! I'm as psyched as anyone for what the future holds, and I'm sure I'll have to defend Skyrim against conservative Oblivion fans if it turns out to be as awesome as I hope.
you can't argue Morrowind has more of everything despited its smaller size
You're right! I can't, and I won't, because it doesn't.
But if you are expecting Skyrim to be Oblivion part 2, you will be disappointed.
I don't expect it to be Oblivion part 2. Like I said, it will be to Oblivion what Oblivion was to Morrowind.
how wrong some things were and compare them to Morrowind
Oh sure, there were some things that weren't as good. The lack of spears, for example, and the enchanitng system wasn't as fun. The point is, though, the list of things Oblvion did worse is small compared to the list of things Oblivion did better than Morrowind... in particular, the much more open world design.
Otherwise I don't think our discussion is so OT, the thread is about a geographical concern which part of our discussion is about.
I agree with this! This is totally OT, or at least mostly OT, if only a bit tl;dr. The main point behind all this is what sort of world design should they follow for Skyrim: small and boxy with awkward travel options, like Morrowind, or open and diverse with streamlined travel options, like Oblivion. That's a very valid and nuanced question, I think, and gets right to the heart of how Skyrim's ingame geography should be approached.

-edit- Sorry, Dean, if you really want us to shut up I will, but I think this discussion can prove fruitful.
Image
(USER GOT 3 KARMA FOR THIS POST)
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Dean »

DorostheConqueror wrote: -edit- Sorry, Dean, if you really want us to shut up I will, but I think this discussion can prove fruitful.
To the both of you: Just be mindful of the swearing and that, and try your best not to get to off-topic that is all I ask. I'm not 100% feeling great today so just do me that favour and it's all gravy.

I shan't interrupt anymore unless it's urgent. :wink:
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Kestral »

They could go the way of New Vegas or Fallout 3. Take a world and jam pack it with locations. Or maybe, which I'm kind of hoping for, is to take Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfall all in one game. It would be as big as Cyrodiil, but the game probably would take it in mainly Skyrim in the way of major conflict within the story.
Listenin'Darthteej
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 45
Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 8:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion,Morrowind,
Platform: PC
Location: The good ol' US of A.

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Listenin'Darthteej »

Okay, yeah, I'm forced to agree that Morrowind had a lot more diversity than Oblivion. It's fine if you don't like the visual style, but Morrowind objectively has more unique dungeon designs and one-of-a-kind textures.

However, it's really based on a bell curve. Oblivion's normal dungeons were more interesting and well designed than Morrowind's(the vast majority of ancestral tombs were literally the exact same design), but there were more uniquely designed dungeons with non-leveled loot or a story to tell, and I loved those. One example that stands out are the caves in the grazelands that have Daedric ruins deep inside.
Image The ultimate knowledge, the ultimate power. Join me in worship of Hermaeus Mora.
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

