What Skill is missing?
What Skill is missing?
If you could add any skill(s) to Oblivion, what would it be?
I would add a skill that lets you have a damage resistance without armor. With the 'Hand to Hand' skill you can do damage with no weapons. With the skill I would add(I haven't thought of a name) you could have a damage resistance with no armor.
I would add a skill that lets you have a damage resistance without armor. With the 'Hand to Hand' skill you can do damage with no weapons. With the skill I would add(I haven't thought of a name) you could have a damage resistance with no armor.
For once, I don't have a signature.
- Caldyn_Blade
- Champion

- Posts: 814
- Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2008 8:29 pm
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: Florida: land of dangling chads and amorous teachers
- Doctor Meaticus
- Champion

- Posts: 834
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 6:23 am
- ES Games: Oblivion and Skyrim.
- Platform: PC and 360. Definitely not PS3.
- Deandra
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1746
- Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2007 10:18 pm
- ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion
- Platform: PC
- UESPoints: 6
- Location: Seattle, WA
Re: What Skill is missing?
You can do this with alteration, or do you mean something like a passive evasion skill that kicks in if you're not armored?Alien wrote:If you could add any skill(s) to Oblivion, what would it be?
I would add a skill that lets you have a damage resistance without armor. With the 'Hand to Hand' skill you can do damage with no weapons. With the skill I would add(I haven't thought of a name) you could have a damage resistance with no armor.
Re: What Skill is missing?
umn sure that worksDeandra wrote:You can do this with alteration, or do you mean something like a passive evasion skill that kicks in if you're not armored?Alien wrote:If you could add any skill(s) to Oblivion, what would it be?
I would add a skill that lets you have a damage resistance without armor. With the 'Hand to Hand' skill you can do damage with no weapons. With the skill I would add(I haven't thought of a name) you could have a damage resistance with no armor.
Re: What Skill is missing?
I mean if you didn't have any armor on, you would have the 'Fortitude'(thanks Caldyn) skill give you damage resistence. So then Mages can have some damage resistence, 100% spells, and room for some enchantments on clothing.Deandra wrote:You can do this with alteration, or do you mean something like a passive evasion skill that kicks in if you're not armored?Alien wrote:If you could add any skill(s) to Oblivion, what would it be?
I would add a skill that lets you have a damage resistance without armor. With the 'Hand to Hand' skill you can do damage with no weapons. With the skill I would add(I haven't thought of a name) you could have a damage resistance with no armor.
For once, I don't have a signature.
- The Tourist
- Journeyman

- Posts: 325
- Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am
- jdcoffey92
- Novice

- Posts: 72
- Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2007 12:07 am
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: the bat-cave.
Craftsman- allows you to use the pickaxe, yarn, pelts etc. to create your own weapons and armor.
Gardener ( could also go with alchemy) - allows you to increase the chance of getting a successful harvest when picking ingredients, allows you to plant your own ingredients, allows you to pick ingredients from the same plant more often.
Gardener ( could also go with alchemy) - allows you to increase the chance of getting a successful harvest when picking ingredients, allows you to plant your own ingredients, allows you to pick ingredients from the same plant more often.
joker-how bout I show you a magic trick (smashes pencil into table) im gonna make this pencil dissapear.
thug-enough with this clown! (grabs joker)
joker-(smashes pencil into thugs eye) ta-dah!!!
thug-enough with this clown! (grabs joker)
joker-(smashes pencil into thugs eye) ta-dah!!!
- Sir Frederick Chook
- Apprentice

