Hi all, I want to become thane in Falkreath, but the Jarl (Siddgeir) doesn't have the dialogue option to start me on the initial "kill a bandit leader/giant/dragon" quest. I understand this is a well-known issue in that hold. In my journal I have a couple such early thane quests left over from Dawnstar, where I nevertheless became thane without problems. These two quests are "kill a giant" and "collect bounty from Skald", and I cannot complete them anymore. I couldn't complete them even when Skald was still Jarl, and now he is Jarl no longer. I went to talk to him in Ulfric's palace, then tried talking to the current Jarl Brina, but there's still no option to complete those quests. I visited the giant camp in question and there is no one there, so I must have killed that giant before being given the quest, and now I can't get the bounty or even mark these two quests in the journal.
Anyway, in Falkreath I'm about ready to become thane: I completed the Clavicus Vile and Hircine quest, and did two radiant quests for the old disgruntled ex-Jarl there (killing his vampire ancestor, and stealing a letter from the blacksmith), and now he offers me no more quests. I also did a few other people some favors, so all I need now is for Jarl Siddgeir to just start me on the initial thane quests. And he never does.
Could anyone help please?
Uncompleteable thane quests preventing Falkreath thane quest
- SuperNull
- Warder

- Posts: 468
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2011 9:50 pm
- Status: Has Amazing Horse
- Location: Other Places
Re: Uncompleteable thane quests preventing Falkreath thane q
First some general advice: if you come across a quest that bugs out, do not continue the the game but search for a solution first because the only option may be to reload a previous save.
Secondly, most quest are fixable with console commands, just look up the quest on the wiki. If the page itself does not offer the info you need, also look at the associated discussion page for some informal chatter.
I do not know if it is possible to fix any of the stuck radiant bounty quests. You however should be able to force the Falkreath thane quest to start by using setstage Favor258 x. What the right value of x could be is hinted at at the appropriate quest page: http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Thane_of_Falkreath.
General info on how to use the console is here: http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Console
Secondly, most quest are fixable with console commands, just look up the quest on the wiki. If the page itself does not offer the info you need, also look at the associated discussion page for some informal chatter.
I do not know if it is possible to fix any of the stuck radiant bounty quests. You however should be able to force the Falkreath thane quest to start by using setstage Favor258 x. What the right value of x could be is hinted at at the appropriate quest page: http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Thane_of_Falkreath.
General info on how to use the console is here: http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Console
Re: Uncompleteable thane quests preventing Falkreath thane q
Just to add my experience here:
I also couldn't get the dialogue option from Falkreath Jarl (Siddgeir) to start the quest to become thane. Just as the discussion page at http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim_talk:Thane_of_Falkreath says, the questline is tied up with the "Rare Gifts" quests. I searched for started quests in my journal and found one of the rare gift's quests - to search for the book "Song of the Alchemists". So I did this one and went to the Jarl again. To my surprise, he gave me one of the rare gift's quests too - to get him a bottle of Black Briar's mead. So I fetched him one and voila! The dialogue for "kill a bandit leader" (becoming a thane) was there!
Neat!
For completion of the "thane" quest here I did A Daedra's Best Friend, Ill Met By Moonlight, Dark Ancestor, Lod's Lot, fetched some cabbages (should be wheat but he also takes cabbages) for the farmer in Falkreath and got some wood (you'll need woodcutters axe) for Hert over at Half-Moon mill.
I also couldn't get the dialogue option from Falkreath Jarl (Siddgeir) to start the quest to become thane. Just as the discussion page at http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim_talk:Thane_of_Falkreath says, the questline is tied up with the "Rare Gifts" quests. I searched for started quests in my journal and found one of the rare gift's quests - to search for the book "Song of the Alchemists". So I did this one and went to the Jarl again. To my surprise, he gave me one of the rare gift's quests too - to get him a bottle of Black Briar's mead. So I fetched him one and voila! The dialogue for "kill a bandit leader" (becoming a thane) was there!
Neat!
For completion of the "thane" quest here I did A Daedra's Best Friend, Ill Met By Moonlight, Dark Ancestor, Lod's Lot, fetched some cabbages (should be wheat but he also takes cabbages) for the farmer in Falkreath and got some wood (you'll need woodcutters axe) for Hert over at Half-Moon mill.

