A Geographical Concern

Pre-Release Archive

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

User avatar
the Savage Hippie
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 300
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 pm
ES Games: 1, 2, 3 & Tactics
Platform: PC
Status: doesn't really come from outer space
Location: Cyclopean and many-columned Y'ha-nthlei

A Geographical Concern

Post by the Savage Hippie »

Hi everyone.

I can't wait for TESV :D
But alas, I'm concerned... I want it to be a huge world... But Cyrodiil is the largest land in Tamriel. Do you think they're gonna make it bigger so the distance between cities and places are going to be even greater? I personally hope so.
Avron the S'wit wrote:Hippie, you are too cool.
“I am free of all prejudice. I hate everyone equally. ”
"Just because you're offended, doesn't mean you're right"
User avatar
mulder
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 171
Joined: Mon Aug 09, 2010 8:08 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: The Truth is out there

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by mulder »

I hope so too. They could make blizzards and great storms stop the adventurer from traveling too fast. And they can cancel fast travel and make the transportation more like Morrowind.

Btw, isn't Morrowind bigger than Cyrodiil?
Twice and twice shall he be marked, twice to live and twice to die.
Once the heron, to set his path. Twice the heron, to name him true.
Once the Dragon, for remembrance lost. Twice the Dragon, for the price he must pay.
User avatar
nyk45
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by nyk45 »

In-game Cyrodiil was much smaller than Lore Cyrodiil. It really depends on the scale they're going for. They can go for a map smaller than Oblivion's but with more to do, a bigger, more true-to-lore map with also more to do, or many other things.

I'd bet on a game map at least the size of Oblivion's Cyrodiil, though.
Image
Thus, He saith: To Nine Thousand... and Beyond!
User avatar
the Savage Hippie
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 300
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 pm
ES Games: 1, 2, 3 & Tactics
Platform: PC
Status: doesn't really come from outer space
Location: Cyclopean and many-columned Y'ha-nthlei

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by the Savage Hippie »

I would not care to do with out fast travel if they made a travel system like the Silt Striders... But I would like the world to be more true to lore as you guys say..
I always found it kind of funny in one of the Mazoga the Orc quests in Oblivion that she described a distance as a "six hour walk" and it was actually just a 30 minute run (in game time).

And blizzard and stuff would be just awesome!
Avron the S'wit wrote:Hippie, you are too cool.
“I am free of all prejudice. I hate everyone equally. ”
"Just because you're offended, doesn't mean you're right"
User avatar
Hadrianus
Warder
Warder
Posts: 516
Joined: Sun Apr 04, 2010 11:58 pm
Status: Hearing damage.

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Hadrianus »

I agree with Greg Keyes when he says the game world is merely a representation of the real thing.

Besides, the time scale in Oblivion is thirty times faster, so travelling from one place to another can take days, as to say, the areas are days apart...
Lord Edvard
Layman
Layman
Posts: 2
Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:46 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: Xbox (360)

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Lord Edvard »

I'm certainly hoping it'll include more area than Skyrim alone... for example addings of northwestern (mainland) Morrowind and eastern High Rock would give some change of terrain to the game. No need for endless white and light blue.
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

Daggerfall was two provinces and it takes at least 20 hours to walk from one end to the other diagonally, so I wouldn't judge Skyrim's size based on Cyrodiil's in Oblivion.

As far as cities go, I really, really hope there are more of them. Settlements, imperial forts, I don't know, but Cyrodiil felt too simplistic and limited. 9 major cities and that's all? I find it surprising that the shores of lake Rumare has almost nothing but ruins and some inns, one would have thought there'd be villages or something. There's only 4 cities in Morrowind (Vvardenfell), one of them being Vivec which has 10 cantons, but there's also 13 (!) towns, not counting wizard towers. So there was both a lot of variety and quantity, smaller fishing villages didn't offer much, but they were there and had a quest or two, Vvardenfell felt a lot more believable than the imperial province, the seat of the Empire having a measly 9 major cities (one of them being destroyed!) with nothing else. I don't know, it felt weird to walk all over Cyrodiil for so long only to rarely see any city. Hell, where were the real imperial cities? Most cities were influenced by other cultures and had non Imperial counts... Even the Imperial City isn't so imperial at all, it's Aldemri, while there were tons of Imperial settlements all over Morrowind.
Image
theo1170
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 29
Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2010 8:40 am
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PS3

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by theo1170 »

Stendarr wrote:Daggerfall was two provinces and it takes at least 20 hours to walk from one end to the other diagonally, so I wouldn't judge Skyrim's size based on Cyrodiil's in Oblivion.

