Oblivion best game ever?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions

Oblivion best game ever? (please tell why)

Yes
28
67%
No
14
33%
 
Total votes: 42

User avatar
bas237
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 740
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:45 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: No longer in Oblivion!

Post by bas237 »

The Tourist wrote:Ah.. how could I miss an opportunity to come down on Oblivion! :D

No, of course it's not the best game ever. Best First-Person Role Player? Obviously, because it had the biggest budget, and a long lineage of titles from which to develop/evolve from.

As far as iconic impact goes? FFVII takes the crown.
As far as actual quality, verve, imagination, perfection of game-engine? Only one game stands head-and-shoulders above all else; Half-Life 2...

...oh, and of course hardcore-MW has training-wheels-Ob beaten on multiple fronts, so Ob's not even the most accomplished game in the TES series.
Half-Life 2 is cool, the graphics&physics are fantastic, but I haven't played it as long as Oblivion. I played through the singleplayer twice (medium and hard difficulty) and did a few multiplayer battles, but that's it.
It's a nice shooter with some nice puzzles, but you don't have as many options as in Oblivion, and I've always loved realistic medieval/fantasy worlds.

It seems this is a discussion on which we can go on forever :)

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to post this up here, but let's say Oblivion is the best First-Person RPG ever.
What do you think is...
the best first person shooter ever?
the best action game ever?
the best adventure game ever?
the best RTS game ever?
the best racing game ever?
the best TBS game ever?
the best ... (fill in yourself) game ever?

Oh and my opinion:
Best FPS > Half-Life 2
Best Action game > GTA II
Best Adventure game > Monkey Island, Sam&Max (can't choose)
Best RTS game > Rome Total War, Age of Empires II, Age of Mythology, Command&Conquer, Red Alert II (can't choose, ok: Red Alert II then)
Best TBS game > Civilization... (all the Civ. games, there are 4, except expansion packs)
Best Sporting game > Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2

EDIT:
I think this belongs in the General forum ;)
So if I'm not allowed to post this, please ignore it :)
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Post by Dogmantra »

the best first person shooter ever?
XIII
the best RTS game ever?
War of the ring or Rise of Nations: Thrones & Patriots
the best racing game ever?
Mario Kart DS :P
the best TBS game ever?
Heroes Of Might and Magic 3 in the Wake of Gods
BANG → !
User avatar
Caldyn_Blade
Champion
Champion
Posts: 814
Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2008 8:29 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Florida: land of dangling chads and amorous teachers

Post by Caldyn_Blade »

Oblivion is simply the best video game I've ever played.... It's basically the game I would make myself if I could make my own... The only thing for me it's lacking is the ability to have a friend join me in the game. Sure, there are other little things that could be better, but it's still simply the best one I've ever played.
Deathmist
Warder
Warder
Posts: 518
Joined: Sat Apr 05, 2008 12:34 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC, PS3

Post by Deathmist »

I haven't played the best game ever. :wink:

There are a lot of minor flaws I could list, but it is nothing I can't ignore. :D
So it is one of my favorite games, but it isn't the best game ever. (IMO)
User avatar
Ergukrael
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 219
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2008 4:53 am

Post by Ergukrael »

Dogmantra wrote:the best TBS game ever?
Heroes Of Might and Magic 3 in the Wake of Gods
Totally agree! HOMM3 was the bomb! Then they broke it with IV. V tries hard to go back to III's glory, but the AI is still terrible, and I find the game quite unsatisfying. The sequels just don't hold a candle.

FWIW, up until the HOMM4 and M&M10 fiascos, the storylines, backstory, realm, etc. were top notch. On par with TES as far as telling a story with the game.
User avatar
Alien
Champion
Champion
Posts: 898
Joined: Sat Apr 12, 2008 9:11 am

Post by Alien »

I love Oblivion, and it is certainly the game i have put the most hours in, but it's not my favorite game. My favorite games are probably: LoZ Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask, Assasin's Creed(there's nothing more fun thn walking through a crowd, a assasinating someone, completely unseen...), Skate, Halo 3 (Halo 3 is way better than Call of Duty 4, in campaign AND multiplayer), Bioshock(I love setting up traps with the crossbow that shoots electric tripwires :Twisted Evil: ), Red Faction (in my opinion, it has the greatest destructible enviroment. Tank going across a bridge? Make a 10 foot long gap in the bridge!), and...

