Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
Locked
Listenin'Darthteej
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 45
Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 8:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion,Morrowind,
Platform: PC
Location: The good ol' US of A.

Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Listenin'Darthteej »

Okay, this is something that's bothered me for a while on the forums. A lot of people seem to think that the conjuration of the Undead is necromancy, and that the Mages Guild selling these spells is a plot hole.

But the book "The Black Arts on Trial" clearly mentions conjuring undead as part of normal lessons for a mage. Several scholars in the Arcane University summon them, and Bossirean sells high level "necromancy" spells(including the expert-level Summon Lich and Summon Gloom Wraith).

The difference is that Necromancers attempt to communicate with, understand, and keep the undead. Conjurers do the same thing with Daedric summoning. But most mages use Conjuration as extremely brief assistance battle, the creatures are not friends or familiars, but tools to be used and disposed with.

Finally, there is a difference between Necromancers and the Order of the Black Worm. The Order aren't even true necromancers, they are interested in serving Mannimarco first, and much like the mages they mostly use Undead as tools for battle.

Like I said, this has always bothered me, and I'm trying to clear things up. Discuss please :mrgreen:
Image The ultimate knowledge, the ultimate power. Join me in worship of Hermaeus Mora.
User avatar
Hunter22
Warder
Warder
Posts: 417
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 5:33 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, morrowind
Platform: PC
Location: Good ol' blighty

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Hunter22 »

That is an interesting idea, i didnt really think of it like that...
What i want to know is where do the bodies that they summon come from?
The Friend Of The Night of The Brotherhood
"I didnt just fill a crate full of C4 and blow it up when my whole team was in there, you and your crazy accusations..."
Self proclaimed king of earl grey.
User avatar
Pancake
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 12:27 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim, Morrowind
Platform: PC
Location: Pelagiad
Contact:

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Pancake »

Hunter22 wrote:That is an interesting idea, i didnt really think of it like that...
What i want to know is where do the bodies that they summon come from?
my thoughts exactly...
User avatar
Generalno1
Master
Master
Posts: 1128
Joined: Fri Mar 20, 2009 6:04 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: X-box 360(post), PC
Status: tiddly do
Location: I'm the quiet guy nobody notices.

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Generalno1 »

Hunter22 wrote:That is an interesting idea, i didnt really think of it like that...
What i want to know is where do the bodies that they summon come from?
According to lore and quite a few posts,the Soul Carin(or something thereabouts)
The realm people go to when they die.
I'm not arrogant. I'm insecure.
Spoiler:
Made you look
User avatar
Aces Andre
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:17 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Location: Norway

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Aces Andre »

I always thought of it as Necromancy using real bodies of the recently (and not so recently) deceased, dug up and worked upon, for their permanent undead. Summoning is just calling something into existence briefly, and doesn't actually interfere with the remains of the dead, rather a shell is created from the magic for the spirit that is called forth. I could be way off though.
User avatar
Hunter22
Warder
Warder
Posts: 417
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 5:33 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, morrowind
Platform: PC
Location: Good ol' blighty

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Hunter22 »

I think its one of those oblivion moments where its make what you will of it...
The Friend Of The Night of The Brotherhood
"I didnt just fill a crate full of C4 and blow it up when my whole team was in there, you and your crazy accusations..."
Self proclaimed king of earl grey.
User avatar
Hex Link
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 208
Joined: Fri Oct 09, 2009 7:59 pm
ES Games: Oblivion Collectors Edition, morrorwind soon :D
Platform: PC
Status: Playing Oblivion....?
Location: Cyrodiil

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Hex Link »

Aces Andre wrote:I always thought of it as Necromancy using real bodies of the recently (and not so recently) deceased, dug up and worked upon, for their permanent undead. Summoning is just calling something into existence briefly, and doesn't actually interfere with the remains of the dead, rather a shell is created from the magic for the spirit that is called forth. I could be way off though.
That's what I thought.
That the Necromancers make the dead bodies fight for them. And that the normal mages only conjure things out of nothing.
Dont Drink And Drive - You might spill your drink!
Listenin'Darthteej
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 45
Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 8:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion,Morrowind,
Platform: PC
Location: The good ol' US of A.

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Listenin'Darthteej »

Hex Link wrote:
Aces Andre wrote:I always thought of it as Necromancy using real bodies of the recently (and not so recently) deceased, dug up and worked upon, for their permanent undead. Summoning is just calling something into existence briefly, and doesn't actually interfere with the remains of the dead, rather a shell is created from the magic for the spirit that is called forth. I could be way off though.
That's what I thought.
That the Necromancers make the dead bodies fight for them. And that the normal mages only conjure things out of nothing.
That's one of the things that I was trying to say.
Image The ultimate knowledge, the ultimate power. Join me in worship of Hermaeus Mora.
grannas211
Novice
Novice
Posts: 55
Joined: Sun Feb 07, 2010 2:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by grannas211 »