As far as cities go, I really, really hope there are more of them. Settlements, imperial forts, I don't know, but Cyrodiil felt too simplistic and limited. 9 major cities and that's all? I find it surprising that the shores of lake Rumare has almost nothing but ruins and some inns, one would have thought there'd be villages or something. There's only 4 cities in Morrowind (Vvardenfell), one of them being Vivec which has 10 cantons, but there's also 13 (!) towns, not counting wizard towers. So there was both a lot of variety and quantity, smaller fishing villages didn't offer much, but they were there and had a quest or two, Vvardenfell felt a lot more believable than the imperial province, the seat of the Empire having a measly 9 major cities (one of them being destroyed!) with nothing else. I don't know, it felt weird to walk all over Cyrodiil for so long only to rarely see any city. Hell, where were the real imperial cities? Most cities were influenced by other cultures and had non Imperial counts... Even the Imperial City isn't so imperial at all, it's Aldemri, while there were tons of Imperial settlements all over Morrowind.
good thing there was Skingrad, Skingrad had that awesome Imperial look to it, with it's nice wood and stone, the grape farms, I love that city.
Image
User avatar
DorostheConqueror
Champion
Champion
Posts: 833
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 8:20 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by DorostheConqueror »

mulder wrote:And they can cancel fast travel and make the transportation more like Morrowind.
Or the individual player can exercise restraint and not click the fast travel button if he's got issues with it.

My main question isn't so much about size (although bigger is obviously better!), it's about geographical features. One of the things that made Cyrodill so much fun to play in was the scenery. If you got sick of rolling hills, you could visit a swamp. If you got sick of the swamp, you could go to a forest. Or a snow covered mountain peak. Or a sunbaked coast. Or a great flat, featureless expanse of presumably desert, outside the game boundaries. Will Skyrim have as much in the way of ecological diversity? Or is it going to be like the Capitol Wastelands with snow?
Image
(USER GOT 3 KARMA FOR THIS POST)
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

DorostheConqueror wrote:
mulder wrote:And they can cancel fast travel and make the transportation more like Morrowind.
Or the individual player can exercise restraint and not click the fast travel button if he's got issues with it.
That's missing the entire point.
Image
User avatar
mptrj
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 379
Joined: Tue Sep 22, 2009 2:26 am
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY Deluxe, Morrowind GOTY
Platform: PC, PS3
Location: New Yawk
Contact:

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by mptrj »

As for the thought that there isn't enough diversity in a cold climate, I foresee deciduous forests with autumn leaves and placid lakes, glaciers, tundras, and mountains. Skyrim is also described as being "a battle-scarred wasteland" or something along those lines, so maybe we'll see the old battlefields of the armies from previous wars?
Image
The Not a Member of Any Forum Groups.
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Dean »

No, Oblivion is in fact a tiny bit bigger. You just move slower in Morrowind and there is less flat land. It's all an illusion.
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

Dean wrote:No, Oblivion is in fact a tiny bit bigger. You just move slower in Morrowind and there is less flat land. It's all an illusion.
It's an illusion, but I think it has mostly to do with how everything is spread across the map, as well as how some quests are made. Few cities spread all across the province with huge chunk of lands with nothing but daedric shrines spread far away helped make Cyrodiil feel smaller.
Image
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by The Raven »

Also the fast-travel system made it feel tiny. You could bounce everywhere in Cyrodiil, while you snailed your way to Balmora on Vvardenfell.

The Oblivion map is indeed bigger than MW map.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
mulder
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 171
Joined: Mon Aug 09, 2010 8:08 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: The Truth is out there

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by mulder »

No, no, I was asking if the province Morrowind is bigger than Cyrodiil
Twice and twice shall he be marked, twice to live and twice to die.
Once the heron, to set his path. Twice the heron, to name him true.
Once the Dragon, for remembrance lost. Twice the Dragon, for the price he must pay.
User avatar
The Raven
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1762
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 4:09 pm

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by The Raven »

mulder wrote:No, no, I was asking if the province Morrowind is bigger than Cyrodiil
oh..../facepalm
Don't know, sorry. I tried taking a look at the 'fficial maps, but I can't tell.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
User avatar
DorostheConqueror
Champion
Champion
Posts: 833
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 8:20 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by DorostheConqueror »

