Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Discussions and questions about the CS and mods for Oblivion
Locked
Kagemitsu
Layman
Layman
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2010 12:09 am
ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC

Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Kagemitsu »

Well, first off, hi all. New user here. I've been using the UESP wiki since forever, being the awesome source of info we all know.
I'm an avid Oblivion player and I love modding it, just like pretty much everyone. Sadly, I can't avoid getting headaches each time I try playing with some mods because such mods end up screwing the game some way or another.

This time I tried to give the famous OOO a go, along with MMM, Stealth Overhaul (I love playing stealthy characters), Oblivion XP and the Unofficial patches. The game has been a complete hell so far: besides the fact that I can't kill a bandit for the life of me, and even a well placed sneak attack deals merely 1/20 of anything's total life, the mods create a plethora of bugs like hell. I can't complete some of the main quests, sometimes quest characters get stuck on a rock, sometimes the mob I need to kill spawns god knows where and I'm in "combat" for the next 20 mins and can't fast travel...

Oblivion is an incredibly glitchy game, and mods sometimes make it really, really worse. This happens every time I try and use some of the mods with the most impact on the game and I'm kinda surprised that I seem to be the only one with these kind of problems. And yes, I read all the damn readmes and I install everything correctly.

How's your experience with modding? Ever had such a bad gaming experience that you just wanted to uninstall and start anew?
Spiney
Master
Master
Posts: 1498
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 11:12 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfal, Redguard, Morrowind, Oblivion + DLC, Skyrim
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Status: Laughing like every jokes my last
Location: Laughing at life
Contact:

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Spiney »

First off welcome.

Second: I've never experienced bugs like this. You may have a faulty copy. Or is it a cracked. Cracked versions are very unstable. If your it finding too hard you can lower the difficulty in gameplay section in the options menu. Other than that you might need to wyre bashing. I can't post a link on my phone unfortunately.
Image
Aquatic Beauty
shadowchao
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 392
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 12:36 am

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by shadowchao »

I've had the bad path finding occur before, but that's usually only on inclined terrain. OOO does make the game more difficult than vanilla though, if you don't like that aspect then turn the difficulty down...
User avatar
KrisCrash
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2063
Joined: Mon May 24, 2010 6:59 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Status: reading Matt's status
Location: inside 3ds Max
Contact:

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by KrisCrash »

Some of the big overhaul mods just don't get along, though. Especially OOO and MMM - you should probably get FCOM http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Tes4Mod:FCOM

And headaches from mods? Yes. Modders can be so lazy and sloppy. Last one I tried added merchandise to a shop, and accidentally renamed the shop to what it was called in their language. Examples like these unforeseen side effects are many.
"A lady likes a weapon she can fit in her purse."
Want to see my drawings?
User avatar
Codex
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2994
Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2006 12:24 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC
Status: Retired

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Codex »

95% of my modding experiences has been positive. I have never tried any of the large overhauls, so that's perhaps why I've been spared for major issues. I think as long as you're a bit selective about what mods you download, and make sure they are compatible with eachother, most of them should work.
I used to play Oblivion, then I took an arrow in the knee.

A viking is just a horny pirate.
User avatar
KalleFlaxx
Warder
Warder
Posts: 519
Joined: Fri Jul 30, 2010 12:58 pm
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Location: Sweden

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by KalleFlaxx »

A while ago, I used pretty much all mods I could find, including FCOM and a lot of other stuff, but that pretty much ruined the game. I couldn't uninstall it because some files or something were missing. So I just deleted all files and copied the correct, umodded files from another computer. So now I'm playing vanilla Oblivion except for the Unofficial Oblivion Patch and one mod: Living Economy. I actually think the vanilla Oblivion is both funnier and easier to play.
Only... In the ancient legend, it is stated
that one day an Undead shall be chosen
to leave the Undead Asylum, in pilgrimage
to the land of the ancient lords

Lordran
User avatar
Andere
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1603
Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2010 3:19 pm
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: PC desktop
Status: Concerning games, restarting my engine
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Andere »

Well, I've certainly had that kind of experiences as to start anew... and I've done it. I'd say like Codex that 95% of my mod experiences have been positive. And the 5% being negative hasn't changed my view a bit: I've only started to play Oblivion, and I already have mods... I come to think of Boss Springsteen when he sings, "You want it, You take it, You pay the price".

That's how it goes. You can't get it, unless you reach for it. And if you reach for it - it may come with a cost.

