mage vs warrior vs sneak

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions

who would win?

Mage
20
40%
Warrior
12
24%
Sneak
18
36%
 
Total votes: 50

gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

GoatLiver wrote:
gibson wrote:Why not 100, its the most logical, everyones maxed out there skills

Why have them at 50, thats just retarded, noone would be able to used the most of there skills.
Well one reason is it's just not a good representation of level 10 characters, also if everyone has 100 on all major skills it gives the mage access to endgame spells at level 10 but the warrior and theif would be left with level 10 gear, Glass and Daedric stuff isn't available untill level 20+ and could probably come with some harsh enchantments.
No were just saying there level 10 for the attributes.

The warrior would have deadric and such
User avatar
Rhcpftw
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 168
Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2008 6:09 pm
Location: In your base, killing your dudes

Post by Rhcpftw »

The mage would win as we're the smart ones, remember?

Not only can we summon large creatures that stall you, we can also use destruction to tear you apart from afar.

If we have to flee, we can walk on water, or breath in it, if that should be necessary

You won't do much damage against us if we use a shield, while we can use spells to amplify the damage caused

How can you swing that mighty sword if you're paralyzed? Or what good would come from it if you don't see us?

If there would be some kind of hide and seek, we'd win that too, since we can detect life.

Aaaaand we can also use our potions
I used to make polls, but then I took an arrow in the knee.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

The mage is smart facticiously. The others have cunning and battle experiance. Also, WE can use potions too, just not make them. And even if you have detect life, what would you do if you find me? I can dodge quite quickly as I'm an Expert in Acrobatics, and I would probably shoot you down as you fight the warrior.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:The mage is smart facticiously. The others have cunning and battle experiance. Also, WE can use potions too, just not make them. And even if you have detect life, what would you do if you find me? I can dodge quite quickly as I'm an Expert in Acrobatics, and I would probably shoot you down as you fight the warrior.
Well according to be poll the mage would beat you :lol:
Last edited by gibson on Tue Apr 28, 2009 1:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Well, according to the poll, the Stealthy One and Warrior could team up and beat YOU!

Proof: 18 vs 25... Ha!

The Stealthy One and Warrior would fight later after defeating you. An honorable match that would be. The comradery that would build when teamed up might give the opportunity for the Warrior and Stealthy One to become friends and spare each other's life, who ever would win.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Well, according to the poll, the Stealthy One and Warrior could team up and beat YOU!

Proof: 18 vs 25... Ha!

The Stealthy One and Warrior would fight later after defeating you. An honorable match that would be. The comradery that would build when teamed up might give the opportunity for the Warrior and Stealthy One to become friends and spare each other's life, who ever would win.
You cant assume that, your just want to make sure stealth wins :lol: , kind of funny watching you try so hard.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Kind of funny watching you get pwned by the Warrior too... :lol: I can imagine him chopping you down to size as you focus your attention on my, firing my arrow at you.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Kind of funny watching you get pwned by the Warrior too... :lol: I can imagine him chopping you down to size as you focus your attention on my, firing my arrow at you.
im not a mage
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Lucky for you... Then what are you?
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Lucky for you... Then what are you?
Like most people a mix.

But seriosuly man your arguments are weak, they all depend on things like: - no one can hit a stealth but he can hit anyone, - the warrior will somehow team up on the mage

honestly a mage would need is a shield 100% for 30 seconds, and a healing spell and he could stand there and just wait till you run out of arrows.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

I got 200 of them and If he DOES use one do you think I'd just fire my arrows at him without thinking twice?! No way, I'm not that stupid!
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:I got 200 of them and If he DOES use one do you think I'd just fire my arrows at him without thinking twice?! No way, I'm not that stupid!
What else could you do but fire at him?
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Wait for the spell to wear off. Maybe get into a better position while doing so.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Wait for the spell to wear off. Maybe get into a better position while doing so.
Spells like that you can keep them going forever cause when the 30 seconds run out all your magicka is back so you can recast.
User avatar
GoatLiver
Warder
Warder
Posts: 554
Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Post by GoatLiver »

Rhcpftw wrote:The mage would win as we're the smart ones, remember?

