Atronach Birthsighs: Pros and Cons

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Juggernaut Mudcrab
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 165
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:21 am

Atronach Birthsighs: Pros and Cons

Post by Juggernaut Mudcrab »

I have experimented with at least 6 different characters with this birthsigns and the results were rather interesting. Does anyone want to chirp in before I actually start?
User avatar
Shanks
Novice
Novice
Posts: 82
Joined: Thu Sep 25, 2008 1:10 am
ES Games: All of them and a collector's edition of Skyrim.
Platform: PC
Status: M.I.A
Location: Australia

Post by Shanks »

Well I havent tried one for a while. Cons; Dont regenerate Magicka Automatically over time, Pros; You Recharge magicka by absorbing 50% of all spells derected at you but not many NPCs use spells so that isnt that great, Fortify magika 150 points
User avatar
Alien
Champion
Champion
Posts: 898
Joined: Sat Apr 12, 2008 9:11 am

Post by Alien »

The Atronach birthsign is a peculiar one that is subject to many controversy and heated debate. But if one looks at it, the advantages outweigh the cons- ahem the con- significantly. And the con itself is very easily remedied.

Let's dissect the birthsign, shall we?

First; we have two pros.
1: We have increased Fortification of our Magicka by 150 Magicka points. Obviously, this comes in handy at the early game and the late game; something that few birthsigns can boast. The increased Magicka helps mitigate the con (you will be able to cast more spells)somewhat, which I will discuss later. Not only does it mitigate (reduce) the con, it supplements the other pro, which I will also discuss later. How does it supplement the other? Well, if you are gaining Magicka every other spell cast at you (on average), then you will be regaining Magicka fairly quickly. If, say, we had the Mage birthsign's Magicka Fortification, we would be capping and reaching the limit of our Magicka supply pretty quickly. But thanks to this 150 extra Magicka points, we can have more Magicka for a much longer duration.

2: Ah, the Spell Absorbtion. First, let's get into the mechanics of this peculiar effect known as 'Spell Absorbtion'. As many players do not realize, you do not absorb half of the power of each spell flung at you, but, rather, you have a chance of absorbing the FULL power of every spell cast at you. What exactly is this so called 'chance'? It is 50%, to be precise. So, you will on average, Absorb half of the spells cast at you. Let's look into the other ways for obtaining this effect. There are various rare necklaces and amulets and robes that provide this effect, but these are semi-permanent. They are for unlimited duration as long as you don't take the said article of clothing off. Unfortunately, you cannot enchant with this effect through normal means. The only way to 'enchant' it yourself is with a Sigil Stone. But again, as mentioned earlier, this is semi-permanent. It is for unlimited duration, as long as you don't take it off.
There are other ways of attaining Spell Absorption, but these are for a limited duration. These are, of course, spells and potions. The Spell Absorption spells are very costly, and are of limited duration. The Spell Absorption potions will provide you with less drain, but for a limited time. Notice how I used 'less drain', and not 'no drain'? The drain to you is a 'Potions Drank' slot filled up, of which there are 4, and the other drain is, obviously, you do not have the potion anymore. Oh, I almost forgot. This also mitigates the con, by providing an ever-present, albeit erratic, source of Magicka regain.

You are taking notes, right? :lol:

The con:

Ah this one singular con of the Atronach is one that everyone gets caught up on. This con, of course is the effect called 'Stunted Magicka'. What exactly is Stunted Magicka? It is an effect that doesn't stunt your Magicka, per se. It just 'slows it down'. I'm talking about, of course, the fact that Stunted Magicka does not allow you to rejuvenate your magicka. But this does not mean you are not able to regain it. You just have to be creative :wink: . There are multiple ways to rejuvenate yourself magically. One, is by the means of potions; arguably the most effective. The potions method not only increases your Alchemy skill, but assures you that you have a steady, although not unlimited, source of regeneration. The other method, perhaps the most obvious, is the one that every Atronach has built-in. I am talking about, of course, the means of increasing your Magicka through the aforementioned Spell Absorbtion. This one, can usually go unchecked. By that, I mean you do not nourish it and feed it like a new rose, but you can certainly do that through increasing your Spell Absorption chance. No, with the Atronach's stalwart Spell Absorption, it can just 'be', like a weed, no pruning or watering required, although its intentions are benevolent. The other method, although less common, can provide a reliable source. I am talking about those odd, quaint Ayelid wells of magical power. The activation of one of these will increase your Magicka even further but also regenerate it to its limit. Although the well must be allowed three days inbetween activations to regenerate, not unlike a 'commoner's' normal means of Magicka. Another way, which works with a weed metaphor, is by the use of the Absorb Magicka spell or enchantment. This is pretty straight forward, just create a spell or enchantment on your favorite weapon or staff for an area-of-eefect spell for about 10 points, although it is entirely up to you.


