Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fifth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Old Greg
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Dec 29, 2010 7:18 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim, Daggerfall
Platform: PC
Location: New Zealand

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Old Greg »

@SajuukKhar
Not necessarly, it is possable the AD could win the war, in which case we would have a rebelion turing into a civil war situation. I could see it now the hero's name could be the the rebel, or the Prisoner :D but evn in this case it would still end with the AD ultimitly losing. What do mean by There couldn't be a ES game period because Tamriel, Nirn, and Mundus would be gone? You don't mean that Business about the Towers do you?
I there, Pleased to meet ya... What you doing in my waters?
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

Old Greg wrote:@SajuukKhar
Not necessarly, it is possable the AD could win the war, in which case we would have a rebelion turing into a civil war situation. I could see it now the hero's name could be the the rebel, or the Prisoner :D but evn in this case it would still end with the AD ultimitly losing. What do mean by There couldn't be a ES game period because Tamriel, Nirn, and Mundus would be gone? You don't mean that Business about the Towers do you?
The Aldmeri Dominion's goals is the utter annihilation of Talos, who is Lorkhan reborn, and the removal of man not only from the mortal realm, but from all possibility itself.

After Talos, and the sons of Talos, are gone they will unbind the time dragon removing his hold on linear time causing everything to go back to how it was in the dawn era.

Tamriel, Nirn, and even Mundus itself, will be gone, there will be only Oblivion, Atherius, and The Void.
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
Br3admax
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 3904
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 3:32 pm
ES Games: I-V
Platform: PS3, PC
Location: The line between radiance and shadow

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Br3admax »

SajuukKhar wrote:
Old Greg wrote:@SajuukKhar
Not necessarly, it is possable the AD could win the war, in which case we would have a rebelion turing into a civil war situation. I could see it now the hero's name could be the the rebel, or the Prisoner :D but evn in this case it would still end with the AD ultimitly losing. What do mean by There couldn't be a ES game period because Tamriel, Nirn, and Mundus would be gone? You don't mean that Business about the Towers do you?
The Aldmeri Dominion's goals is the utter annihilation of Talos, who is Lorkhan reborn, and the removal of man not only from the mortal realm, but from all possibility itself.

After Talos, and the sons of Talos, are gone they will unbind the time dragon removing his hold on linear time causing everything to go back to how it was in the dawn era.

Tamriel, Nirn, and even Mundus itself, will be gone, there will be only Oblivion, Atherius, and The Void.
If the Thalmor had there way we would all sit in Gray Nothing-ness
Justice knight wrote:Oh and listen to Br3ad he speaks wisdom.
User avatar
Mefris Elmek
Master
Master
Posts: 1135
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2011 6:18 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion GOTY, Arena, Skyrim + DLCs ,Battlespire,Redguard
Platform: PC,PS3
Status: Reading...
Location: The Imperial Library or The Arcaneum

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Mefris Elmek »

