What is the allure of the forsworn?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fifth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

There is a grand total of

*drumroll*

one non-Reachman Breton in the Reach.
User avatar
Rynkar
Warder
Warder
Posts: 481
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox-360
Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
Location: Nightingale Hall.

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Rynkar »

Eltee wrote:Once again, there is the following chide for Reachmen:
-Live in poverty and discrimination, toiling for tiny wages to enrich your tourmentors
-Fight for freedom.

Easy choice.
Its not that black and white.
They could just go away from the reach, it has no meaning besides the land of the forsworns birth, Go to a more accepting place, like cyrodil. Don't create enemies and everything will work out. And if your place of birth is so important for you to fight and die for it, maybe it would be best if no one could have it.
Spoiler:
In their tongue, I am Dovahkiin: Dragon Born!
Lee 95
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2012 5:39 am
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Lee 95 »

Gameplay, more or less. You can't exactly realistically populate Skyrim with NPCs unless you're using a computer borrowed from NASA.
First to fight for the right, and to build the nation's might, the Army goes rolling along.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

And where are you getting the resources to uproot yourself from your native land and move somewhere else? The Reachmen are largely poor. Not exactly conducive for moving to the Metropolitan province. High Rock persecutes the people of the West Reach just as harshly as the Nords do in the east.

@Lee
He makes an in-game comment about being the only Breton in Markarth.
User avatar
Hissien
Archmage
Archmage
Posts: 1902
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 5:10 pm
ES Games: Morrowind Oblivion and Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Something pretentious.
Other Profiles: Xbox: AbroadHarpy22 Steam: Hissien
UESPoints: 1
Location: The astral plane

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Hissien »

Rynkar wrote:
Eltee wrote:Once again, there is the following chide for Reachmen:
-Live in poverty and discrimination, toiling for tiny wages to enrich your tourmentors
-Fight for freedom.

Easy choice.
Its not that black and white.
They could just go away from the reach, it has no meaning besides the land of the forsworns birth, Go to a more accepting place, like cyrodil. Don't create enemies and everything will work out. And if your place of birth is so important for you to fight and die for it, maybe it would be best if no one could have it.
Trail of tears much? But really? The black and white argument from you? Who calls them savages?

But I agree if they can leave they should. I doubt it is so much them wanting to stay as having no way to be sure. To the west is the wrothgarian mountain range filled with most likely hostile orcs. Cyrodiil would be great if they didn't have to go through hostile territory. But it may be their only hope.
\[T]/ Praise the Sun Y'all
Lee 95
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2012 5:39 am
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Lee 95 »

@Eltee ; That being said, I did say the Reach, and not specifically Markarth. You can't really judge an entire state by the capitol. Though to be fair, I am assuming that the dialogue I heard came from Bretons. I may have to recheck, given that it can be hard to differentiate.
First to fight for the right, and to build the nation's might, the Army goes rolling along.
User avatar
Rynkar
Warder
Warder
Posts: 481
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox-360
Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
Location: Nightingale Hall.

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Rynkar »

The forsworn seem like they can easily cross mountains, the have hunting skill and magic that could sustain them. And northern cyrodil is very vacant, they have plenty of room to live it up, without bumping elbows with anybody.
Spoiler:
In their tongue, I am Dovahkiin: Dragon Born!
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

I'd say it's a fairly good representation.

The population is slightly more than half Reachman, counting Forsworn, it is astronomically higher. The Reachman popular opinion, as can be gleaned by a mere five minutes of dialogue, is with the Forsworn.

And, coincidentally, against 'true Bretons, who oppress them to the same degree as the Nords do.