Conclusion: As you can see, the pros heavily outweigh the con. The con can be reduced in several ways as I mentioned, so it is not a heavy burden. The Atronach is a intelligent choice for a birthsign, definitely.
For once, I don't have a signature.
User avatar
Redguard_Master
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2267
Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 6:20 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: xbox 360
Contact:

Post by Redguard_Master »

The only real way is to play and see. I don't like it.
I would be a procrastinator, but I keep putting it off.

Image
Image
User avatar
Juggernaut Mudcrab
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 165
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:21 am

Post by Juggernaut Mudcrab »

I will only post my first reply b/c I have some pre-calculus to do very soon(stupid trig).

One of the cons that I have noticed for the Atronach birthsign(at least on the 360) is that you cannot obtain any blessings(50% of the time) from any sort of thing that would normally give blessings. Is there anyway to get around this, or is saving and reloading the only solution?
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Unfortunately, there's no way around it. The Atronach will either greedily absorb the enchantment that would bless you, or you get lucky and it sticks. If you're just trying to activate whatever object gives you the blessing for a quest then it still counts, but if you're trying to receive the blessing, indeed the only way is to either reload or to wait a game day to try and get it again.

Also, since it hasn't been mentioned. One particularly nifty (and broken) restoration method that comes in handy if you're near it or when grinding up skill levels for the magicka schools is the Lucky Lady statue in Bravil. You can activate it as many times as you want as quickly as you want for as much magicka regeneration as you need. This only works if you haven't finished the Dark Brotherhood quests yet, though.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

Personally I've never seen the problem with Atronach. Several months ago I tried a game out as a High Elf with Atronach, just to see the problem. I loved it. It was a problem at first, but with the aid of my quickly expanding alchemy abilities, it was soon a problem of the past.
User avatar
DynV
Associate
Associate
Posts: 19
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:34 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Montreal, Canada

Incredible

Post by DynV »

I've made a few characters and always thought Atronach birthsign was a rather useless ... until I tried it by necessity. I was creating a monk so wouldn't be versed in magic and wouldn't need it so it wasn't a loss at all that I couldn't regenerate magicka anymore.

Well that didn't turn out the way I planned at all ! Now when I see magick NPCs I laugh a little inside and the ones that act all mighty like Mannimarco make me laugh out loud. I picked up a few items including one from the mages guild (not going into detail to avoid spoiling) and I now have over 100 absorb, 120 something I think. So with hers (character) newfound source of power, she specialized in destructive magic literally using fire against fire. Another aspect that I didn't think about is that curses are absorbed as well so even if you don't use your magicka, it's a nice plus ; this can also be a curse as it also absorb blessings but I try to think about it ahead so use a portion my magic before receiving (absorbing) the blessing. Thinking ahead of absorption is nice so you don't "waste" what's absorbed, you can't be fuller than full.

This is the best choice I've ever made even if it's accidental. I'm pretty sure I will have all my characters with atronach birth sign unless it goes again the character and I can't think of much reason why that would be ...
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

I have 1 Morrowind and 2 Oblivion characters who were Atronarchs. I planned these characters more than other ones cos this birthsign dictates how you play if you're going to use magic a lot (which i did with my atronarchs). I like to go the whole hog: Altmer Atronarchs all the way. My morrowind bloke was a conjurer, my oblivion characters were good at everything eventually.

I have to say I really liked playing Atronarch mages and the down side added to the challenge, there's no easy fix for stunted magika, so you need a strategy. I don't think any other birthsigns offer this to that extent.