SajuukKhar wrote: -Not an excuse at all, even if Skyrim was going through the worst famine, or the most brutal plague, in all of Tamrielic history, there is no excuse for forcing your peoples to live in such poverty.
-It isn't within the steward's power to allow the Argonians into the city or not, that is something Uflric has to do.
-That isn't the steward's job either, Ulfric is supposed to make sure his hold is safe, war or not.
-Again, totally irrelevant, war, or famine, or plague, the Jarl is supposed to make sure the people of his city are safe.
-That was based on someone elses comment that Ulfric wasn't too stupid to stop trading with The Empire.
~Everyone is doing poorly regardless of race,still,the Dunmer are under Jarl Ulfric's protection and they are excused from paying taxes.
-Oh yes it is.You can't wage a war and worry about someone's stolen sheep or about potential spies on the homefront.You think Tulius goes around giving food to the people or helping farmers fight off bandits?Of course not.He has to fight a war.
-^
-No,it's totally relevant.Who do you go to for information or when you have finished the investigation?Yeah...the steward.
-It's a no brainer.What government would provide trade with it's rebels and vice versa?
Sajuuk wrote:The thing is though, history shows The Thalmor weren't doing jack [&@%!] until Ulfric made a big deal and started doing his Stormclock shiz. It's made abundantly clear, by MANY people, that they were still able to worship Talos, and live their normal lives without fear of being dragged off into the night. That is until Ulfric came, started being an idiot, and let The Thalmor use their powers to drag people off.
History shows diddly squat.How would any of the those people know if the Thalmor were killing Talos worshippers?
Also I find it funny you blame me of scapegoating, when you were doing THE EXACT SAME THING, further up in your post with the Jarl's steward. You entirely ignored the fact that even IF Ulfric was too busy wit the war to help his people, which he obviously isn't because he sits around all day. it's his job to make sure a competent person does it for him, and if the person he hires isn't doing his job then he should be fired and replaced with someone who will. The steward's inaction, although most of the things you claim the steward should be handling are obviously out of his power, can be laid almost soley at the feet of Ulfric for not hiring a man who can get the job done, and not making sure the man he hired is doing his job.
Which is EXACTLY what Tulius is doing.I will not repeat myself for the billionth time the evidence is there,you choose if you can see it.
So the problems of Eastmarch, are still, and always have been, Ulfric's fault, because he is a terrible leader who can't manage his own hold, and who can't get people to manage his own hold for him. He's a double failure.
:roll Of course.
Sajuuk wrote: A fine example of a person living in a city of intolerance because the Jarl, and his appointed peoples, do nothing but help themselves, and let it happen. Had Ulfirc not been such a racist bigot, Rolff might not have turned out the way he is.
Hm,funny,I consider you a fine example of a person that could never become an attorney.Why?Because you keep tossing around allegations based on circumstantial evidence or no evidence whatsoever.Give me one quote of Ulfric being a racist.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Conversation between Galmar and Ulfric :
U="Tell me Galmar,why do you fight for me?"
G="I'd follow you into the dephts of Oblivion,you know that."
U="Yes,but why do you fight?If not for me,what then?"
G="I'd die before elves get to dictate the fates of men!Are we not one in this?"
U="I fight for the men I've held in my arms, dying on foreign soil! I fight for their wives and children, whose names I heard whispered in their last breath!I fight for we few who did come home,only to find our country overrun with strangers wearing familiar faces!I fight so that all the fighting I've already done hasn't been for nothing! I fight... because I must."
Yup,he's a racist son of a [&@%!] alright.
Yep because that obviously BS propaganda is such a fine example of how he really is.
Instead Ulfric has go to all dumb on them, start a frivolous civil war over rights that he only really lost on paper,
:shock: :shock: :shock: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: I rest my case.
Talk to Alvor after escaping Helgen, he confirmed that before Uflric started making a big deal of this people could worship Talos in their own home,and be known worshipers of Talos, without having to fear being dragged off.
Hm,thats horse [&@%!] and you know it.
Why does it mater if they cant for 20-30 years?
I'm guessing you never fought for something you believed in because if did you wouldn't have said something so stupid.Fight for freedom or stay with a chain around your neck for 30 years?Decisions,decisions ...
~ ~ ~
Stormcloak and Dunmer Lover of the UESP Forums
~ ~ ~
Right-Hand-Of-Sithis
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 226
Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2012 8:04 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Right-Hand-Of-Sithis »

An interesting topic.

I would have to question the forces of the Empire given in the first post. The novels are set approx 200 years before Skyrim, and following the Great War, it is stated that the Empire didn't even have any legions at half strength. However, in the 30 years since the War, it is likely that the Empire has recovered some forces (given a new generation).

Furthermore, we do not know the capacity of the Imperial Treasury. Following the Great War, the Empire's Treasury would have been all but extinguished (as is common with wars of such severity), and as such, it is quite possible that the Empire downsized its forces. It is also likely that the Cyrodiilic infrastructure was destroyed in the war, and is only just recovering now.

Tullius also states that he was only given "a bare handful of Legions". While it is inevitable that the Empire needs its forces on the Borders with the Dominion, it does indicate that the Empire does not have such a grand force.

On the issue of populations, I don't think we can estimate the populations of provinces from the games alone. There are variables such as the size of the game, if the developers were rushed etc. However, I do believe that Skyrim's population would be limited for geographical reasons. And Oblivion only had 886 NPCs including guards (not 2000).

Furthermore, it is known (through Cicero) that Cyrodiil is in chaos. His journals directly state Bravil has erupted into violence, it imply that CHeydinal has followed suit, it is likely that Bruma is following in the footsteps of Skyrim, and it is likely that the rest of the Cyrodiilic cities are effected. It is also known that the city of Wayrest has been sacked by corsairs, and knowing High Rock, it has likely fallen back to its strong feudal system, and as such, it would be plagued by infighting.

Now on to the practical side of my argument.

I believe that, in the event of a Thalmor offensive, Hammerfell and Skyrim would unite. I base this off the saying "my enemies enemy is my friend' and history-both real, and Tamrielic.

For example, in WW2, the USSR and the Western allies were in a standoff. However, they had both united with in the face of fascism (only to enter into the cold war later). If such mortal enemies could unite, why can't Skyrim and Hammerfell unite?

In Tamriel, the Cyrodiilics united against the Akaviri (the Army of Reman) while during the Interregnum, Skyrim, Morrowind and Black Marsh all signed the Ebonheart Pact (ES Online). These three nations ahd been at war for thousands of years, and allied knowing it was the only way to defend themselves. Again, in light of this historical evidence, why wouldn't Hammerfell and Skyrim unite?

As pointed out, any invasion into Skyrim would stretch the Thalmor's supply lines. Not only that, to invade Skyrim by land, they would be forced to occupy the lands they annex in order to keep it. This would put a huge strain on the available forces of the Dominion, and, if the forces of man got the upper side, it would be likely that the citizens of any occupied lands would revolt (Warsaw in WW2) putting further strain on the Thalmor's forces.

And my opinion on tactics.

In the event of a Stormcloak victory in Skyrim, I would move that Skyrim takes control of Bruma. This could be achieved through direct military annexation, or preferably through insurrection in the mainly Nord population of that city. This would act as a Bulwark for Skyrim proper, securing Pale Pass and forcing any Imperial or Thalmor force to climb the mountains leading to Bruma.

In the event of an Imperial victory, I would heavily fortify Skingrad, Bravil and Leyawiin, and place reserves in the Imperial City, Kvatch and Bruma. However, this relies on the ammount of available soldiers and the cost to maintain them. I would also promote relations with Hammerfell while also using any avaliable forces (the reserves if necessary) to force order in the cities of Cyrodiil.
Resident Marxist of the UESP
The Void and the Webspinner: The Shrouded War. A mod aiming to expand on Skyrim's Dark Brotherhood questline.

http://sdbm.userboard.net/
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

Mefris Elmek wrote: ~Everyone is doing poorly regardless of race,still,the Dunmer are under Jarl Ulfric's protection and they are excused from paying taxes.
-Oh yes it is.You can't wage a war and worry about someone's stolen sheep or about potential spies on the homefront.You think Tulius goes around giving food to the people or helping farmers fight off bandits?Of course not.He has to fight a war.
-^
-No,it's totally relevant.Who do you go to for information or when you have finished the investigation?Yeah...the steward.
-It's a no brainer.What government would provide trade with it's rebels and vice versa?
-Except on The Empire's side, all races seem to be doing well there.
-Tullius isn't the Jarl of Solitude, Elisif is, so it isn't his job, and Falk Firebeard, the person Elisif hired, actually seems to get stuff done, and showed more active involvement in the Wolfskull cave issue then Ulfric's steward did about the murders.
-Ditto.
-About a serial killer plaguing the streets? I would ask to see the Jarl, the person wo is in command, and should be the one making sure stuff about it gets done.
-I know, but I was responding to someone else's post on the hypothetical that "Ulfric isn't that Dumb", I dont think he would either.
Mefris Elmek wrote:History shows diddly squat.How would any of the those people know if the Thalmor were killing Talos worshippers?
I dont know, maybe because people weren't being dragged off into the streets at night, and known Talos worshipers weren't mysteriously disappearing for seemingly no reason. The lack of random disappearances, and Thalmor hit-squads roaming around, gives good credence to the fact that they weren't there doing stuff.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Which is EXACTLY what Tulius is doing.I will not repeat myself for the billionth time the evidence is there,you choose if you can see it.
Fun fact, Tullius is not the Jarl of Solitude, it isn't his job.

Also Tullius spends all day in the castle around his war map talking the Rekkete. After that first time entering into Ulfric's castle, and after he gives his speech, he just sits in his chair. Tullius does more active war planning then Ulfirc does.
Mefris Elmek wrote: :roll Of course.
Yeah, it actually is his fault. It's his hold, it's his problems, he has failed to take care of his problems himself, or get someone who can. The fault lies on him.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Hm,funny,I consider you a fine example of a person that could never become an attorney.Why?Because you keep tossing around allegations based on circumstantial evidence or no evidence whatsoever.Give me one quote of Ulfric being a racist.
All you have to do is look at how he treats his people.
Mefris Elmek wrote: :shock: :shock: :shock: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: I rest my case.
Your very poorly though out case, that relies on silly comparisons.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Hm,thats horse [&@%!] and you know it.
How is it horse [&@%!]? The game hammers in from several people that what they said is true.
Mefris Elmek wrote: I'm guessing you never fought for something you believed in because if did you wouldn't have said something so stupid.Fight for freedom or stay with a chain around your neck for 30 years?Decisions,decisions ...
I actually have fought for something I believed in.

And you know what, I am not so vain, and self-centered, as to plunge my nation into a civil war, weakening both sides against the overall threat, over something I would have gotten anyways.

I would have some sympathy for Ulfric's cause if there was nothing in the works to undo the WGC, and there was no hope of freedom any time in the immediate future, but there are, Ulfric is just acting like a spoiled brat who wants his cookies done faster.
Last edited by SajuukKhar on Sun Jul 08, 2012 2:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
Derp53
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2391
Joined: Sun Mar 04, 2012 7:26 pm
ES Games: Skyim, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Idon't have 888 posts anymore, but I do have cake

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Derp53 »

@Sajuukhar- i'd promised my self i'd pull out of this debate earlier but i have to point out that alot of your points are disputable like the treatment of his people. Also Ulfric is smarter than he looks, if you ever completed the civil war questline on the stormcloak side and ask why Falk Firebeard why Ulfric didn't have Elisif killed then his answer will surprise you. He calls it a clever POLITICAL move by Ulfric.