- Posts: 117
- Joined: Sat Feb 02, 2008 10:27 am
- UESPoints: 0
- Location: MELBOURNE
- Contact:
Unarmoured was assimilated into Acrobatics with the Dodge moves. I think amalgamating Blunt and Axe works fine, too - I'm no martial artist but as far as I can tell, they would involve exactly the same skills. Spear would be cool to have, but did you really ever use it? All spear was good for was ensuring the big reward for completing Bloodmoon was useless to most folks.
Separating Short Blade and Long Blade would make a bit more sense, but I can't honestly say I've ever had a moment where I screamed "JESUS! The fact that both long and short swords use the same skill set just RUINED my day!"
Sorry if I seem overly harsh on the MW/OB comparisons... but, well, read the old fan interviews over at chorrol.com and tell me you don't want to throttle the lot of the whining cretins every time "is x going to be the same as morrowind" "No, it's-" "OMG YOU'VE NERFED IT" comes up. They complain about the combat system, they complain about the landscapes renderer, they complain about the fact that Chorrol's emblem is an oak tree!
*ahem* So, what skill do I think would do well in Oblivion? Hmm! Perhaps another social skill, so Speechcraft and Mercantile don't get lonely, but I can't think what.
Separating Short Blade and Long Blade would make a bit more sense, but I can't honestly say I've ever had a moment where I screamed "JESUS! The fact that both long and short swords use the same skill set just RUINED my day!"
Sorry if I seem overly harsh on the MW/OB comparisons... but, well, read the old fan interviews over at chorrol.com and tell me you don't want to throttle the lot of the whining cretins every time "is x going to be the same as morrowind" "No, it's-" "OMG YOU'VE NERFED IT" comes up. They complain about the combat system, they complain about the landscapes renderer, they complain about the fact that Chorrol's emblem is an oak tree!
*ahem* So, what skill do I think would do well in Oblivion? Hmm! Perhaps another social skill, so Speechcraft and Mercantile don't get lonely, but I can't think what.
- The Tourist
- Journeyman

- Posts: 325
- Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am
Sir Frederick Chook;
Artist A* releases a seminal record-breaking record of genre bending, genre defining greatness, touted as one of the most influential and significant albums of all time**. 3 years later his second album had none of its innovation, verve, or subtlety. His third album is a complete departure from what made his debut so groundbreaking. His fans - of which I am definitely one of them - bemoan the loss of his genius.
Did things change? Or did things get worse. By my pointed use of italics, you can easily infer what my stance is. And a lot of people believe the same. In cold reality, both occurred; things changed simply becuase evolution is a good thing but they also got worse.
Unarmoured
Oblivion forces you to wear armour. Because if you don't? It's one of the few ocassions Oblivion punishes you - but this time it's for diversity. In Morrowind, you could truly craft and mould a subtle character using all four armour classes combined - with the superior clothes customisation - allowing for a completely individual character. Short Sword, Spear, and the specific Axe skill allowed for greater, genuine class specificity. All the streamlining consessions weren't for the fans, that's for sure.. they were for the dollar, the yen, and the pound. They run a business, so that's fine: but don't pretend there's any artistic merit in what they did.
* - DJ Shadow
** - Endtroducing
[Back In The Realm Of On-Topic]
Lock-Break; apparently there's a PC mod to do this, but another way to open locks would be nice, specifically for higher level warrior characters. Based on the Strength attribute and Blade skill, a character is able to force open locks, or destroy chest locks entirely. The lower your skill? The more damage you can do to any goods inside (thus punishing a less than subtle approach to lock-picking.. ). The higher your skill? The more goods are left intact.
So, I basically, completely, 100% stole the idea from KOTOR... but it'd work a treat in TES as well.
Artist A* releases a seminal record-breaking record of genre bending, genre defining greatness, touted as one of the most influential and significant albums of all time**. 3 years later his second album had none of its innovation, verve, or subtlety. His third album is a complete departure from what made his debut so groundbreaking. His fans - of which I am definitely one of them - bemoan the loss of his genius.
Did things change? Or did things get worse. By my pointed use of italics, you can easily infer what my stance is. And a lot of people believe the same. In cold reality, both occurred; things changed simply becuase evolution is a good thing but they also got worse.
Unarmoured
Oblivion forces you to wear armour. Because if you don't? It's one of the few ocassions Oblivion punishes you - but this time it's for diversity. In Morrowind, you could truly craft and mould a subtle character using all four armour classes combined - with the superior clothes customisation - allowing for a completely individual character. Short Sword, Spear, and the specific Axe skill allowed for greater, genuine class specificity. All the streamlining consessions weren't for the fans, that's for sure.. they were for the dollar, the yen, and the pound. They run a business, so that's fine: but don't pretend there's any artistic merit in what they did.
* - DJ Shadow
** - Endtroducing
[Back In The Realm Of On-Topic]
Lock-Break; apparently there's a PC mod to do this, but another way to open locks would be nice, specifically for higher level warrior characters. Based on the Strength attribute and Blade skill, a character is able to force open locks, or destroy chest locks entirely. The lower your skill? The more damage you can do to any goods inside (thus punishing a less than subtle approach to lock-picking.. ). The higher your skill? The more goods are left intact.
So, I basically, completely, 100% stole the idea from KOTOR... but it'd work a treat in TES as well.
Last edited by The Tourist on Sat Apr 26, 2008 2:11 pm, edited 3 times in total.
[ data pending ]
- Daedra Prince
- Journeyman

