Oblivion better then Morrowind?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the third part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

Morrowind is a living breathing world of history, myth, culture, choice and a game of fond memories that I'll cherish until I give up gaming
...and if you can find this in Morrowind, who are you to say that others can not also find that in Oblvion.

I think that you are missing the point here. I very rarely respond with my opinions. I typically say what needs to be said. My replies were a turn around of what others, mainly you say about Oblivion. It was not actually what I thought about Morrowind.

It is has nothing to do about people not being able to voice their opinions if they chose to do so.

It has everything to do with how they voice their opinions.

You can state what you like, or do not like about something, without talking down to others, and without being insulting to others.

You have complained about having to wear kid gloves, but the Irony is, it is becasue of people like you, and your "Overbearing Opinions", why that rule is in place.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
The King
Master
Master
Posts: 1006
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
ES Games: Obliwind.
Platform: Game Cube 360
Location: Texas

Post by The King »

Oblivion is different, it's for different people, some prefer graphics over lore, that's their choice, if you were to say that Oblivion has more lore than Morrowind then you would be lying and you know it.Personally I would like a compromise, the ability to turn the compass on and off, Tourist doesn't like it but I do, I hated hours of pointless toil trying to find a mother f***** cave that was so remote that the nearest city was a good 20 min real time getting too, fast travel is amazing, then again it's just my opinion.

Anther thing, Oblivion is probably the best game ever created for the use of mods, sooo amazing.

Magic-Morrowind on this one.
Thief-Tie
Combat- despite earlier comments, I recently played Oblivion at a friend's house and then played Morrowind.Oblivion wins, simply because of the keys that you can hot key, the shielding is better.
Graphics-Oblivion,obviously
Lore-Morrowind by 1,000


Overall- Morrowind

Sorry for the text wall, just my little comments.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow

"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Jeff wrote:
Morrowind is a living breathing world of history, myth, culture, choice and a game of fond memories that I'll cherish until I give up gaming
...and if you can find this in Morrowind, who are you to say that others can not also find that in Oblvion.
Seriously, if you can find any of the underlined aspects--- well, you'll be levelling up Conjuration, as they simply aren't in Oblivion.
I very rarely respond with my opinions. I typically say what needs to be said.
I think that second sentence was supposed to have been "...what I think needs to be said".
My replies were a turn around of what others, mainly you say about Oblivion. It was not actually what I thought about Morrowind.
Well, perhaps communication would flow more readily if you actually, y'know, said what you think?
You can state what you like, or do not like about something, without talking down to others, and without being insulting to others.
All I've ever talked about is the games, and the functionality and differences between them. Objectively, you'd be very hard pressed to find anyone who sees Oblivion with more to do, with a deeper narrative, a more diverse land, and a richer more detailed lore.

King; I pretty much enjoyed being lost, because it felt real. Having to double back and check signs, having to re-check your journal, and then look out for waypoints? That's how you connect to the land, because you have to learn it. And - once again - Morrowind rewards the player with their efforts; as you begin to know your way around.
[ data pending ]
User avatar
Guy No. 2
Warder
Warder
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:18 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC.
Status: Lurking....duh-dun....duh-dun...duh duh duh dun du
Location: Here.

Post by Guy No. 2 »

It's not good to berate the Oblivionites on the Ob board, and I no longer do so in any way, but Jeff, I believe those who came to Oblivion from Morrowind - and saw a game with undeniably less content and depth - have cause to get a little peeved
OK so what about Oblivion players that have decided to play Morrowind? Do we not have cause to complain about the poor graphics for example? Do we not have cause to complain about everything Morowind doesnt have but Oblivion has? Personally I think we should if Morowind players do but we dont. We dont arrogantly go into the MW forums and complain to our heart's content or complain about the game in the OB forums. Whereas I have seen plenty of MW players do that the opposite way around, which was also a point Jeff was trying to make(sort of :lol: ), I think. Roughly two years after Ob has come out and people are still complaining about it. Which leads me onto what Jeff said earlier
“"Old dogs not being able to learn new tricks"
Im still here :)
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

I don't think graphics are a valid argument when you're playing old games. It's like popping in Super Mario World and complaining that it's pixilated. However, I like the graphics in Morrowind. Not as "good" but I think they look interesting. I'm a Oblivion first, Morrowind second guy and I still sort of prefer Morrowind. But, like I said in a previous post, it might just be because it's new.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

It's not good to berate the Oblivionites on the Ob board, and I no longer do so in any way, but Jeff, I believe those who came to Oblivion from Morrowind - and saw a game with undeniably less content and depth - have cause to get a little peeved
I did catch that people have quite doing that, and it is much appreciated. Not only by me. I did not say anything last time, until I saw it was bothering some of the others.

