What is the allure of the forsworn?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fifth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
Locked
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

Oops
Last edited by Eltee on Sat Mar 03, 2012 2:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

I'll state it again... An end is not an option for the Reachmen. Once more, I will state the two choices in life faced by the Reachmen
a) Resign yourself to Nord rule, give up your gods, your culture, and everything you hold sacred, work yourself nearly to death every day in silver mines for a pittance, while doing so is enriching the very people who cause this misery in your life. You live a short life of shame and misery, dying young due to overwork and unsafe work practices in the mine, if it isn't at the tip of a Nordic sword...

b) The other option is to join the forsworn. Instead of abandoning your gods, you embrace them, instead of forsaking your pride and honour, they become integral parts of your being. You fight for freedom, for the freedom of your friends, for justice for all those lost.
You likely die at a young age, but you do so honorably, in battle. Not coughing in the deep recesses of a mine.

Looking at the huge amount of Reachmen who are in the Forsworn in game, they seem to represent the larger part of the Reach's population.

Your thesis, that they should all just stop fighting, is intenable for one simple reason: For the Forsworn to give up their fight, living in peace must present a better life than dying in war.

I don't see this precondition fulfilled in the slightest.

Let's compare this to the options of a Nord.

a) Life your life in peace and prosperity, with no infringement upon your rights but what the Empire is forced to impose by the Treaty. The worship of Talos, that which is overlooked when done in secret.

b) You can join Ulfric's damnfool rebellion, bringing death and destruction for your nation for a negligible benefit, and at the cost of bringing senseless racial persecution to the elves and the beasts. At the cost of bankrupting the eastern holds. Likely, at the cost of your life.

A very different picture here. A Nord can not join the Stormcloaks, and his life will be longer, happier, and more productive. Can we say the same of the Reachmen? No.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

I will repeat myself again: I never said surrender.

I said to be offered their recognition, and be offered their own land. This means that they would not be under Nord Rule, but under their own Reachman Rule. Like with the Orc's and Orsinium.

Look at the Orc Strongholds in Skyrim. They keep to and rule themselves. The Nords are not attacking them, or forcing their rule upon them.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

If the Nords agreed to such an agreement, I'd be all for it.

But.

I cannot see them ever deigning to do such.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

I originally stated: If I could influence the Empire to do this.

I also stated: The hard part would be to get the Nords to agree.

I additionally said: Since there is the Western Reach, which includes part of High Rock, and maybe some of Hammerfel, so each area only gives up a bit.

If you look at the game/map, the Forsworn occupy/control a large part of the Reach Hold. They have two options:
- Continue to attack the Nords to take all of the Reach, lose more men and women, and possibly more land due to conter attacks.
- Keep and build upon what they have. Make them viable communities, cities, and defensable strongholds. Making them a viable economic asset.

Nowhere in my game, is there a Questline to attack and destroy the Forsworn. There are a few Quests, which ask for me to attack the Forsworn, for actions that the Forsworn commited, like taking a mine, killing miners and travelers, kidnapping a child (Dibella) and such. They are reactions to the actions made by the Forsworn. The Forsworn even attack the mine of a Breton/Reachman... which is why there are silver-blood mercenary's there.

The Forsworn can continue on their path of war, and barbarianism... or chose the path of evolution.

I have never had a Forsworn ask me to retaliate against the Nords, for attacking and killing them. I can not even talk to the Forsworn. I am able to talk to the Orcs, do favors/quests for them, and become Blood Kin.

I do get where you are coming from with the Romantic Fantasy Story of the downtrodden people... but in game, that is not what is happening. I would honestly like to be able to help out the Forsworn. I do not like Ulfric, or the Silver-Bloods. Unfortunatly, in game, I am only left with one choice... or two, which is to leave them alone.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

Aha! Okay, I see where you are coming from.

I'm wrong, it seems. There is a better alternative that I haven't included. I concede defeat, and do so happily.