PPPPP OOOO N N GGGGG I
P P O O NN N G I
PPPPP O O N N N G GGGG I O I
P O O N N N G G I
P OOO N N GGGGG I :D

Edit: That looked like 'PONG' when I was making it... :(
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Ah Red Faction... probably the single greatest example of what games should add to environmental interaction. (Unfortunately, it seemed like they majorly cut that down in the second game... either that or 4 hours of play wasn't enough to get back to the fun of being able to blast away the ground beneath you) Think of how much greater any open-ended RPG such as Fable, TES, and Deus Ex would be with that added ability to literally change your surroundings to your liking (and the enemy to theirs!!!).
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
User avatar
Alien
Champion
Champion
Posts: 898
Joined: Sat Apr 12, 2008 9:11 am

Post by Alien »

Ya, I also loved the bots in that game, one person multiplayer was awesome. I loved creating huge tunnels in the wall with the rocket launcher. The taser was the best :Twisted Evil:
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

basleijser wrote: Oblivion only "punishes" you with having Speechcraft/Mercantile as major skills if it are the only skills you're using. But you've got to choose 7 major skills so you can use Blade/Blunt/Marksman/Hand2Hand as well and that will increase your Strength and thus makes you stronger.
So it's completely your fault and not Bethesda's if you get owned when only using Speech/Merc. It's realistic.
What i mean is that it's missing quest where those skills would be good to have - like for example the House Hlallu in morrowind where speachcraft could help you a lot as well as mercantilism.

as for these i haven't played many games so i try to judge what developers did with what they had at the time game was created.
the best first person shooter ever?
Half life 1 - for the time breakthrough graphics which ran excelent on very low end maschines as well as high end ones. and a great on storyline often missed in games.

the best action game ever?
As in platform? i dont' really like them, but prehistoric brought a lot of fun back in the days.
the best adventure game ever?
don't like them, so i haven't played them much
the best RTS game ever?
didn't play much of them (no time), but Red Alert seemed quite ok to me. New ones have improved graphics and "realistic" phisics, but that's about it, mostly. I also enjoyed settlers 3 a lot. because the units move slow enough for you to actually control them.
the best racing game ever?
I enjoyed need for speed series when it first came out. again no time for games :(
the best TBS game ever?
HOMM series, also Civ 1 (revolutionary design), 2 & 3 are good improvements. as well as Alpha centauri. Galactic civ is also not so bad.
the best ... (fill in yourself) game ever?
still waiting fo rthe perfect one. there is a lot to be done. but what would it be like?

- A lot of fun
- Great environment (stunning views, realistic effects, fully breakable environment, option to actually hide behind a bush) - anyone knows why you can't crawl in OB? or shoot from the city walls when defending a city? didn't really made that one too good, huh?
- Good look - graphics
- A lot of choices
- When you go hard mode - get a smart AI (instead of just more health or more of them)
- a lot of specific difficulty options - for kids and pros
- enemies wouldn't expose themselves out in the open for example when shooting at you in FPS and you are mowind them with MG (and they knwo that you are doing that) - yeah i miss the "sturmbot smartness" when they duck and throw a grenade at you instead of charging you like idiots.
- and also a great story that would be interactive - your actions would reflect the world arround you. for example you bought a lot of stuff form certainmerthant, so he would hire a maid or build himself a new house
- and NO bugs. - Oblivion wiki has plenty notes ahout bugs almost with each quest. but most don't seem fatal (unless you are on console and can't use the console) like maybe in "Buggerfall" :D. still doesnt' do it good when talking about best and perfection...
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Half-Life was a breakthrough in graphics? Huh? The only breakthrough thing I remember from the graphics of the game is that they were (I think) the first game to have character mouths moving while they spoke. o.O There were plenty of other games with graphics just as good at the time, they just added a tad more realism which overall made the game more appealing to people.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Post by Dogmantra »

Ergukrael wrote: Totally agree! HOMM3 was the bomb! Then they broke it with IV.
I have III and IV but only IV's installed at the moment. If you have Wake of Gods, it's awesome, except the 8th level creatures do make it a bit over the top. The music in III is the best music EVER!
BANG → !
User avatar
bas237
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 740
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:45 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: No longer in Oblivion!