However, I played Morrowind for two years. I did not like most of the changes from MW to OB at first. For me, I don't play alot of different games. I don't start a game, and if it doesn't catch me right off, I don't give up on it, and go play another game. Once I played Oblivion for a while, I got used to it, and started to enjoy it. Heck, I didn't like Morrowind a first either.

Again, I am not saying that one of the games is better than the other.

The difference for me with Oblivion, is that I never, ever, posted on a Game Forum. Games don't really mean that much to me. I knew about the Wiki from plyaing Morrowind. USEP didn't have a forum back then. When I came to the Wiki for Oblivion, I noticed the Forum, and had a few questions that the Wiki did not answer. This was early in the Oblivion Wiki, and was still under much development. I liked the way the Forum actually discussed the game, and not alot of "Fanbooy" activity. I saw how the other members knew alot about the game, and could offer much help. I decided to learn as much about Oblivion as I could, so I could also give help. I studied & learned the Console Commands, the Construction Set, and (some) Modding.

To get to the point here. Oblivion is much more immersive, has much more depth, and allows me to do much more, because I know it so well. Being on the Forums, and discussing the game, make it much more of a part of me than Morrowind did.

Very few days pass, that I don't learn something new about the game, by being on the Forums. I have learned most of what I know, by actually giving help. It made me research, and find answers for questions that I never would have thought of.

I'm 43. I am pretty sure that very few people would share my opinions, on games, or even more importantly, life. Being a Soldier, I have seen and done things that I hope none of you ever have to experince. This has shaped alot of my opinions, and if you have not been there, you probably won't get where I am coming from. I at least have the courtesy to not try and force those opinions on others. I am not here to impress people with my opinions. I am here to help people out, and learn more about a game I enjoy playing.

The few times I say anthing about things other than related to playing the game(s), is to help shape the board, to make it a better place, and not be just another fanboy site.
Last edited by Jeff on Wed Jul 23, 2008 1:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Jeff wrote: Oblivion is much more immersive, has much more depth, and allows me to do much more, because I know it so well.
Much more depth in what? Story? Non playable characters?

It's shinny, it's fun, it's easy. I like it. That's it.

When i need depth, story and diverse environment Morrowind serves me better. But that's just me.

I believe the critics were due to the fact that Morrowind really had a lot to offer when it came out, so expectations were high for Oblivion. They managed to do some things very good. things like for example meeting another adventurer (eventhough it only happened to me once). Horses, magic is better. Skills have interesting perks. Graphics - wow - the forest - at the time when it came out... very few games had it like that. Oh and the AI! wish they could make it as it was planned, but there were too many complications. Still it is so interesting.

Game impressed me in a lot of things. But depth & story really isn't one of them. Also wearing armour over naked body ... brrr. :lol:

Best story and surprise was offered to me (i don't play much games as i don't have time for them+i play a lot of "old" ones) in Arx Fatalis. Many would disagree and maybe dismiss the game as just another Ultima Undewrold "clone" (well it is a tribute). But to me that game is great. I enjoyed playing UW1. And Arx was a propper upgrade.
I enjoyed Morrowind (still do) but i don't think Oblivion is propper upgrade.

I think they finished it too fast. They had plenty of things planned for it, but you know how it is with sales pushing for release...
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Post by The Raven »

^^(To Jeff)
One word..Wow..Just Wow..

Else im a bit split between the games.
I Love Oblivion, seeming as it was my very first TES Game, but i also like Morrowind.

As i might have stated before.

