Then don't! Use the fast travel.
It's because I want to do so according to lore and the game's setting, I don't want to teleport from anywhere to anywhere without any other reason than the game not showing me walk all the way. I find fast travel too easy and convenient, it kills a certain spirit. Vvardenfell felt bigger and also felt harder to get around (which I think is a good thing because of how it's a volcanic island among other things), sometimes you needed to take a guild teleportation service and two boats to get somewhere, it really gave a sense of place and immersion to me. Rather than going from one of the few cities to the other like this, crossing the whole province more than one time. Morrowind rarely asked you to do this anyway, the main quest first asking you to do things around a certain area, then moving somewhere else to again go do some things, and at some point needing to get across the whole island to purse your goal, it was more realistic. Why would the Grey Fox ask you to get around the whole province to give his quests and then asking you to get across again for another quest...
It's the same thing, though! There's absolutely no difference between what I suggested and the system in place in Morrowind. And it IS using an existing system in-game; no mods required! I swear, try it out in the vanilla game, and it should work.
Yes there is a difference, because I wouldn't be using an existing travel service, no carriage, no mages guild teleportation. Why would I put money in some random box to use a travel system which makes me walk to another point in an instant? It's not immersive. Again, I'd have to elaborate my travel web, which I shouldn't. Each services were already connected to somewhere else in Morrowind, that's because the travel system existed, it doesn't in Oblivion, I'd have to create it and pretend some things work some way, not immersive.
I already did! The bulk of the post was devoted to showing how the volcanic valleys in Morrowind are utter rubbish and one of the root problems in Morrowind's flawed world design. That was what STARTED the discussion in the first place!
No, because I already answered this. I told you it was in regard with Morrowind's lore and written geography before the game was even designed. This has nothing to do with bad level design, you may not like it, fine, but Foyadas are an important part of Morrowind's unique geography. You probably won't see across Skyrim like that and the view will be obstructed by mountains.
Yes we are! Well, I'm more interested in facts, but ultimately it all boils down to whether you prefer the cramped confines of Morrowind or the superior environments of Oblivion.
Oblivion's environments being superior IS an opinion. It's like saying Canada's wilderness is superior to the states' That's not the subject here. The subject is HOW they use the environment.
There is too plenty of Imperial cultural influences! The whole PLACE is Imperial. It's like saying New York City isn't American because there are Chinese restaurants and no picket fences anywhere. I'm guessing that you think the monotone "Imperial" architecture present in Morrowind is THE archetypical Imperial architecture, is this correct? And anything that deviates from that pattern is somehow "inauthentic" or not culturally Imperial?
More or less. I mean Bruma is Nord Influenced, Cheydinhal is Dunmer influenced, Anvil is Redguard influenced and the Imperial City is Aldmeri. Bravil is mainly shacks. I mean, otherwise the others are all different, and it's hard to tell if it's culturally Imperial, particularly considering they don't have Imperial counts. Plus, Anvil HAS archetypical Redguard architecture, why wouldn't Cyrodiil have some archetypical imperial architecture found in Morrowind?Those forts are, believe it or not, supposed to be representative of Imperial culture, they were imperial settlements. Reminds me, except for lone farmhouses, have you seen any town with Pelagiad's style? It IS supposed to be an Imperial settlement, yet what Oblivion tells us, is that the Imperial people have lost a lot of their culture. I'm not telling you everything should have been like this, but the imperial's culture should have been more present. Like it or not, Pelagiad and the imperial forts of Morrowind were supposed to be representative of the Imperial culture, yet it seems with Oblivion they decided not. Wouldn't you find it weird for Skyrim to have no cities looking like Bruma, when it is stated that it is highly influenced by Nord architecture?
4 broad resource sets, you mean. It's true that Oblivion has fewer such sets, but each set is far better developed than the sets present in Morrowind, to the point where there might as well have been well over a dozen sets had they decided to keep dungeons in a simplified Morrowind-like state. Bethesda opted for quality over quanity on this point, and clearly they made a good choice! What's more, you have to remember that there's a big difference between a dungeon "looking the same" and a dungeon utilizing similar resources. NO two dungeons in Oblivion look the same, and any opinion otherwise is demonstrably false.
We must not be playing the same games. The 4 resource sets didn't feel broad at all to me. You must have missed a lot of Morrowind dungeons if you think they are all simple and look-alike, I already presented you few examples of the more elaborate ones. And I'm really not the only one to think all of Oblivion's dungeons of the same set look alike. They were not identical, but constructed the same way, a lot of Morrowind's dungeons tried something unique with completely different places. Oblivion had some like this too, but more limited.
