I'm getting tired of this. Seriously, read the entire thread before taking conclusions!
That is partly my point, they're much higher than level 10. With 50 on everything it's closer to level 10, with 100 on everything it's closer to level 30. By having 100 and level 10 you put the mage at an advantage because the warrior looses atleast 200hp from what he would have at level 30.
The Warrior starts with 65 Endurance.
Level 2 - 70 End
Level 3 - 75 End
Level 4 - 80 End
Level 5 - 85 End
Level 6 - 90 End
Level 7 - 95 End
Level 8 - 100 End
etc.
Level 30 - 100 End
Starting health: 130
Health at level 2: 137
Health at level 3: 144
Health at level 4: 152
Health at level 5: 160
Health at level 6: 169
Health at level 7: 178
Health at level 8: 188
Health at level 9: 198
Health at level 30: 408
The Mage/Thief start with 30 Endurance.
Level 2 - 35 End
Level 3 - 40 End
Level 4 - 45 End
Level 5 - 50 End
Level 6 - 55 End
Level 7 - 60 End
Level 8 - 65 End
Level 9 - 70 End
Level 10 - 75 End
Level 11 - 80 End
Level 12 - 85 End
Level 13 - 90 End
Level 14 - 95 End
Level 15 - 100 End
etc.
Level 30 - 100 End
Starting health: 60
Health at level 2: 63
Health at level 3: 67
Health at level 4: 71
Health at level 5: 76
Health at level 6: 81
Health at level 7: 87
Health at level 8: 93
Health at level 9: 100
Health at level 10: 107
Health at level 11: 115
Health at level 12: 123
Health at level 13: 132
Health at level 14: 141
Health at level 15: 151
Health at level 30: 361
So the Warrior has 47 more Health points than the Mage/Thief.
The Warrior looses around 200HP but the Mage/Thief approximately 150HP, so that's not a big difference.
At level 10 (with the Mage/Thief not allowed to raise their Endurance attribute), the Warrior already has more health than the Thief/Mage.
I picked level 10 because at that point, the Thief, Mage and Warrior have maxed their favored attributes. It would be unrealistic to have a level 30 Mage/Warrior/Thief battle, because level 30 characters also level up other attributes, and we can't allow them to raise different attributes (like the Mage who raises his Endurance stat) because that makes it impossible to compare them fairly.
You can say that they level up all their attributes with +2/+3 bonuses, so they're 100 at level 30. This makes for exactly the same situation, except that everyone has a bit more health and the Warrior has a bit more health than the Mage/Thief. I find this to be unfair, but even in this situation, the Mage will win both fights.
1 No race has been assigned, we must therefore assume that we have no magicka bonus from it.
I've posted a while back that the Mage is a Breton, the Thief an Argonian/Wood Elf and the Warrior a Nord/Redguard.
So the Mage gets a +50 Magicka bonus.
2 No birthsign has been assigned, but it is logical that each of the three prime classes will use the sign of the same name, therefore we can assume that we have a +50 bonus (up for discussion).
See ^. The Mage has the Mage birthsign, the Warrior the Warrior birthsign and the Thief the Thief birthsign
3 No equipment has been assigned, therefore we assume base equipment without enchantments, therefore we do not have superbuffed clothing with +magicka.
This has also been discussed. All characters have access to level 10+ items. Only Mages can enchant items. Warriors can wear the Umbra armor. So Mages can enchant items with Fortify Magicka (but they can't get Transcendent Sigil Stones because they're level 10).
And then we have to ask ourselves a few questions about spells. Are we allowed to buy spells, are we allowed to create our own spells, none of this seems to have been decided. Personally I don't see why we should be allowed to make custom spells, a mage is not by default a member of the Mage's guild and therefore doesn't necessarily have access to a spellmaking altar. But we should be able to buy spells, there is no requirement for that apart from money (unless people want to make buying items exclusive to the thief, in which case the warrior and mage are possibly rather screwed)
Every class may only use his major skills with the one exception of Athletics. This has been discussed a lot.
So the Warrior is the only one who may wear Heavy Armor, with the exception of Bound Armor summoned by the Mage.
The Thief is the only one who may wear Light Armor.
The Mage may only wear clothes.
The Mage is the only one who can create his own spells (only he has access to the Arcane University, and he's a mage after all) and he's the only one who can use spells and that means buying them.
But the Thief is the only one who can join the Thieves Guild and earn items there and the Warrior can join the Fighters Guild.
The Dark Brotherhood doesn't really fit in, this guild is suited for Warriors, Mages and Thieves, so perhaps we should allow all of them to join that guild.
Same for the Main Quest and Knights of the Nine storyline.
Now onto the MAGE vs. WARRIOR fight.
There's been a lot of discussion about it, but it's 100% clear that the Mage will win.
The Warrior has no ranged attack. He cannot cast spells or use a bow. He must get close to the Mage in order to attack him. He can use poisons and potions but just like the Mage/Thief, there are limitations for this.
He'll try to charge to the Mage, that's honestly the only thing he can do.
The Mage has all the time he want. He simply boosts his Speed stat and walks away from the Warrior. Simple as that. In the meantime, he turns invisible, raises his health, runs around the Warrior and hits him in the back with a nasty Destruction spell. Round over.
MAGE vs. THIEF
The Thief can only use ranged attacks, with his bow. He's quite a nasty enemy for the Mage, because he'll use poison attacks.
However, the Mage can summon a bow, is allowed to have arrows and can do exactly the same.
And he can do even more: he has a lot of spells to react on the Thief's actions.
He can also just block and spam dozens of fireballs and kill the Thief.
Potion/poison limitations - We can't allow the Mage/Thief/Warrior to have 200 Strong Potions of Health, 100 Strong Potions of Invisibility etc.
IMO, the Mage would be the only one who's allowed to use potions because he has Alchemy.
But if we do allow the Thief/Warrior to use potions, there's some kind of maximum, like 40 Potions in total.
This means, of course, that the Thief/Warrior can use a Strong Potion of Invisibility and a Strong Potion of Detect Life.
The Mage can do exactly the same.
And the fact that the Mage will win, is because he has one other weapon. His Magicka.