Post by bas237 »

Alien wrote:I love Oblivion, and it is certainly the game i have put the most hours in, but it's not my favorite game. My favorite games are probably: LoZ Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask, Assasin's Creed(there's nothing more fun thn walking through a crowd, a assasinating someone, completely unseen...), Skate, Halo 3 (Halo 3 is way better than Call of Duty 4, in campaign AND multiplayer), Bioshock(I love setting up traps with the crossbow that shoots electric tripwires :Twisted Evil: ), Red Faction (in my opinion, it has the greatest destructible enviroment. Tank going across a bridge? Make a 10 foot long gap in the bridge!), and...

PPPPP OOOO N N GGGGG I
P P O O NN N G I
PPPPP O O N N N G GGGG I O I
P O O N N N G G I
P OOO N N GGGGG I :D


Edit: That looked like 'PONG' when I was making it... :(
Has Red Faction already been released? Not up here in Europe -> Holland.

Or do you mean Red Faction number one? Because within some months a new version will be released!
It's called Red Faction Guerrilla

http://media.insidegamer.nl/screenshots ... 118456.jpg

(Oh, it's a Dutch site, but just watch the screen :P)
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Well I was just talking about the first Red Faction... I didn't even know they were working on a third one. The second one wasn't that great unless suddenly 6+ hours into the game (I only played for 4) it put you somewhere that gave you the same options as the first game did.

Oh, and how could I forget to mention these... Chrono Trigger and Chrono Cross. Two of the greatest games ever. (Cross could've used a bit of combat tweaking but it worked out just fine anyway) These don't quite make the top list I made earlier (which I didn't exactly make clear, it's all just in one long paragraph), but they're still awesome.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
WoCoNation
Associate
Associate
Posts: 12
Joined: Wed Mar 26, 2008 2:16 pm

Post by WoCoNation »

Oblivion is a great game, no doubt. It's easily in the 95th percentile of all games I've played, but best ever is really pushing it....

SMB3
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Oathbreaker wrote:Half-Life was a breakthrough in graphics? Huh? The only breakthrough thing I remember from the graphics of the game is that they were (I think) the first game to have character mouths moving while they spoke. o.O There were plenty of other games with graphics just as good at the time, they just added a tad more realism which overall made the game more appealing to people.
Thief, Unreal... what else?

The point is that good graphics worked on low end maschines. i remembered that celerons 266Mhz were quite custom built then... well at least here. Some had P2-400Mhz. and it had all that cool environment which was changing (scripted events etc.)... switching from Quake to HL was great improvement.

Heh funny... upon checking the wiki a bit, the game got numerous Best game ever "awards" and it's on the list of best ever games on some sites. :)
User avatar
bas237
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 740
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:45 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: No longer in Oblivion!

Post by bas237 »

What about classics like Commandos, Command and Conquer, Age of Empires, Red Alert, Doom, Quake, Battlefield 1942, Return to Castle Wolfenstein, Warcraft III, Starcraft, The Settlers, GTA, Fallout, Team Fortress, Alone in the Dark, Resident Evil, Mario Kart, Super Mario 64, Super Mario World/Bros, and so on...


And Bioshock, Medieval II Total War, Call of Duty 4 and Supreme Commandor are also great.
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Well when you look at classics and how good they are by today's standards... you just have to find out how awesome they still are to play. Graphics are a moot point (though I think even I've mentioned them somewhere on here), it's all about the gameplay, story-telling, plot and character development... all that good stuff that makes a great game. There's no need to label any game as classic just because it's from an older (and less graphically refined) age.

And here's my first "best racing game" vote. The original Mario Kart. :Twisted Evil:
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

I'd be tempted to say it's also a bit of an age thing; the demographic of the UESP is pretty darn young, and Oblivion is a flashy, high-profile, very succesful title - but it's by no means the be all and end all of videogames.

But as a videogame that breeches the media trappings, as can truly be counted amongst the finest mankind has to offer in music, cinema, literature, H-L2 is the one. BioShock could also be counted, but for me it fell way short of what was expected, and it's too exclusively 'weird' for its own damn good.

Humane storytelling, a convincing world, proper grown-up themes (with Dr Breen being one of the great 'anti'-villains), a script that surpasses most films, a hefty budget, and as a game experience - peerlessly revolutionary. And Valve improved up this with Episodes 1&2.
Oathbreaker wrote:it's all about the gameplay, story-telling, plot and character development..all that good stuff that makes a great game
...like in Mario Cart? :D

I'd love for that to be the case - and judging by those standards, Oblivion fails completely (aside from the important one; gameplay). But the truth is, games don't need story, plot or characters to be great. ...even if those aspects are very important to me - they're certainly not to Nintendo (who I kindof.. um.. loathe entirely).