Then don't! Use the fast travel.
It's because I want to do so according to lore and the game's setting, I don't want to teleport from anywhere to anywhere without any other reason than the game not showing me walk all the way. I find fast travel too easy and convenient, it kills a certain spirit. Vvardenfell felt bigger and also felt harder to get around (which I think is a good thing because of how it's a volcanic island among other things), sometimes you needed to take a guild teleportation service and two boats to get somewhere, it really gave a sense of place and immersion to me. Rather than going from one of the few cities to the other like this, crossing the whole province more than one time. Morrowind rarely asked you to do this anyway, the main quest first asking you to do things around a certain area, then moving somewhere else to again go do some things, and at some point needing to get across the whole island to purse your goal, it was more realistic. Why would the Grey Fox ask you to get around the whole province to give his quests and then asking you to get across again for another quest...
It's the same thing, though! There's absolutely no difference between what I suggested and the system in place in Morrowind. And it IS using an existing system in-game; no mods required! I swear, try it out in the vanilla game, and it should work.
Yes there is a difference, because I wouldn't be using an existing travel service, no carriage, no mages guild teleportation. Why would I put money in some random box to use a travel system which makes me walk to another point in an instant? It's not immersive. Again, I'd have to elaborate my travel web, which I shouldn't. Each services were already connected to somewhere else in Morrowind, that's because the travel system existed, it doesn't in Oblivion, I'd have to create it and pretend some things work some way, not immersive.
I already did! The bulk of the post was devoted to showing how the volcanic valleys in Morrowind are utter rubbish and one of the root problems in Morrowind's flawed world design. That was what STARTED the discussion in the first place!
No, because I already answered this. I told you it was in regard with Morrowind's lore and written geography before the game was even designed. This has nothing to do with bad level design, you may not like it, fine, but Foyadas are an important part of Morrowind's unique geography. You probably won't see across Skyrim like that and the view will be obstructed by mountains.
Yes we are! Well, I'm more interested in facts, but ultimately it all boils down to whether you prefer the cramped confines of Morrowind or the superior environments of Oblivion.
Oblivion's environments being superior IS an opinion. It's like saying Canada's wilderness is superior to the states' That's not the subject here. The subject is HOW they use the environment.
There is too plenty of Imperial cultural influences! The whole PLACE is Imperial. It's like saying New York City isn't American because there are Chinese restaurants and no picket fences anywhere. I'm guessing that you think the monotone "Imperial" architecture present in Morrowind is THE archetypical Imperial architecture, is this correct? And anything that deviates from that pattern is somehow "inauthentic" or not culturally Imperial?
More or less. I mean Bruma is Nord Influenced, Cheydinhal is Dunmer influenced, Anvil is Redguard influenced and the Imperial City is Aldmeri. Bravil is mainly shacks. I mean, otherwise the others are all different, and it's hard to tell if it's culturally Imperial, particularly considering they don't have Imperial counts. Plus, Anvil HAS archetypical Redguard architecture, why wouldn't Cyrodiil have some archetypical imperial architecture found in Morrowind?Those forts are, believe it or not, supposed to be representative of Imperial culture, they were imperial settlements. Reminds me, except for lone farmhouses, have you seen any town with Pelagiad's style? It IS supposed to be an Imperial settlement, yet what Oblivion tells us, is that the Imperial people have lost a lot of their culture. I'm not telling you everything should have been like this, but the imperial's culture should have been more present. Like it or not, Pelagiad and the imperial forts of Morrowind were supposed to be representative of the Imperial culture, yet it seems with Oblivion they decided not. Wouldn't you find it weird for Skyrim to have no cities looking like Bruma, when it is stated that it is highly influenced by Nord architecture?
4 broad resource sets, you mean. It's true that Oblivion has fewer such sets, but each set is far better developed than the sets present in Morrowind, to the point where there might as well have been well over a dozen sets had they decided to keep dungeons in a simplified Morrowind-like state. Bethesda opted for quality over quanity on this point, and clearly they made a good choice! What's more, you have to remember that there's a big difference between a dungeon "looking the same" and a dungeon utilizing similar resources. NO two dungeons in Oblivion look the same, and any opinion otherwise is demonstrably false.
We must not be playing the same games. The 4 resource sets didn't feel broad at all to me. You must have missed a lot of Morrowind dungeons if you think they are all simple and look-alike, I already presented you few examples of the more elaborate ones. And I'm really not the only one to think all of Oblivion's dungeons of the same set look alike. They were not identical, but constructed the same way, a lot of Morrowind's dungeons tried something unique with completely different places. Oblivion had some like this too, but more limited.

