Jeff wrote:To get to the point here. Oblivion is much more immersive, has much more depth, and allows me to do much more, because I know it so well. Being on the Forums, and discussing the game, make it much more of a part of me than Morrowind did.
But that's the thing, your connection to Ob is thus - by your account - more subjective than anything else. I've played MW and Ob pretty much in equal measure (taking into account there's simply more things to do in MW, so it takes longer), and whilst I have a massively subjective love of MW, I'm also trying to be wholly
objective.
So, objectively (by going with number of factions etc, different environments, sub-plots etc), here's how I see things.
Oblivion - less factions, less skills, less variety in landscape, less detailed story, less backstory, less lore. I don't believe anyone could counter any of those accounts. Subjectively, people could still obviously prefer what is present in Oblivion.
Design flaws such as world levelling can either be put up with, or disliked by gamers, but that mini list is pretty much irrefutable.
Touristic Intentions
Well, like you,
Jeff, I'll try to clarify some things.
My intention here on this thread was to essentially come-back at your post reffering to 'Morrowhiners', and try to explain how people could have
such a volatile reaction to Oblivion. Through my last main post, could you not see
some sympathetic reason behind their [at times vociferous] methods of expression?
Videogames are 'just' videogames, in the same way that music is just music, or cinema is just cinema; all are creative artforms, often requiring a large body of individuals to work co-operatively on an entertaining, artistic, expressive end product. I don't view game design as a lesser artform - it's just different.
We connect emotionally and intellectually to what we are exposed to; Morrowind affected people - it entertained the eyes, ears, fingers, and stimulated the mind. For me, the latter aspect is the one thing that truly elevates it far above and beyond its (literally) lesser successor.
It all Began, when..
I truly challenge ANYONE to find a profound narrative clearly delineated in Oblivion. Morrowind's strength of plot and narrative is easy to see; through the Blades, the Temple, the Cave of the Incarnates, the 'false gods' of the Tribunal, the Ashlander Prophecies, and the mythos of the Nerevarine - and the mysteries of Red Mountain - Morrowind weaves an increasingly complex, mult-facetted plot, where history, Fate, identity, the nature of redemption, and personal choice are integral to the very outcome of the entire main quest.
As someone else stated here, Morrowind's lore is like real history - written by the victors, and re-written as legacy and potential falsehood. When you meet Vivec and Dagoth Ur, both have their sides to the same coin - there is no real good or evil, merely personal intention. Both have grievances, and both share the source of the same power. What then defines them? Their morality? Their power? Or their choice and responsibility?
Amongst all this, you as the Nerevarine were personally involved. When you read about Lord Nerevar - the "hero", the "betrayed", the "saviour" - you read about the actions or possible actions of your very own soul and being.
The Nerevarine stands amidst the Empire, the Ashlanders, the Tribunal, the Great Houses, the Temple, and even the Daedra. All want a piece of the action, and all have their own versions of events and wishes. Are you, as Nerevar Reborn, defined by what you have
done? Or what you are to
do.
I've eulogised Morrowind enough, so I'll shut it..

But
Jeff, if my views on Oblivion had verged on the downright unpleasantly hostile, it was because all I genuinely loved in Morrowind was taken from Oblivion - and in its place was something much less.