The deaths of Sotha Sil, Almalexia... and Vivec??

A place to discuss and ask questions about the third part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Post by The Tourist »

Tsk.. did I just see someone get their Nerevar/Chimer/Dunmer/Red Mt mythos completely wrong?! Bad gregor (and Shadowsforu, whilst I'm handing out de-merits)! :wink:

Way back to the original thread; I chose - and will always choose - to never take retribution on Vivec, as I believed his presence at the end is one of the central testaments to any moral-lesson dealt out. Unfortunately, you have to do in the other two, so that's out of my hands.
[ data pending ]
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Oh and since this was something I was SUPPOSED to do at some point...

Yes it turns out the Chimer and the Altmer are the same lineage, but with DEFINITE and different cultures, and there are also subtle differences in their skin (The Chimer's are indeed slightly brighter and the Altmer's slightly duller) and not only did I do the visual comparison with an altmer character standing next to Almalexia, but I got that from the lore too. I'm still not sure why they're shorter though o.O they lived in the same region until Veloth led them to Morrowind so they could practice worship of Daedra. And I love how stupid the Altmer really are... believing only the Aedra are their true ancestors... :lol: arrogant morons.
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

Well you don't get to talk to Sotha sil, Almalexia goes mental, but Vivec seems always nice to you. And even helps you in the quest.
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Sotha Sil either killed himself or was killed by Almalexia, never possibility is really made clear though there's evidence for both of them. Almalexia was mad with power, and mad with the obsession with not losing it. She may have originally wanted her Nerevar back, but as soon as she realized he may not completely agree with her power-scheming, she decided to attempt to kill you too. Vivic is the only member of the Tribunal that became repentant in a non-self-depressing way (Sotha Sil became repentant, and locked himself up in his little domain because of his emotional shift thereafter). And that is why Vivic is the only one that helps you. Sotha Sil may have if he never died, and Almalexia may have if she either cared about you enough, or if you had the option of talking her out of her madness and actually being her husband (or wife? O.o) again. <---- interesting mod idea... is there one like this out? :P
User avatar
akatosh
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 169
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 12:00 am

Post by akatosh »

It is not known what really happened with Nerevar. Some sources say the Tribunal murdered him, other say he was mortally injured during the battle of Red Mountain. It is unclear what really happened.

In Oblivion, I once heard people saying that Vivec was imprissoned by the Daedra. But at this time he was already insignificant.

The fact is that The Tribunal, whether they killed Nerevar or not, did many good things for their people, the dunmer. So in my opinion their passing should be mourned and unless your play as an evil character, Vivec should not be killed.
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Well, considering the ashlanders are the only source that haven't questioned and theorized other possibilities of what happened, not to mention that the dissident priest's theory agrees with the lore of the Ashlanders in the sense that the Tribunal used the Profane Tools against Nerevar's wishes. Since the Tribunal's story is the only one that doesn't agree with either of these, it's quite easy to assume they just aren't telling the truth (although yes, for the sake of protecting the inhabitants of Morrowind). But even for the sake of protecting thousands, abusing divine powers and profane objects is NOT a good thing. Think about it. Immortality and Divinity- abusing those things goes far beyond the concerns of a few thousand petty mortals that would rather make war with eachother anyway. Imagine if the Tribunal got unlucky like the Dewmer and ended up erasing their whole race from existence. Considering the lineage, it could've also wiped out the Altmer since they were still in the realm of Tamriel (the only reason what's-his-face in the Corprusarium isn't erased from existence is because he was beyond the borders of Tamriel when the battle at Red Mountain took place).

As for Vivic in Oblivion... I highly doubt it's more than a rumor, as I said, if any Daedra were to imprison Vivic, it would be Azura, and she'd have come for him personally. All of Morrowind would've known about it, which essentially means that all of Tamriel would've heard about it also. After all, it's not often a Daedra Prince assumes a physical form for the sole purpose of taking a prisoner. Opinion? Yes, very much. But a very accurate one, especially since it was Azura herself who placed the curse on the Chimer in the very presence of the Tribunal after they killed Nerevar.
User avatar
akatosh
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 169
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 12:00 am

Post by akatosh »

I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

I think the Tribunal were very ambitious and the fact that they used the Profane Tools to make themselves gods is without doubt an offense for the other deities like Azura. Before the Tribunal the Chimer worshipped both good and evil daedra and the Tribunal offered them an alternative and they did many good things for their people.