But why can't we desire to have more dungeon types? Like I said, more variety the better it is. Not just when exploring inside, but outside. If the environment is dotted with countless of identically looking forts and ruins, it's weird. Morrowind had wrecked boats along the shores, dwemer ruins and daedric shrines scattered across, mines and caves along mountains, etc. And you can't totally put Oblivion's and Morrowind's dungeons on the same level, Oblivion has the technological advantage. Give Morrowind the same technology, and I'm sure the dungeons would be more elaborate with switches, traps and all the fancy Oblivion stuff. All this to say, I want Skyrim to feel as immersive and unique as possible. I can't believe the only ruins in Cyrodiil were forts and ayleid ruins, no daedric shrine was ever constructed in a remote wilderness region? No gang of bandits ever built sanctuaries anywhere rather than always seeking refuge in forts? No ships ever wrecked along the coast of Anvil? If we want Skyrim to feel as believable, deep and varied as possible, more dungeon types should be something we look forward too. It'd make exploration so much more interesting.
No, I saw all those. Unfortunately, they weren't as good as you make them out to be; the Observatory, for example, became my personal Lair, but only after I ran it through the CS for a few hours to tidy it up and make it look less bleak and depressing.
What can I tell you, I like bleak and depressing. Weren't ruined forts bleak and depressing too?
Yes. I'll find the same spear I found last playthrough. Or the same pair of pants. Or the same generic clutter item.
How is that any different as in Oblivion? You always find the same loot. The lack of artifacts only make it worse.
I never said it did! The "fact" is that Fallout's Wastelands are bleak and monotonous. My "opinion" is that this state of affairs sucks. Maybe you like bleak monotony, and if so, that's totally fine!
You never said it, but that's not what we're talking about. Plus, I may be referring to Morrowind, but that doesn't mean everything has to be referred to it as the environment. Environment can be related to level design, but is not particularly important. If you don't like the environment it's fine, but that doesn't meant that how it's been used is bad (scattering different types of dungeons, cities...)
Not at all! Or at not yet, at any rate, although if I fail to hold Oblivion to the same standards of critical analysis that I currently hold Morrowind (which, despite what you may think, IS my nostalgia game for TES), please call me on it! I'm as psyched as anyone for what the future holds, and I'm sure I'll have to defend Skyrim against conservative Oblivion fans if it turns out to be as awesome as I hope.
I hope you don't think I'm particularly conservative to Morrowind. Most of my problems have to do with quantity and variety of several elements(quantitative), not a qualitative appraisal, like how I love Morrowind's alien look and how Cyrodiil should have been like this, as someone who would love Skyrim to be vibrant and colourful as Oblivion. My other problems have to do with HOW several systems work, which I'm pretty sure is something Bethesda are trying to look at for a better implementation, rather than doing it differently on the basis each TES game should be different.
you can't argue Morrowind has more of everything despited its smaller size
You're right! I can't, and I won't, because it doesn't.
Something I'm wondering if you're doing it on purpose... I'm not speaking of sheer size. Again, I pulled off plenty of stats to defend this. And I'm saying Skyrim should have a much better use of it's environment. We shouldn't loose ourselves in kilometers of wilderness with nothing but ruins of the same look which none contain anything worth the exploration of these, with no quest even asking us to get there. To make a world feel alive and worth exploring, you need to offer an incentive to explore, variety and something to do within a certain radius. Oblivion lacked this in some big chunks of land.
I don't expect it to be Oblivion part 2. Like I said, it will be to Oblivion what Oblivion was to Morrowind.
Yes, but as I said afterwards, you shouldn't expect this either. Morrowind wasn't to Daggerfall what Daggerfall was to Arena. Daggerfall expanded on Arena on every aspect, and Morrowind downgraded on every Daggerfall aspect, same with Oblivion. Nothing tells us which direction Bethesda took, because they said numerous times that each game are supposed to be quite different. Bethesda themselves said certain "answers" they had for Oblivion didn't turned out as they hoped. Considering Fallout New Vegas' hardcore more, they may implement it. Considering the big turmoil in the beth forums fast travel made, they may make a compromise or change it a bit. Considering how many people felt the "gps" hold too much your hand, they might make some modifications. There's no template or trend they try to follow, they just make a new game, look how they can make some systems better and how they can make the game unique. It might end up true, but that's nothing I'd wage on, not at all considering how Bethesda works. Fallout 3 wasn't to Oblivion what Oblivion was to Morrowind at all, in fact, if you Morrowind and Oblivion in line, Fallout 3 isn't after Oblivion, it would be between MW and OB.
Oh sure, there were some things that weren't as good. The lack of spears, for example, and the enchanitng system wasn't as fun. The point is, though, the list of things Oblvion did worse is small compared to the list of things Oblivion did better than Morrowind... in particular, the much more open world design.
I wouldn't argue about the open world design (though keep in mind Morrowind was entirely hand pieced together compared to Oblivion which had generated flora for example) as they're not of the same nature. But I could write again, with numbers, how Oblivion dumbed down a lot of things, but that's out of topic.


