Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Pre-Release Archive

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

Post Reply
User avatar
Rat Kiosk
Associate
Associate
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2010 11:46 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Pc, Xbox 360

Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Rat Kiosk »

It [&@%!] me off how you could make your character be a complete [&@%!] the entire time and everyone in the main quest will treat you the same.

*Knocks out martin kills most of the Blades* Martin gets up and is just like "Hello Friend" and I shout at my computer going "NO! I want concequences!"

Also I want to feel awefull when I kill some townsfolk. I want to be made to feel horrible. Going to jail for 10 seconds doesn't make a difference.
User avatar
Jakarius321
Champion
Champion
Posts: 802
Joined: Sat Oct 10, 2009 5:03 pm
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC, PS3
Status: Does anyone actually read these?
Location: Can't remember

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Jakarius321 »

kotarski wrote:Also I want to feel awefull when I kill some townsfolk. I want to be made to feel horrible. Going to jail for 10 seconds doesn't make a difference.
We could stick your character in the stocks and pelt you with rotten vegetables? But there's probably famine in the area so that would just waste food, and humiliation is just going to make you want revenge. :mrgreen:

Or maybe there could be capital punishment? For the most serious crimes (mass murder). A bit like resist arrest but they send you to jail without an option to resist (e.g. the guards tackle/catch you) and schedule your execution for (for example) the next day. You have until then to break out of jail. If you don't then you are executed, but I don't know how that would work with the current death system and would probably just land the game with a big fat M rating.
Is this meant to be witty, informative or deep? I doubt I can manage all three.
User avatar
Mucro
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 368
Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2011 4:07 pm
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: PS3, PC
Status: Exploiting poor people.

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Mucro »

Or maybe there could be capital punishment? For the most serious crimes (mass murder). A bit like resist arrest but they send you to jail without an option to resist (e.g. the guards tackle/catch you) and schedule your execution for (for example) the next day. You have until then to break out of jail. If you don't then you are executed, but I don't know how that would work with the current death system and would probably just land the game with a big fat M rating.
i like that idea, it would add real consequence to make you thing about. And if you are given the death sentance, you would have the feeling of desperation to escape. Also desperation to not be caught, this may lead to you killing more. eventually leading to masses hunting you
User avatar
The Tourist
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 325
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2008 4:44 am

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by The Tourist »

Not to be controversial or anything, but I'd say crime and punishment doesn't work in any game, really. If there was a balance between action and consequence, you wouldn't be continuing on your merry if you'd just gone postal on a town: you'd be dead, or permanently in jail. Which would be stoopid (and dull).

But the gaming norm - be it GTA or Fable - isn't very believable or satisfying either: escape or fight off 'the law' for a few minutes, and then hey presto! Sweet, sweet moral neutrality... (or a few disgruntled NPC's back in town)

Ambitious games have big problems. Letting the player essentially do what they want isn't conducive to a tight narrative. Going 'evil' might be fun (I don't see how), but an ultimate freedom of killing off the main quest givers kinda runs contrary to, y'know, being able to play the whole game.

I think Red Dead Redemption, as with so much else, found a fairly decent middleground: NPC's would react slightly differently to you if you strayed morally, thus maintaining a consistent player feedback re his or her own actions. And the vigilante posses would grow in number and threat if you kept on the run, but not punish you by ALWAYS being right on your tail. I'd be happy with a similiar system in Skyrim, but I think Bethesda's aims and design ethos will simply be very different to Rockstars, so who knows. I doubt in TES such things really affect a players experience to any important degree.
[ data pending ]
User avatar
JJSmart
Layman
Layman
Posts: 0
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 8:48 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by JJSmart »

I think this could work. If they implement some kind of disguise system, sort of like in Fallout: NV, except instead of making you part of a city's faction, you could join the "miscellaneous NPC" faction (essentially making people see you as a nobody, as in "not the player") if you wear a cloak and hood, and don't linger near guards or you'll be busted.
It would force an evil player to find a disguise when going near "good" encampments, villages or cities, and to find a new disguise if they're caught with the current one.
The more severe your crimes, the more guards start to patrol and look around for you.

I've always played sneaky rogue-like characters in Morrowind and Oblivion, and while i've always been on the "good" side, i'd absolutely LOVE something like this.
Molag Bal
Layman
Layman
Posts: 0
Joined: Fri Dec 24, 2010 4:41 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Molag Bal »

I think this is an interesting question, and I think the best answer to it would be to use a Fallout: New Vegas-like faction system. In that game, every freaking action has its resulting consequence, and your reputation with every faction in the game (and there are a whole lot of 'em) is influenced steadily by your choices. And you can be a MAJOR evil ***hole in New Vegas during the Main Quest, and be perceived as such ; but you can still finish the game, and every decision you took concerning important places and people is exposed in the ending and modifies it.

Therefore, the ultimate punishment in a game is not a prison sentence, nor even a death sentence ; it's to realize that, because of your actions, and solely of your actions, some avenues of the game are permanently blocked, and you must find some other way around. And this punishment, in some sense, brings its own rewards. (I hope I didn't get too philosophical here :P)

Concerning actual punishment for crimes like murder, theft and trespassing, I don't expect the Imperial Guard to make you STOP ! because YOU VIOLATED THE LAW ! I have a hunch that justice might be a more personal affair, and that the places and towns we'll get to visit might be more Skaal-like than Imperial-like. So yes, I'm expecting (and kinda hoping) an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth in handling the justice.