I like Morrowind for its lore,
but Oblivion for the gameplay, the combat system, the fast travel, though i only use it to get from one city to another, like Silt Striders in Morrowind, and the fact that that caves, ruins and forts are marked on your map so you dont have to go explore all the time to find a silly cave.

So Oblivion is just my favorite game.

There are some things that i hate about Oblivion(almost only this little small thing) and that is, that Oblivion dont got throwing weapons, spears or crossbows.

That's my opinion, feel free to unagree with me, i simply dont care.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
Guy No. 2
Warder
Warder
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:18 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC.
Status: Lurking....duh-dun....duh-dun...duh duh duh dun du
Location: Here.

Post by Guy No. 2 »

Umm just thought Id mention this,
Jeff you put in brackets [quote="guy no. 2"]
but you quoted The Tourist not me :wink:
Unless I have read your post wrong and I missed something :oops: ....

Also Cactus I was using the Graphics argument as an example to show that MW players find things they dont like about Ob like the good graphics(as mentioned by King), but in the same way Ob players would find problems with MW graphics.
Im still here :)
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

Guy No. 2 wrote:Also Cactus I was using the Graphics argument as an example to show that MW players find things they dont like about Ob like the good graphics(as mentioned by King), but in the same way Ob players would find problems with MW graphics.
Ah, I gotcha. You're right, too. Whenever you go from one game to another in a series you're going to find things the first game had that the second doesn't that you miss, or things the second has you think are stupid that the first was without.

I know personally I always find moving backwards in games VERY difficult. I tried playing Metal Gear Solid after having played Metal Gear Solid 3 first. So far, isn't happening. It was the same way with Morrowind. I tried three times before I could get into it at all. I hated it the first time. The second time I played a week or so, then got bored. It was this page that finally turned me on to it. Now I love it.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

gregor wrote:
Jeff wrote: Oblivion is much more immersive, has much more depth, and allows me to do much more, because I know it so well.
Much more depth in what? Story? Non playable characters?
I started playing D&D back in 1978. True, there is a DM, but a good DM does not play your character, by forcing them to do things. He guides the characters, and adjusts the game to what the characters are doing.

Just because MW has more text, doesn't mean it has a better story. If I really want an Immersive Storyline, I will read a book. I prefer fantasy book series, more than a book, or trilogy. Most of the book series I read, Have 10+ books in them.

- - - - - -

I think that you are missing my point there. It is not that the game has more to give, it is that I get more out of the game.

If I would have done to Morrowind, like I did to Oblivion, then I would be just as much into Morrowind. My preference for Ob over Mw, is not the game, it is me. It is not what I am playing, it is how I am playing it. If I ever get tired of Ob, then I may try Mw again. Unlike what Cactus said, the more I learn about Ob, the more I get into it. I get more ideas, and think of more things to try out. I am not playing Oblivion the Game, I am plaing IN Oblivion the World.

- - - - -

Back to more of my Original point. I read in the MW Forum where people are switching from Ob to Mw. I don't see that as jumping ship, or changing teams. Unfortunately, what I tend to see, is people see these topics as an oportunity to Bash Oblivion. That really is not helpful, and can tend to turn people off of Mw.

I feel that it would be more constructive to point out the differnces, to help in the transition from one to the other. Rather than the difference of why you think Mw is better than Ob. Just as I posted the Articles on the Wiki, those that have made the transition, can point out additional tips that helped them to make the transition less painful.

Seriously, most of the replies to me, have done nothing to help me out, or want to play Morrowind. Most of them have been arguments to why they think Mw is better than Ob. I haven't really read anything explaining what I need to do to get into Mw.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Jeff wrote:To get to the point here. Oblivion is much more immersive, has much more depth, and allows me to do much more, because I know it so well. Being on the Forums, and discussing the game, make it much more of a part of me than Morrowind did.
But that's the thing, your connection to Ob is thus - by your account - more subjective than anything else. I've played MW and Ob pretty much in equal measure (taking into account there's simply more things to do in MW, so it takes longer), and whilst I have a massively subjective love of MW, I'm also trying to be wholly objective.

So, objectively (by going with number of factions etc, different environments, sub-plots etc), here's how I see things.
Oblivion - less factions, less skills, less variety in landscape, less detailed story, less backstory, less lore. I don't believe anyone could counter any of those accounts. Subjectively, people could still obviously prefer what is present in Oblivion.