My atronarchs were masters of The Big Spell, whether it was an almighty Summon or Lightning Strike, or whatever. At high level you have the 100 luck, 100% absorb, a load of magika 'batteries' (eg amulet fortify magica 50, hotkeyed), you have the chaining spells that cost 50 to cast, etc and you are an expert in the intricacies of spell casting perhaps more than other races with other starsigns because you have had to deal with more cons.

So i would recommend it if you want to play a different magic using character. Its useful for non spellcasters cos its a good defense against magic too, but i find most other starsigns are more interesting for non mages. An atronarch monk sounds interesting, though
User avatar
Apocalypse
Champion
Champion
Posts: 916
Joined: Mon Feb 18, 2008 7:10 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: Playing TES with my Horsemen
Location: Serbia

Re: Incredible

Post by Apocalypse »

DynV wrote:I picked up a few items including one from the mages guild (not going into detail to avoid spoiling) and I now have over 100 absorb, 120 something I think.
Since Spell Absorption treats units as if they were percentage, obtaining over 100 points is useless because you cannot have more than a 100% chance. Therefore, you might want to consider replacing a few items with something that will actually benefit you.
Ry an kynd loria, la na vasha
Auran sou aran
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

I recommend at least having one character with the Atronach birthsign, preferably a Dark Elf, Breton or High Elf.

And if you have OOO, you'll get 200 extra points of Magicka instead of 150.
User avatar
DynV
Associate
Associate
Posts: 19
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:34 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Montreal, Canada

Re: Incredible

Post by DynV »

Apocalypse wrote:Since Spell Absorption treats units as if they were percentage, obtaining over 100 points is useless because you cannot have more than a 100% chance. Therefore, you might want to consider replacing a few items with something that will actually benefit you.
Very useful to know ! Thanks you. :)
User avatar
kjdanext
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 631
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2008 1:24 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, favourite game probably.
Platform: xbox360, used to be on PC
Location: Back @ UESP :D

Post by kjdanext »

Its handy if you get 100% spell absorption and enchant a few items with fortify magicka from a transcendant sigil stone, this gives you a MUCH larger amount of magic(1 item enchanted item with the best sigils give you the effects of the mage birthsign, imagine multiplying this by 2 or 3).

Get the spelldrinker amulet(Mages guild quest)23% spell absorption

And enchant 2 rings with a sigil stone, for 15% spell absorption.

These items give you 53% spell absorpion and with the 50% from the atronach you have 103%

Now, for the extra magicka you must get 5 peices of clothing, yes clothing and 1 fur shield(Dont worry, you wont really be wearing it so you dont reduce your magic effectiveness)

Enchant these 6 items with with fortify magicka 50pts(Sigil stone) and you get 300 extra magicka so running out wont be a problem.

For the shield, you can use it with no reduced effectiveness if you dont use a weapon(Hand 2 Hand) or use a 2 handed weapon(Claymore, battleaxe, warhammer).


With these enchantments, and the atronach birthsign, you become very VERY powerfull. Altmer would be prefferable over breton for this because of the extra magicka and for the fact that the weaknesses wont matter because for Altmer because you absorb all magic cast at you.
GrandChampion wrote:
Argonanza wrote:How come convicts never save the world from certain destruction in real life? Well, except for Mandela.
User avatar
Juggernaut Mudcrab
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 165
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:21 am

Post by Juggernaut Mudcrab »

josjie wrote:I recommend at least having one character with the Atronach birthsign, preferably a Dark Elf, Breton or High Elf.

And if you have OOO, you'll get 200 extra points of Magicka instead of 150.

Still new to these boards: OOO?

By the way, I thought it was worth mentioning that if you have 100% resist magicka, don't use spell absorb, if you have 100% absorb spell, don't use resist magicka. I personally find resist magicka more preferable just because it gets rid of the atronach's birthsign's cons and I have no idea why this is so. I have never had a blessing resisted or one of my spells resisted against myself(like alteration and mysticism stuff)
User avatar
Juggernaut Mudcrab
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 165
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:21 am

Slightly off topic but...

Post by Juggernaut Mudcrab »

How does the ranking system on these boards work and what are the order of the ranks?
Cepakano
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 42
Joined: Sat Jan 17, 2009 1:51 am

Post by Cepakano »

I made a warrior type character with the Atronach birthsign, since most of the others were just statbonuses and whatnot that would be made up for the in the normal course of the game.