Not only can we summon large creatures that stall you, we can also use destruction to tear you apart from afar.

If we have to flee, we can walk on water, or breath in it, if that should be necessary

You won't do much damage against us if we use a shield, while we can use spells to amplify the damage caused

How can you swing that mighty sword if you're paralyzed? Or what good would come from it if you don't see us?

If there would be some kind of hide and seek, we'd win that too, since we can detect life.

Aaaaand we can also use our potions
Every point you just said has been raised and answered in previous posts and to aviod writing another novel I'm not going to respond to your post other than to say you should read the rest of the thread before posting.
gibson wrote:No were just saying there level 10 for the attributes.

The warrior would have deadric and such
That is partly my point, they're much higher than level 10. With 50 on everything it's closer to level 10, with 100 on everything it's closer to level 30. By having 100 and level 10 you put the mage at an advantage because the warrior looses atleast 200hp from what he would have at level 30.
The Ninja wrote:Well, according to the poll, the Stealthy One and Warrior could team up and beat YOU!
I maintain the warrior doesn't need to team up!

gibson wrote:Like most people a mix.

But seriosuly man your arguments are weak, they all depend on things like: - no one can hit a stealth but he can hit anyone, - the warrior will somehow team up on the mage

honestly a mage would need is a shield 100% for 30 seconds, and a healing spell and he could stand there and just wait till you run out of arrows.
That first part is true, stealth is the weakest in a straight up fight because the arrow is the only weapon he has, the others have multipule attacks. Not to say that the stealth couldn't win given the right circumstances. However I also think losts of your (gibson) arguments depend on the opponent being a brain dead baboon in a suit of armor, while the mage has a 4 foot brain sticking out his head which no-one can hit. Moving on I thought the maximun sheild you could have is 85%? What if for example the stealth guy shooting arrows where to shoot an arrow poisoned with scilence or damage magika/intelegence, and aslo still has the chance to paralyze you if all skills are indeed at 100, standing there is not a good Idea.
gibson wrote:Spells like that you can keep them going forever cause when the 30 seconds run out all your magicka is back so you can recast.
When your casting defencive spells your still vunerable to attacks, from the warrior especially.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

If your silenced: potion of dispel.

You cast the sheild spell before the other one ends.

And what would the warrior do against this.. like honestly, if you came close enough to power attack mage spams paralyze 1sec+ shock damage

Although if the warrior gets in a kockback or paralyze it could be end game for the mage.


Also i agree with you on the level 10 thing, didnt realise that.
User avatar
GoatLiver
Warder
Warder
Posts: 554
Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Post by GoatLiver »

gibson wrote:If your silenced: potion of dispel.
I think you would actually require a potion of cure poison...I'm not shure though.
gibson wrote:Although if the warrior gets in a kockback or paralyze it could be end game for the mage.
...I'm using Mehrunes Razor! 8)
User avatar
Aces Andre
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:17 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Location: Norway

Post by Aces Andre »

What I find interesting about this thread is how many people are portraying mages as supermen. I prefer playing a mage, but we are nowhere near as powerful as that if we take a few things into consideration.

Magicka:

1 No race has been assigned, we must therefore assume that we have no magicka bonus from it.

2 No birthsign has been assigned, but it is logical that each of the three prime classes will use the sign of the same name, therefore we can assume that we have a +50 bonus (up for discussion).

3 No equipment has been assigned, therefore we assume base equipment without enchantments, therefore we do not have superbuffed clothing with +magicka.

What does this mean? That we are standing with 250 points of magicka, lets use them wisely. Another limitation is that we should only have access to 8 spells, as that is the number of hotkeys available. I understand that a mage would just "remember his spells", but that is actually what the hotkeys are. At least that is the way I always thought of it, and the menu as a spellbook.

