Page 1 of 1

Roleplaying... why?

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:23 pm
by The Royal Druid
Okay, I understand that some people get bored with the quests in Oblivion and want to roleplay. I can understand some of the ideas because they will still level you up and help you when you want to get back to the game proper.

But it baffles me why some people might want to spend their gaming time as a drunkard, a farmer, a family member, retiree and so on (all the above have come from the wiki's roleplaying suggestions). This is your REAL life you're wasting.

Instead of doing these things in a game, why not do them in the real world! (Just as long as you're not a thief. :D )

Can someone explain to me why they would spend minutes, hours, days, etc. doing this sort of thing or playing games like Sims?

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:33 pm
by Arzock
I agree with you (I love roleplaying death) BHut farming is just booooring.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:39 pm
by The Royal Druid
Actually reading more of the roleplaying ideas I don't even see how some of these work - unless they have been written into the game. How can you be a detective and "look for footprints"?

It's not that I lack imagination, I simply don't see how this works. If you cannot actually do the things you need to, to roleplay, then it straight away destroys the illusion, surely?

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:12 pm
by Mattbott
I agree with you.

To be honest, computer games arent really role playing games, they just re create the mechanics of an rpg and add a plotline to take you through the world. It matters little what you decide cos you'll be 'limited' by the programming, even though a game might give you a million ways of playing it and the freedom to roam around as you will (so long as you make contact with npcs at certain points along the script to keep it moving along).
In Oblivion for instance, Ocato won't ever put a warrant out for your death because as the Champion you offered to help him run the place and he saw this as a threat to his power and he doesn't like you anyway. You simply aren't given the opportunity to act outside the plotted story, which is fair enough cos programming can't out think a mind.

If you really want to role play, you should do it with humans round a table/over skype (i have tried it, works great with sci fi games). With a good human referee you really can change the way the story unfolds and interraction between the other players is really where role playing is at.

But i do really enjoy Ob and Mw cos even though you don't get the role playing moments in the 'dice and paper rpg' sense, everything else is present and correct.
:D


Hope you're still reading this, i'll finish with what i think are the important elements of a roleplaying game (not in any particular order):

role-playing (interracting with the players and world youre in as if you are your character)

good immersive plot

frequent action (combat, skills checks, action hero stuff)

your character (someone you like playing who grows and develops as the game progresses)

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:46 pm
by Josjie
Some of those role-playing idea's are kind of boring.
Spending hours playing as a farmer sucks.

But now I am role-playing an assassin. I use this mod to create my own journals of what I've done. I create a story that unfolds around my character.

I'm not that limited to the game mechanics, though. If I want Ocato death and be the leader of the Imperial City, I can do so through the Oblivion Construction Set. I simply create a quest in which I kill Ocato and in which someone tells me that I'm the new leader. Simple as that.

Playing an assassin is fun. First I pick a target. Then I follow him/her around. Then I plan the assassination. Finally, I do the best part: the killing.

I'm using tons of mods, like a mod that adds the armor of Altair from Assassin's Creed to the game, or a mod that makes combat more fun (more blood & gore).

These all help in my role-playing experience.

I'm also pretending I've got to sleep every night and eat at some points. This isn't a waste of time. It sucks you more into the game and makes it more realistic. And by that, you enjoy your experience in the game more.

Besides, I'm also just progressing by gaining levels and I'm following the DB quests right now, pretending I'm trying to become Lucien Lachance's servant.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:08 pm
by kjdanext
And just to say that if you were playing as farmer in OB and you get attacked by someone you can kill them and live a life of crime in-game while RP'ing

But in rel life you cant just kill people and run amuck like a crazy person without the concequenses because you get put in jail/killed and you cant just restart.

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:09 pm
by jelpower
Most people play sims for example, just because they can create a second life, an alter ego.