A headache's not that bad. Swallow some pain killers, perhaps reinstall it all... that's it. Life goes on. Cheers. :D
Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to those who feel. - Jean Racine
User avatar
Elune
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Sat Jun 19, 2010 8:21 pm
ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC
Status: A Light Shining in Darkness
UESPoints: 7

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Elune »

Modding your game is slow work, you need to set high standards for a start. You have to be on the look out for conflicts, keep your load order good and most importantly, ask yourself:
Is this mod improving my experience? If not or "not really" or if it makes no difference then chuck it.
THE BEATINGS WILL CONTINUE UNTIL MORALE IMPROVES
Leilah
Master
Master
Posts: 1116
Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2009 12:25 pm

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Leilah »

I love my mods. Every last one of them. I just have this little recurring problem: every now and then, I have to fiddle about with my load order, the mods I have active, and sometimes even reinstall completely, since Oblivion decides to crash upon startup. For example, my current configuration worked great for a few months, but then I took a wee break on account of getting a job and other dull stuff, and when I tried playing again on Sunday, without changing a single thing, my game crashed, again...
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Josjie »

I've never been a fan of mods. I've tried hundreds of Oblivion mods and it was really fun to check out all the big houses (castles), complete the new archeology guild (The Lost Spires), have fun with some new spells (Midas Magic spells) and experience the overhauls (OOO, etc.) but I always delete them when I'm done with them. I never use them for my main character. Why? Because almost every mod out there is an immersion breaker for me. Usually they overdo things. A mod starts out as a nice concept, and then they keep adding things and it becomes unrealistic. Like house mods with a coffee machine, a bathtub and a swimming pool. Or a map of Cyrodiil with fast travel portals.
I also dislike all the mods that add a new item to your inventory. Usually it's a misc item and when you select it, it opens a menu where you can change some of the settings of the mod. I see it every time I open my inventory and it breaks the immersion for me.
Oh and not to mention the voice-overs. Usually they're just missing. I've completed a lot of quest mods and they were well designed, but they could've been much better with some voice-overs.

Mods change something about this game. And when I play a mod, I always get the feeling that it doesn't fit in the world of Cyrodiil. Because it changed something, I guess. Mods can also conflict, create new bugs/glitches,etc., and I'd rather spend a few hours playing this game than trying to get a few mods to work.

So the only mods I use for my main characters are interface mods and small fixes, realism and immersion mods. I like Illumination Within, for example ;).
"Not all those who wander are lost"
joen_kwon
Novice
Novice
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Jun 16, 2010 1:11 pm
ES Games: morrowind
Platform: pc

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by joen_kwon »

Kagemitsu wrote: sometimes the mob I need to kill spawns god knows where and I'm in "combat" for the next 20 mins and can't fast travel...
Oh God. This happens to me too. It's not too much of a problem if you have that dragon mount thing. But it's still quiet annoying.
User avatar
Elune
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 383
Joined: Sat Jun 19, 2010 8:21 pm
ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: PC
Status: A Light Shining in Darkness
UESPoints: 7

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Elune »

Josjie wrote:I've never been a fan of mods. I've tried hundreds of Oblivion mods and it was really fun to check out all the big houses (castles), complete the new archeology guild (The Lost Spires), have fun with some new spells (Midas Magic spells) and experience the overhauls (OOO, etc.) but I always delete them when I'm done with them. I never use them for my main character. Why? Because almost every mod out there is an immersion breaker for me. Usually they overdo things. A mod starts out as a nice concept, and then they keep adding things and it becomes unrealistic. Like house mods with a coffee machine, a bathtub and a swimming pool. Or a map of Cyrodiil with fast travel portals.
I also dislike all the mods that add a new item to your inventory. Usually it's a misc item and when you select it, it opens a menu where you can change some of the settings of the mod. I see it every time I open my inventory and it breaks the immersion for me.
Oh and not to mention the voice-overs. Usually they're just missing. I've completed a lot of quest mods and they were well designed, but they could've been much better with some voice-overs.

Mods change something about this game. And when I play a mod, I always get the feeling that it doesn't fit in the world of Cyrodiil. Because it changed something, I guess. Mods can also conflict, create new bugs/glitches,etc., and I'd rather spend a few hours playing this game than trying to get a few mods to work.

So the only mods I use for my main characters are interface mods and small fixes, realism and immersion mods. I like Illumination Within, for example ;).
Someone who summed up my view on mods pretty perfectly.

Midas Magic: Seriously imbalanced the game, those spells were just insane + so many Gold Nuggets needed, no thanks. They went way over board on what was a good concept. I settled on Supreme Magicka instead.

Any Overhaul: They all promise so much, I try them and they never meet my expectations. They always feel mediocore, and the shattered expectations make the mediocrity unbearable. Plus I like the leveling system. Cobl is as close to an Overhaul as I'll ever get.

Combat "Overhauls": Once again they promise a lot but don't actually add new dimensions to combat. Like Deadly Reflex, the super popular mod thats supposed to revolutionize combat, I found it to be disgustingly disappointing. The supposed new dimensions to combat were basically two things (everything else was just a way to instantly kill people with no penalty, also Horse Combat didn't work) 1: Duck. You can duck now! Except it doesn't help NPCs still hit you usually, even more likely when there's more than one. Also you can hit ducking NPCs really easily. So ducking is useless to both you and the NPC. 2: You now press a button to make an enemy stumble no matter what, also while they're stumbling they can't use potions or anything. If this is a new dimension of combat then I'm a talking tree (hint: I'm not a tree). In one vs one situations you can simply sit there and use it over and over and never take a hit (theres no cost or drawback to using it) basically: use it, attack once repeat. Oh but heres where the fun part comes in. NPCs can use it. Fighting two or more NPCs? You'll die. Every. Time. They'll keep using it, and you'll keep stumblng never able to hit back or even drink a potion. Deadly Reflex makes combat much worse, not better.