@ Rynkar
I'll concede the point. You're right, they could move.
Which only circles back to my original point about their culture, their religion, which is so closely bound to the land itself.
If they are forced to become refugees, their lives will be little better than conditions under the Nords. (well... Considerably better. But still pretty primitive.)
They stay and fight for their land, and by extension, their culture, their Gods, their rights, and their honour.
User avatar
Hissien
Archmage
Archmage
Posts: 1902
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 5:10 pm
ES Games: Morrowind Oblivion and Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Something pretentious.
Other Profiles: Xbox: AbroadHarpy22 Steam: Hissien
UESPoints: 1
Location: The astral plane

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Hissien »

Except for: the southern half of skyrim, the orcs, the bretons, and the legion. That said they are still in just as much danger where they are.
\[T]/ Praise the Sun Y'all
Lee 95
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2012 5:39 am
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Lee 95 »

The main issue is that the Forsworn have presented themselves as hostile to everyone: most likely, they'd be attacked by anyone who saw them coming, out of a sense of self defense. As an example, this would be comparable to the population of Israel suddenly deciding to migrate through its Arab neighbours; Arab-Israeli history has always been hostile, and so they'd likely be shot at on sight.

@Eltee

I suppose so, though I'd reckon my general point still stands. They've made an enemy out of almost every power that could have recognized them as a legitimate government, and so have put themselves in a position with no allies and virtually all major powers as enemies.
First to fight for the right, and to build the nation's might, the Army goes rolling along.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

As Morrowind, Hammerfell, Skyrim, Elsweyr and Argonia have before.

The Empire was willing to accept overtures for statehood before Ulfric stampeded through. They will do it again. It seems countertheietic for the Empire to hold a grudge now.
User avatar
Rynkar
Warder
Warder
Posts: 481
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 1:39 am
ES Games: oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox-360
Status: Ready for some skyrim dlc...
Location: Nightingale Hall.

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Rynkar »

I can truly say my mind has been changed on them, no more do I see them as monsters fighting just to fight, but an entire culture stuck in a self dooming cycle.

But I digress, now I wish there was a way to broker some sort of deal where both sides worked out a mutual agreement, to stop all the blood letting.
Spoiler:
In their tongue, I am Dovahkiin: Dragon Born!
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

How about this: Let the people rule, as they did during the great war. People want to be ruled by their own. If the Empire installed Madenach as Jarl of the Reach? The instantaneous acceptance it could bring for the Empire. Happiness, if a bit of confusion at having to rule a prosperous kingdom you lost 2000 years before. Everything can settle into it's natural rhythm.
User avatar
Hissien
Archmage
Archmage
Posts: 1902
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2012 5:10 pm
ES Games: Morrowind Oblivion and Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360, PC
Status: Something pretentious.
Other Profiles: Xbox: AbroadHarpy22 Steam: Hissien
UESPoints: 1
Location: The astral plane

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Hissien »

Rynkar wrote:I can truly say my mind has been changed on them, no more do I see them as monsters fighting just to fight, but an entire culture stuck in a self dooming cycle.

But I digress, now I wish there was a way to broker some sort of deal where both sides worked out a mutual agreement, to stop all the blood letting.
Me too. I identify with them some but I don't think they deserve the apotheosis I gave them. Maybe that will be a DLC setting up new land for the forsworn.

I'm glad I came away with this with a new opinion of the forsworn.

Old gods keep you.
\[T]/ Praise the Sun Y'all
Lee 95
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2012 5:39 am
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Lee 95 »

@Eltee
You have a point on that, though I suppose it'll ultimately be entirely up to Bethesda on how the situation is resolved.

Personally, I doubt the Empire would want to risk upsetting the majoratively Nordic population of Skyrim, especially after having fought a volatile civil war. As I understand it, most Nords are decidedly prejudiced against the Forsworn.
First to fight for the right, and to build the nation's might, the Army goes rolling along.
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

They don't really seem to be too upset about p*ssing off the Nords.

And, really, will the other holds care? Solitude will focus on it's fish, Whiterun on it's grain, and life goes on.
User avatar
Talamare
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 349
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2011 8:04 am
ES Games: Arena, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox, PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Talamare »

Its not as simple as them taking back Markarth

They could probably assault the town and take it back, but if they did then the full extent of the Nord armies would attack


Nords dont want peace with them, so unless a 3rd party interferes there wont be peace

If the Imperials take control of Skyrim once again then there is a chance for peace, but if the Stormcloaks actually succeed and Skyrim becomes pure Nord expect genocide
WARNING:If I begin a sentence with "Clearly", Im using Sarcasm.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

- If the Forsworn have the right to fight for what was theirs, then the Nords have the right to fight for what is theirs....?
- Why should the Forsworn Culture be any more important than the Nord Culture?
- If the Empire Ruled Tamriel for Centuries, then why is there Redguard, Breton, Nord, ect Culture?
- If the Nords Rule Skyrim, and the Reach, then is not the Culture in that Hold Nord?
- Can differing Cultures not Coexist?
- Can you not build your Culture anywhere you are?
- ...so our they really fighting to protect their Culture, their way of life?
- ...or are they just fighting because they can?
- ...because that is all they know?