- Posts: 348
- Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 5:29 am
- ES Games: I, III, IV
- Platform: PC, PS3
- Location: Everywhere.
- Dogmantra
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1518
- Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
- ES Games: Yes
- Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
- Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
- Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
- Contact:
Er... what about medium armour! And I thought you liked Morrowind!The Tourist wrote:Hey, I got some great ideas... check these out:
Unarmoured
Axe
Spear
Short sword
Enchant
(i don't think i forgot any... )
Anyway, all the skills from Morrowind should be there, as well as a sort of addition to all magic skills, possibly linked with another skill called "Ritualism" or something, that lets you (for example) draw runes and stuff to create more powerful destruction spells or longer lasting summons. I mean, an on-the-fly spell wouldn't be as powerful as one you'd actually done with herbs and stuff.
BANG → !
- The Tourist
- Journeyman

- Posts: 325
- Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am
Alright, alright! One at a time..
The "I don't think I forgot any.." was there because I wasn't sure. Which, I clearly wasn't.. but it goes to show MW just keeps on giving.
New Skill-Perks: Stealth Kills
As popularised by 'that guy in Tenchu' (Rikimaru?), and Solid Snake; a means of genuinely whittling down the enemies with fully animated, context-sensitive stealth kills would be a nice reward for assassin characters.
In TES at the moment, you get close, and you hit the attack button. If the multipliers aren't high enough, it reverts to normal - noisy - combat. A way of implementing genuine snatch'n'slash assaults would make sense for higher level stealth characters. The higher the level? The more chance you have of a perfect, noiseless take down.
So... just add a little M G S to T E S. Hey, I should copyright that..
The "I don't think I forgot any.." was there because I wasn't sure. Which, I clearly wasn't.. but it goes to show MW just keeps on giving.
New Skill-Perks: Stealth Kills
As popularised by 'that guy in Tenchu' (Rikimaru?), and Solid Snake; a means of genuinely whittling down the enemies with fully animated, context-sensitive stealth kills would be a nice reward for assassin characters.
In TES at the moment, you get close, and you hit the attack button. If the multipliers aren't high enough, it reverts to normal - noisy - combat. A way of implementing genuine snatch'n'slash assaults would make sense for higher level stealth characters. The higher the level? The more chance you have of a perfect, noiseless take down.
So... just add a little M G S to T E S. Hey, I should copyright that..
[ data pending ]
I can't say I miss medium armour. Light, heavy and unarmoured would do just fine.
Unarmoured - Because it would make sense for a mage/monk to have SOME sort of defense system besides spell diminishing armour before you are able to get enchanted clothes to shield you (and now the shield spells aren't enough as a substitute IMO)
Axe - Because I would think using an axe and a mace are two quite different things
Spear - In a "medieval" world like this spear would be the weapon of choice for many. But not the sort of nerfed spears you had in Morrowind - they weren't good for much IMO
Short sword - Using a knife and a claymore aren't quite the same thing
Useful hand to Hand - I once created a monk type character which I tried to play without using weapons and only Hand to Hand as a combat method. On default difficulty it worked ok in that I could kill my enemies, but it took FOREVER! The fights were about 5 times longer than normal and I needed a lot of cure spells/potions to stay alive and so I tired very quickly. It would be nice with some sort of lethal special attacks that you have a low probability of doing at first but when you get better you get better at killing the enemy quickly with a "Vulcan death grip" or the like. If you choose unarmed combat as your primary weapon I would guess that you make sure it was more useful than a standard bar room brawl? As it is now I really don't know what Hand to Hand is useful for in the game. Maybe I'm missing something?