Early on, it was a little rough, but later on, it was quite amazing. I think it's a great sign even for characters that don't focus on magic, as it basically makes any melee'r a powerhouse against casters and gives them a nice magicka reserve for when they do need to dip into it.

Switching to the Atronach Birthsign on my fighter was largely due to the fact that, I had tried it out once, but didn't see the value of it initially, abandoned the character. Later, I had another character who went to level 10+, and I caught Astral Vapors and for whatever reason just never cured it, and after running around with that for a while realized that stunted magicka really wasn't a huge deal later in the game.
User avatar
Teinaava
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2135
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2008 2:26 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Contact:

Post by Teinaava »

Juggernaut Mudcrab wrote:Still new to these boards: OOO?
OOO stands for Oscuro's Oblivion Overhaul which is a mod that "changes the ways in which the core gameplay elements of TES IV: Oblivion relate to each other." You can only get this if you're playing on a computer.
User avatar
DynV
Associate
Associate
Posts: 19
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:34 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Montreal, Canada

Post by DynV »

Teinaava wrote:OOO stands for Oscuro's Oblivion Overhaul which is a mod that "changes the ways in which the core gameplay elements of TES IV: Oblivion relate to each other." You can only get this if you're playing on a computer.
Getting it
I was going to ask a few questions about it butfound them in OOO Questions: root viewtopic.php (question mark) t=7284
User avatar
Juggernaut Mudcrab
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 165
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:21 am

^

Post by Juggernaut Mudcrab »

Cool picture. What is it?
On a more important note>>>>V

I have always wondered...and I know this is a stupid question, but since we are talking about a birthsign, which pertains to character build, what is probably the best or should I say "most well-rounded race" with no glaring weaknesses.


Thank Mara these formus have an edit button, I had accidentally had put growling reasons where glaring weaknesses should be.
Cepakano
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 42
Joined: Sat Jan 17, 2009 1:51 am

Post by Cepakano »

With no real weakness,

Breton
Dunmer
Imperial

They're all pretty even as things go, not having stats aligned strongly in one direction or another and having fairly balanced racial attributes. Breton starts out a little low on strength in the beginning, but I think it actually makes a decent combat class if you take the time to build it in that direction.

I'd have to say that Dunmer are probably the best all-around race, they're slightly oriented towards stealthing characters, but they do everything fairly well and have no major drawbacks.

Bretons are pretty balanced for a more casting oriented all-around character, they don't have the massive magic reserves of an altmer, but their resistance is pretty nice no matter what sort of character you play. The bonuses to the magics can also be helpful on a fighting character as it'll give you a little bit more punch sooner.

Imperial is probably the most balanced of all the warrior oriented classes and doesn't really excel at anything, but it doesn't have any real weaknesses either.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

Cepakano wrote:With no real weakness,

Breton
Dunmer
Imperial

They're all pretty even as things go, not having stats aligned strongly in one direction or another and having fairly balanced racial attributes. Breton starts out a little low on strength in the beginning, but I think it actually makes a decent combat class if you take the time to build it in that direction.

I'd have to say that Dunmer are probably the best all-around race, they're slightly oriented towards stealthing characters, but they do everything fairly well and have no major drawbacks.

Bretons are pretty balanced for a more casting oriented all-around character, they don't have the massive magic reserves of an altmer, but their resistance is pretty nice no matter what sort of character you play. The bonuses to the magics can also be helpful on a fighting character as it'll give you a little bit more punch sooner.

Imperial is probably the most balanced of all the warrior oriented classes and doesn't really excel at anything, but it doesn't have any real weaknesses either.
Imperial the most balanced of all warrior oriented classes? Wouldn't say so.

None of the other warrior oriented classes - Orc, Redguard and Nord - have ANY weaknesses.

And they do excel at combat.

The Orc has a great Berserk greater power and a 25% Resistance to Magic.
The Nord has nice Nordic Frost and Woad greater powers, and a 50% Resistance to Frost.
The Redguard has a very useful Adrenaline Rush greater power and a 75% Resistance to Disease and Poison.

And if we compare the attributes:

Race - Strength - Endurance
Imperial - 40 - 40
Orc - 45 - 50
Nord - 50 - 50
Redguard - 50 - 50

And the Orc, Nord and Redguard race also offer better skill bonuses.