Thats why games like 'second life' and 'WoW' are so popular. And oblivion... well, who doesnt wanna be an almighty lord with powers so astonishing you almost pee your pants. 8) Last part referring to me ofcourse 8)
EDIT: (ahum, not the peeing pants part) :oops:

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:12 pm
by jelpower
josjie wrote:Besides, I'm also just progressing by gaining levels and I'm following the DB quests right now, pretending I'm trying to become Lucien Lachance's servant.
Uhm kinda spoiler.. but you'll get to that part without pretending if you just advance in ranks with the DB.
Just so you don't use any unnecessary mods :o

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:14 pm
by stk01001
I agree some of the role-playing suggestions they give are a little ridiculous. There are some role-playing ideas that I can see would make the game more enjoyable for some people. For instance, no fast traveling, sleeping in hotels at night, no traveling in rain. I do some of these things myself from time to time. But then I see things like "eating 3 times a day" or "only carrying around two-three inventory items at a time for realism" and I think to myself how the heck would doing these things make the game more enjoyable?? To me, a lot of that stuff would just get EXTREMELY annoying and tedious.

playing the full game out as like a farmer-type character or something though.. that is just crazy.. I think I'd rather become an actual farmer..

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:44 pm
by Dark Spark
I never see those roleplaying articles as being the end-all solution to enjoying the game, but as a means to an end.

That is to say, roleplaying a farmer means you use Shetcombe Farm as a base, but you go on playing the game everywhere else. A drunk tends to trade his wares in a tavern rather than a general store, hangs around the Flowing Bowl and watches the sailors spar late at night.

The roleplaying pages tend to get out-of-hand, but that's because the challenge of the page, the desire to think of something new, is at the core of just exactly what roleplaying is. Of course, you get more misses than hits, but that's Sturgeon's Law for you.

Re: Roleplaying... why?

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:04 pm
by Alchemy Addict
The Royal Druid wrote:Okay, I understand that some people get bored with the quests in Oblivion and want to roleplay. I can understand some of the ideas because they will still level you up and help you when you want to get back to the game proper.

But it baffles me why some people might want to spend their gaming time as a drunkard, a farmer, a family member, retiree and so on (all the above have come from the wiki's roleplaying suggestions). This is your REAL life you're wasting.

Instead of doing these things in a game, why not do them in the real world! (Just as long as you're not a thief. :D )

Can someone explain to me why they would spend minutes, hours, days, etc. doing this sort of thing or playing games like Sims?
Well, maybe some people don't have access to 10+ acres of land :P I would personally like to try farming sometime in my life..

Also, Roleplaying is decent. But I agree that some roleplaying is kind of silly... A family member.. LMAO

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 12:00 am
by Renaldo
All in all Royal Druid I agree with you, people wasting their time making a virtual life is like... the end of the human populous. But in real life it's not so simple without concequences. I could become a Farmer in real life, but it's not as easy as going over and comandeering my own Farm. And what you may hear or believe is not excactly true. I guarentee you this isn't a problem. Videogames are entertainment, and that is all they ever can be. If you let them take over your life you should blame yourself, noone held you down and forced you to use videogames for roleplaying purposes. I may have mixed something up in there, but thats what happens when I rant. :)

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 12:27 pm
by Josjie
Many people like to play WoW to get out of their normal life, because they like the life of their virtual alter-ego more.
Uhm kinda spoiler.. but you'll get to that part without pretending if you just advance in ranks with the DB.
Just so you don't use any unnecessary mods Surprised
What I said wasn't really a spoiler. Someone who hasn't played through the DB quests yet, won't notice it.
It is you who really makes it a spoiler :)

But of all people here on these forums, I think about 90-95% has played through the DB quests at least once. And besides, there are no spoiler tags.

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 4:27 pm
by The Royal Druid
I suppose I can understand some people doing the "farmer" RP because they can't in real life, but then you don't get the real rewards either.

I would be happy to get up at 4 or 5am, work on the land all day then go to bed about 9pm, if I was getting a decent living or other rewards. But to do that (even) virtually so no reward? No thanks.

If you are able to use mods then I suppose some have been written to help facilitate RP - but those of us with Xbox or PS3 can't do it.

I used to have all the Sims expansion packs for my PC and enjoyed it for a time. Then one day I was sitting there playing and thought to myself "What the hell am I doing wasting my time playing at living when I could be out there doing it for real?!" I haven't touched them (nor wanted to) since.