Added Followers: Imbalanced or useless no real inbetween.

New Houses: Somehow basically every new house mod seems to go against Oblivion in some way, either it's the texture or its something that doesn't belong in Oblivion. I've seen a few good ones, but really it's rare. Also a lot of the ones that actually look like they belong in Oblivion also happen to look like 90% of it was a copied and pasted from another vanilla house.

New Quests/Places: Voice Acting. It either isn't there or is terrible, ruins the mod for me either way. Plus the new quests often seem nonsensical. As for new places (caves, ruins etc.) suffers from the same problem as houses.

The Hundreds of "See Your Character Naked" mods: Majority of them are worthless, I did find one that let my character keep her undergarmets, made her body more feminine shaped and armor as well so I ended up using it.

UI Mods: Darns is the only one I'll ever use, I like the color and etc. I just want the stuff smaller.

As you can see my standards are sort of unfair, also I've been waiting to make this rant for awhile. I'd probably continue but it's 3 AM. Basically the only mods I use make things look nicer, add immersion (but not TOO much I've got a world to save I can't stop for lunch, though I do keep the heavy immersion mods around for my pure roleplaying characters) or fix stuff.
THE BEATINGS WILL CONTINUE UNTIL MORALE IMPROVES
BFG
Champion
Champion
Posts: 902
Joined: Sat Oct 18, 2008 3:00 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC/Windows 7 x64, PS3
Status: Exhilarated
Location: Rebuilding the lost city of Sutch

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by BFG »

I'll agree that an awful lot of the mods out there, including the super-popular ones, are often immersion breaking at best, and glitchy/crash prone at worst. I've learned the hard way, not to try to install too many mods at once, and also not to install many of the major "Overhaul" kind.

I've stayed away entirely from Fran's, OOO, and FCOM because (a) I'm not interested in them, but more importantly (b) I've heard plenty of horror stories about people trying to install them and not being able to get them to work. Those people often end up spending more time trying to get such overhauls to work than actually playing the game. In fact, the only major mod I use is MMM, and I would argue it's the "smallest" of the big mods.

I won't use mods like Deadly Reflex, Midas Magic, etc. because I feel they change too much of Oblivion, not to mention they're often really unbalancing. As someone said above, people often take a really good idea and then keep adding and adding until it's a bad idea.

As such, I tend to favor mods that add realism or immersion, add variety without changing the core of Oblivion, improve graphics and sound, or make small tweaks to the gameplay. I also like quest-adding mods such as The Lost Spires, Gates of Aesgaard, Ruined Tail's Tale, Kvatch Rebuilt, etc. The two mods I've created (one which scales the strength of enchantments based on what condition your armor/weapon is in, and one which allows you to control how many Oblivion Gates can open) fall into the "small tweaks" category, which is definitely the category I focus on the most.
Image
Spiney
Master
Master
Posts: 1498
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 11:12 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfal, Redguard, Morrowind, Oblivion + DLC, Skyrim
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Status: Laughing like every jokes my last
Location: Laughing at life
Contact:

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Spiney »

I don't see why you wouldn't want OOO, MMM or FCOM. Most install through an .exe. OOO even has "save game" updater. I've had no issues with them at all and I couldn't play Oblivion with out them. Other than the overhauls I'm stingy with my mods. Only weapon/armour mods that include the items into the gameplay (not to a random shop). Or one that is far past beta. And ones that add a decent quest to keep me immersed for a good while.

And mods like Deadly Reflex, are very well though out. You may just think of it as: Shield Bash then attack. But there are crap loads more it can do. If you punch a enemie whilist he is side power-attacking, he/she'll lose balance and fall over. A side power attack can cut someone hands off. And seeing as NPC's can use the same moves as you it makes combat more challenging. I once tried to sneak up on a Marauder who was of higher level than me. I jumped attacked, he heard me and backhanded me out of the air. I rag-dolled onto the ground and he splattered my head with his War-Hammer. Quite a shock for me.

And seeing as Obivion is a "Fantasy Game". Why does it have to be realistic?
Image
Aquatic Beauty
User avatar
Andere
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1603
Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2010 3:19 pm
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY, Oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: PC desktop
Status: Concerning games, restarting my engine
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Re: Oblivion and Modding: am I the only one getting headaches?

Post by Andere »

Certainly modders very often go too far, somewhere along the road I even suggested that some sort of an "official registry" be made about different mods. Installing mods can mess your system, and even if you can deactivate them, textures and such may have been overwritten, making solving it as difficult as getting sand back in the old order after a storm in Sahara. Not nice.

It's always an issue of responsibility. That responsibility comes with the publishing of a mod, and I don't share the view that giving "No responsibility will be taken by the maker... You use this at your own risk". It's just so cheap.

Beta testers are used all over, I think they could be used here too.

I know this contradicts my earlier message, but that's how my brain works. Mod World is a Wild West World, but it could be made better.
Life is a comedy to those who think, a tragedy to those who feel. - Jean Racine
Locked