And then we have to ask ourselves a few questions about spells. Are we allowed to buy spells, are we allowed to create our own spells, none of this seems to have been decided. Personally I don't see why we should be allowed to make custom spells, a mage is not by default a member of the Mage's guild and therefore doesn't necessarily have access to a spellmaking altar. But we should be able to buy spells, there is no requirement for that apart from money (unless people want to make buying items exclusive to the thief, in which case the warrior and mage are possibly rather screwed)

Anyhow, what I am trying to say is that we can't just assume that the mage has the best of everything, there are limitations which need to be accounted for.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

Aces Andre wrote:What I find interesting about this thread is how many people are portraying mages as supermen. I prefer playing a mage, but we are nowhere near as powerful as that if we take a few things into consideration.

Magicka:

1 No race has been assigned, we must therefore assume that we have no magicka bonus from it.

2 No birthsign has been assigned, but it is logical that each of the three prime classes will use the sign of the same name, therefore we can assume that we have a +50 bonus (up for discussion).

3 No equipment has been assigned, therefore we assume base equipment without enchantments, therefore we do not have superbuffed clothing with +magicka.

What does this mean? That we are standing with 250 points of magicka, lets use them wisely. Another limitation is that we should only have access to 8 spells, as that is the number of hotkeys available. I understand that a mage would just "remember his spells", but that is actually what the hotkeys are. At least that is the way I always thought of it, and the menu as a spellbook.

And then we have to ask ourselves a few questions about spells. Are we allowed to buy spells, are we allowed to create our own spells, none of this seems to have been decided. Personally I don't see why we should be allowed to make custom spells, a mage is not by default a member of the Mage's guild and therefore doesn't necessarily have access to a spellmaking altar. But we should be able to buy spells, there is no requirement for that apart from money (unless people want to make buying items exclusive to the thief, in which case the warrior and mage are possibly rather screwed)

Anyhow, what I am trying to say is that we can't just assume that the mage has the best of everything, there are limitations which need to be accounted for.
Valid point.

I still cant see the warrior beating the mage even if the mage only has 250 magicka, all it takes is the mages staff of paralyzation and a few touch spells.
User avatar
GoatLiver
Warder
Warder
Posts: 554
Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Post by GoatLiver »

I agree with Aces Andre 100%
gibson wrote:I still cant see the warrior beating the mage even if the mage only has 250 magicka, all it takes is the mages staff of paralyzation and a few touch spells.
He just said the mage doesn't have the best of everything, but besides the staff falls under no catogory in particular so could be used by anyone.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

GoatLiver wrote:I agree with Aces Andre 100%
gibson wrote:I still cant see the warrior beating the mage even if the mage only has 250 magicka, all it takes is the mages staff of paralyzation and a few touch spells.
He just said the mage doesn't have the best of everything, but besides the staff falls under no catogory in particular so could be used by anyone.
Ok warrior with 500 health + full deadric.

All the mage needs is three spells.

1. Deathly Visage (invisibility 35 seconds)
2. Lightning Surge (shock damage 80pts on touch)
3. Immobilize (paralyze 7 seconds on touch)


Turn invisible, paralyze warrior, hit a few lightning surges, turn invisible and let magicka regain, paralyze warrior hit a few lightning surges. Rinse and repeat until warrior is dead.

Edit: by the way those spells dont even take lvl 100, first needs level 50, other 2 need lvl 75.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

I'm getting tired of this. Seriously, read the entire thread before taking conclusions!
That is partly my point, they're much higher than level 10. With 50 on everything it's closer to level 10, with 100 on everything it's closer to level 30. By having 100 and level 10 you put the mage at an advantage because the warrior looses atleast 200hp from what he would have at level 30.
The Warrior starts with 65 Endurance.
Level 2 - 70 End
Level 3 - 75 End
Level 4 - 80 End
Level 5 - 85 End
Level 6 - 90 End
Level 7 - 95 End
Level 8 - 100 End
etc.
Level 30 - 100 End

Starting health: 130
Health at level 2: 137
Health at level 3: 144
Health at level 4: 152
Health at level 5: 160
Health at level 6: 169
Health at level 7: 178
Health at level 8: 188
Health at level 9: 198
Health at level 30: 408