Stealth kill - I agree with The Tourist. As it is now if you play an assasin/sneak type of character you can manage the DA and Thieve's guild missions just fine, but in other missions you are quite severly hampered by the fact that after you first stealth attack you must quite often still have to be able to handle yourself well in normal combat to survive, so you really have to be a sort of stealt/fighter type to survive, especially on harder than default difficulty where very few enemies die from the first stealth attack. I say if you manage to sneak up behind them you should be able to cut their throat and not just jab them in the thigh.
EDIT!
Teaching - It would be nice if you could teach those skills you are a master in. Both to earn cash and reputation but also to be able to exceed the max skill level. In teaching you learn a lot yourself so it would be cool if you could reach 110 after some teaching.
vD
Unarmoured - Because it would make sense for a mage/monk to have SOME sort of defense system besides spell diminishing armour before you are able to get enchanted clothes to shield you (and now the shield spells aren't enough as a substitute IMO)
Axe - Because I would think using an axe and a mace are two quite different things
Spear - In a "medieval" world like this spear would be the weapon of choice for many. But not the sort of nerfed spears you had in Morrowind - they weren't good for much IMO
Short sword - Using a knife and a claymore aren't quite the same thing
Useful hand to Hand - I once created a monk type character which I tried to play without using weapons and only Hand to Hand as a combat method. On default difficulty it worked ok in that I could kill my enemies, but it took FOREVER! The fights were about 5 times longer than normal and I needed a lot of cure spells/potions to stay alive and so I tired very quickly. It would be nice with some sort of lethal special attacks that you have a low probability of doing at first but when you get better you get better at killing the enemy quickly with a "Vulcan death grip" or the like. If you choose unarmed combat as your primary weapon I would guess that you make sure it was more useful than a standard bar room brawl? As it is now I really don't know what Hand to Hand is useful for in the game. Maybe I'm missing something?
Stealth kill - I agree with The Tourist. As it is now if you play an assasin/sneak type of character you can manage the DA and Thieve's guild missions just fine, but in other missions you are quite severly hampered by the fact that after you first stealth attack you must quite often still have to be able to handle yourself well in normal combat to survive, so you really have to be a sort of stealt/fighter type to survive, especially on harder than default difficulty where very few enemies die from the first stealth attack. I say if you manage to sneak up behind them you should be able to cut their throat and not just jab them in the thigh.
EDIT!
Teaching - It would be nice if you could teach those skills you are a master in. Both to earn cash and reputation but also to be able to exceed the max skill level. In teaching you learn a lot yourself so it would be cool if you could reach 110 after some teaching.
vD
Last edited by vondobeln on Sat Apr 26, 2008 5:39 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Personally, I like the fact that they've managed to cut out a lot of the pointless redundancy. I also like the fact that the skills balance with the attributes. RPG is in your head. If you want to role-play a barbarian type that only fights with an axe. Equip axes instead of maces. Why bemoan the fact that your character may happen to get better at a skill they never use. And actually, that happened all the time in traditional pen and paper D&D.The Tourist wrote: Oblivion forces you to wear armour. Because if you don't? It's one of the few ocassions Oblivion punishes you - but this time it's for diversity. In Morrowind, you could truly craft and mould a subtle character using all four armour classes combined - with the superior clothes customisation - allowing for a completely individual character. Short Sword, Spear, and the specific Axe skill allowed for greater, genuine class specificity. All the streamlining consessions weren't for the fans, that's for sure.. they were for the dollar, the yen, and the pound. They run a business, so that's fine: but don't pretend there's any artistic merit in what they did.