But why can't we desire to have more dungeon types? Like I said, more variety the better it is. Not just when exploring inside, but outside. If the environment is dotted with countless of identically looking forts and ruins, it's weird. Morrowind had wrecked boats along the shores, dwemer ruins and daedric shrines scattered across, mines and caves along mountains, etc. And you can't totally put Oblivion's and Morrowind's dungeons on the same level, Oblivion has the technological advantage. Give Morrowind the same technology, and I'm sure the dungeons would be more elaborate with switches, traps and all the fancy Oblivion stuff. All this to say, I want Skyrim to feel as immersive and unique as possible. I can't believe the only ruins in Cyrodiil were forts and ayleid ruins, no daedric shrine was ever constructed in a remote wilderness region? No gang of bandits ever built sanctuaries anywhere rather than always seeking refuge in forts? No ships ever wrecked along the coast of Anvil? If we want Skyrim to feel as believable, deep and varied as possible, more dungeon types should be something we look forward too. It'd make exploration so much more interesting.
No, I saw all those. Unfortunately, they weren't as good as you make them out to be; the Observatory, for example, became my personal Lair, but only after I ran it through the CS for a few hours to tidy it up and make it look less bleak and depressing.
What can I tell you, I like bleak and depressing. Weren't ruined forts bleak and depressing too?
Yes. I'll find the same spear I found last playthrough. Or the same pair of pants. Or the same generic clutter item.
How is that any different as in Oblivion? You always find the same loot. The lack of artifacts only make it worse.
I never said it did! The "fact" is that Fallout's Wastelands are bleak and monotonous. My "opinion" is that this state of affairs sucks. Maybe you like bleak monotony, and if so, that's totally fine!
You never said it, but that's not what we're talking about. Plus, I may be referring to Morrowind, but that doesn't mean
everything has to be referred to it as the environment. Environment can be related to level design, but is not particularly important. If you don't like the environment it's fine, but that doesn't meant that how it's been used is bad (scattering different types of dungeons, cities...)
Not at all! Or at not yet, at any rate, although if I fail to hold Oblivion to the same standards of critical analysis that I currently hold Morrowind (which, despite what you may think, IS my nostalgia game for TES), please call me on it! I'm as psyched as anyone for what the future holds, and I'm sure I'll have to defend Skyrim against conservative Oblivion fans if it turns out to be as awesome as I hope.
I hope you don't think I'm particularly conservative to Morrowind. Most of my problems have to do with quantity and variety of several elements(quantitative), not a qualitative appraisal, like how I love Morrowind's alien look and how Cyrodiil should have been like this, as someone who would love Skyrim to be vibrant and colourful as Oblivion. My other problems have to do with HOW several systems work, which I'm pretty sure is something Bethesda are trying to look at for a better implementation, rather than doing it differently on the basis each TES game should be different.
you can't argue Morrowind has more of everything despited its smaller size
You're right! I can't, and I won't, because it doesn't.
Something I'm wondering if you're doing it on purpose... I'm not speaking of sheer size. Again, I pulled off plenty of stats to defend this. And I'm saying Skyrim should have a much better use of it's environment. We shouldn't loose ourselves in kilometers of wilderness with nothing but ruins of the same look which none contain anything worth the exploration of these, with no quest even asking us to get there. To make a world feel alive and worth exploring, you need to offer an incentive to explore, variety and something to do within a certain radius. Oblivion lacked this in some big chunks of land.
I don't expect it to be Oblivion part 2. Like I said, it will be to Oblivion what Oblivion was to Morrowind.
Yes, but as I said afterwards, you shouldn't expect this either. Morrowind wasn't to Daggerfall what Daggerfall was to Arena. Daggerfall expanded on Arena on every aspect, and Morrowind downgraded on every Daggerfall aspect, same with Oblivion. Nothing tells us which direction Bethesda took, because they said numerous times that each game are supposed to be quite different. Bethesda themselves said certain "answers" they had for Oblivion didn't turned out as they hoped. Considering Fallout New Vegas' hardcore more, they may implement it. Considering the big turmoil in the beth forums fast travel made, they may make a compromise or change it a bit. Considering how many people felt the "gps" hold too much your hand, they might make some modifications. There's no template or trend they try to follow, they just make a new game, look how they can make some systems better and how they can make the game unique. It might end up true, but that's nothing I'd wage on, not at all considering how Bethesda works. Fallout 3 wasn't to Oblivion what Oblivion was to Morrowind at all, in fact, if you Morrowind and Oblivion in line, Fallout 3 isn't after Oblivion, it would be between MW and OB.
Oh sure, there were some things that weren't as good. The lack of spears, for example, and the enchanitng system wasn't as fun. The point is, though, the list of things Oblvion did worse is small compared to the list of things Oblivion did better than Morrowind... in particular, the much more open world design.
I wouldn't argue about the open world design (though keep in mind Morrowind was entirely hand pieced together compared to Oblivion which had generated flora for example) as they're not of the same nature. But I could write again, with numbers, how Oblivion dumbed down a
lot of things, but that's out of topic.
Otherwise, I really hope Skyrim is a lot more varied geographically and that we have a more realistic number of cities/towns/settlements and that the wilderness space is used in a better fashion. I mean, why does Cyrodiil has 9 cities and almost 10 times more forts and ayleid ruins counted separately? It does not feel logical, it's as if Cyrodiil's population sinked over time. I hope Skyrim won't give us a feel of a land that is much, much less of what it once was.