Stendarr wrote:
DorostheConqueror wrote:
mulder wrote:And they can cancel fast travel and make the transportation more like Morrowind.
Or the individual player can exercise restraint and not click the fast travel button if he's got issues with it.
That's missing the entire point.
Apparently. What was it?
No, Oblivion is in fact a tiny bit bigger. You just move slower in Morrowind and there is less flat land. It's all an illusion.
Yeah, the "Morrowind's bigger" myth is caused by the poor terrain design and weak draw distances in Morrowind. Everywhere you go in Morrowind, you're hemmed in. There's either a cliff wall rising up in front of you or a hazy fog ten feet away from your eyes; the land "feels" bigger since you're basically plodding through dozens and dozens of tiny, compartmentalized, linear trails, rather than being presented with an open, vibrant swath of terrain to explore.
I was asking if the province Morrowind is bigger than Cyrodiil
It depends on what you mean by "Morrowind". The entire province is almost as large as Cyrodiil, but the bit featured in the game (the island of Vvardenfell) is considerably smaller. Here's a map:
Spoiler:
Image
Image
(USER GOT 3 KARMA FOR THIS POST)
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

DorostheConqueror wrote:
Stendarr wrote: That's missing the entire point.
Apparently. What was it?
We may not want to cross Cyrodiil 50 times more than you. It's not because we can ignore fast travel that we can get from point A to point B in any other way than walking. I don't like fast travel because I think it breaks immersion, being able to get from anywhere to anywhere in an instant, plus if I didn't want to use it, too many quests ask you to get from one end to another of Cyrodiil when Morrowind did that a lot less often. Morrowind had a complete travel system with boats, sylt riders, mage guild teleporters, mark/recall/almsilvi and divine interventions. It's still "teleportation", but asks you to use actual services which you can't use to get from any city to any city like this, it was made in a realistic way. Yeah sometimes you needed to reach areas far from cities, but you didn't need to use the same damn road 50 times between Anvil and Cheydinhal because you didn't want to use fast travel. Plus, it was an incentive to get propylon indexes, use mark/recall intelligently with the intervention spells for return and maybe use the boots of blinding speed, or recreate a non-fatal version of the über jumping spell of our poor wood elf who kills himself near Seyda Neen. I found all of this to be pretty fun honestly, but it's just totally inexistent in Oblivion.
No, Oblivion is in fact a tiny bit bigger. You just move slower in Morrowind and there is less flat land. It's all an illusion
Yeah, the "Morrowind's bigger" myth is caused by the poor terrain design and weak draw distances in Morrowind. Everywhere you go in Morrowind, you're hemmed in. There's either a cliff wall rising up in front of you or a hazy fog ten feet away from your eyes; the land "feels" bigger since you're basically plodding through dozens and dozens of tiny, compartmentalized, linear trails, rather than being presented with an open, vibrant swath of terrain to explore.
Do you know what Foyadas are? This is not poor terrain design, but fitting terrain design with lore in order to make a unique area to explore. They tried to create an alien looking land and unique one, while I like Cyrodiil quite a bit, it is generic at best. Plus, there are long draw distances mod. Adding to this, most people don't even bring these points as why Vvardenfell feels bigger. There's the Balmora effect (lack of fast travel making cities feel more alive and explore more the surroundings of the city, rather than asking you to go again, to another city), there's the fact that there's towns and such (Morrowind had 4 important cities (Vivec had 10 cantons) and 13 towns) as well as more things in the winderness to find and do. Again, there's big chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with random loot and pretty landscapes in Oblivion, Morrowind managed to cram so many things into a much smaller area, without it feeling actually crammed, well maybe Morrowind isn't crammed and it's Oblivion which is empty. You also walked slower and didn't run way too fast with good athletic skills.
Image
User avatar
Dagoth Ur
Novice
Novice
Posts: 56
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 5:50 pm

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Dagoth Ur »

Daggerfall was two provinces and it takes at least 20 hours to walk from one end to the other diagonally, so I wouldn't judge Skyrim's size based on Cyrodiil's in Oblivion.
Daggerfall is twice the size of Great Britain, it took Bethesda over two weeks to walk from one end to the other.
User avatar
DorostheConqueror
Champion
Champion
Posts: 833
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 8:20 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by DorostheConqueror »

Stendarr wrote:
DorostheConqueror wrote:
Stendarr wrote: That's missing the entire point.
Apparently. What was it?
We may not want to cross Cyrodiil 50 times more than you. It's not because we can ignore fast travel that we can get from point A to point B in any other way than walking.
You can get from point A to point B without walking. It's called "a horse"!
I don't like fast travel because I think it breaks immersion,


Right! So, don't use it!

Look, if you're really so concerned about it and want all the hassle and immersion-killing headache of the old sylt rider system back, here's a handy tip. It's called "role playing"! Set yourself a house rule, like this one: stables are fast travel points. Get to a stable, and you can fast travel to simulate buying a ride on a horse or a carriage or whatever. If you'd like, you can further increase the house rule to restrict destinations to settlements, or even other stables. Simple as can be.


No, Oblivion is in fact a tiny bit bigger. You just move slower in Morrowind and there is less flat land. It's all an illusion
Yeah, the "Morrowind's bigger" myth is caused by the poor terrain design and weak draw distances in Morrowind. Everywhere you go in Morrowind, you're hemmed in. There's either a cliff wall rising up in front of you or a hazy fog ten feet away from your eyes; the land "feels" bigger since you're basically plodding through dozens and dozens of tiny, compartmentalized, linear trails, rather than being presented with an open, vibrant swath of terrain to explore.
Do you know what Foyadas are?
Yes, they're nonsense.
This is not poor terrain design, but fitting terrain design with lore in order to make a unique area to explore.
Right, a "unique area" that also happens to be small, cramped, bleak, and linear.
They tried to create an alien looking land
That's one way of putting it.
there's the fact that there's towns and such (Morrowind had 4 important cities (Vivec had 10 cantons) and 13 towns) as well as more things in the winderness to find and do.
Yes, and Oblivion had 9 important cities (The IC has 10 full sized districts, not counting subdistricts and underground areas) and around 30 villages and estates. And more things in the wilderness to find and do.
Again, there's big chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with random loot and pretty landscapes in Oblivion,
Right. And the only difference between that and Morrowind is that Morrowind had small chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with the same old boring, pre-determined loot playthrough after playthrough. And ugly landscapes.
You also walked slower and didn't run way too fast with good athletic skills.
A minute ago you were complaining about having to walk everywhere in Oblivion! Now you're upset that you move faster?

I get it. Much of this boils down to raw opinion, and you like Morrowind. For whatever strange reasons, you like small, fog covered, poorly textured rectangles perfectly designed to funnel cliffracers right at you. And I get it, that's totally cool! I like Morrowind too, despite it's many, many, many shortcomings. But facts are facts; Oblivion is much bigger, and far more open and majestic. A trend which is bound to be followed by Skyrim.
Last edited by DorostheConqueror on Tue Dec 14, 2010 7:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
(USER GOT 3 KARMA FOR THIS POST)
User avatar
the Savage Hippie
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 300
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 pm
ES Games: 1, 2, 3 & Tactics
Platform: PC
Status: doesn't really come from outer space
Location: Cyclopean and many-columned Y'ha-nthlei

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by the Savage Hippie »

mulder wrote:Btw, isn't Morrowind bigger than Cyrodiil?
http://images.uesp.net//thumb/c/c3/Tamr ... ielMap.jpg
They seem to comparable in size, but I think I'm almost certain to have read somewhere that Cyrodiil is the biggest province.
Stendarr wrote:Daggerfall was two provinces and it takes at least 20 hours to walk from one end to the other diagonally, so I wouldn't judge Skyrim's size based on Cyrodiil's in Oblivion.

As far as cities go, I really, really hope there are more of them. Settlements, imperial forts, I don't know, but Cyrodiil felt too simplistic and limited. 9 major cities and that's all? I find it surprising that the shores of lake Rumare has almost nothing but ruins and some inns, one would have thought there'd be villages or something.
I totally agree. I always found it sad that whenever you discovered a new place in Oblivion it was either an Ayeleid ruin, a cave or a fort dungeon or a random camp... only few of the places you found were actually places. Most of the settlements had quests related to them that would ruin them like Borderwatch, Bleaker's Way Hackdirt - couldn't Bethesda just make more of this kind of small villages? It's fine if they are quest related, but do they really need to be ruined by quests?
Generally, more farmhouses (although, Skyrim doesn't seem as the smartest place to farm), houses, priories, chapels, inns... we need lots more of those IMHO...
Avron the S'wit wrote:Hippie, you are too cool.
“I am free of all prejudice. I hate everyone equally. ”
"Just because you're offended, doesn't mean you're right"
User avatar
Stendarr
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 27
Joined: Wed May 26, 2010 2:55 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: Monster of the Earth
Location: Heavy Metal Mountain

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Stendarr »

DorostheConqueror wrote:
Stendarr wrote: We may not want to cross Cyrodiil 50 times more than you. It's not because we can ignore fast travel that we can get from point A to point B in any other way than walking.
You can get from point A to point B without walking. It's called "a horse"!
No [&@%!] Sherlock, did I seriously need to spell it out to you that this was including horse travel? Plus, my wood elf runs faster than any horse right now.
I don't like fast travel because I think it breaks immersion,


Right! So, don't use it!

Look, if you're really so concerned about it and want all the hassle and immersion-killing headache of the old sylt rider system back, here's a handy tip. It's called "role playing"! Set yourself a house rule, like this one: stables are fast travel points. Get to a stable, and you can fast travel to simulate buying a ride on a horse or a carriage or whatever. If you'd like, you can further increase the house rule to restrict destinations to settlements, or even other stables. Simple as can be
Except it's stupid, time consuming and certainly even less immersive since I use my head rather than the game to pull it off. It's like saying you can fix this or that with mods, it's still not in the game. By that same logic I can tell you just use the console like everyone who got tired of travelling did in Morrowind.


Yeah, the "Morrowind's bigger" myth is caused by the poor terrain design and weak draw distances in Morrowind. Everywhere you go in Morrowind, you're hemmed in. There's either a cliff wall rising up in front of you or a hazy fog ten feet away from your eyes; the land "feels" bigger since you're basically plodding through dozens and dozens of tiny, compartmentalized, linear trails, rather than being presented with an open, vibrant swath of terrain to explore.
Do you know what Foyadas are?
Yes, they're nonsense.
Yes?
This is not poor terrain design, but fitting terrain design with lore in order to make a unique area to explore.
Right, a "unique area" that also happens to be small, cramped, bleak, and linear.
Small? Not that much. Cramped? That depends on the perspective, but if you thought Oblivion was not empty and more of a modder's playground than anything else, sure. I mean, it REALLY didn't feel like the goddamn seat of the Empire. Bleak? How does that have anything to do with quality? It's an aesthetic. If you don't like a bleak looking environment, that's your problem, not the developer's. Linear? I don't know how a sand-box type area can be linear. Plus, there were tons of crossroads and such. Not everywhere were Foyadas, there were islands, grasslands, the bitter coast and even more desert-like ashlands. While Bloodmoon was an expansion, since the terrain was designed to not be a roughed up volcanic island it was pretty different. I doubt they started doing less "poor" design with an expansion. Cyrodiil still had plenty of mountains hard to climb.
there's the fact that there's towns and such (Morrowind had 4 important cities (Vivec had 10 cantons) and 13 towns) as well as more things in the winderness to find and do.
Yes, and Oblivion had 9 important cities (The IC has 10 full sized districts, not counting subdistricts and underground areas) and around 30 villages and estates. And more things in the wilderness to find and do.
Yes, 10 important cities which most were not so bigger than a couple of Morrowind's towns, which in turn some had more quests and things to do than some of Oblivion big cities. And please, don't count those 30 "villages" and estates. Estates are that, estates, Morrowind had plenty of wizard towers which I didn't count. Most Oblivion villages were a couple of houses with nothing to do but a single quest. I'm not counting sole farms and such for obvious reasons (I didn't even count such properties like shacks in Morrowind, not even the Dres plantation).