The Mage/Thief start with 30 Endurance.
Level 2 - 35 End
Level 3 - 40 End
Level 4 - 45 End
Level 5 - 50 End
Level 6 - 55 End
Level 7 - 60 End
Level 8 - 65 End
Level 9 - 70 End
Level 10 - 75 End
Level 11 - 80 End
Level 12 - 85 End
Level 13 - 90 End
Level 14 - 95 End
Level 15 - 100 End
etc.
Level 30 - 100 End

Starting health: 60
Health at level 2: 63
Health at level 3: 67
Health at level 4: 71
Health at level 5: 76
Health at level 6: 81
Health at level 7: 87
Health at level 8: 93
Health at level 9: 100
Health at level 10: 107
Health at level 11: 115
Health at level 12: 123
Health at level 13: 132
Health at level 14: 141
Health at level 15: 151
Health at level 30: 361

So the Warrior has 47 more Health points than the Mage/Thief.
The Warrior looses around 200HP but the Mage/Thief approximately 150HP, so that's not a big difference.
At level 10 (with the Mage/Thief not allowed to raise their Endurance attribute), the Warrior already has more health than the Thief/Mage.

I picked level 10 because at that point, the Thief, Mage and Warrior have maxed their favored attributes. It would be unrealistic to have a level 30 Mage/Warrior/Thief battle, because level 30 characters also level up other attributes, and we can't allow them to raise different attributes (like the Mage who raises his Endurance stat) because that makes it impossible to compare them fairly.
You can say that they level up all their attributes with +2/+3 bonuses, so they're 100 at level 30. This makes for exactly the same situation, except that everyone has a bit more health and the Warrior has a bit more health than the Mage/Thief. I find this to be unfair, but even in this situation, the Mage will win both fights.
1 No race has been assigned, we must therefore assume that we have no magicka bonus from it.
I've posted a while back that the Mage is a Breton, the Thief an Argonian/Wood Elf and the Warrior a Nord/Redguard.
So the Mage gets a +50 Magicka bonus.
2 No birthsign has been assigned, but it is logical that each of the three prime classes will use the sign of the same name, therefore we can assume that we have a +50 bonus (up for discussion).
See ^. The Mage has the Mage birthsign, the Warrior the Warrior birthsign and the Thief the Thief birthsign :P
3 No equipment has been assigned, therefore we assume base equipment without enchantments, therefore we do not have superbuffed clothing with +magicka.
This has also been discussed. All characters have access to level 10+ items. Only Mages can enchant items. Warriors can wear the Umbra armor. So Mages can enchant items with Fortify Magicka (but they can't get Transcendent Sigil Stones because they're level 10).
And then we have to ask ourselves a few questions about spells. Are we allowed to buy spells, are we allowed to create our own spells, none of this seems to have been decided. Personally I don't see why we should be allowed to make custom spells, a mage is not by default a member of the Mage's guild and therefore doesn't necessarily have access to a spellmaking altar. But we should be able to buy spells, there is no requirement for that apart from money (unless people want to make buying items exclusive to the thief, in which case the warrior and mage are possibly rather screwed)
Every class may only use his major skills with the one exception of Athletics. This has been discussed a lot.
So the Warrior is the only one who may wear Heavy Armor, with the exception of Bound Armor summoned by the Mage.
The Thief is the only one who may wear Light Armor.
The Mage may only wear clothes.
The Mage is the only one who can create his own spells (only he has access to the Arcane University, and he's a mage after all) and he's the only one who can use spells and that means buying them.

But the Thief is the only one who can join the Thieves Guild and earn items there and the Warrior can join the Fighters Guild.
The Dark Brotherhood doesn't really fit in, this guild is suited for Warriors, Mages and Thieves, so perhaps we should allow all of them to join that guild.
Same for the Main Quest and Knights of the Nine storyline.

Now onto the MAGE vs. WARRIOR fight.
There's been a lot of discussion about it, but it's 100% clear that the Mage will win.
The Warrior has no ranged attack. He cannot cast spells or use a bow. He must get close to the Mage in order to attack him. He can use poisons and potions but just like the Mage/Thief, there are limitations for this.
He'll try to charge to the Mage, that's honestly the only thing he can do.
The Mage has all the time he want. He simply boosts his Speed stat and walks away from the Warrior. Simple as that. In the meantime, he turns invisible, raises his health, runs around the Warrior and hits him in the back with a nasty Destruction spell. Round over.

