Questions regarding Necromancy and Enchanting
Questions regarding Necromancy and Enchanting
Hi. I have two things I've been wondering about:
1) I want to make a set of enchanted clothes (shirt, pants, gauntlets, two shoes, two rings, a necklace, etc) I can wear to make me run fast, which I will use to zoom around Oblivion (I find closing gates is much simpler when you don't stop to fight). Will I get better results enchanting them with Speed, or Athletics? Assume I have both stats at 100. I tried figuring this out from the movement formulas page but didn't really get it.
2) Throughout the Mage's Guild story, you're reminded about how bad and immoral Necromancy is. Yet from what I can tell, the practice involves summoning undead things (which itself doesn't seem to be banned by the guild), and hanging out in caves with corpses (which is creepy to say the least, but not itself wrong). Why specifically was Necromancy banned?
1) I want to make a set of enchanted clothes (shirt, pants, gauntlets, two shoes, two rings, a necklace, etc) I can wear to make me run fast, which I will use to zoom around Oblivion (I find closing gates is much simpler when you don't stop to fight). Will I get better results enchanting them with Speed, or Athletics? Assume I have both stats at 100. I tried figuring this out from the movement formulas page but didn't really get it.
2) Throughout the Mage's Guild story, you're reminded about how bad and immoral Necromancy is. Yet from what I can tell, the practice involves summoning undead things (which itself doesn't seem to be banned by the guild), and hanging out in caves with corpses (which is creepy to say the least, but not itself wrong). Why specifically was Necromancy banned?
- Lunarsweets
- Champion

- Posts: 898
- Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2007 5:56 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Daggerfall
- Platform: Teh Box of Xitude. Also the 'puter.
- Status: UESP (Un-)Official Date-keeper.
- Location: The Archives.
I didn't read num. 1..
But for number two, Necromancy was mostly banned for the reasons that people would bring creature back to life. Summoning undead things is a strtch off of Conjuration, so people wouldn't count it Necromancy(I think they should..I stick with Deadra myself) But, yeah, that's basically why..the banning of necromancy in a can...
But for number two, Necromancy was mostly banned for the reasons that people would bring creature back to life. Summoning undead things is a strtch off of Conjuration, so people wouldn't count it Necromancy(I think they should..I stick with Deadra myself) But, yeah, that's basically why..the banning of necromancy in a can...
...and diplomacy continues to fail. Their ears fall deaf, and their eyes fall blind, yet they are still not mute. They will not know their errors. Only what they believe themselves. But we... we shall not be silenced.
-
Deathmist
- Warder

- Posts: 518
- Joined: Sat Apr 05, 2008 12:34 am
- ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
- Platform: PC, PS3
Re: Questions regarding Necromancy and Enchanting
If you don't want Feather, then I think that Speed would be better.Chintzy wrote: 1) I want to make a set of enchanted clothes (shirt, pants, gauntlets, two shoes, two rings, a necklace, etc) I can wear to make me run fast, which I will use to zoom around Oblivion (I find closing gates is much simpler when you don't stop to fight). Will I get better results enchanting them with Speed, or Athletics? Assume I have both stats at 100. I tried figuring this out from the movement formulas page but didn't really get it.
Sorry, I don't really know how to answer the other question.
- Sir Frederick Chook
- Apprentice

- Posts: 117
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 10:27 am
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: MELBOURNE
- Contact:
I don't think it is ever stated directly why necromancy is banned. It is however implied that necromancers need live victims and thats why it was stopped.
Summoning the undead and ghosts seems to be tolerated. Hence why you can do it and not get kicked out of the guild. It's doing things that involve living human souls that they want to stop. Like the black soul gems, as well as some back story quests like the Anvil house quest. Most of the necromancer lairs have remains of freshly killed people
Summoning the undead and ghosts seems to be tolerated. Hence why you can do it and not get kicked out of the guild. It's doing things that involve living human souls that they want to stop. Like the black soul gems, as well as some back story quests like the Anvil house quest. Most of the necromancer lairs have remains of freshly killed people
- Deandra
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1746
- Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2007 10:18 pm
- ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion
- Platform: PC
- UESPoints: 6
- Location: Seattle, WA
As to whether speed or athletics is better:
Both can be raised to 255 (unlike most skills, athletics isn't capped at 100) so that doesn't change your decision.
Speed affects running, walking, sneaking, swimming, and jump height.
Athletics affects running, sneak-running, and swimming. It doesn't affect jump height or walking.
Increasing your base athletics skills will increase your fatigue regeneration (as you gain the passive apprentice/journeyman/etc perks) but enchantments will not affect this. Anyway, since you said you're already at 100, you should have the mastery perk.
So in short speed > athletics
Both can be raised to 255 (unlike most skills, athletics isn't capped at 100) so that doesn't change your decision.
Speed affects running, walking, sneaking, swimming, and jump height.
Athletics affects running, sneak-running, and swimming. It doesn't affect jump height or walking.
Increasing your base athletics skills will increase your fatigue regeneration (as you gain the passive apprentice/journeyman/etc perks) but enchantments will not affect this. Anyway, since you said you're already at 100, you should have the mastery perk.
So in short speed > athletics
- Caldyn_Blade
- Champion

- Posts: 814
- Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2008 8:29 pm
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: Florida: land of dangling chads and amorous teachers
- Oathbreaker
- Guardian

- Posts: 712
- Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
- UESPoints: 0
The cut and dried answer for Necromancy being banned is that it seems like all cultures of Tamriel highly frown upon disrespecting the dead and desecrating their tombs and corpses by re-animating the bodies for (obviously) use as servants.
It's just like how grave-robbing is (I think) illegal just about EVERYWHERE.
Now, taking into account that nobody likes their dead ancestors being disrespected or desecrated, if Necromancers re-animated the body AND resurrected the proper soul belonging to that body (along with some youth perks- nobody wants a stinky rotting half-torn-apart-by-time body) then it might be slightly more acceptable (after a few centuries; the initial shock to man, mer, and divinity that the dead could be properly resurrected by masses of people at a time could be enough to altogether cause an insurrection directed at eradicating knowledge of how to do it).
It's just like how grave-robbing is (I think) illegal just about EVERYWHERE.
Now, taking into account that nobody likes their dead ancestors being disrespected or desecrated, if Necromancers re-animated the body AND resurrected the proper soul belonging to that body (along with some youth perks- nobody wants a stinky rotting half-torn-apart-by-time body) then it might be slightly more acceptable (after a few centuries; the initial shock to man, mer, and divinity that the dead could be properly resurrected by masses of people at a time could be enough to altogether cause an insurrection directed at eradicating knowledge of how to do it).
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
- Sir Frederick Chook
- Apprentice

- Posts: 117
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 10:27 am
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: MELBOURNE
- Contact:


