Game Crashes when Saving

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
Clusterfunk
Layman
Layman
Posts: 5
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 10:45 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC, Xbox 360

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by Clusterfunk »

I could, but that wouldn't fix the problem. I think affecting the bounty at all then saving is the problem. I don't want to cheat, I just want the game to stop crashing.
gasparin
Associate
Associate
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Aug 19, 2010 4:49 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by gasparin »

Going back to the issue of keys (or the keychain mod) causing savegame crashes, I just had a strange case of corruption.
Spoiler:
I was doing the Sanguine Daedra quest in which everything in your inventory is removed after you cast the spell on the party guests. After I finished the quest, and got all my inventory from the chest, each time I saved the game, it would crash, and that save game was corrupted.
By only removing some of my items from the chest and saving after each step, I was finally able to figure out that one particular set of two keys was corrupting my game.
Spoiler:
I think the keys come from the quest in which you are tricked into going to an island fort and hunted - one is the "real" key and the other is not. I'm not sure if I am remembering that quest correctly with respect to the keys
At any rate, if I left those two keys in the chest, I never got the corruption issue. I figure I won't be needing those keys again.

Also, I agree with H8Ball regarding the DarkUI'd Darn being a great mod. However, I wanted the KeyChain mod because of the fact that the Darnified UI does not collapse the keys when you looking at a container (as has been noted). However, as has also been noted, the KeyChain mod ended up being too buggy, and I have had fewer issues since uninstalling it.
User avatar
KrisCrash
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2063
Joined: Mon May 24, 2010 6:59 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Status: reading Matt's status
Location: inside 3ds Max
Contact:

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by KrisCrash »

Oh so those are the 2 rotten keys!

I had keychain crash my game because of some rotten keys, might be the same problem. How would they corrupt your save, I wonder?

Well.. DarnUI doesn't collapse keys AT ALL, container or none, so I dunno?
"A lady likes a weapon she can fit in her purse."
Want to see my drawings?
gasparin
Associate
Associate
Posts: 10
Joined: Thu Aug 19, 2010 4:49 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by gasparin »

Darnified DarkUI collapses keys for me when I look in my inventory. I can expand them, but, by default, they are collapsed.
UFAlien
Layman
Layman
Posts: 1
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2011 3:44 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by UFAlien »

Forgive the necro, but I've recently run into a similar problem. I'm running a Windows 7, 64-bit laptop well above recommended system requirements. I bought Oblivion: GOTY on Steam, installed the unofficial patches for the core game, Shivering Isles, and official plug-ins, and installed a body replacer using Wyre Bash. These are the only mods I have installed. While I was playing around in Wyre Bash one day, I noticed it was telling me two official plug-ins - Frostcrag Spire and Horse Armor - shared the same load order (despite the fact that one was labeled as 4, the other 5). Hoping it would avoid any further problems, I unloaded Horse Armor.

The next time I loaded a save, I got a message saying it relied on objects that no longer existed, and that said objects may not exist in-game. I clicked "okay" and continued onward. For quite a while, everything was normal. I started the Knights of the Nine questline, and that's when the problems started. At one point during Pilgrimage, I experienced a sudden CTD - I had no idea why at the time, but now I suspect I'd moved into a new cell and the game was trying to autosave. I loaded my last save, continued on, and made it to the Sword of the Crusader quest (picking up two levels in the process). Unfortunately, I started getting more CTDs in the cave. At one point it crashed just as I hit the quicksave button. Upon restarting the game, I saw that the save had gone through and I was able to load it, but a later quicksave had the same effect - and this time, the save didn't work (though I can't remember if it was corrupted or just not listed). I decided to stop quicksaving, completed the quest, and left the cave.

Leaving the cave, of course, triggered an autosave and another crash. I turned off all autosaving and attempted to load the one that had caused the crash, but it was corrupted. I loaded the previous save, completed the quest again, and before leaving the cave, made sure to do a manual save. CTD. The next time I launched the game, not only was that save corrupted, but so was the one I'd been using in the middle of the quest. I've deleted all those saves, reloaded Horse Armor, and now things are working again - for the moment. After reading through this thread, though, I'm a bit nervous that it'll crop up again. And even if it doesn't, it already cost me most of a questline and two levels.

I'll keep you posted on the situation as it progresses. If anyone has any insight, questions, or comments, I'd love to hear them.
Mathyz
Layman
Layman
Posts: 1
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2011 11:46 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by Mathyz »

Hey. I don't know if this is the case for you but it happened to me and seems to be topic related. (I'm posting this more as a help for people who might encouter this and google it). I could save and see all my saves in the loading menu, most were corrupted but some worked, loading one of them would cause the game to be extremly unstable and crash very often. I looked it up for a while and i came to this conclusion:

It can't be my computer since it can take oblivion on very high settings without any fps drop, and i tried lowering everything and got the same results. I tried re-installing and still it didn't work. Then I figured out what it was. I had about 400+ saves, and whenever my amount of saves got over that amount (somewhere between 380 - 400) the game started reacting accordingly. I had to get a cd crack for my beloved game beacuse my cd was "stolen" (aka borrowed and never returned) and I can't play it without it. However i recall having this exact issue when use the cd a couple years back so that isn't the issue. I hope this might help someone. Removing the 100 earliest saves fixed it for me so that should have been the issue.

Hope it helps!
Mephisto_VI
Layman
Layman
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Jun 08, 2012 5:16 am
ES Games: Daggerfall (briefly), Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC (primary) Xbox 360 (secondary)

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by Mephisto_VI »

HUGE necro, but potentially worth it. I just started suffering from the crash-on-save bug as well. Wondering if it is indeed a problem with the game, I decided to poke around with a hex editor in my last save it would let me make. Deciding to search for the save number inside the save itself, I did find the number (494 in my case) and changed it to 94 instead, then saved it using the naming scheme from the edited save. Trying to save after loading that edited save let me save again! Not sure if this is a one-time fix, or if there is indeed a bug/intentional limit on saves. Will continue testing. If this pays off, Oblivion might not be "Crashlivion" anymore... -fingers crossed-
RayeGunn
Layman
Layman
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Jun 14, 2012 6:49 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by RayeGunn »

This thread is actually what prompted me to sign up here. I was having the same problem as well, after rummaging around the Layawiin Mages Guild, I would try to save, game would crash, and the save would be corrupted. I had been relying on the quicksave a bit too much so to go back before the Mages guild would erase hours of gameplay. While there was one lucky save post Mages Guild in there, I couldn't advance past this point without the game constantly crashing and corrupting the save. so I hit the web looking for what might be causing the problem and found this thread. disabled the keyring mod I had, and voila, fixed! I realize now that while going through the guild's chests, I had picked up a 'rusty key' and that must have been the culprit. And as with people above, I had Darn UI anyway, so it's not like i even really needed the keyring, it's just one of those mods I had from way back when, and never bothered to get rid of it. I intend on also eliminating any unecessary keys that I can think of and putting them in a container somewhere, or something, since several keys themselves seem to be glitchy even without the keyring
aralin
Layman
Layman
Posts: 1
Joined: Sat Jul 14, 2012 5:04 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC

Re: Game Crashes when Saving

Post by aralin »

My game suddenly started having this problem, but then I read this thread and fixed it! Here's what I did if it helps someone:
1. Update pluggy from v122 to v125c
2. Check Oblivion.ini for references to Francesco's 2 .bsa files
3. Make sure keyring mod is not installed
4. Right click on save game I wanted to play in Wrye Bash and click "Remove Bloat"
5. Right click on save game in Wrye Bash and click "Repair Abomb"
6. Right click on save game in Wrye Bash, choose File>"Renumber Save(s)...", and change from number 1886 to number 1
(You could also do this yourself with a hex editor as Mephisto suggested. It's in the fist few lines of data.)
7. Remove ALL other saves from Oblivion's Saves folder
8. Play and save to your heart's content!

To avoid any other save game related crashes in the future:
1. Never overwrite saves, always make a new save
2. Never use autosave, make sure it's turned off
3. Use streamline instead
4. Reset the save game number periodically

So, for me OBSE nor any of its mods and plugins were the problem. The save game number just got too high. Thanks everyone- I didn't have to reinstall the game!

5/8/13 Edit: I was able to play the game normally for awhile, but it began crashing when saving again around 50 hours later for an apparently different reason. It seems now to be related to load order and mods rather than the above causes, especially considering it affects all my saves.
Spoiler:
While I was playing around in Wyre Bash one day, I noticed it was telling me two official plug-ins - Frostcrag Spire and Horse Armor - shared the same load order (despite the fact that one was labeled as 4, the other 5).
It's interesting to note that this same thing that happened to UFAlien happened to me soon before the crashes started. Wrye Bash showed that about 4 plugins from Less Annoying Magic Experience had identical load orders (the same modification date) , although I hadn't done anything to them that might cause that. I manually changed the date of the files to restore the load order. In hindsight, I recommend that anyone encountering this completely delete all affected mods and reinstall them.

I spent a long time changing the load order, removing recently added mods, and removing various other mods, including the LAME plugins. I was able to save with a few early savegames by doing this, but this tenuous saving capability was lost when the load order was altered again. So changing the load order had an effect, but was ultimately useless. I also tried waiting for cell buffers to reset to no avail. I'm still not sure whether a certain mod was the cause or not.

New games are unaffected by this mod corruption, though. I'm going to have to start a new game. I'm also going to reinstall Oblivion and carefully reinstall my mods, cutting down on nonessential ones, to minimize the likelihood of this happening again. I won't use pluggy this time because although changing its version didn't fix anything, pluggy makes me nervous, considering how greatly it affects saving. I'll consider foregoing Streamline as well for similar reasons.
Here's a Nexus thread with additional discussion about crashes upon saving and similar issues (remove spaces):
http: //forums. nexusmods. com/ index.php?/ topic/ 38009-corrupted-saves/
Locked