Otherwise, I really hope Skyrim is a lot more varied geographically and that we have a more realistic number of cities/towns/settlements and that the wilderness space is used in a better fashion. I mean, why does Cyrodiil has 9 cities and almost 10 times more forts and ayleid ruins counted separately? It does not feel logical, it's as if Cyrodiil's population sinked over time. I hope Skyrim won't give us a feel of a land that is much, much less of what it once was.
Image
Incarnal
Novice
Novice
Posts: 81
Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 1:51 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Arena
Platform: PS3, PC, Xbox 360, Xbox

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Incarnal »

I'm definitely hoping for a similar sized world with more life in it, and a more limited fast travel system. Perhaps there could be Imperial outposts scattered throughout Skyrim that you can fast travel between, but you can't fastravel to random caves.
User avatar
legoless
Global Wiki Admin
Global Wiki Admin
Posts: 2553
Joined: Sun Sep 13, 2009 2:02 pm
ES Games: All
Platform: PC, Switch
UESPoints: 420
Location: Ireland
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by legoless »

I loved the feel of Solstheim. The coniferous forests, giant glacier, desolate snowy wastes, secret snow caves and Nords settlements were a nice break from the constant otherworldliness of Vvardenfell. If Skyrim is anything like that, I'll be satisfied.
Wiki admin. Contact me on my talk page or via PM.
User avatar
heratik
Novice
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:39 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Alive

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by heratik »

Stendarr wrote: 9 major cities and that's all?
On the map I can only see 8 cities marked up for Skyrim! :shock:

Hopefully they will either be much bigger and more detailed than Oblivions, or there will be a wealth of other locations where you can trade/find side missions etc etc
edgukator
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 329
Joined: Thu May 06, 2010 10:04 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC, Xbox

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by edgukator »

OK, keeping to the actual topic of the thread...

Has anyone considered the possibility that they could make it bigger in the same way GTA made IV bigger... adding depth. In this case, because it's based in Skyrim, I wonder how much Scandanavian lore comes into play.

Imagine an "underworld", which has as much territory below ground as above... Like the Mines of Moria lying under the mountains of Hrothgar...
User avatar
SwedishBerzerker
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 5:12 pm
ES Games: In order: Arena (PC, completed, Dec 2008), Oblivion GOTY (X360, 100% completed except investments, Feb-July 2009), Daggerfall (PC, completed, Dec 2009), Morrowind GOTY (X360, 100%, mar-jun 2010) and soon enough - SKYRIM!
Platform: Xbox 360, DosBox
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by SwedishBerzerker »

edgukator wrote:Imagine an "underworld", which has as much territory below ground as above... Like the Mines of Moria lying under the mountains of Hrothgar...
That's something I missed in Oblivion and Morrowind - the huge dungeons. Daggerfall was a bit too much (where every random dungeon took two hours effective time to explore), but there should be a couple of really huge ones, quest-related of course.
SwedishBerzerker at youtube.com

http://www.youtube.com/user/SwedishBerzerker
User avatar
Owl in a Fridge
Layman
Layman
Posts: 3
Joined: Mon Dec 27, 2010 3:46 pm
ES Games: Morrowind and Oblivion
Platform: PC and Xbox 360.
Status: Scandinavia is totally based on Skyrim. Duh.
Location: Norway

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Owl in a Fridge »

Incarnal wrote:I'm definitely hoping for a similar sized world with more life in it, and a more limited fast travel system. Perhaps there could be Imperial outposts scattered throughout Skyrim that you can fast travel between, but you can't fastravel to random caves.
That would be great! Perhaps a travel system that allows you to fast travel along the major roads, but you would have to go out and explore the wilderness to reach caves and such. Imperial/Nord outposts would be a good way to do this. But this is a bit off-topic.