Also, where does one draw the line for the sake of realistic high specialization versus streamlined code and ease of use? For example, here is the skill list from Daggerfall:
Alteration, Archery, Axe, Backstabbing, Blunt Weapon, Centaurian, Climbing, Critical Strike, Daedric, Destruction, Dodging, Dragonish, Etiquette, Giantish, Hand to Hand, Harpy, Illusion, Impish, Jumping, Lockpicking, Longblade, Medical, Mercantile, Mysticism, Nymph, Orcish, Pickpocket, Restoration, Running, Short Blade, Spriggan, Stealth, Streetwise, Swimming, Thaumaturgy
Gee. Too bad I can no longer take "Daedric" as a skill. It really puts a damper on my Mythic Dawn assassin character.
I personally don't think it's pointless redundancy to differentiate skills between e.g. daggers and claymores. If you only use daggers then IMO you shouldn't be able to pick up a nice enchanted claymore you come across at level 23 and be as good with that as with your daggers. Of course there is a balance to be struck and no I don't miss being able to choose daedric either, but if you play Daggerfall maybe you'd miss it? There can be too many but too few can make it feel bland IMO. Why differentiate between weapons at all? If you role play you will only use the weapon type you want to use anyway right? So why not lump all melee weapons together in Melee weapons since they all have the same governing attribute of Strength. Actually you could reduce the number of skills to the number of Attributes - Let's just have Strength skills, Willpower skills, Endurance skills etc. since if you role play you won't take advantage of the "extra" skills you gain anyway.
Again of course there is a balance to be struck here, and I for one think they have simplified the skill system a tad bit too much in Oblivion (where are Britney and Jamie i.e. the spears e.g.!?!?), but naturally there will always be different opinions.
vD
Again of course there is a balance to be struck here, and I for one think they have simplified the skill system a tad bit too much in Oblivion (where are Britney and Jamie i.e. the spears e.g.!?!?), but naturally there will always be different opinions.
vD
- arrow-lock
- Novice

- Posts: 86
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2008 3:16 pm
- The Tourist
- Journeyman

- Posts: 325
- Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am
Using a dagger is not the same as using a claymore... Short Sword and Longblade (or whatever it was called in MW) were sensible, consistent skills. So broadly, I agree with vondobeln's take on things.
Alien; I've done both - rambled about Morrowind's skills, and put forth some tasty new ones. I rock!
As in...
Dual Wield: in the vanilla flavoured proper way - unlocked once you've mastered the Longblade.
Weapon Throw: "Close to death, but not close enough to the bad guy? Throw that sucker!" - I like the idea of desperation that comes with hurling a claymore or axe at an advesary. The Havoc physics in Oblivion are well done for thrown objects, so why not show it off a little more?
Alien; I've done both - rambled about Morrowind's skills, and put forth some tasty new ones. I rock!
As in...
Dual Wield: in the vanilla flavoured proper way - unlocked once you've mastered the Longblade.
Weapon Throw: "Close to death, but not close enough to the bad guy? Throw that sucker!" - I like the idea of desperation that comes with hurling a claymore or axe at an advesary. The Havoc physics in Oblivion are well done for thrown objects, so why not show it off a little more?
[ data pending ]