So really, Oblivion has 10 villages. Pells Gate has 3 houses including an inn, Weye: 2 houses including an inn, Aleswell: again 3 houses including an inn. Caldera had 17 (!) houses including the mages guild and the governor's hall. Smaller ones like Hla Oad had 6 houses (plus a boat), two or three times more houses than most Oblivion villages. And again, I didn't count all 5 imperial forts, INCLUDING Ebonheart which is pretty much a town is almost bigger than Skingrad if you take out the Castle. And again, I didn't count major landmarks like the inhabited Arvel, Arano, Gro-Bagrat and Dren plantations, the Ghostgate or the Holamayan monastery. And if you really want to know, there's also 6 ashlander camps (more than 2 or 3 shacks obviously), 9 farmhouses and 6 shacks/houses in the wilderness. Morrowind destroys Oblivion in both quantity and quality as far as cities/towns/others go. Ald'ruhn is massive with its huge manor district, Sadrith Mora is bigger than Oblivion city except the Imperial city, etc... There's not any real imperial city in Oblivion! They're all based on other cultures, the imperial city itself is Aldmeri.
Again, there's big chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with random loot and pretty landscapes in Oblivion,
Right. And the only difference between that and Morrowind is that Morrowind had small chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with the same old boring, pre-determined loot playthrough after playthrough. And ugly landscapes.
Morrowind had tons of unique dungeons, and caverns. Oblivion had some, but nowhere near any of Morrowind's quantity. Morrowind had 62 (!) unique artifacts which a big portion of them were found (via quests or not) in a unique dungeon - often, VERY cool - and the game had a lot of cooler places than in Oblivion. In fact, what sorts of dungeons do you have in Oblivion? Ayleid ruins, forts, mines and caves, that makes 4. Morrowind had: Dunmer strongholds, Dwemer ruins, Daedric shrines, ancestral tombs, Velothi towers, mines, caves, grottos and ships, that's 9 of them, more than 300 hundred total. In each of my playthroughs I was always discovering new places and cool loot. In Oblivion, I had no incentive to explore because I knew all ruins were identical with a very small possibility of finding a unique place as well as finding worthwhile items since, the loot was IDENTICAL everywhere. There were differences between Ayleid ruins, forts and caves, but beyond that you always knew what you'd get and it was depending on your level. In Morrowind you never knew what you'd get (may be some boring stuff though, but almost everything was boring in Oblivion anyway) and it was regardless of your level. Pre-determined stuff, yeah, but I'd be surprised you'd remember how each caves and ruins looked like and what you found there by your second playthrough.

Oh, and how does ugly landscapes have anything to do with quality? I doubt you found Fallout 3's landscapes beautiful.
You also walked slower and didn't run way too fast with good athletic skills.
A minute ago you were complaining about having to walk everywhere in Oblivion! Now you're upset that you move faster?
That's hardly a contradiction. First moving faster was in relation with how Oblivion seems smaller (logic), but it's also unrealistic. It's not because I want to walk less that I want to walk faster, I still walk the same damn road all the friggin time because the game is constructed around the fast travel feature, so they decide they can make you cross the whole province often.
I get it. Much of this boils down to raw opinion, and you like Morrowind. For whatever strange reasons, you like small, fog covered, poorly textured rectangles perfectly designed to funnel cliffracers right at you. And I get it, that's totally cool! I like Morrowind too. But facts are facts; Oblivion is much bigger, and far more open and majestic. A trend which is bound to be followed by Skyrim.
The fog can be taken out via mods. Textures can be way better via mods (in fact there's a Morroblivion mod out there which makes Morrowind run with Oblivion's engine), even then, there's the MGE mod which still makes a big difference. Plus, I don't see why I should prefer a game because it has better graphics and is newer, by the same logic old movies are less good. Bigger =/= better. Oblivion is bigger, but is more empty, more of the same, less of everything. Morrowind has more dungeon types, more cities, more towns of varying sizes, more variety in them period, more quests, more artifacts, more skills, more weapons and weapon types, more armor, more spells, more guilds/factions, more NPCs, etc... Yes radiant AI is all good and neat, but it doesn't change that Cyrodiil doesn't seem as civilized as the seat of the Empire should, feels empty and feels much less alive than Morrowind despite the radiant AI. You could say more =/= better, true enough as proven with Daggerfall, but thing is, Morrowind isn't as extreme as Daggerfall and it's mainly about variety (more variety = better) and a more believable and immerisve experience too.

If Skyrim get bigger but gets even less of everything than Oblivion, I will be sorely disappointed. I don't want an empty environment with nothing interesting to do in it to explore, I want a big environment to explore WITH worthwhile things to do. More unique dungeons, more different kinds, non-scaling loot, more artifacts (not only 10 of them all related to the main quest), bigger cities, more towns/villages of varying sizes. I want an incentive to explore, finding something new and sweet loot. Different kinds of low value loot is better than always finding the same damn items and make the process tedious and boring. I never was excited finding glass armor in Obivion, I was more annoyed than anything else, in fact, I was never excited finding any loot ever.
Last edited by Stendarr on Tue Dec 14, 2010 8:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
User avatar
TheoC
Novice
Novice
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 6:44 pm
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: Xbox 360, PC

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by TheoC »