Design flaws such as world levelling can either be put up with, or disliked by gamers, but that mini list is pretty much irrefutable.

Touristic Intentions
Well, like you, Jeff, I'll try to clarify some things.

My intention here on this thread was to essentially come-back at your post reffering to 'Morrowhiners', and try to explain how people could have such a volatile reaction to Oblivion. Through my last main post, could you not see some sympathetic reason behind their [at times vociferous] methods of expression?

Videogames are 'just' videogames, in the same way that music is just music, or cinema is just cinema; all are creative artforms, often requiring a large body of individuals to work co-operatively on an entertaining, artistic, expressive end product. I don't view game design as a lesser artform - it's just different.

We connect emotionally and intellectually to what we are exposed to; Morrowind affected people - it entertained the eyes, ears, fingers, and stimulated the mind. For me, the latter aspect is the one thing that truly elevates it far above and beyond its (literally) lesser successor.

It all Began, when..
I truly challenge ANYONE to find a profound narrative clearly delineated in Oblivion. Morrowind's strength of plot and narrative is easy to see; through the Blades, the Temple, the Cave of the Incarnates, the 'false gods' of the Tribunal, the Ashlander Prophecies, and the mythos of the Nerevarine - and the mysteries of Red Mountain - Morrowind weaves an increasingly complex, mult-facetted plot, where history, Fate, identity, the nature of redemption, and personal choice are integral to the very outcome of the entire main quest.

As someone else stated here, Morrowind's lore is like real history - written by the victors, and re-written as legacy and potential falsehood. When you meet Vivec and Dagoth Ur, both have their sides to the same coin - there is no real good or evil, merely personal intention. Both have grievances, and both share the source of the same power. What then defines them? Their morality? Their power? Or their choice and responsibility?

Amongst all this, you as the Nerevarine were personally involved. When you read about Lord Nerevar - the "hero", the "betrayed", the "saviour" - you read about the actions or possible actions of your very own soul and being.

The Nerevarine stands amidst the Empire, the Ashlanders, the Tribunal, the Great Houses, the Temple, and even the Daedra. All want a piece of the action, and all have their own versions of events and wishes. Are you, as Nerevar Reborn, defined by what you have done? Or what you are to do.

I've eulogised Morrowind enough, so I'll shut it.. :roll:
But Jeff, if my views on Oblivion had verged on the downright unpleasantly hostile, it was because all I genuinely loved in Morrowind was taken from Oblivion - and in its place was something much less.
[ data pending ]
User avatar
The King
Master
Master
Posts: 1006
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
ES Games: Obliwind.
Platform: Game Cube 360
Location: Texas

Post by The King »

You people berate Morrowind on graphics, if you don't like the graphics then I suppose you don't like any xbox game or any game on any console before the xbox because of graphics, if not, then why just Morrowind.


If you find more depth in Oblivion the apparently more depth means less content, lets review, less joinable factions, less story, less lore, mainly, less quests. For a side note, Oblivion does hold my top three favorite quests though.

Same thing here as in halo, the first had much better story and great game play, the next one pretty much just copied it with a touch on the story and graphics, enjoyable, but where is the innovation, same thing in the elder scrolls.

Morrowind has more text therefore more story, do you think actions of random npcs are lore, no, the books gave history and enjoyable time, not in oblivion.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow

"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
User avatar
apploud
Warder
Warder
Posts: 561
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 2:04 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim.
Platform: Xbox, PC.

Post by apploud »

Jeff wrote:
Dogmantra wrote:
The King wrote:Oblivion is far better is you enjoy zero story, crap fighting and less effective items, with less cooler spells, so yeah, it's better..... than nothing.
Well, let's not be that harsh... it's better than "Crazy Frog Racer"
(((I played Morrowind for two years, it is not a bad game, but neither is it better than Oblivion. They are two different games. I like that it was not another Morrowind Expansion.)))

You want to know what is really sad...???

Most of the reason most of you complain about Oblivion, are the things that I like about Oblivion. Most of the reasons most of you complain about, made me realize that I could never play Morrowind again.