-Another thing i cannot stress enough is that nords in general don't like being ruled by the weak(empire) the white gold concordat was the same crap the that the thalmor had pushed in the empire's face at the start of the war not to mention the imperial government is filled with pompous noble fops who are waaaaay to conceited for their own good.
HatofMadness wrote:To protect the forums from devastation.
To unite all members within our nation.
To denounce the evils of truth and love.
Until our post count reaches the stars above.
Spoiler:
Musicman247 wrote: I don't suck, I blow.
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

derp53 wrote:@Sajuukhar- i'd promised my self i'd pull out of this debate earlier i have to point out that alot of your points are disputable like the treatment of his people. Also Ulfric is smarter than he looks, if you ever completed the civil war questline on the stormcloak side and ask why Falk Firebeard why Ulfric didn't have Elisif killed then his answer will surprise you. He calls it a clever POLITICAL move by Ulfric.

-Another thing i cannot stress enough is that nords in general don't like being ruled by the weak(empire) the white gold concordat was the same crap the that the thalmor had pushed in the empire's face at the start of the war not to mention the imperial government is filled with pompous noble fops who are waaaaay to conceited for their own good.
He's still pretty dumb overall though. even the biggest idiots can have their moments of clarity. Tullius did outsmart him, leading to his capture, and his destiny/prophecy gotten in the way, Ulfric would be dead.

Actually, the general opinion of most NPCs in the game is "they really dont care either way". The actual number of NPCs that show any strong hate for one side or the other is limited. You have an ass empire, and an ass rebellion, for most people its "just another day".
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
Derp53
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2391
Joined: Sun Mar 04, 2012 7:26 pm
ES Games: Skyim, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Idon't have 888 posts anymore, but I do have cake

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Derp53 »

SajuukKhar wrote:
derp53 wrote:@Sajuukhar- i'd promised my self i'd pull out of this debate earlier i have to point out that alot of your points are disputable like the treatment of his people. Also Ulfric is smarter than he looks, if you ever completed the civil war questline on the stormcloak side and ask why Falk Firebeard why Ulfric didn't have Elisif killed then his answer will surprise you. He calls it a clever POLITICAL move by Ulfric.

-Another thing i cannot stress enough is that nords in general don't like being ruled by the weak(empire) the white gold concordat was the same crap the that the thalmor had pushed in the empire's face at the start of the war not to mention the imperial government is filled with pompous noble fops who are waaaaay to conceited for their own good.
He's still pretty dumb overall though. even the biggest idiots can have their moments of clarity. Tullius did outsmart him, leading to his capture, and his destiny/prophecy gotten in the way, Ulfric would be dead.

Actually, the general opinion of most NPCs in the game is "they really dont care either way". The actual number of NPCs that show any strong hate for one side or the other is limited.
if Ulfric is completely dumb then give me a situation outside of Eastmarch that proves Ulfric's incompetency and how thats worse than having multiple courts of corrupt and useless nobles that have probably been bought by the Aldmeri Dominion, i hate puppet governments and thats what the empire made itself when Titus Mede signed the WGC
HatofMadness wrote:To protect the forums from devastation.
To unite all members within our nation.
To denounce the evils of truth and love.
Until our post count reaches the stars above.
Spoiler:
Musicman247 wrote: I don't suck, I blow.
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

derp53 wrote:if Ulfric is completely dumb then give me a situation outside of Eastmarch that proves Ulfric's incompetency and how thats worse than having multiple courts of corrupt and useless nobles that have probably been bought by the Aldmeri Dominion, i hate puppet governments and thats what the empire made itself when Titus Mede signed the WGC
Well lets see, there is the fact that within the few months that Tullius was leading The Empire's forces in Skyrim he was able to beat Uflric, capture him, and get within axe balde's reach of killing him.

There's the fact that all of his Jarls are idiots
-Jarl Korir is racist to Mer, and too busy blaming the college of Winterhold for [&@%!] they didn't do to be able to do anything at all. Maybe if he wasn't such a total ass to them they might help him out with some enchanted weapons?
-Jarl Skald is so blinded by the holyness of the cause that he is critically under-staffing his guard, leaving his city nearly defenseless
-Jarl Laila Law-Giver is a puppet, like a text box definition of puppetry.
-Jarl Ulfric himself, cant seem to manage his own hold.

On the other hand
-Siddger may be a spoiled brat, but at least he leaves his hold in the care of his apparently competent steward
-Idgrod tries to get her people tolerant ofo thers, and takes a more active role in solving the towns problems then most other Jarls
-Elisif isn't that great of a Jarl, but listens to the advice of her stewards and actually DID something about the Wolfskull cave problem, in that she sent more guards to protect the town.
-Igmund is blind to the corruption inside his city, but then again a super power crime faimly was making it impossible for him to do anythign about it, and he does take an active stance on fighting the forsworn menace.

