Prowler's Profit OTT?

[Drewski]

Don't get me wrong, it's a massive undertaking to get Prowler's Profit in the first place, but the reward seems just too overpowered to me (while very nice).

My Thief/Assassin has 90 in speech and has invested in every merchant in Riverwood, Whiterun, Solitude and Riften. Shortly after obtaining Prowler's Profit, he got sent on a side quest, which involved a medium Nordic ruin. Each and every burial urn basically becomes a treasure chest, containing min 1, normally 2-4 Gems (often flawless), every dead (not resting) Draughr has a gem or two. Only collecting gems, and leaving weapons, he took every penny off of every Riverwood, Whiterun, Solitude and Riften merchant, just by selling the gems (and even had a handful left)! That's roughly 25-30k gold, from one medium dungeon.

Am I the only one that thinks this is just a little too powerful?

[Mattbott]

I never heard of this item before tbh,

Spoiler:

reminds me of the skeleton key in Oblivion - once you get it lockpicks and the security skill are obsolete, so use with caution

you do have a high score in speech so it might be less unbalanced for people who haven't improved merchants throughout.. but yes it does seem like a loot spoiler to me if you maxed out this aspect of the game, so use with caution i'd say

[SithisIsMyCopilot]

Wow. It seems like one of those rewards where by the time you get it, you don't really need it...

[Drewski]

I never heard of this item before tbh,

Spoiler:

reminds me of the skeleton key in Oblivion - once you get it lockpicks and the security skill are obsolete, so use with caution

you do have a high score in speech so it might be less unbalanced for people who haven't improved merchants throughout.. but yes it does seem like a loot spoiler to me if you maxed out this aspect of the game, so use with caution i'd say

It's not an item, it's a permanent ability reward for completing

Spoiler:

The Quest - No Stone Unturned

[Drewski]

Wow. It seems like one of those rewards where by the time you get it, you don't really need it...

I started this thief/assassin from scratch and that was his first aim. I had the quest 1/2 completed at lvl 4, finished it around lvl 20, because I got bored/couldn't avoid some necessary combat (quite a lot actually )....it's probably completable at a much lower lvl, if you run away from combat, and don't take the thief standing stone at the start....your sneak tends to go through the roof doing this quest.

[Trelares]

It is bad that those gemstones have not many uses, it would be awesome if they could be of more use than just selling. And yes it is a bit overpowered, you can get sometimes like 20 to 40 gemstones in one dungeon.

[urthdigger]

It is bad that those gemstones have not many uses, it would be awesome if they could be of more use than just selling. And yes it is a bit overpowered, you can get sometimes like 20 to 40 gemstones in one dungeon.

You can make expensive jewelry with them and sell them for even more. Or even better, enchant the jewelry after.

[Drewski]

It is bad that those gemstones have not many uses, it would be awesome if they could be of more use than just selling. And yes it is a bit overpowered, you can get sometimes like 20 to 40 gemstones in one dungeon.

You can make expensive jewelry with them and sell them for even more. Or even better, enchant the jewelry after.

But my point was and still is, that it kinda kills the game. One dungeon, and you can go and pay to train a skill from say 85-90 (in fact 2 or more as mentioned).

I'd prefer say a 50% increase in the chance of an extra gem in each chest/urn (but Im on Xbox so havent seen the code, so Im really guessing the parameters).

[Vardark]

Overpowered? Not at all. Just as in Oblivion, you have absolutely no use for all the cash you earn throughout the game. None. The only really expensive thing in the game are houses. The game would have been a lot better if you actually had to save up for certain weapons and other rarities, instead of smithing and enchanting all the good stuff yourself.

[Gideon Dragontongue]

Yes, I wouldn't say it's overpowered at all. Like Vardark said, there isn't much you can do with last quantities of valuable metal, besides the fact that it's only fair for the amount of work you have to do in the quest.

[yodah]

Overpowered? Not at all. Just as in Oblivion, you have absolutely no use for all the cash you earn throughout the game. None. The only really expensive thing in the game are houses. The game would have been a lot better if you actually had to save up for certain weapons and other rarities, instead of smithing and enchanting all the good stuff yourself.

That is false. Playing as a pure mage character (No armor, and only magic), I usually find myself at a loss for gold whenever I need to buy something, and end up having to save up and limit my spending for a bit before I can get it. Most notable of this is new robes, as the College of Winterhold sells them for ridiculous prices, and I end up having to save up money for a few days. I enjoy this, as it makes me feel like I'm actually earning the things I buy, unlike Oblivion where I could just clone some rings and sell them.