I like that there is (several short) stories, but I can also make up my own. I have the freedom to control what I do. I Usually don't do all of the Quests. I actually played one character, where I did not do any of the Main/Guild/DLC quests, only a dozen or so misc/side quests. I played another character that did not use any armour, weaons, or magic. I had much more fun doing this, then playing all of Morrowind. I am much more immersed in Oblivion, because I decide what I do, or do not do.

:::My dis-scription (sic) of Morrowind:::

You read a bunch of text
You travel from one side of the map, to the other, and back
After reading a bunch more text
You travel back to the same location you just came from
You spend 4 real time hours, mostly traveling, across the same terrain,
to complete one quest.

You have to find all of the God Items/Spells. You have to use the Glitches/Cheats. Otherwise you die, restart, rinse, repeat...

[[[Bottom Line]]]

If you expect Oblivion to be Morrowind, or the other way around, you will be sadly dissappointed.

If you expect them to be two different games, and play/accept them as such, you will enjoy yourself.
Are you sure youve played Morrowind? Because you can do the EXACT same things that you credited oblivion for...
User avatar
Guy No. 2
Warder
Warder
Posts: 536
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:18 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC.
Status: Lurking....duh-dun....duh-dun...duh duh duh dun du
Location: Here.

Post by Guy No. 2 »

The King wrote:You people berate Morrowind on graphics, if you don't like the graphics then I suppose you don't like any xbox game or any game on any console before the xbox because of graphics, if not, then why just Morrowind.


If you find more depth in Oblivion the apparently more depth means less content, lets review, less joinable factions, less story, less lore, mainly, less quests. For a side note, Oblivion does hold my top three favorite quests though.
Ok this is my last post here.
King did you not read my earlier post about the graphics argument?? I thought it had been very clear on why I chose to "berate" the graphics of Morrowind.
Also the second paragraph above, did you just read what Tourist said and just rephrase it???
Tourist wrote:less factions, less skills, less variety in landscape, less detailed story, less backstory, less lore
King wrote:means less content, lets review, less joinable factions, less story, less lore, mainly, less quests
Im still here :)
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

Another problem that affects all forums here, is that people don't read the whole topic.

The first replies were overexagerated examples of what I've seen going on. It was bait. I've explained that as the topic has progressed.

As I've stated, on three (different) topics, I've tried to just set the example, and give help for people switching games. Some people have caught on. Most have not. This time I tried another tactic.

If you think that what I've originall started posting in this topic is bad, then you need to take a look at how you are replying to topics. That is exactly how others are reading what you post.

- - - - -

There is no truth in life. The truth is based on how others precieve things. You can honestly believe, with all your heart, that what you are doing is the best thing, and that you are doing good. While someone else may precieve that as the most evil thing on earth. It is all OPINIONS.

No matter how hard you try, you may never, ever, change someone elses opinion. ...so really, what is the point?

I'll state this for the third time: I could care less what game you think is better. I don't think either game is better than the other. I think that they are both two seperate games. I think that trying to compare two seperate games, is silly, and a waste of time.

- - - - -

I'll state my point in another way:

If they are in the Morrowind Forum, stating that they have played Oblivion, and have decided to play Morrwoind, then they don't need to be converted, they need help to understand the differences between the two games, so that they can make a smooth transition, and enjoy Morrowind.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
xenolion
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 268
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2008 3:22 am
UESPoints: 0
Location: Splitting time between Arus and Second Miltia

Post by xenolion »

I have to confess I played Oblivion before trying morrowind. Oblivion is my first TES game. I also have Oblivion for the PS3 and Morrowind for the PC.

There are reasons I like one game more than the other, but both are really fantastic games. However I find myself playing OB more than MW.

I read people complaining about the fast pace of OB, but that is one of the things I prefer. I don't have a lot of time to play games.

MW is a much slower game, thus a little harder to get into. Starting off I have to "force my" to play. I hear it gets better, but still am waiting for that.

I know it is not fair, but the keyboard controls are really annoying to me too. I started off playing PC RPG's, but got spoiled by the console controls, so going back is a little mind bending for me.