Oblivion is the leader by a huge space-mile - in its particular sub-genre. But it's got a long way to go before it can play with the big boys.
[ data pending ]
User avatar
bas237
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 740
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 2:45 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: No longer in Oblivion!

Post by bas237 »

Yes you're right. I recently played games like Red Alert II, Command and Conquer Renegade and Delta Force and even though the graphics were awful, it was still fun to play those games and recognize lots of things :)
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

The Tourist wrote:
Oathbreaker wrote:it's all about the gameplay, story-telling, plot and character development..all that good stuff that makes a great game
...like in Mario Cart? :D
Erm, I'll have you know that (as you partially said yourself) a game doesn't need all that to be great. Mario Kart just has the gameplay (and a bit of story-telling if you read between the lines when you win a cup), and that's all it needs.

For most of the rest of what you say... yeah I more or less agree. But even if all the good stuff isn't very important to Nintendo (which it actually is on some level), they still have Zelda going for them. You could say it's their "redeeming feature."

... All I know is that Sony better follow through with that tech demo they showed of FFVII on the PS3. Giving us that kind of false hope could possibly result in the sudden disappearance of Sony and Square employees. :Angry: I demand to play that game on the PS3.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Maybe COD4 and Ninty's latest Non-Game could be paralleled (in that COD4 really doesn't have story or character arcs - even if some of the protagonists do a lot of 'character') - but it's their current spurning of technology that grates me the most. To me, games need to push the boundries of visuals, as well as incorporating intelligent, truly adult storylines and themes. Otherwise games will simply always be perceived to be the domain of kids. Which is why I have the peculiar stance on being pretty much 'anti-fun' with videogames... :roll:

FFVII on PS3? Please god no... I've always wanted the classics to be left well and truly alone. Would Michael Bay directing a Seven Samurai-remake make it better just because it was in colour and had more blood? No... I just don't understand why people want a FFVII re-hash. It smacks not only of grave-robbing, but an admission of 'we don't have any more original ideas, and all of our RPG's have sucked since FVIII'. (I loathed IX, and the rest have almost been jokes for me)
[ data pending ]
User avatar
Jordy666sic
Associate
Associate
Posts: 23
Joined: Sun Feb 03, 2008 2:38 pm
UESPoints: 0
Contact:

Post by Jordy666sic »

Ravey wrote:My favourite game is still Little Big Adventure 2. 8)
..your are kidding me right..? :shock:
User avatar
Caldyn_Blade
Champion
Champion
Posts: 814
Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2008 8:29 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Florida: land of dangling chads and amorous teachers

Post by Caldyn_Blade »

I have to say, for FF fans....my wife is currently playing Lost Odyssey on 360, and it looks just like FF to me...(and she's a big fan of that series)...

Personally, I can't stand that (I take a turn, she takes a turn, monster's turn) stuff...but to each their own.... I want my dodge to be because I dodged, not because some random numbers said so. Not to mention, it's more satisfying when you see your arrow hit someone right in the head because you compensated for the arrow's arc due to distance, etc. :Twisted Evil:
User avatar
Blackhawk Vegal
Champion
Champion
Posts: 800
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2008 6:03 am
ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion, alittle of Marrowwind and now ESO
Platform: PS3 / PS4 / PS5
Status: alive and ticking according to the pulse
Location: Seabrook, Texas (SE HU)
Contact:

Post by Blackhawk Vegal »

Caldyn_Blade wrote: Not to mention, it's more satisfying when you see your arrow hit someone right in the head because you compensated for the arrow's arc due to distance, etc. :Twisted Evil:
thats what i like about the Bow to, getting good at hitting them in the head at over 100 ft away,

My best shot is 130 ft, right in the left eye. awesome
SNES / PS / PS2 / PS3 / PS4 / PS5 Player

Quote of the Week =

"Writers don't get mad they get even in their novels."
― Candace C. Bowen
Deathmist
Warder
Warder
Posts: 518
Joined: Sat Apr 05, 2008 12:34 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC, PS3

Post by Deathmist »

FFVIII > FFVII. :P

FFVIII deserves a remake before FFVII does. :P

(IMO)
Last edited by Deathmist on Tue Apr 15, 2008 8:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Post Reply