Also Empire towns also manage to be FAR more tolerant.


Also how is The Empire a puppet government when during all the time they have been under the WGC they have been planning to kick the AD ass in the next war? A puppet government usually doesn't plan on killing the puppeteer, nor do leaders in puppet governments usually blatantly and forthrightly proclaim how much they hate their puppeteers.
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
Vigrtor Blood-Tears
Novice
Novice
Posts: 83
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2012 7:25 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Vigrtor Blood-Tears »

It's also implied that Torygg was taking what Ulfric had to say very seriously and was even thinking of siding with him. Ulfric jumped the gun big time.

It's a good thing my Stormcloak Dohvahkiin will either be able to smarten him up or kill him and blame Tullius, Tiber Septim style (depending).

Ulfric isn't totally un-sympathetic though. It's implied his irrational elf hate stems from the torture (both physical and mental, they basically lead him to believe he lost the Great War, so he probably feels the whole mess in Skyrim and elsewhere is his fault) The AD put him through.

So the only real answer is: ambiguity.
rpbraley868
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 640
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2011 12:17 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Location: NH-United States

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by rpbraley868 »

SajuukKhar wrote: Also how is The Empire a puppet government when during all the time they have been under the WGC they have been planning to kick the AD ass in the next war? A puppet government usually doesn't plan on killing the puppeteer, nor do leaders in puppet governments usually blatantly and forthrightly proclaim how much they hate their puppeteers.
Er where does it ever say that they have been planning against the AD? Thats pure speculation.

And how does the incompetence of those following Ulfric, make Ulfric incompetent? Dont get me wrong, i'm pro Empire, but I never found him lacking in care for his people or his leadership of them. As for not doing anything about the racism or letting Argoinians in and such, there are times where leaders must appease the masses despite their personal feelings. His people are angry at their beliefs being attacked, so they hate those that attacked them. They look for someone to blame for their problems and thus they blame outsiders and those different from them. As for affairs happening within the cities, well i believe thats the Stewards job, at least during war time. Ulfric has a war to worry about
User avatar
Mefris Elmek
Master
Master
Posts: 1135
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2011 6:18 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion GOTY, Arena, Skyrim + DLCs ,Battlespire,Redguard
Platform: PC,PS3
Status: Reading...
Location: The Imperial Library or The Arcaneum

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Mefris Elmek »

-Except on The Empire's side, all races seem to be doing well there.
-Tullius isn't the Jarl of Solitude, Elisif is, so it isn't his job, and Falk Firebeard, the person Elisif hired, actually seems to get stuff done, and showed more active involvement in the Wolfskull cave issue then Ulfric's steward did about the murders.
-Ditto.
-About a serial killer plaguing the streets? I would ask to see the Jarl, the person wo is in command, and should be the one making sure stuff about it gets done.
-Like the Khajit?They're doing well?Imperial?The war is affecting every race regardless of faction.
-Elisif isn't even in charge of her own bra,Tulius and her steward handle 90% of Solitude's affairs.Falk was more involved?Ha :lol: nonsense
-I wasn't asking what you'd do.
I dont know, maybe because people weren't being dragged off into the streets at night, and known Talos worshipers weren't mysteriously disappearing for seemingly no reason. The lack of random disappearances, and Thalmor hit-squads roaming around, gives good credence to the fact that they weren't there doing stuff.
And?What?The reason they didn't have a strong presence was probably because they were fighting in Hammerfell.Do you honestly believe the Thalmor would leave Talos worshippers alone for30 years?
Fun fact, Tullius is not the Jarl of Solitude, it isn't his job.

Also Tullius spends all day in the castle around his war map talking the Rekkete. After that first time entering into Ulfric's castle, and after he gives his speech, he just sits in his chair. Tullius does more active war planning then Ulfirc does.
(There must be a problem with your game because in mine he consults Galmar and he visits the war map daily).