Yes this is why i think there should be something else to summon for good characters. Something like a good creature of some sort. This is one of the biggest things I want on the next game.
User avatar
Hunter22
Warder
Warder
Posts: 417
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 5:33 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, morrowind
Platform: PC
Location: Good ol' blighty

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Hunter22 »

I also think there should be a chance to practice "true" necromancy in the next game. So you have to gather certain items and then create a undead creature that permantly follows you... which would be quite cool :wink:
The Friend Of The Night of The Brotherhood
"I didnt just fill a crate full of C4 and blow it up when my whole team was in there, you and your crazy accusations..."
Self proclaimed king of earl grey.
Rhys
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 36
Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2010 11:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Rhys »

grannas211 wrote:Yes this is why i think there should be something else to summon for good characters. Something like a good creature of some sort. This is one of the biggest things I want on the next game.
Couldn't the Dark Seducers or the Golden Saints be considered as "Good"
User avatar
Generalno1
Master
Master
Posts: 1128
Joined: Fri Mar 20, 2009 6:04 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: X-box 360(post), PC
Status: tiddly do
Location: I'm the quiet guy nobody notices.

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Generalno1 »

Rhys wrote:
grannas211 wrote:Yes this is why i think there should be something else to summon for good characters. Something like a good creature of some sort. This is one of the biggest things I want on the next game.
Couldn't the Dark Seducers or the Golden Saints be considered as "Good"
Why?they're still daedra.Not much different than a dremora,other than their masters
I'm not arrogant. I'm insecure.
Spoiler:
Made you look
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Mattbott »

a lot of what is considered necromancy could be down to Mages guild politics - i don't like what you are doing- Necromancer!
i think Bethesda have made this whole area a bit vague to keep their options open but also to allow us and npcs to have this ambiguity. It is possible to permanently summon things into magic items (Frostcrag spire also gives you permanently summoned creatures) so the line between 'good' and 'evil' summoners in TES is very blurry indeed.

Elric (Michael Moorcock) summons beings his people are allied with, and each summoning usually means a bargain being made. To the people he's summoning the creatures to attack, he's evil but there's nothing particularly evil about befriending a sea god and asking mutual favours now and then so long as other beings aren't harmed in the process.. it would be interesting to see if a systm like this could be used in conjuration here. I would love conjuror characters if they had to seek out the critters and do a deal to allow their being summoned

SI spoiler:
with the saints and seducers, Staada is an enemy in Morrowind but she is your number 1 Saint once you get the main quest done, so good and evil are very arbitrary (and subjective) in these games. Summoning Aedra would be different perhaps
User avatar
Siken
Warder
Warder
Posts: 417
Joined: Wed May 28, 2008 11:00 am
Platform: PC
Location: Srbija

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Siken »

This no evil/good summons, is all about Ethics.
If you have sword, what way you will use him is what make actions good or bad, summons are in your control so they are like weapon.
And ther is social ethic, people dont like wen some use they ancestors in that way, but agen if i remember Dark Elves have Ancestor Guardian greater power, so they call for help of they ancestors so that is not evil action.
Now my blind eyes see what others cannot!
Image
User avatar
Tim Faal
Novice
Novice
Posts: 96
Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2010 12:15 am
Platform: PC
Status: Sanguinary

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Tim Faal »

I always thought of it as Necromancy = dig up a corpse, noodle about with it, then keep the results long term. Where as summoning plays on the ashes to ashes, dust to dust thing and creates a vessel for a soul temporarily...kill a zombie it leaves remains.
Go for the Eyes, Boo!!!
Kage
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 226
Joined: Mon Feb 22, 2010 9:29 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Kage »

Hunter22 wrote:I also think there should be a chance to practice "true" necromancy in the next game. So you have to gather certain items and then create a undead creature that permantly follows you... which would be quite cool :wink:
Yeah, sorta like the atronach altar for frostcrag spire in Oblivion, they could just add on to it, maybe make it so you can create different creatures (Dremora, Seducers, Saints, Winged Twilight, etc.) depending on your preferences, and make them available as permanent followers once you gain enough favour with the appropriate daedra lord.
I am shadow...A shadow is immaterial, and thus, everywhere...
Listenin'Darthteej
Initiate
Initiate
Posts: 45
Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2010 8:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion,Morrowind,
Platform: PC
Location: The good ol' US of A.

Re: Summoning undead isn't Necromancy

Post by Listenin'Darthteej »

Kage wrote:
Hunter22 wrote:I also think there should be a chance to practice "true" necromancy in the next game. So you have to gather certain items and then create a undead creature that permantly follows you... which would be quite cool :wink:
Yeah, sorta like the atronach altar for frostcrag spire in Oblivion, they could just add on to it, maybe make it so you can create different creatures (Dremora, Seducers, Saints, Winged Twilight, etc.) depending on your preferences, and make them available as permanent followers once you gain enough favour with the appropriate daedra lord.
I definitley agree, I've actually thought about making a Conjurer faction mod for Oblivion with Daedric familiars as a reward, but then I remembered that I don't know anything about programming.
Image The ultimate knowledge, the ultimate power. Join me in worship of Hermaeus Mora.
Locked