Graphics in both games are phenomonal. I love MW because I have an excuse to put on the headphones and ignore everyone else. I actually jumped when it was storming. OB in HD is sweet! It just reminds me that players now are so spoiled.

Comparing OB to MW is like comparing apples to oranges. Remember they are two different games from two different continents, focusing on two different type of players. It seems that all rpg's are getting shorter, not only OB.

I will finish MW someday I know that, but right now I am going to cause some havoc with my OB player...then reload and play as nothing happened.
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

xenolion wrote:I will finish MW someday I know that, but right now I am going to cause some havoc with my OB player...then reload and play as nothing happened.
I did that yesterday, actually. I popped Oblivion into my PS3 (not for the first time) with my new 32" LCD TV (for the first time) and... holy crap. It looked so amazing I ended up playing about two hours running around blasting people with the mage I made several months back when I first started playing on the PS3. Man that was fun.
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

I truly challenge ANYONE to find a profound narrative clearly delineated in Oblivion.
Well, the larger part of Morrowind was the main plot. It represented at least 70% of what I spent my time on with the game (ignoring the Tribunal and Bloodmoon episodes). The writers thought a lot about the situation in Vvardenfell and when you read 'on Morrowind' in any Oblivion bookshop, it really sounds like an interesting place. Because it is. A lot is going on in Vvardenfell and any plotline which can lead you through the place, is going to be good.

SPOILER ALERT SPOILER ALERT:

However, Cyrodiil is not Vvardenfell, there's no James Bond volcano, it's not an island so when you get to the edge a sign says 'go back', which is not very immersive.
The empire is at relative peace which doesn't make for interesting times. The main plot in Oblivion is the solution of a crisis like in Morrowind. Unlike in Morrowind, the main plot is quite short (you find a bloke who opens a gateway to another world, and then you have a humungous fight with a god that's followed you back).
But just because it's shorter doesn't mean the game is shallower. In fact, Oblivion contains profound narrative throughtout the other quest lines - the mages guild which is at war with itself, culminating in a face off with Mannimarco. The Thieves will eventually send you into the Imperial library itself so that you can change reality (!) by helping someone rewrite an actual Elder Scroll. These other questlines are not part of the main plot but separate strands of the same game.
Towards the end of the Morrowind main plot I found things quite tedious. Once I'd become Nerevar and killed Dagoth Ur, there wasn't much to do until the expansions came along, and I don't think I ever did the Morrowind main plot again in 2 1/2 years of play. And the Morrowind relies on the main plot to carry the game more that Oblivion does.

With Oblivion they have simplified the system (less skills, different spell system), which suprised me at first, but really all they did was de-clutter things and the game is more elegant because of it. But not necessarily less complex. The combat system especially has become much more than it was.
I do miss the Morrowind hardness of certain areas, I think that the levelling of beasties in Oblivion could be more selective. I would like there to be some dangerous areas with great loot from the beginning, simply because of the replay value in taking young characters into a hot spot to get the Daedric bow at 5th level, for example.

Morrowind is atmospheric but uniformly brown. And I definitely didn't want to do chores for so many ashlanders...
Oblivion is bright and clear but looks sometimes a bit like someones garden. But playing Oblivion has consolidated a lot of Tamreilic/Morrowind lore for me, the world is just as rich despite having a less involved Main plotline.
The structure of the various story lines seem to suit the locations of Cyrodiil and Vvardenfell respectively and makes for two distinct games.
They are equals despite different approaches and nearly 10 years difference in the technologies available. The game designers are still on target.

I hope that they change things again for the next game. It was good to start Oblivion after years of Morrowind and be in completely unfamiliar territory.
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Jeff wrote:No matter how hard you try, you may never, ever, change someone elses opinion. ...so really, what is the point?
I gave up trying to change peoples opinions when I was 19 or so. My intention in this thread - once, to my surprise, it had actually become a MW/OB thread - was to point out, mostly to you, why people have such strong feelings for Morrowind. And - just taking the lists of factions, variety of landscape, skills, weapons - I think I've objectively done that.

And on the thorny subject of 'truth'; there is no one reality, one truth, I agree. But in this compartmentalised world we live in, things can be quantified and measured. Going on the simple basis of 'less stuff = worse', MW's successor was a let down.

