Not too long ago I went over major scales in my mandolin music book. It was easy enough to understand and master, but I came across a snag. In the music book, it lists the G major scale, for example, as covering a certain octave, starting on the second to bottom line on the music staff and concluding on the in-between-space above the top line. Now the mandolin can cover some 2+ octaves, so I can play this particular scale one octave lower. But do I still sharp the F? As any competent musician knows, in the specific case of the G maj scale, the F note is sharped. But how often is it done so?
I think I already know the answer to this, but I have some confusion when it comes to denoting a specific scale on a musical piece. Again, back to the G maj scale, it is denoted by placing a sharp symbol on the top line, in between the treble cleff and time signature. But suppose in that musical piece I should be required to play an F note, one that isn't on that top staff line? IS it still sharped? Short and sweet of it, if I am playing any music piece "in key", is every note that is denoted sharp always played as sharp, regardless of where it falls on the staff?
Hopefully you understand my confusion and question. Because though I am at least familiar with music, I am not the one some one should come running to for help. Hence this.
As always, thanks for the help I know you will give.
A Query about Musical Sharping
Moderator: Tea Party Mods
- Venger
- Guardian

- Posts: 664
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2010 4:48 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind GOTYE (Xbox), Oblivion GOTYE (PC)
- Platform: Xbox (original), PC
- Status: ...Processing...
A Query about Musical Sharping
The signature is the common man's attempt at a wise one-liner.
- Jakarius321
- Champion

- Posts: 802
- Joined: Sat Oct 10, 2009 5:03 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
- Platform: PC, PS3
- Status: Does anyone actually read these?
- Location: Can't remember
Re: A Query about Musical Sharping
If the key signature says that F should be sharp (in G Major's case on the top line of the treble clef) then any F you play is always sharp unless marked as natural ♮ .
So if I've understood your question correctly then yes any note denoted to be played as sharp or flat by the key signature should be played sharp or flat unless specified otherwise by a natural sign (but you don't get naturals in scales I don't think).
EDIT: Regardless of where it is on the stave.
So if I've understood your question correctly then yes any note denoted to be played as sharp or flat by the key signature should be played sharp or flat unless specified otherwise by a natural sign (but you don't get naturals in scales I don't think).
EDIT: Regardless of where it is on the stave.
Is this meant to be witty, informative or deep? I doubt I can manage all three.
- Venger
- Guardian

- Posts: 664
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2010 4:48 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind GOTYE (Xbox), Oblivion GOTYE (PC)
- Platform: Xbox (original), PC
- Status: ...Processing...
Re: A Query about Musical Sharping
Thanks Jak. Like I said, I surmised as much already. And from just twiddling around I knew it just "sounded right" if I sharped ever F (in G maj case). But still, I felt the need to confirm my assumptions.
The signature is the common man's attempt at a wise one-liner.
- Jakarius321
- Champion

- Posts: 802
- Joined: Sat Oct 10, 2009 5:03 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
- Platform: PC, PS3
- Status: Does anyone actually read these?
- Location: Can't remember
Re: A Query about Musical Sharping
Hey no problem, this sort of theory sort of gets drilled into you when you have to practise a multitude of scales over 3 octaves for Grade 5 piano 
Is this meant to be witty, informative or deep? I doubt I can manage all three.
- Musicman247
- Mod On Leave

- Posts: 2876
- Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2011 5:06 am
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: Xbox, PC, STD
- Status: Smurfin'
- Other Profiles: Gamertag: MightyGo0dLeadr
- UESPoints: 15
- Location: Your dreams
Re: A Query about Musical Sharping
Great answers! Key signatures cover every note played in a piece unless the note is preceded by an accidental.
My work here is done
My work here is done
"Yer a wizard, Musicman." - scribbane
Can't post links or set up your avatar? Click here.
Forum Rules | Report a Problem
The Mod Squad
Can't post links or set up your avatar? Click here.
Forum Rules | Report a Problem
The Mod Squad