Tulius is not the Jarl nor is he High King in title but that doesn't change the fact that he rules half of Skyrim(Solitude included).He was sent by the emperor to act as Dictator until the SC issue is resolved,not to stand hanging on a childs skirt until she decides to do this or that.
Yeah, it actually is his fault. It's his hold, it's his problems, he has failed to take care of his problems himself, or get someone who can. The fault lies on him.
He hasn't failed at anything.You on the other hand lack on the "proof" department.
All you have to do is look at how he treats his people.
With respect and love.Yes,I know.
Your very poorly though out case, that relies on silly comparisons.
Funny as always.You make it a habit of being a hypocrite when it goes downhill for you.Basically,you have nothing going on other then circumstantial evidence,biased opinions and unreliable sources.
Propaganda? :lol: Good grief that was a poor comeback.
I actually have fought for something I believed in.
:| Like what?CHIM?No,I mean fighting against an oppressive regime,racism,injustice etc.
I've been a victim and fought against all the things mentioned above (and then some) and I can honestly say you have no idea what you're talking about with the "30 years wait" remark.
And you know what, I am not so vain, and self-centered, as to plunge my nation into a civil war, weakening both sides against the overall threat, over something I would have gotten anyways.
You're missing the point about what it means to stand up for yourself.
He's still pretty dumb overall though.
I'd call that weak character judgement on your part.
Well lets see, there is the fact that within the few months that Tullius was leading The Empire's forces in Skyrim he was able to beat Uflric, capture him, and get within axe balde's reach of killing him.
Is that so?Could you link the article that has the specifics on that event?
Also Empire towns also manage to be FAR more tolerant.
:lol:
Also how is The Empire a puppet government when during all the time they have been under the WGC they have been planning to kick the AD ass in the next war?
:roll: Words,without Hammerfel and Skyrim the only thing the Empire can do is bend over.The Thalmor are present in every corner of the empire including the IC.Everyone dances to there tune.
It's implied his irrational elf hate stems from the torture
Irrational elf hate? :lol: Talos almighty.......where is this hate?Fan fiction?This forum?Because I can't find it in him (although he has every right to be resentful and angry).
~ ~ ~
Stormcloak and Dunmer Lover of the UESP Forums
~ ~ ~
User avatar
Vigrtor Blood-Tears
Novice
Novice
Posts: 83
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2012 7:25 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Vigrtor Blood-Tears »

Well he is unkind to the Dunmer (not full Hitler to them like some say, but he's definitely not doing everything he can or should.), and he isn't exactly polite about it either. However you can join the Stormcloaks as any race and he doesn't seem to have any condescending dialogue with elf PC's so it's ambiguous which is how bethesda wants it (if one side was clearly and completely righteous it wouldmake the descision of who to join easy.). It's also stated that things get barely any better for the Dunmer after Free-Winter takes over and he obviously cares about them so maybe there just isn't much the Jarl of Windhelm can do to improve their lives, or maybe Brunwulf is secretly an [&@%!] or just not cut out for Jarlin'.

Regardless Ulfric and Tullius actions can both be interpreted in a number of ways because ambiguity seems to be the theme of all the Dovahkiin's possible allies (aside from guilds, which are pretty straight forward).
User avatar
Br3admax
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 3904
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 3:32 pm
ES Games: I-V
Platform: PS3, PC
Location: The line between radiance and shadow

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Br3admax »

Why do people say Ulfric is Hitler-like, when that is clearly the Thalmor's job? And Ulfric will except anyone, even before he knows you are Dragonborn, hating the Empire is enough.
Justice knight wrote:Oh and listen to Br3ad he speaks wisdom.
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

Mefris Elmek wrote: -Like the Khajit?They're doing well?Imperial?The war is affecting every race regardless of faction.
-Elisif isn't even in charge of her own bra,Tulius and her steward handle 90% of Solitude's affairs.Falk was more involved?Ha :lol: nonsense
-I wasn't asking what you'd do.
-The Khajiit aren't part of The Empire, and even despite that, the Khajiit traders are, by thier own admission, making some serious cash off of the Nords. So yeah they are doing well.
-Actually Tullius handles nothing but the war, and yeah Falk, Elisif's steward, was more involved. He actually, in a visible manner, does his job.
-I think most people would ask to see the person who is supposed to be dealing with the situation also.
Mefris Elmek wrote:And?What?The reason they didn't have a strong presence was probably because they were fighting in Hammerfell.Do you honestly believe the Thalmor would leave Talos worshippers alone for30 years?
The Thalmor stopped fighting in Hammerfell 25 years before the start of the game. Ulfric's rebellion only started several months ago. There was a period of around 25 years were The Thalmor did relatively nothing.

