If Morrowind got a good deal and they didn't have their race slaughtered at the tips of Imperial Broadswords,
what's the problem? They have their own government, their own religion, their own economy, so what?


Because of the fact that they got invaded in the first place! jesus christ it is not that hard to comprehend.RobotNixon wrote:So why aretheyyou complaining?

They didn't fight, they have no standing to complain.Newsound wrote:Because of the fact that they got invaded in the first place! jesus christ it is not that hard to comprehend.RobotNixon wrote:So why aretheyyou complaining?

I see you edited this in. Because the Imperials still have power over these things. What Emperor in his right mind would let a province have this much power? Not only that but the Imperials control most of the mines, If you had bothered to read the thread from the beginning you wouldn't be asking these things again.RobotNixon wrote:If Morrowind got a good deal and they didn't have their race slaughtered at the tips of Imperial Broadswords,
what's the problem? They have their own government, their own religion, their own economy, so what?
You have really got to stop with the questions already answered. They can't start a revolution due to Imperial Forts in the area of every main city. Not only that but if the forts got attacked then Cyrodil would send an army into the province, the Dunmer would get attacked by the forts and an army.RobotNixon wrote:They didn't fight, they have no standing to complain.
As soon as they start a revolution I will give them the respect you think they deserve.


I'm not implying anything, the fact that I keep getting the same questions is rather irritating. I don't mind you putting your view point down but if you read through the whole thread things will become clearer and we can get away from the same points and further the discussion.RobotNixon wrote:Lets get one thing straight.
I know exactly what your argument is, and I think it's wrong.
Don't imply that I don't know what you're trying to say just because I don't agree with you.
And Britain, France, and Spain had Forts all over North America at one point in the past.
"Ooh, they have big scary stone buildings!" So what?

The forts in North America served a double purpose.Newsound wrote:I'm not implying anything, the fact that I keep getting the same questions is rather irritating. I don't mind you putting your view point down but if you read through the whole thread things will become clearer and we can get away from the same points and further the discussion.RobotNixon wrote:Lets get one thing straight.
I know exactly what your argument is, and I think it's wrong.
Don't imply that I don't know what you're trying to say just because I don't agree with you.
And Britain, France, and Spain had Forts all over North America at one point in the past.
"Ooh, they have big scary stone buildings!" So what?
And what does the forts in North America have to do with it? they where there to protect and weren't always next to towns.
The forts in Morrowind where strategically placed, not to protect but to stop uprisings.


I have a differing opinion from you, so I'm trying to derail the thread? Excuse me for having an opinion.Veck wrote:Nixon, please stop attempting to derail this thread. It was actually quite interesting, and I'd hate to see it locked.
Down with Cyrodiil.

Well, when I wrote that I had that "a bully only stops bullying once he meets someone bigger" thought in my head. And I don't find it acceptable, but if someone bullies or beats me or someone close to me then I wouldn't try to get back with logic, I'd rather use brute force to teach them a lesson, human rights be damned.To bad I'm a weak coward.It may be Human, but the thought is actually one of greed. Does that make it acceptable to you? If we lived in another time yes this would of been the norm, but what I am talking about is with our understanding on Human rights today would you agree with it? This is more to do with your views then the views of people at the time.


Good questionMilder Despues wrote: Which makes this discussion more interesting to me: Would it be okay for Septim to try to force the races to join the Empire if he thought he could make things better for them, bearing in mind that they could submit without bloodshed.




This I completely agree with. What you said earlier on in your post about how Empires eventually fall makes there reasoning that much smarter. Once the Empire falls the Dunmer people will have the ability to rid there province of Imperial occupation and once again be able to make there own decisions with little interference. Pacing themselves and not rushing into conflict was the smartest thing they could of done, the average life span of a Dunmer is long so in the end Imperial control would seem a lot shorter for them then it would us.Backfire wrote:Was it right that the Empire came in and took Morrowind? Well, no, but what's right doesn't matter as much as what actually happens, and the Empire went through with it. Given the case, the Dunmer made the best choice. What'd you want them to do, get their whole population wiped out just to have their land taken from them anyway? That's dumb on sooo many different levels.
I'm interested to know why you think the Dunmer are better of on this one? The only thing I can think of is that no one will want to attack there province if they are backed by the Empire. Although you could say this is a good thing, my personal opinion is that it is not worth the same as complete freedom.Backfire wrote:With what all happened, both sides are not only better off, but very little changed.