MAGE vs. THIEF
The Thief can only use ranged attacks, with his bow. He's quite a nasty enemy for the Mage, because he'll use poison attacks.
However, the Mage can summon a bow, is allowed to have arrows and can do exactly the same.
And he can do even more: he has a lot of spells to react on the Thief's actions.
He can also just block and spam dozens of fireballs and kill the Thief.

Potion/poison limitations - We can't allow the Mage/Thief/Warrior to have 200 Strong Potions of Health, 100 Strong Potions of Invisibility etc.
IMO, the Mage would be the only one who's allowed to use potions because he has Alchemy.
But if we do allow the Thief/Warrior to use potions, there's some kind of maximum, like 40 Potions in total.
This means, of course, that the Thief/Warrior can use a Strong Potion of Invisibility and a Strong Potion of Detect Life.
The Mage can do exactly the same.
And the fact that the Mage will win, is because he has one other weapon. His Magicka.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
Aces Andre
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:17 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Location: Norway

Post by Aces Andre »

Actually I don't think guilds should be included. They are entirely optional in this game. No mage has to be in the Mage's guild (mine rarely is), nor do the thief and warrior have to be in their respective guilds.

Also, rather than dictate what the settings for this competition are, you should suggest and gain approval for them. If we can agree on appropriate stats, equipment and so on, that will make this easier to decide. Rather than some saying "he does have this" and the rest saying "he doesn't".

Personally I think you'd be better off not choosing a race, and giving them 40 in each stat except luck (50), plus whatever class bonuses (willpower and intelligence for the mage, agility and speed for the thief and endurance and strength for the warrior). And of course their matching birthsigns. This makes them all rather equal on the starting level, and doesn't grant them any racial abilities, because any race can be anything in this game.

That's my suggestion for a balanced starting point, what do you think?

PS: I'm curious how you figured out the health for thief and mage when they would not be increasing endurance, at least not by +5 modifiers, due to them not raising skills that involve endurance.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

If we compare these characters at level 30, it seems logical the Thief/Mage also raise other attributes like Endurance.

But Oblivion is a game. This comparison is between actual, possible in-game characters. Not thought up characters who, in theory, all have 40 in every attribute.

I don't want to sound mean or something ;) I'm glad you participate in this discussion, just like everybody else. Sometimes it's interesting to read someone else's opinion/idea.

You can say:

Put the Warrior, Thief and Mage in an arena. This will result in 3 1vs1 battles. The Warrior has full Steel, the Thief has full Leather and the Mage has a robe and a hood. Each character will receive some random potions and the Mage has a few random spells. The Thief gets a bow and the Warrior a sword. That's it.

And still the Mage will win. Because he'll be faster than the Warrior.
In theory, he can have the same potions as the Thief, but he has spells to compensate his actions, and so he will win that fight too.

Warrior vs. Thief, Thief will win, because he's faster than the Warrior.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

If it were me designing the fight I would do this:

-They all have lvl 100 in there skill/attributes and level 20 (mage/theif have to stay at 50 endurance)

-Mage has mage birthsign, warrior has warrior birthsign, theif has theif birthsign.

-There is no set race so no gains from this

-Warrior gets full deadric with his choice of weapons (2h or 1h + sheild). He can chose 3 weapons (sheild not included as weapon) incase of breaks.

-Mage gets hood and robe, access to 10 spells (that can be bought from vendors) and 3 scrolls.

-Theif gets full glass with deadric bow/arrows (300).

-The warrior gets 5 potions of his choice (all strong), the mage gets 5 potions and 5 custom potions (made with master equipement) and the theif gets 5 potions of his choice (all strong) and 3 poisons (all strong, no custom).

Also no enchants for anyone.

Battles: 3 1vs1 and 1 1vs1vs1 battle. All the battles take place in the arena
Locked