Mmmh... Speaking of which, can you imagine what a Forsworn city or town would look like, if it was expanded to a respectable size? THAT would be cool.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

There is no right or wrong (theory's). I was only trying to bring forth another option besides war/genocide. I wasn't trying to win anything, so no need to admit to defeat. I was just point out that it could be a viable option, and hopes that it would be acknowledged as such. :wink:

I would also be curious what a town would look like. How much of the architecture in the Reach, is from the Original Reachmen? ...or would it be like some of the camps, where it is wooden walled, with wooden walkways, and bridges?
Last edited by Jeff on Sat Mar 03, 2012 3:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

I'm sure it would also include aspects of ancient Nordic architecture periodically... Perhaps built over it.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

What I was meaning, with the Nords taking over the lands from the Reachmen, how much of the architecture of the Reach is actually taken from the Reachmen, and not the Nords.

An example is when you look at Lost Valley Redoubt, which is more similar to Aztec Stepe Framing, with tiered levels, as opposed to the Domed Ruins of the Ancient Nords.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

Hmm... I see what you mean.

I seem to be missing the point of your posts the first time round fairly consistently.

Hmm... Lost Valley Redoubt certainly is unique. It was almost certainly built before Tiber Septim's time, I don't think that Ancient Nord ruins were produced during the third age. So... Theoretically, most nord ruins in the reach have the potential of being Reachman.

Which implies that modern forsworn culture might be very similar to anient Nordic culture... Looking at the nigh-on identical architecture and patterns.
User avatar
Hissien
Archmage
Archmage
Posts: 1902
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 5:10 pm
ES Games: Morrowind Oblivion and Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Something pretentious.
Other Profiles: Xbox: AbroadHarpy22 Steam: Hissien
UESPoints: 1
Location: The astral plane

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Hissien »

Actually nordic and reachmen culture are near identical. But nords abandoned the old ways and chose the nine divines. That's why reachmen are known as "followers of the old ways".
\[T]/ Praise the Sun Y'all
User avatar
Evil-i
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2086
Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 10:51 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox, 360
Status: I have a pulse; it's a good day.

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Evil-i »

Hissien wrote:Actually nordic and reachmen culture are near identical. But nords abandoned the old ways and chose the nine divines. That's why reachmen are known as "followers of the old ways".
I guess that makes Froki Whetted-Blade a nordic reachman. Or a reachmanic nord.
"Keep your arrows in their archer" *quiver*
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

Perhaps the interbreeding of the Reachmen with Elves that made them more Bretonic than Nordic happened AFTER Talos's conquest?
User avatar
Pilaf The Defiler
Imperial Legate
Imperial Legate
Posts: 4359
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:03 pm
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, ESO
Platform: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360
Status: Fresh
UESPoints: 20

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Pilaf The Defiler »

Eltee wrote:Perhaps the interbreeding of the Reachmen with Elves that made them more Bretonic than Nordic happened AFTER Talos's conquest?

The Reachmen were already totally a thing during Talos' ascent to the throne. They were considered a mongrel race even then by Imperial scholars.
Monsters are bred in labyrinths, labyrinths are bred from walls. There is a reason the Giants choose to remain nomadic rather than follow their shield kin the Nords in building permanent settlements. The Tower is the beginning of all walls.
bushwhacker2k
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 5:23 pm
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Alabama, USA

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by bushwhacker2k »

Jeff wrote:There is no right or wrong (theory's).
I quite agree.

I actually chose the Forsworn in the Cidhna Mine quest for one simple reason. Conflict.

I don't want certain sides to win, I want constant conflict. I want to see what happens after long periods of conflict, with both sides gaining and losing holds, to see what shapes from the remains.

I don't think I've seen much good come of victory for one side, the other side suffers greatly and the victorious side is somewhat prosperous for a short period afterwards until another side comes along and fights them.

I guess constant conflict might balance that.

---

Almost forgot to add! With both sides fighting, I get to kill that many more people! :D
Sansreal
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2011 7:38 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PS3

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Sansreal »

The reason that the forsworn are hostile to everyone that isn't a reachman is probably because there have been attempts to infiltrate their ranks or gain their trust and betray them. They have been driven to being fiercely territorial. Just look at the Hagravens' creations, the Briarhearts. I doubt they do that ritual lightly, but the way they see it, they have no choice.
Sadly, this is also one of the reasons why I believe it would be nearly impossible to join them as a faction. The only time I can think of when someone who wasn't a Reachman joined them was the few in Cidhna mine who weren't of the Reach, and they spent years gaining the personal trust of the leader of the Forsworn.
"I'm so glad Eola invited you to dinner."
Locked