The Dunmer's resources are not being "raped". Yes, the Empire is taxing the population and has a large part in the mining industry, but there's no way that anyone could convince me that Vvardenfell is being starved by the Empire. Its people aren't living in impoverished slums, nor is Morrowind's agriculture tainted by the Empire. Would the Dunmer be better off without the Empire? Maybe, but it's hard to tell. The Empire itself brings new opportunity to the province just as it brings disadvantages, so it could be a matter of opinion as to whether or not they're better off. The Dwemer artifacts? That's hardly a reason to get upset about anything.In which ways are they worse off? Simple, there resources are being raped by the Imperials and the allying Hlaalu house. Every Dunmer in the province of Morrowind has to pay extra taxes which goes to Cyrodil, one example of this is the war tax inflicted upon them. Dwemer artefacts are no longer there's to study which in turn hinders Dunmer knowledge and advancement.

The Empire is taking something which is not of there land, the mines should be the Dunmer peoples mines. Each Province would be better off and richer if they where in complete control of there resources, what the Empire is doing is daylight robbery and in turn puts a negative on Morrowinds financial status. Just because they aren't taking all the materials does it still make it right to claim that which is on Dunmer soil? In my opinion no. It is like me taking a chunk out of some child's pocket money.Backfire wrote:The Dunmer's resources are not being "raped". Yes, the Empire is taxing the population and has a large part in the mining industry, but there's no way that anyone could convince me that Vvardenfell is being starved by the Empire. Its people aren't living in impoverished slums, nor is Morrowind's agriculture tainted by the Empire.
I agree, this whole thread is after all about everyone's opinions on the situation which I initially stated in the first post. Many like myself would say complete freedom is worth more then anything the Empire could give in return, others would say that taking away that freedom and giving different opportunities is the better way of things.Backfire wrote:Would the Dunmer be better off without the Empire? Maybe, but it's hard to tell. The Empire itself brings new opportunity to the province just as it brings disadvantages, so it could be a matter of opinion as to whether or not they're better off.
The Dwemer lived on there land in a co-existence and then disappeared meaning everything they own goes to the other ruling race. You wouldn't go into France and declare all the relics from the past in there country now belong to you. I would be very upset if someone took that away from me.Backfire wrote:The Dwemer artifacts? That's hardly a reason to get upset about anything.


To be fair, Indoril Nerevar and Dumac Dwarfking made a truce between there peoples and lived in relative harmony for quite some time. This would of continued if it was not for Kargenac's choice to try and ascend the Dwemer race.Backfire wrote:The Dwemer were a blaspheming, warring race in the eyes of the Dunmer.
I'm not saying they have no chance to study the artifacts but they do have to get Imperial permission otherwise it counts as illegal in a sense. Not that anybody cares about that law but it is still in place which means that it is harder for the Dunmer to do so.Backfire wrote:Not only do I doubt that the Empire forbids any Dunmer inclusion in studying the Dwemer; but Caius Cosades, an elite Imperial office, gives a Dwemer artifact to a Dunmer Telvanni in the main quest.


Tis a sad truth really for the conquerors, but also quite a good thought for the conquered. The Great British empire did not fall but rather gave away the land it had claimed back to the original owners. America I'm not sure about, it doesn't really count as an Empire but rather a really large country.Backfire wrote:The Dwemer were b.a., I'll give them that. But they, just as all of the empires that I stated earlier, bit off more than they could chew and got themselves destroyed. If only an empire could say, "Alright, the stuff we have now, it's enough. Let's not push our luck here, guys." That's why I don't think that America's going to fall like the rest, if / when it does. It's not built off war.

Exactly. Great Britain didn't fall like the others but dwindled with time. I think that they still managed to keep their bad-a*sery, though, so that's good.The Great British empire did not fall but rather gave away the land it had claimed
Well, we could try to continue the discussion about the Empire, but I feel that we've all made our points. One thing that I am interested to know is other people's opinions on Dagoth Ur. Was he evil or just insane? There's a lot to be said on this subject.Anyway, we can't have real life political discussions on here. It is against the rules, lets get back on track

True, there isn't much more to discuss on that. Of course if anybody who hasn't joined in has a good point to put down they should definitely tell us there views on things.Backfire wrote: Well, we could try to continue the discussion about the Empire, but I feel that we've all made our points. One thing that I am interested to know is other people's opinions on Dagoth Ur. Was he evil or just insane? There's a lot to be said on this subject.

For me, it's hard to judge whether or not Ur was evil or just ignorant. The blight that he released on Vvardenfell was, in his eyes, a way to free the Dunmer. All the Ash Gouls, Sleepers, Dreamers, and other Dagoths who speak to you say that blight is a blessing, not a curse, and will open your eyes rather than make you rabid and monstrous. Ur's insane, there's no doubt, but I think that it's the Heart that caused his insanity, not his lust for power. All of what Ur's done since the Battle of Red Mountain isn't the real Dagoth Ur but rather the Heart's power gone wrong, in my opinion.His 'evilness' showed in a few ways, the corprus blight he made from the depths of Red Mountain is in my opinion a completely evil act. He is actually using chemical warfare to get what he wants, that is terrorism.