Leaving Talos worshiper's alone most likely wasn't their choice, The Empire has shown that they marganilize the hell out of The Thalmor's presence making them sit in half dilapidated forts in the middle of nowhere. The Thalmor probably couldn't.
Mefris Elmek wrote:(There must be a problem with your game because in mine he consults Galmar and he visits the war map daily).
Actually there is a problem with most people's games in that the Jarls repeat their dialog that they are only supposed to give once over and over. Ulfric and Igmund suffer from the bug, which is why you hear the EXACT same speech happen over and over again.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Tulius is not the Jarl nor is he High King in title but that doesn't change the fact that he rules half of Skyrim(Solitude included).He was sent by the emperor to act as Dictator until the SC issue is resolved,not to stand hanging on a childs skirt until she decides to do this or that.
And yet the game itself shows that Tullius doesn't rule the hold's under The Empire's command, he just organizes the armies. The care of the holds is left to that hold's Jarl.
Mefris Elmek wrote:He hasn't failed at anything.You on the other hand lack on the "proof" department.
Except you know, half the people in Windhelm talking about it.
Mefris Elmek wrote:With respect and love.Yes,I know.
respect? love? are you really that delusional? all those Dunmer are getting SOOO much respect...
Mefris Elmek wrote: Funny as always.You make it a habit of being a hypocrite when it goes downhill for you.Basically,you have nothing going on other then circumstantial evidence,biased opinions and unreliable sources.
I apparently have more then you who ignores half of what everyone says in the game, or outright ignores what the jobs of certain peopel are.
Mefris Elmek wrote: :| Like what?CHIM?No,I mean fighting against an oppressive regime,racism,injustice etc.
I've been a victim and fought against all the things mentioned above (and then some) and I can honestly say you have no idea what you're talking about with the "30 years wait" remark.
Which is why your probably acting the way your are, your letting your own personal experiences delude the facts of the game, and if you had fought for something you were going to get anyways, I would still call you an idiot.
Mefris Elmek wrote:You're missing the point about what it means to stand up for yourself.
And your missing the point that standing up for yourself, and in the process destroying the one thing that has the best chance at stopping a world destroying evil, for something you were already going to get, is dumb.
Mefris Elmek wrote:I'd call that weak character judgement on your part.
Because not liking an idiotic Hitler wanna be is bad character judgement?
Mefris Elmek wrote:Is that so?Could you link the article that has the specifics on that event?
It's called Hadvar, talk to him after you get to Riverwood
Mefris Elmek wrote: :lol:
Typical, your standard "im gonna throw in a laughing icon instead of make an actual point because I have no counter point, response.
Mefris Elmek wrote:Words,without Hammerfel and Skyrim the only thing the Empire can do is bend over.The Thalmor are present in every corner of the empire including the IC.Everyone dances to there tune.
Really? could you link to the article that has the specifics of that event?

Because from all evidence presented in Skyrim, the thalmor are an exceedingly marginalized force that The Empire keeps in out-of-the-way locations so they dont have to bother them.

This "they infest every corner of The Empire" nonsense is something made up entirely in the minds of anti-Empire people, and has no real basis in any presented information.
Mefris Elmek wrote: Irrational elf hate? :lol: Talos almighty.......where is this hate?Fan fiction?This forum?Because I can't find it in him (although he has every right to be resentful and angry).
Real The Thalmor's dossior on Ulfric, it specifically mentions they tricked him into believing that info he gave them lead to the fall of the Imperial City.
Br3admax wrote:Why do people say Ulfric is Hitler-like, when that is clearly the Thalmor's job? And Ulfric will except anyone, even before he knows you are Dragonborn, hating the Empire is enough.
Ulfirc is like Hitler himself

The Thalmor are like the SS/The Nzai party as a whole.
Last edited by SajuukKhar on Mon Jul 09, 2012 3:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
Vigrtor Blood-Tears
Novice
Novice
Posts: 83
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2012 7:25 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Vigrtor Blood-Tears »

I think comparing him directly to Hitler is somewhat heavy handed. The Dunmer are not treated fairly or with the respect they deserve but they don't have it quite so bad as the Jews did in Nazi Germany. Ulfric is far from noble but I wouldn't say he's downright evil either. Like you say, he might just be stupid.
User avatar
SajuukKhar
Master
Master
Posts: 1245
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 11:09 am

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by SajuukKhar »

Vigrtor Blood-Tears wrote:I think comparing him directly to Hitler is somewhat heavy handed. The Dunmer are not treated fairly or with the respect they deserve but they don't have it quite so bad as the Jews did in Nazi Germany. Ulfric is far from noble but I wouldn't say he's downright evil either. Like you say, he might just be stupid.
True, but hes like Hitler, I wouldn't call him 100%, exactly the same, as Hitler.

But he is a great orator with obvious discrimination against races he doesn't like.

He's like Hitler-light.
So where is my dream? It is the continuation of reality. But where is my reality? It is at the end of your dream.
User avatar
philfredobob
Master
Master
Posts: 1305
Joined: Fri Dec 09, 2011 8:50 am
ES Games: Morrowind , Oblivion , Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: Sick and tired, tired and sick.
Location: Irbid, Jordan

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by philfredobob »

do you mean Hitler-Like ?
anyways , i wouldnt say ulfric is like hitler , hes a numpty , i'll give you that , but he doesnt try to kill the dunmer , he simply ignores them , and turns a blind eye to their problems , hes a scumbag , but hes no hitler :P
My Pokemon signature :
''I HAVE ARRIVED , AND I'M FABULOUS''
User avatar
Br3admax
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 3904
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 3:32 pm
ES Games: I-V
Platform: PS3, PC
Location: The line between radiance and shadow

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Br3admax »