Anyway, on-topic i highly doubt that after the big in-game worlds of Oblivion and Morrowind, they would go on and make a small, map that is proportionate to the world. I think that Bethesda would definately make the in-game world of Skyrim bigger than the earlier games, ignoring the fact that Skyrim is a smaller part of the world than Cyrodiil. Also, I hope it would be packed with inns and villages but also allow areas that are inhabited and desolate, like some tundra.
"A Bro never admits being unable to drive stick, even after an accident"
User avatar
Sir Tavic
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2010 3:15 am
ES Games: Morrowind GotY, Oblivion GotY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Skyrim non est ludus. Est via vitae.
Location: DC, USA

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Sir Tavic »

Kestral wrote:They could go the way of New Vegas or Fallout 3. Take a world and jam pack it with locations. Or maybe, which I'm kind of hoping for, is to take Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfall all in one game. It would be as big as Cyrodiil, but the game probably would take it in mainly Skyrim in the way of major conflict within the story.
I was thinking of the multi-province thing, too. However, instead of including all of High Rock and Hammerfell, it would be cool if Skyrim was raiding the border towns of Hammerfall, High Rock, Morrowind, and maybe even Cyrodiil, though I doubt it. That way you'd have access to a few new cities, like Blacklight in mainland Morrowind, Elinhir in Hammerfell, and Jehanna in High Rock, but under a different context with (the threat of) military invasion. This would get you different cultures and more cities, which would be a welcome addition for me.
Spoiler:
STOP! YOU'VE VIOLATED THE LAW.
The Ranger Mottle Green of The UESP Colored Post Movement
User avatar
SwedishBerzerker
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 5:12 pm
ES Games: In order: Arena (PC, completed, Dec 2008), Oblivion GOTY (X360, 100% completed except investments, Feb-July 2009), Daggerfall (PC, completed, Dec 2009), Morrowind GOTY (X360, 100%, mar-jun 2010) and soon enough - SKYRIM!
Platform: Xbox 360, DosBox
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by SwedishBerzerker »

Sir Tavic wrote:
Kestral wrote:They could go the way of New Vegas or Fallout 3. Take a world and jam pack it with locations. Or maybe, which I'm kind of hoping for, is to take Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfall all in one game. It would be as big as Cyrodiil, but the game probably would take it in mainly Skyrim in the way of major conflict within the story.
I was thinking of the multi-province thing, too. However, instead of including all of High Rock and Hammerfell, it would be cool if Skyrim was raiding the border towns of Hammerfall, High Rock, Morrowind, and maybe even Cyrodiil, though I doubt it. That way you'd have access to a few new cities, like Blacklight in mainland Morrowind, Elinhir in Hammerfell, and Jehanna in High Rock, but under a different context with (the threat of) military invasion. This would get you different cultures and more cities, which would be a welcome addition for me.
I can imagine there'll be lots of cultures in the cities along the coast, at least Winter Hold. Maybe suburbs belonging to different cultures like Argonia town etc. :P
SwedishBerzerker at youtube.com

http://www.youtube.com/user/SwedishBerzerker
bran
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 29
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2010 5:52 pm
ES Games: arena,daggerfall, morrowind goty, oblivion,skyrim
Platform: xbox, xbox 360

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by bran »

SwedishBerzerker wrote:
Sir Tavic wrote:
Kestral wrote:They could go the way of New Vegas or Fallout 3. Take a world and jam pack it with locations. Or maybe, which I'm kind of hoping for, is to take Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfall all in one game. It would be as big as Cyrodiil, but the game probably would take it in mainly Skyrim in the way of major conflict within the story.
I was thinking of the multi-province thing, too. However, instead of including all of High Rock and Hammerfell, it would be cool if Skyrim was raiding the border towns of Hammerfall, High Rock, Morrowind, and maybe even Cyrodiil, though I doubt it. That way you'd have access to a few new cities, like Blacklight in mainland Morrowind, Elinhir in Hammerfell, and Jehanna in High Rock, but under a different context with (the threat of) military invasion. This would get you different cultures and more cities, which would be a welcome addition for me.
I can imagine there'll be lots of cultures in the cities along the coast, at least Winter Hold. Maybe suburbs belonging to different cultures like Argonia town etc. :P

that would be cool 8)
User avatar
Sir Tavic
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2010 3:15 am
ES Games: Morrowind GotY, Oblivion GotY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Skyrim non est ludus. Est via vitae.
Location: DC, USA