I think the smaller size of Skyrim will turn out to be a good thing. While there space, I'm sure they will fill it with much more stuff than in Cyrodiil. The Oblivion playable zone was probably too big to be honest, there was a lot of endless, repetitive forest :/
Check out my Oblivion Machinima Series!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfTiIE7T7GQ
User avatar
DorostheConqueror
Champion
Champion
Posts: 833
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 8:20 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็ก็็็็็็็็็็

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by DorostheConqueror »

Right, this is getting OT, but you took awhile to write that so I'll respond.
Spoiler:
Stendarr wrote:
DorostheConqueror wrote:
Stendarr wrote: We may not want to cross Cyrodiil 50 times more than you. It's not because we can ignore fast travel that we can get from point A to point B in any other way than walking.
You can get from point A to point B without walking. It's called "a horse"!
No [&@%!] Sherlock, did I seriously need to spell it out to you that this was including horse travel? Plus, my wood elf runs faster than any horse right now.
So, dear Watson, where's the problem?
I don't like fast travel because I think it breaks immersion,


Right! So, don't use it!

Look, if you're really so concerned about it and want all the hassle and immersion-killing headache of the old sylt rider system back, here's a handy tip. It's called "role playing"! Set yourself a house rule, like this one: stables are fast travel points. Get to a stable, and you can fast travel to simulate buying a ride on a horse or a carriage or whatever. If you'd like, you can further increase the house rule to restrict destinations to settlements, or even other stables. Simple as can be
Except it's stupid, time consuming and certainly even less immersive since I use my head rather than the game to pull it off. It's like saying you can fix this or that with mods, it's still not in the game. By that same logic I can tell you just use the console like everyone who got tired of travelling did in Morrowind.
Stupid and time consuming, exactly like Morrowind's travel system. Consistency, man, consistency! You can't praise a feature of Morrowind and then turn around and claim the exact same setup is stupid in a different game.


Do you know what Foyadas are?
Yes, they're nonsense.
Yes?
Yes.
Small? Not that much. Cramped? That depends on the perspective, but if you thought Oblivion was not empty and more of a modder's playground than anything else, sure. I mean, it REALLY didn't feel like the [&@%!] seat of the Empire. Bleak? How does that have anything to do with quality? It's an aesthetic. If you don't like a bleak looking environment, that's your problem, not the developer's. Linear? I don't know how a sand-box type area can be linear. Plus, there were tons of crossroads and such. Not everywhere were Foyadas, there were islands, grasslands, the bitter coast and even more desert-like ashlands. While Bloodmoon was an expansion, since the terrain was designed to not be a roughed up volcanic island it was pretty different. I doubt they started doing less "poor" design with an expansion. Cyrodiil still had plenty of mountains hard to climb.
Ah, but you admit that the environments are bleak. I'm perfectly willing to concede that preferring good graphics and nice environments is an aesthetic choice; I'm only pointing out that the simple fact that Morrowind is cramped and ugly, Oblivion is not. You're free to interpret that as you will.
There's not any real imperial city in Oblivion! They're all based on other cultures, the imperial city itself is Aldmeri.
Well, I'm sorry Cyrodiil is multicultural. I'd say it's inevitable given the highly cosmopolitan nature of Tamriel's central province, and I for one like diversity and variety, but if you'd rather have a dozen interchangeable settlements with bland textures and nothing to do in them save look at the same three generic Dunmer faces over and over again, then I guess that's your choice.
Again, there's big chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with random loot and pretty landscapes in Oblivion,
Right. And the only difference between that and Morrowind is that Morrowind had small chunks of nothing to do but similar dungeons with the same old boring, pre-determined loot playthrough after playthrough. And ugly landscapes.
Morrowind had tons of unique dungeons, and caverns.