There's no discussion that using the Tools must've been extemely controversial but would Nerevar's friends and wife have murdered him to do it? Since the Tribunal can be considered as 'good' gods I doubt they would've killed their king.

I think Nerevar died after the battle because he was seriously injured and that he didn't want the tools to be used but the Tribunal did it nevertheless after Nerevar passed away and this caused the wrath of Azura.
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

The truth probably does lie somewhere in the middle, considering if the Ashlanders were COMPLETELY correct the Tribunal wouldn't have had their divine power before Azura cursed the Chimer, meaning they would've had the same Dunmeri skin and likely wouldn't have been able to alter it after becoming divine. Oooh, a new theory, perhaps Nerevar was mortally wounded at Red Mountain due to the Tribunal not acting to save him? And due to the first betrayal, Azura may have already been angered, and then with their second betrayal of using the Profane Tools against Nerevar's wishes she simply flew into a rage and cursed them (and their entire race)?

A thought crossed my mind that I find very funny. For all the Tribunal did and risked to become divine... they still weren't powerful enough to defeat the Numidium when Tiber Septim invaded Morrowind. And when the Numidium fought the Tribunal, it didn't even have its original heart (Lorkhan's). I have the strangest feeling that even a single Daedra Prince could've crushed Numidium out of existence if all it took was a necromancer to dismantle it.
User avatar
satan_n_stuff
Champion
Champion
Posts: 989
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2006 10:20 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY
Platform: pc, xbox
Status: blue eyed demon from hell
Location: The End of Time

Post by satan_n_stuff »

Oathbreaker wrote:The truth probably does lie somewhere in the middle, considering if the Ashlanders were COMPLETELY correct the Tribunal wouldn't have had their divine power before Azura cursed the Chimer, meaning they would've had the same Dunmeri skin and likely wouldn't have been able to alter it after becoming divine. Oooh, a new theory, perhaps Nerevar was mortally wounded at Red Mountain due to the Tribunal not acting to save him? And due to the first betrayal, Azura may have already been angered, and then with their second betrayal of using the Profane Tools against Nerevar's wishes she simply flew into a rage and cursed them (and their entire race)?

A thought crossed my mind that I find very funny. For all the Tribunal did and risked to become divine... they still weren't powerful enough to defeat the Numidium when Tiber Septim invaded Morrowind. And when the Numidium fought the Tribunal, it didn't even have its original heart (Lorkhan's). I have the strangest feeling that even a single Daedra Prince could've crushed Numidium out of existence if all it took was a necromancer to dismantle it.
A daedra prince can crush nearly anything, except for another daedra prince, because they have almost infinite power, in their sphere at least.
Image
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Ah, but keep in mind the Tribunal declared themselves more powerful than the Daedra Princes, which is in essence how they began renouncing Daedra Worship.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
User avatar
ragged-gothic
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 196
Joined: Tue Jul 24, 2007 12:02 am
UESPoints: 0
Location: Alone, in a darkened room... (the count)

Post by ragged-gothic »

:idea: Here is an aspect to this question that no one has mentioned yet. When your character has finished the main quest in Tribunal, both Sotha Sil and Almalexia are dead. So, assuming you have killed Vivec (or kill him subsequently),what happens to the ghostfence? Does it disappear? Theoretically it ought to, after all, it is only constant magicka maintenance by the Tribunal that keeps it functioning in the first place. If they are all dead, it should vanish.

This also should have major implications on a Nirn where the PC has finished the main Tribunal quest but not the main Morrowind quest. The red blight storm should constantly expand across Vvardenfell, and the whole island should start to be overrun with even more corprus creatures than before.

I have absolutely no idea whether the developers have taken this into account however. Has anyone tried killing Vivec and finishing the Tribunal main quest while the main Morrowind quest remains incomplete, to find out? :?:
User avatar
Oathbreaker
Guardian
Guardian
Posts: 712
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2008 12:08 am
UESPoints: 0

Post by Oathbreaker »

Actually I can put that theory to the test right now. I made a character that has literally done no quests whatsoever and has maxed stats. So I could just breeze through Mournhold and then kill Vivic using Barilzar's Mazed Band or w/e it's called. But, it would probably stay up anyway because the Ghost Fence is an enchantment, not a spell. Sure the Tribunal feeds magicka into it occasionally to keep up maintenance on it as you said, but that's just it, it could still stay up without them, but it would wear away much faster. But considering it's been up for hundreds of years, you wouldn't be able to wait it out until it completely fades within your character's life span.
The shadow of the past never dies, so walk forward knowing you can become better than what you've left behind.
Locked