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Sir Tavic »

SwedishBerzerker wrote:
Sir Tavic wrote:
Kestral wrote:They could go the way of New Vegas or Fallout 3. Take a world and jam pack it with locations. Or maybe, which I'm kind of hoping for, is to take Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfall all in one game. It would be as big as Cyrodiil, but the game probably would take it in mainly Skyrim in the way of major conflict within the story.
I was thinking of the multi-province thing, too. However, instead of including all of High Rock and Hammerfell, it would be cool if Skyrim was raiding the border towns of Hammerfall, High Rock, Morrowind, and maybe even Cyrodiil, though I doubt it. That way you'd have access to a few new cities, like Blacklight in mainland Morrowind, Elinhir in Hammerfell, and Jehanna in High Rock, but under a different context with (the threat of) military invasion. This would get you different cultures and more cities, which would be a welcome addition for me.
I can imagine there'll be lots of cultures in the cities along the coast, at least Winter Hold. Maybe suburbs belonging to different cultures like Argonia town etc. :P
I can't imagine there will be too many Argonians in Skyrim... :P Along the coast is the coldest part of Skryim! I think there will be more 'culturally diverse' towns in the south east and west, although everywhere will be cold. Anyways, I was more thinking along the line of architecturally diverse, like the difference between Skingrad's houses and Cheydinhall's buildings. Still, I agree that Skyrim itself will have enough racial diversity.
Spoiler:
STOP! YOU'VE VIOLATED THE LAW.
The Ranger Mottle Green of The UESP Colored Post Movement
User avatar
lostlast
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 220
Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 7:01 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC and PS3
Location: Southie, Australia.

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by lostlast »

This game is so going underground. With all the mountains that cover Skyrim and the fact that it was the first province settled. There has to be some form of cities or ruins buried into the mountains. If and it's a BIG if, Bethesda makes the majority of the province snowy mountains it makes sense that they would escape the cold by building underground cities into them. It still leaves for a bleak game compared to Oblivion. Could walk the country side in that game endlessly. Underground gets depressing fast, makes me want to kill, kill and kill again. *sighs* I'd hate to be sitting in the forest wondering how I'm going to explain myself to the law as to why I slaughtered an entire town after coming out of a dreary, seemingly endless underground chore of a quest, when "My eyes were adjusting to the light" just won't cut it.
User avatar
SwedishBerzerker
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 5:12 pm
ES Games: In order: Arena (PC, completed, Dec 2008), Oblivion GOTY (X360, 100% completed except investments, Feb-July 2009), Daggerfall (PC, completed, Dec 2009), Morrowind GOTY (X360, 100%, mar-jun 2010) and soon enough - SKYRIM!
Platform: Xbox 360, DosBox
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by SwedishBerzerker »

Sir Tavic wrote:I can't imagine there will be too many Argonians in Skyrim... :P Along the coast is the coldest part of Skryim! I think there will be more 'culturally diverse' towns in the south east and west, although everywhere will be cold. Anyways, I was more thinking along the line of architecturally diverse, like the difference between Skingrad's houses and Cheydinhall's buildings. Still, I agree that Skyrim itself will have enough racial diversity.
I was thinking more about trading routes and since Winter Hold's the capital (it seems).

"A wealthy and influential county in Skyrim. It is heavily affected by Dunmer ways and ideas, being close to the border. It contains the Ysmir Collective, and the well known College of Winterhold. It is located in Northeastern Skyrim."
http://uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Winterhold

It seems there'll also be a lot of Dunmer culture, and perhaps slavery...
SwedishBerzerker at youtube.com

http://www.youtube.com/user/SwedishBerzerker
User avatar
Sir Tavic
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2010 3:15 am
ES Games: Morrowind GotY, Oblivion GotY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Skyrim non est ludus. Est via vitae.
Location: DC, USA

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Sir Tavic »

SwedishBerzerker wrote:
Sir Tavic wrote:I can't imagine there will be too many Argonians in Skyrim... :P Along the coast is the coldest part of Skryim! I think there will be more 'culturally diverse' towns in the south east and west, although everywhere will be cold. Anyways, I was more thinking along the line of architecturally diverse, like the difference between Skingrad's houses and Cheydinhall's buildings. Still, I agree that Skyrim itself will have enough racial diversity.
I was thinking more about trading routes and since Winter Hold's the capital (it seems).