I think there are very valid reasons why people got so riled by Oblivion.
Mattbot wrote:Morrowind is atmospheric but uniformly brown.
Except for the white bits (Solstheim). And the green bits (Grazelands). And the funny coloured bits (Telvanni settlements and Mournhold). But with regards to the overall hue and feel of the game (and this is obviously just subjective), I have to say I much preferred the darker, more brooding land of Vvardenfell. Where Cyrodiil was all saturated colour and obvious waypoints, Vvardenfell was dark and messy - like a land that had been lived on by numerous people, and changed constantly.

Its isolation as a province - because of the Blight - was another touch I loved. The Empire was besieged, distrusted, and to make things worse, essentially cut-off. The Empire was an imposition on the land, and the political rivalries lent great weight to your allegiences (the Dunmer with their split loyalties, the Ashlanders with their heritage and grievances/Prophecy, the Temple with Tribunal, etc).

The Big Bad
And it's funny that you mention it, Mattbot, but Mannimarco has to be one of my worst moments in Oblivion. I dislike mage characters anyway, so the Mages guild was never fun, but Mannimarco was like Dagon/Mankar; annonymous, with no connection to your character.

All through MW's main quest, there is a Biblical dynamic of temptation and percieved friendship; it begins with the dreams, and it ends at Red Mountain as you descend into the final citadel, with Dagoth Ur - your companion, your once trusted servant - welcoming you as a old friend, and tempting you to join him.

Dagon (or Mankar), like Mannimarco, was simply 'a bad guy'. Neither had any personal connection to your character, completely diminishing the moments you actually came face to face. With Dagoth there was history, and the truth of what really happened at the battle of Red Mountain regarding the Heart and the tools of Kagrenac. Dagoth was not just a 'bad guy'; he was simply all too human in his potentiality for corruption and a fall from grace.

And as I've stated, even at Oblivion's end, your victory is stolen. By a guy called Martin... and you were nothing but (effectively) a merc for hire, a nobody, the 'muscle' of the operation, a bodyguard. Whereas in MW - after a blessing by Azura - you come up into the sun as the prophetic saviour of the entire land (yet with an uncertain future), with the Ghostfence no longer there. Even then, there is another meeting with Vivec, to discuss what must still be done.

Oblivion had no one as wise, as interesting, or as brilliantly contradictory as Vivec - and had no antagonist who was essentially betrayed by those he had been loyal to. Morrowind also dealt thematically with religion. Where were the themes or narrative in Oblivion? Where was the content to make me think and question my own actions?
[ data pending ]
User avatar
The Most Unholy
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics

Post by The Most Unholy »

Tourist that was, hands down, the best post I have read on here in a long time and probably ever.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Mattbott wrote: Towards the end of the Morrowind main plot I found things quite tedious. Once I'd become Nerevar and killed Dagoth Ur, there wasn't much to do until the expansions came along, and I don't think I ever did the Morrowind main plot again in 2 1/2 years of play. And the Morrowind relies on the main plot to carry the game more that Oblivion does.
yes it is tedious. but seriously, "there wasn't much to do"?!? have you actually played the game? i have plenty of characters where i simply threw away the papers given in beginning of the game.

So, you played through all the houses, all the guilds, all religions, imperial legion, vampire quests and did the morag tong. not to mention plenty of miscelaneous quests?!? and here you say there is nothing much to do after the main quest.

changing reality in thieves guild quest seemed a bit phoney. it seems like they came up with it later, because they didn't know how to finish the quest lines in a cool way. and oh btw here is an idea - why not just rewrite it and delete the lord dagon?! Emperor must have had access, so why run arround, hide, get killed, involve your illegitimate offspring into it and an innocent jailed guy?! why not just reqrite the freaking scroll. it seems simple enough!!!