Tulius turned the war around, but he didn't beat Ulfric. Ulfric was captured during a ambush by the Empire. Hadvar talks about how Tulius suprised Ulfric, he did not win the war beat him. Also I guess every single president in any country ever is also Hitler-lite, America has it's share of underpovershed citizens, and the government does nothing about that. And even Free-winter says Ulfric is a good leader. And making speeches really, when did rhetoric make you Hitler? In that case, every High School in the world is training Little Hitlers and Hitler-lites everyday of school. My entire Junior year of English was devoted to it, and I'm hardly a Hitler-in-training. Talking in an accent and making speeches does not make you a genocide crazed dictator.
Justice knight wrote:Oh and listen to Br3ad he speaks wisdom.
User avatar
Br3admax
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 3904
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 3:32 pm
ES Games: I-V
Platform: PS3, PC
Location: The line between radiance and shadow

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Br3admax »

philfredobob wrote:do you mean Hitler-Like ?
anyways , i wouldnt say ulfric is like hitler , hes a numpty , i'll give you that , but he doesnt try to kill the dunmer , he simply ignores them , and turns a blind eye to their problems , hes a scumbag , but hes no hitler :P
He means lite, as in a healthier less dangerous version.
Justice knight wrote:Oh and listen to Br3ad he speaks wisdom.
Right-Hand-Of-Sithis
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 226
Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2012 8:04 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Right-Hand-Of-Sithis »

Br3admax wrote:Also I guess every single president in any country ever is also Hitler-lite, America has it's share of underpovershed citizens, and the government does nothing about that. .
That's right. That's the reason why we need socialism, where the people seize power and the state is run by the people (or a vanguard, which answers directly to the people).

And before you ask. No, the USSR, China, DPRK etc were not communist or socialist. They were degenerated workers states (or state capitalist, depending on who you ask). I could explain this more, but I don't want to bore people.

And yes, that was completely off topic.
Resident Marxist of the UESP
The Void and the Webspinner: The Shrouded War. A mod aiming to expand on Skyrim's Dark Brotherhood questline.

http://sdbm.userboard.net/
User avatar
Br3admax
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 3904
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 3:32 pm
ES Games: I-V
Platform: PS3, PC
Location: The line between radiance and shadow

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Br3admax »

Socialism, IMO, would never work because it does noy inspire anyone to do better, you are already on top. Why would someone strive to be a doctor, or scientist, or even a teacher. Too much school for to little turn out. I could just as easily work in a gas station. Capitalism forces me to adapt, it makes me want to succeed. It makes me want to be up top, and makes me feel like I accomplished something for a reason. But lets get back on to the task at hand.
Justice knight wrote:Oh and listen to Br3ad he speaks wisdom.
Right-Hand-Of-Sithis
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 226
Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2012 8:04 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Contact:

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by Right-Hand-Of-Sithis »

Br3admax wrote:Socialism, IMO, would never work because it does noy inspire anyone to do better, you are already on top. Why would someone strive to be a doctor, or scientist, or even a teacher. Too much school for to little turn out. I could just as easily work in a gas station. Capitalism forces me to adapt, it makes me want to succeed. It makes me want to be up top, and makes me feel like I accomplished something for a reason. But lets get back on to the task at hand.
Most people have aspirations. And some people, because of family/financial background are unable to succeed.

And Lenin described socialism as "he who does not work, nor shall he eat". By the time we reach a purely communist society, the human mindset will be altered from a 'capitalist' one, to a 'communist' one.

Now, I'm sure many people have come to this page to witness a Stormcloak/Imperial debate, not a Capitalist/Communist debate.

If anyone wishes to discuss this with me, feel free to give me a PM.
Resident Marxist of the UESP
The Void and the Webspinner: The Shrouded War. A mod aiming to expand on Skyrim's Dark Brotherhood questline.

http://sdbm.userboard.net/
User avatar
philfredobob
Master
Master
Posts: 1305
Joined: Fri Dec 09, 2011 8:50 am
ES Games: Morrowind , Oblivion , Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: Sick and tired, tired and sick.
Location: Irbid, Jordan

Re: Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion

Post by philfredobob »

Vigrtor Blood-Tears wrote:Well he is unkind to the Dunmer (not full Hitler to them like some say, but he's definitely not doing everything he can or should.), and he isn't exactly polite about it either. However you can join the Stormcloaks as any race and he doesn't seem to have any condescending dialogue with elf PC's so it's ambiguous which is how bethesda wants it (if one side was clearly and completely righteous it wouldmake the descision of who to join easy.). It's also stated that things get barely any better for the Dunmer after Free-Winter takes over and he obviously cares about them so maybe there just isn't much the Jarl of Windhelm can do to improve their lives, or maybe Brunwulf is secretly an Anus or just not cut out for Jarlin'.
But brunwulf pays you out of his own gold to go and eliminate a group of bandits who raided a group of dunmer , he clearly cares for their wellbeing .
he simply doesnt manage anything upon becoming jarl because he JUST became jarl , and these things take time ( a few months, maybe)
My Pokemon signature :
''I HAVE ARRIVED , AND I'M FABULOUS''
Locked