"A wealthy and influential county in Skyrim. It is heavily affected by Dunmer ways and ideas, being close to the border. It contains the Ysmir Collective, and the well known College of Winterhold. It is located in Northeastern Skyrim."
http://uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Winterhold

It seems there'll also be a lot of Dunmer culture, and perhaps slavery...
Coolio... I'm just hoping for as many fun cities as possible. It seems a major worry for people is that Skyrim will be bleak and snowy everywhere, with not as much unique country side as Cyrodiil and Morrowind. I just don't want 8 Brumas with slight variations. I figured that getting a taste of Hammerfell, High Rock, and Morrowind would prevent that. If Winterhold is effected by Morrowind then I'll be happy! My consoling thought is that Bethesda picked Skyrim because they thought they could make a game based in Skyrim that would sell the best, and I know that they know we want diversity and uniqueness.
Spoiler:
STOP! YOU'VE VIOLATED THE LAW.
The Ranger Mottle Green of The UESP Colored Post Movement
User avatar
mptrj
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 379
Joined: Tue Sep 22, 2009 2:26 am
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY Deluxe, Morrowind GOTY
Platform: PC, PS3
Location: New Yawk
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by mptrj »

I hope that Bethesda decides to go the Morrowind route of making everything different-looking except for the Imperial buildings, as opposed to the Oblivion route of making everything an Imperial building, even those on the borders of other provinces.
Image
The Not a Member of Any Forum Groups.
User avatar
SwedishBerzerker
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 5:12 pm
ES Games: In order: Arena (PC, completed, Dec 2008), Oblivion GOTY (X360, 100% completed except investments, Feb-July 2009), Daggerfall (PC, completed, Dec 2009), Morrowind GOTY (X360, 100%, mar-jun 2010) and soon enough - SKYRIM!
Platform: Xbox 360, DosBox
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by SwedishBerzerker »

Sir Tavic wrote:
SwedishBerzerker wrote:
Sir Tavic wrote:I can't imagine there will be too many Argonians in Skyrim... :P Along the coast is the coldest part of Skryim! I think there will be more 'culturally diverse' towns in the south east and west, although everywhere will be cold. Anyways, I was more thinking along the line of architecturally diverse, like the difference between Skingrad's houses and Cheydinhall's buildings. Still, I agree that Skyrim itself will have enough racial diversity.
I was thinking more about trading routes and since Winter Hold's the capital (it seems).

"A wealthy and influential county in Skyrim. It is heavily affected by Dunmer ways and ideas, being close to the border. It contains the Ysmir Collective, and the well known College of Winterhold. It is located in Northeastern Skyrim."
http://uesp.net/wiki/Lore:Winterhold

It seems there'll also be a lot of Dunmer culture, and perhaps slavery...
Coolio... I'm just hoping for as many fun cities as possible. It seems a major worry for people is that Skyrim will be bleak and snowy everywhere, with not as much unique country side as Cyrodiil and Morrowind. I just don't want 8 Brumas with slight variations. I figured that getting a taste of Hammerfell, High Rock, and Morrowind would prevent that. If Winterhold is effected by Morrowind then I'll be happy! My consoling thought is that Bethesda picked Skyrim because they thought they could make a game based in Skyrim that would sell the best, and I know that they know we want diversity and uniqueness.
Nah, like I said before, I think even Skyrim has different conditions in different parts. I think we'll see everything from glaciers, mountains and tundras to snowy pineforests, melting creeks and dry pineforests. :D
SwedishBerzerker at youtube.com

http://www.youtube.com/user/SwedishBerzerker
Post Reply