So if you're caught while doing some horrible act like murdering an innocent or bloodsucking a victim dry, I don't think a prison sentence will be in order :P.
The Inquisitor
Layman
Layman
Posts: 0
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2011 10:56 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by The Inquisitor »

I absolutely agree. To be honest Oblivion didn't give nearly enough opportunities to be evil (sure, there's the Dark Brotherhood, but that's practically the only evil faction out there). You should be able to take a few decisions if you attain some kind of leadership position, too. I always thought it would be fun to reinstitute the legality of necromancy if you become Archmage.
User avatar
TheoC
Novice
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 6:44 pm
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: Xbox 360, PC

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by TheoC »

I agree that the short jail time was nothing tbh. But can they make it so the player genuinely doesn't want to get caught? They couldn't really make it so you have to actually serve the time instead of just sleeping, because that would take ages and be boring. The only punishment I can think of is putting you in a cell with a wierd muscly orc who hasn't seen a woman in a long time, if you know what I mean
*Shudder* :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock:
Check out my Oblivion Machinima Series!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfTiIE7T7GQ
User avatar
JJSmart
Layman
Layman
Posts: 0
Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2011 8:48 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by JJSmart »

True. Jail time in Oblivion didn't feel like a punishment at all, unless you were loaded with stolen items and weren't able to ditch (hide) them before getting caught.
They should make you do prisoner stuff like forced labor so after your first trip to a prison you'll genuinely be like "I'm never going back to that hell hole!!!"
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Mattbott »

there's a load they could do. The fame/infamy didn't have much impact in Oblivion imo but it was there working away at npc attitudes to you behind the scenes, so a guard would be frowning at you if you were the sort who regularly sent out dark minions from deepscorn hollow. I would have preferred it if the guards started following and harrassing evil doers, or running you out of town if you were that much of a threat to goodness. Likewise, as the guards kick you out of the local pub, you could be intercepted by the local thugs and invited into their 'private gentleman's club' for a quick pint

TES is far more 'hero' orientated than fallout, it might be intentional cos fantasy usually means good vs evil (ie black and white), so it would be good to be able to join bandits/necromancers/or even the imperial watch or the local lord's honour guard if your character has done deeds to recommend them to the group

the main plot in a game will invariably involve the end of the world so even evil characters would have a motivation in stopping the ultimate villain, if necessary the villain can always reject an evil character's attempts to join in with the plan
Spoiler:
(tho Dagoth Ur does invite the nerevarine to join him i seem to remember, and its a shame you can't do so if youve decided that Vivec should pay for his deeds)
the point is, there is no reason why you couldnt be totally evil, and go along with the main quest to save the land

i think this thread highlights where the real innovation should be in Skyrim, graphics are all very well to be expected and new ai is always going to wow us if done successfully, but rpgs are about making choices and living with the consequences and feeling you have played a unique version of the game
User avatar
Rat Kiosk
Associate
Associate
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2010 11:46 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Pc, Xbox 360

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Rat Kiosk »

What if going too jail had some permanent consequences like how getting knocked out in fable 2,3 gave you permanent scars. Say if going to Jail permanently aged you. Obviously the whole crime system would have to be overhauled from oblivions though. No psychic guards etc.
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Dark Spark »

The only way I can see an evil character play its way through the same story is if there were an equal number of support mechanisms for the evil character as the good one.

The white hat gets all these stereotypical allies— the law, the sovereign, the church, etc. In many such games, you're tasked with getting the king and the guards and the mages on your side so they can join together to defeat the overwhelming blight upon the land.

If you were going for a black hat character, you'd need equally helpful forces aligned to your goals. The thing is, the black hat's friends aren't going to get along with the white hat's folks— to "win" the game for one side usually means you ignore or even destroy the elements from the other side. Brigands, assassins, and raiders who are going to present the same level of potency as the king, guards, and mages that that "other guy" would've brought to the final battle.

If a game designer set up a game complex enough to flow through either of these two paths, chances are they'll find it too difficult to present the game in anything less than a cheap "This or That" scenario: once you make friends with one side, you'll never be able to set up an alliance with anyone from the other path. The big bad dragon at the end of the game is going to look at your hero and his assembled friends, then mutter "At least they're all wearing the same sort of clothes."

A game that is dynamic and integrated enough to let you choose A) one path to salvation, B) the other path to the same goal, or C) some negotiated coalition between the two is a game complex enough to use in college-level Political Science as a classroom training tool. And the last thing we need in this world is a game that produces more and more aspiring politicians... :shock:
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Rat Kiosk
Associate
Associate
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2010 11:46 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Pc, Xbox 360

Re: Evil in the main quest. PLEASE!

Post by Rat Kiosk »

Dark Spark wrote:The only way I can see an evil character play its way through the same story is if there were an equal number of support mechanisms for the evil character as the good one.

The white hat gets all these stereotypical allies— the law, the sovereign, the church, etc. In many such games, you're tasked with getting the king and the guards and the mages on your side so they can join together to defeat the overwhelming blight upon the land.

If you were going for a black hat character, you'd need equally helpful forces aligned to your goals. The thing is, the black hat's friends aren't going to get along with the white hat's folks— to "win" the game for one side usually means you ignore or even destroy the elements from the other side. Brigands, assassins, and raiders who are going to present the same level of potency as the king, guards, and mages that that "other guy" would've brought to the final battle.

If a game designer set up a game complex enough to flow through either of these two paths, chances are they'll find it too difficult to present the game in anything less than a cheap "This or That" scenario: once you make friends with one side, you'll never be able to set up an alliance with anyone from the other path. The big bad dragon at the end of the game is going to look at your hero and his assembled friends, then mutter "At least they're all wearing the same sort of clothes."

A game that is dynamic and integrated enough to let you choose A) one path to salvation, B) the other path to the same goal, or C) some negotiated coalition between the two is a game complex enough to use in college-level Political Science as a classroom training tool. And the last thing we need in this world is a game that produces more and more aspiring politicians... :shock:

I completely agree. Maybe they will, they did in new vegas.
Post Reply