So for those who said they would rather die, than give up their right, culture, way of life... (put the shoe on the other foot)... If someone came along, and said "I have a deed that says that my forefathers owned this property centuries ago"... would you just leave, and give up that land, and house, and all you own?

Why should the Nords do that then?

Honestly, the Divines should just wipe all existance off of the planet, since after thousands of years, the only thing they have learned is war.
User avatar
Trelares
Master
Master
Posts: 1374
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2010 12:52 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: ...
Location: Vienna, Austria (and no we have no Kangaroos!)

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Trelares »

The problem is like in the real world, both sites want to win on fullscale. But such a conflict can't be won by one side without drastic measures (like a genocide). Both sides should make concessions for the other sides and meet somewhere in the middle.
Kinsman, House Hlaalu

RFC 5513
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

That is what I have been saying from the begining. I wish I had the ability (in game), to influence the Empire to recognize the Forsworn/Reachmen, and give them land, like they did with the Orcs and Orsinium. A little bit from Skyrim, High Rock, and Hammerfel, so each area only loses a little, but the Forsworn/Reachmen get a place to call their own.

What this have been is: Who has the right to kill and murder the other side...

It is sort of dissapointing that I am the bad guy, and get ridiculed for suggesting peace...???
User avatar
Jagged
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 305
Joined: Fri Jan 20, 2012 11:37 am
ES Games: Skyrim
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jagged »

Hissien wrote:"The nords didn't care who was or wasn't involved with the rebellion, I had spoken to madanach once. That was enough. But my daughter didn't want to see her papa leave and begged the nords to take her instead. And after they made me watch her head roll off the block they threw me in here to dig up their silver". I memorized this yet I cant remember his name.
Ah so not the Nords, the Silver Bloods. Annoyed we don't get to see if their blood is really silver :Angry:
User avatar
Eltee
Master
Master
Posts: 1153
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2011 8:28 pm
ES Games: TES II-III-IV-V
Platform: PC
Status: Elsewhere
Location: Ontario

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Eltee »

It is no less honorable to encourage fighting against injustice than to encourage submitting, for the sake of peace.
User avatar
Jeff
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 4680
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 2:35 pm
Status: Gone

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jeff »

- I did not say surrender or submit.
- I said to offer them recognition, and a land to call their own, which is what they are wanting.., in order to stop the fightig.
- Both sides have to compromise for there to be peace.
- There is NO honor in fighting when you have the option for peace.
- You are no longer fighting against injustice when you have the option for peace.
- If you have the option for peace, yet refuse that peace, then you are the one that is commiting the acts of injustice.
User avatar
JVElEven
Master
Master
Posts: 1234
Joined: Sun Apr 17, 2011 9:26 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, Skyrim (DUH!)
Platform: PC
Status: The last damn purist around here!
Other Profiles: I'm always JVElEven. Look me up on Steam
Location: Jylland

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by JVElEven »

Honor/Peace:

That depends on your world view. A warrior in Tamriel would perhaps choose honor of battle over honor of peace.
Because there's no fun to be found in being normal.
User avatar
Jagged
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 305
Joined: Fri Jan 20, 2012 11:37 am
ES Games: Skyrim
Platform: PC

Re: What is the allure of the forsworn?

Post by Jagged »

Jeff wrote:- If you have the option for peace, yet refuse that peace, then you are the one that is commiting the acts of injustice.
That kind of assumes all offers are acceptable and fair.

It also absolves all initial injustices. I steal half your garden (by moving my fence), we get in a dispute so I offer you half back. Its now on you if you don't accept? I think not.
Locked