As Oblivion did. So many, in fact, that I STILL haven't explored them all. And just a minute ago you were complaining about the diversity of Oblivion's cities! It's OK for dungeons to be unique, but not towns and cities?
Morrowind had 62 (!) unique artifacts which a big portion of them were found (via quests or not) in a unique dungeon - often, VERY cool - and the game had a lot of cooler places than in Oblivion.
"Cooler" is a matter of opinion. Frankly, I can't recall any locations in Morrowind that really stood out, save for the oh-so tiny ships, and even those were nothing compared to the ships present in Oblivion. Nor can I recall any artifacts offhand, except for the ones which were ALSO in Oblivion, and the Boots of Blinding Speed... which I only remember because they were rubbish.
Pre-determined stuff, yeah, but I'd be surprised you'd remember how each caves and ruins looked like and what you found there by your second playthrough.
Each, nothing. Find one cave with some Orc or Glass armor and hey! Every single game. Oh, look what I found, it's that SAME glass pauldron I found the last fifty times I played.
Oh, and how does ugly landscapes have anything to do with quality? I doubt you found Fallout 3's landscapes beautiful.
I didn't, and it bothered me to no end; in fact, the monotony of the Wasteland is my biggest Fallout petpeeve. New Vegas was slightly better, but it's still not as much fun to simply wander around aimlessly as it was in Oblivion.
You also walked slower and didn't run way too fast with good athletic skills.
A minute ago you were complaining about having to walk everywhere in Oblivion! Now you're upset that you move faster?
That's hardly a contradiction. First moving faster was in relation with how Oblivion seems smaller (logic), but it's also unrealistic. It's not because I want to walk less that I want to walk faster, I still walk the same damn road all the friggin time because the game is constructed around the fast travel feature, so they decide they can make you cross the whole province often.
So, what are you proposing? That they make the roads BIGGER, so it takes more time to walk them?

I really don't follow, you'll have to explain what you're upset about a bit more clearly. It sounds to me like you're either frustrated by all the walking, but don't want to go faster, or you simply find yourself walking down the same paths over and over, which is a problem that was MUCH worse in Morrowind owing to the level design and the fact that you didn't have as much lateral movement. If I want to go from Skingrad to Chorrol, I can pick any direction and blaze a trail. If I wanted to go from Vivec to Balmora, I basically had no choice but to walk through the same miserable valley as I always did. Or awkwardly fast travel via a travel station which we've already agreed is a terrible idea.
I get it. Much of this boils down to raw opinion, and you like Morrowind. For whatever strange reasons, you like small, fog covered, poorly textured rectangles perfectly designed to funnel cliffracers right at you. And I get it, that's totally cool! I like Morrowind too. But facts are facts; Oblivion is much bigger, and far more open and majestic. A trend which is bound to be followed by Skyrim.
The fog can be taken out via mods. Textures can be way better via mods (in fact there's a Morroblivion mod out there which makes Morrowind run with Oblivion's engine), even then, there's the MGE mod which still makes a big difference.
Oh, yes, sure, and you can get dozens more villages in Oblivion via mods. You can get wizards guild teleporter pads via mods. You can get guns, jetpacks, a Japanese island, and anything else you can think of. Because they're mods. If Morowind needs mods to bring it on par with vanilla Oblivion- and I agree with you, it does!- then what does that tell us about Morrowind?
Oblivion is bigger, but is more empty,
Not so much. It's more spread out. More immersive. Taken all together, Oblivion has more content than Morrowind, and I'm sure if you sunk it down to Morrowind's size you wouldn't be able to go two feet without stumbling on something fantastic goody. But Bethseda had the right idea, they knew that large areas with lots of variety, where you could go for ten minutes without running into dozens of generic, dusty, elven mud huts, was the way to go. Frankly, if I had my way, they'd make Oblivion four times larger with the same amount of content...


...and that's exactly what's going to happen with Skyrim. Don't forget, Skyrim will not be Morrowind. I hate speculating on motives, but as I've said in other threads (and as seems to be supported by your sometimes contradictory stances on Morrowind's key features), much of this "Morrowind nostalgia" that grips the boards from time to time is due not to any real, sober, objective analysis of Morrowind's merits as a game, but to emotional baggage and a text-book myth of a "Golden Age". Morowind is clearly an inferior package, when viewed objectively, but some people still insist on loving it, and reject anything that isn't their memory of what the game SHOULD be. That won't change with Skyrim, and I expect there to be building discontent from the Morrowind crowd as Skyrim approaches.

Skyrim is building on Oblivion, and will be to Oblivion what Oblivion is to Morrowind. Bigger areas, broader biomes, more spread between settlements, and fast travel to compensate! I'm looking forward to this, and I hope, Azura willing, that you'll come to your senses as the day draws nearer! :mrgreen:
Image
(USER GOT 3 KARMA FOR THIS POST)
User avatar
Dean
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2023
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:07 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PC
Status: Strange, deranged, twisted, insane
Location: Lemonworld

Re: A Geographical Concern

Post by Dean »

Topic on this one please, this is not for discussing how 'one game is better then another'. They both have there flaws at the end of the day.
Post Reply