So the Imperial race is only recommended for role-playing purposes, if you really like the race itself or if you have a Personality/Combat oriented character.

Dark Elves are the best "jack-of-all-trades" races. But "Juggernaut Mudcrab" is asking for:
what is probably the best or should I say "most well-rounded race" with no glaring weaknesses.
And that question has actually two answers: Breton and High Elf, and I recommend Breton.

With a single Mundane Ring you'll have a 100% Resistance to Magic with the Breton, which makes you immune to it.
User avatar
Chaos the N'wah
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1555
Joined: Wed Mar 19, 2008 3:25 am
Status: Always lurking
Location: Tenmar Forest

Post by Chaos the N'wah »

I always found the sign to be great for roles like Paladin or witchhunter where you don't always use magic so that fighting none-magic monsters isn't impossible without alchemy.
User avatar
kjdanext
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 631
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2008 1:24 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, favourite game probably.
Platform: xbox360, used to be on PC
Location: Back @ UESP :D

Post by kjdanext »

Imperial with maxed stats so what

Breton with maxed stats 50% resistance to magic, handy

Dunmer with maxed stats 75% resistance to magic, also very handy

Redguard with maxed stats 75% resistance to poison and deasese hooraah!

Nord with maxed stats 50% resistance to magic, cool

Agonian with maxed stats water breathing, go fishy fishy!

Orc with maxed stats beserk power, axe em up!!

Altmer with maxed stats extra magicka, weaknesses can be sorted out later, but extra magicka! OMG cool!

Khajiit with maxed stats, booring

Bosmer woth maxed stats, also booring

Dwemer with... Wait! you cant play them haha!


Anyways, here you can see that some races will still have advantages even at max levels, some may also have really good power, but I feel sorry for those who have powers that are useless at higher levels.
GrandChampion wrote:
Argonanza wrote:How come convicts never save the world from certain destruction in real life? Well, except for Mandela.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

kjdanext wrote:Imperial with maxed stats so what

Breton with maxed stats 50% resistance to magic, handy And +50 Magicka.

Dunmer with maxed stats 75% resistance to magic, also very handy The Dunmer has a 75% Resistance to Fire, not to Magic.

Redguard with maxed stats 75% resistance to poison and deasese hooraah! And Adrenaline Rush

Nord with maxed stats 50% resistance to magic, cool The Nord has a 50% Resistance to Frost, not to Magic.

Agonian with maxed stats water breathing, go fishy fishy! Not really something the Imperial or any other race can't, just use some water breathing spells or potions.

Orc with maxed stats beserk power, axe em up!! And 50% Resistance to Magic.

Altmer with maxed stats extra magicka, weaknesses can be sorted out later, but extra magicka! OMG cool! Breton has also extra magicka. Only the High Elf has more, +100 Magicka.

Khajiit with maxed stats, booring Night-Eye. If you make a note about the water breathing ability of the Argonian, you should make a note about the night-eye lesser power of the Khajiit. But other than that, no real advantages.

Bosmer woth maxed stats, also booring

Dwemer with... Wait! you cant play them haha!

Anyways, here you can see that some races will still have advantages even at max levels, some may also have really good power, but I feel sorry for those who have powers that are useless at higher levels.
You've made some small mistakes :)

This should be the top 10:
1) Breton +50 Magicka, 50% Resistance to Magic
2) High Elf +100 Magicka, 25% Weakness to Fire, Frost and Shock
3) Orc Berserk power, 50% Resistance to Magic
4) Dark Elf 75% Resistance to Fire
5) Redguard 75% Resistance to Disease and Poison, Adrenaline Rush power
6) Nord 50% Resistance to Frost
7) Khajiit
8) Argonian
9) Imperial
10) Wood Elf

In my opinion of course :) and this is only the top 10 for uber characters that are good at magic, combat and stealth, and mostly magic and combat.
User avatar
kjdanext
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 631
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2008 1:24 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, favourite game probably.
Platform: xbox360, used to be on PC
Location: Back @ UESP :D

Post by kjdanext »

Yeah I know I didnt add some powers but I was only trying to point out wich races would be more useful.
GrandChampion wrote:
Argonanza wrote:How come convicts never save the world from certain destruction in real life? Well, except for Mandela.
Locked