Minimarco? Just a bad guy, practising necromancy. Although i am still not sure what is the really bad thing they did. So they dig out dead bodis (which are usualy burried in abandoned mines - how is that for a final resting place) and resurrect them. trying to overthrow the mages guild. well why not? what did they do for the people? as i know they think of them selves as a better people than everyone else. And how i killed this super duper evil overlord? i made my self invisible and stabbed him in the back. wow! no other mage could really do that. oh no. i dont' know hwo he planned to rule this part of Tamriel.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Post by Jeff »

KJR1012 wrote:Go ahead and play. Then you can answer the topic's title question for yourself. It's a subjective issue, not an objective one.

We can't really do that for you; some folks think MW is better, some think OB is better. Others like them both the same.
This is the best post eeeeeeeevar.

Amazing how just a few words can sum it all up.

It has my vote for Post of the Year, even Best Post in all of UESP/TES.
"à tout le monde, à tous mes amis, je vous aime, je dois partir"
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

Gentlemen, thank you for your replies.

To answer some of your points (Gregor and Tourist):

yes, I did go through the game and complete more or less all of the sub plots. I think I missed the East Empire Company stuff out, but am pretty sure from reading the wiki that I got eveything else. And, when you ignore the expansions, the Morrowind main plotline in my view, dominates the content and overshadows vampires, guilds and houses. But I take your point Gregor, after all I must have found something to do in the 100's of hours I spent playing MW.

I tried to suggest in my last post that it might not be fair to judge OB by holding the MW main plot next to it. It's rather like saying a giraffe is superior to a buffalo because it has a longer neck, and that the buffalos lack of patternation on its pelt was disappointing. I think that the game developers made OB the way it is precisely because they wanted to give it a different shape to the animal that is MW.

My last post was comparing the core games, minus the expansions, and yes, Morrowind is very brown. In fact, a reviewer of the GOTY edition alluded to this when he described it as 'many hours of extra play, mostly brown' (not a direct quote, but you get the idea).
Solstheim was a welcome change. I used to visit it just so that I could see white and blue things, much the way I'd fly up to Sadrith Mora or wander round Pelagaid for my green hit of the day.

I did happen to like the sepia quality of the graphics in MW. The visual design in MW is subtle and exotic compared to OB in many ways. Vvardenfell is also completely alien to us whereas Cyrodiil is similar to our notion of medieval/ renaissance Europe. This makes OB design familiar and perhaps mundane. However, the Shivering Isles expansion and visits to Dagon's Oblivion are juxtaposed with the ordinariness evident in Cyrodiil. Sheogorath and Dagons' realms contrast Cyrodiil in their strangeness/hellishness.
I was gobsmacked the first time I arrived in Kvatch and jumped through the gate into hell. That was a good moment. In it's way, as much fun and profoundly affecting as things which happened to me in MW.

However, you hit the nail on the head, Tourist.
(and this is obviously just subjective)

You never liked mages, and Mannimarco is shallow and contrived when compared to your expectations of a worthy Enemy character. I personally don't mind mages, and for a short while one of my main characters was doing the mages plotline. I really got into the part and when it came to the showdown with Mannimarco, I enjoyed the final dungeon immensly. (admittedly Mannimarco himself was a bit of an anticlimax, I was expecting something different, but I still enjoyed myself. As punishment I had Mannimarco follow me round as a zombie for a few days)

Yes, this is all subjective. People will read this discussion and agree or disagree with what's being said. Some might even read our words and become inspired by our enthusiasm for playing these games.

Each has its good points and bad points. I'm not playing MW at the moment, but reading these posts has made me think that I might well dig it out again.
There are good reasons why people get riled by Oblivion. I would never dispute this. I would probably agree with many of these reasons, but I won't allow these gripes to mar my enjoyment of a game which I have experienced to be as much fun as Morrowind. And fun is what I'm looking for in a game.

Yes, MW does have a biblical dynamic and extraordinarily involved plotline.
Yes, OB structure is more 'modular' and the main plot isn't much larger than any of the others, but so what?
I didn't play OB expecting another MW. They are two different games, and should be judged on their merits. Right now I am enjoying the type of gameplay which OB offers.
And a big reason for my appreciation of Oblivion is that I got so much from Morrowind.
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

I mucked up my quote punctuation.
The quote is from Tourist ("and this is obviously just subjective")
The part which follows shouldn't have appeared as a quote.

sorry, I hope the post still reads ok :oops:
Locked