[Drewski]

Overpowered? Not at all. Just as in Oblivion, you have absolutely no use for all the cash you earn throughout the game. None. The only really expensive thing in the game are houses. The game would have been a lot better if you actually had to save up for certain weapons and other rarities, instead of smithing and enchanting all the good stuff yourself.

That is false. Playing as a pure mage character (No armor, and only magic), I usually find myself at a loss for gold whenever I need to buy something, and end up having to save up and limit my spending for a bit before I can get it. Most notable of this is new robes, as the College of Winterhold sells them for ridiculous prices, and I end up having to save up money for a few days. I enjoy this, as it makes me feel like I'm actually earning the things I buy, unlike Oblivion where I could just clone some rings and sell them.

I have to agree...and there are also things you cant buy cheaply :- i.e Skill training. 4000+ gold per point isnt cheap, but it is when u have overflowing gems (and pls no exploit comments).

[Gideon Dragontongue]

Well, that's true about training, but on any of my characters where I might have feasibly gotten it, I'm already at ninety in the skills that I have access to the master trainers.

[RedDeadFred]

Honestly, I was actually disappointed by this reward. Ok so I can now get even more money from dungeons than I could before. The thing is, by the time I finished this quest, I was so far into the game that I could easily just make things at little price and then sell my creations for tons of money.

I think I would have been happier if you got to take the crown and it gave you some kind of amazing bonus to health, stamina, and magika (like maybe 100 each).

Then not only would you be running around looking like the richest person on the planet, you would get a stat boost worthy of the amount of time you had to spend getting all of the gems.

[Lotet]

now with the latest patch, the Prowlers Profit perk actually has a use, leveling up your Smithing skill, since smith levels with the value of the created item now.

though I hope it's not as bad as Alchemy, I made like 300,000 gold or something while leveling my Alchemy, I had more money at the end of that than I made throughout the entirety of the rest of my gameplay.

[Mattbott]

from what has been said, imo the true value of prowlers profit is not making loads of gold at all

it sounds like PP allows you to play a character who no longer has to lug round tons of loot but can still trade and buy equipment they need - a great boon for light travellers (or heroes with low stamina) who feel silly carrying 10 suits of chainmail and a load of maces just cos they need to make some money and buy a spell or two.. in effect this could free your character (and companions) up from looting bodies of stuff you don't want to use (interesting new concept for fantasy role playing lol) does that make sense? i don't have this yet so am not 100% sure

so much in this game tips the balance unless you use it a certain way but i think i like the sound of this after all

[Pilaf The Defiler]

That Barenziah really knew how to get ahold of men's jewels, didn't she?

[Mattbott]

lol

yes, it was one of her greatest charms if i remember correctly

[urthdigger]

That Barenziah really knew how to get ahold of men's jewels, didn't she?

Especially khajiit

[Reizoko13]

Have to agree that this power is kinda ridiculous, and it almost seems to me like some developer missed a decimal point for the frequency of gem appearances or something. The only thing that didn't make it quite game-breaking for me was the fact that I was already hoarding gems instead of selling them. It meant that my poor housecarl's main job was to lug around 50 lbs of pretty rocks, though. And that's just silly.

[roleplayer242426]

Dark Brotherhood Spoiler Warning:

Spoiler:

It may seem like it, but considering you can do an infinite number of generic assassinations after the DBH Questline that literally makes 1,000 septims a pop and takes on average 10-20 seconds, I see it as less of a problem.

. It's been said, but Alchemy is worse, making an outrageous amount of coin.

[Drewski]

My earlier mentioned Thief/Assassin now has so much money, I was thinking of giving a few 100k to some kind of (evil) charity, but you can't even do that. It was kinda fun for a while , trading a handful of diamonds for 5 skill points worth of training, but since the combat skills he uses are mostly maxed out, levelling is extremely slow (50+), and he can earn a few hundred k gold per level without trying.....well apart from the endless shopping...

Character : The Abyss

Traits: Evil, remorseless killer. Will assist someone on a quest, then murder them afterwards anyway.

Vocation: Sleeping & Eating 25%, Killing 5%, Shopping 70%.....

(The last is starting to disturb him, as he has noticed himself more frequently employing terms such as "then liiike he said" and "I was so...oh my god....no waaay", and has also noticed a definite rising intonation at the end of sentences that should be statements. This caused confusion on his last assassination job, as he stared into the eyes of his victim and said, "It's time to die". The victim replied "Is that a question, because I'll say it isn't time". "No", said the killer, "it wasn't". "Well you made it sound like one", replied the victim. A short discussion followed, which made The Abyss so angry, that he killed the victim in such an unspeakable way, that we won't speak of it............Then he went shopping.)