Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

The place to discuss movies, TV, games, etc

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

Vivec's Tears
Master
Master
Posts: 1253
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm
ES Games: Morrowind GotY
Platform: Pee See
Status: 50% complete
Location: With Mad Dog and the Companion Cube

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Vivec's Tears »

Josjie wrote:
Vivec's Tears wrote:Overrated:

WoW

Fallout

The Sims 2

Underrated:

The Sims 1

Morrowind

Diner Dash ( :shock: :oops: )
I agree that Morrowind is under-rated. Press average: 8.8 on IGN.com (IGN gives it a 9.4).

But Fallout over-rated? Which Fallout game do you mean?
I mean Fallout 3 on here :mrgreen:
Image
Spoiler:
Ratwar wrote:Brains......
Brains......




Livers.......
Sleeper of House Dagoth
Galvanized Gordon Freeman of the VGCC
User avatar
nyk45
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by nyk45 »

Over-Rated

I never really got disappointed by any game I picked up. I always know if I am going to get a masterpiece or just something that is fun for me. So the so-called masterpieces are usually masterpieces for me as well, and the games that were just supposed to be fun and not 10/10's are just that, nothing less. If anything, I am going to have to say Fallout 3. Don't get me wrong, the game isn't over-rated per se, it's just that people went crazy about the level of freedom in it and said it was unprecedented when Oblivion achieved much bigger freedom 2 years earlier. Fallout deserves everything it gets, it's jsut that Oblivion and Morrowind (never played it, but I trust you addicts) didn't get enough. Oh and the PES series for the last three games.

Under-Rated

X-Men Origins: Wolverine. It's a perfectly good action game, addictive gameplay, enough level variety, some, but not many RPG mechanics. It's a perfect example how trophies/achievements make a game last twice as much as it normally would. The game is really good by itself, and its flaws (like the unvaried bosses and some textures that don't load as fast as expected) aren't game-breakers at all, but I had a LOT of fun achieving all trophies, because the game had orgasmic gameplay, and I just needed goals to achieve. Sure, it's not videogames art either, but it's a great game.

TES Series. How come the best RPG series around doesn't get as much recognition as some crappy (compared to TES) Bioware games do?

Far Cry 2. (By the players, not game sites. Those scored it fairly, kind of) People say it was bad. Couldn't disagree more. Open world, FPS, AFRICA. There are lots of guns, most of them pretty darn fun, and not very common to see in games. The setting is great, so are the graphics. The AI can actually be pretty good. It has its flaws, like super human foes and malaria, but even those make it special. I dunno, I just think it's a great game.

Valkyria Chronicles. I actually need to play it, I got stuck in a mission with a massive enemy tank and have been playing other games ever since. I don't think I have reached half of the campaign, actually. It has the best gameplay I have seen in JRPG's, original graphics, and it's just deep as an RPG. Sleeper hit, much?
Image
Thus, He saith: To Nine Thousand... and Beyond!
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Josjie »

@nyk45
Wikipedia wrote:The game was well-received, earning high scores and winning numerous awards[5] and scoring an average of 94% in Metacritic's aggregate, based on ninety reviews, at least nineteen of which produced perfect scores. It also scored 9.3 at IGN.[6] Oblivion had shipped 1.7 million copies by April 10, 2006,[7] and sold over three million copies by January 18, 2007.[8] A package including both Shivering Isles and the official plug-in Knights of the Nine, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Game of the Year Edition, was released in Autumn 2007 for Windows PCs, the Xbox 360, and the PlayStation 3.
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion is still quite popular and has sold many copies :D.

And I do not agree that Oblivion offers more freedom than Fallout 3. You can look at it in various ways.
Oblivion has a more open world while Fallout 3 has many "blockades", piles of rubbish. Fallout 3, however, has a good working karma system that actually allows you to be evil. And you can finish many quests, even the main quest, in an evil or non-evil way. It's your choice.
In Oblivion, by doing the Main Quest you're forced to save Cyrodiil and defeat the Daedra. During the Dark Brotherhood questline, you cannot save Lucien. During the Mages Guild, you cannot join the Necromancers.
So Fallout 3 offers more choices, which is also freedom IMO. So I think Fallout 3 offers more freedom than Oblivion.

In Oblivion, any character turned out to be a jack-off-all-trades in the end. In Fallout 3, that becomes impossible thanks to your SPECIAL stats and perks. A level 30 character who forgot to take Grim Reaper's Sprint, Sniper etc. cannot suddenly become a great V.A.T.S. fighter.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
nyk45
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by nyk45 »

I know it scored well on the reviews when it was released, but it seems to have been forgotten shortly after, and not set as a benchmark for current RPG's like it should. It scored well, sold well, but was left out soon enough. Just my impression.

And by freedom, I meant they became amazed by the freedom of being able to explore and doing side quests without caring about the main quest. Some people did, at least. Especially game reviewers here. And in the way of forgetting about the main quest and exploring, I think Oblivion offers more freedom, or at least a different kind of freedom. Lots of dungeons that respawn after three days, bigger map, more monster variety, I think. Much more loot to win. Like you said, no piles of junk blocking your path. Fallout does offer more lore reward for exploration, with interesting unmarked quest, and every single building seems to have been carefully planned, whereas Oblivion's dungeons are pretty dull.

I mean, Fallout is a great game, and I have over 100 hours in it, and I still have a LOT to do. Quests to do in a different way, lots of buildings to explore, almost all unmarked quests to do, and those are lots of fun, all DLC's to buy, different kinds of characters to try, and the world itself to explore to the limit.

I just don't feel Oblivion had the acclamation it deserved, considering that if it's still impressive in 2009 and will be for some more years, it was even more back in 06. They are both great games, and in your Oblivion vs Fallout 3 vs Morrowind, I couldn't decide between 'em. They're different styles, but I just feel F3 had the recognition that Oblivion should have had.
Image
Thus, He saith: To Nine Thousand... and Beyond!
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Josjie »

nyk45 wrote:but I just feel F3 had the recognition that Oblivion should have had.
Agreed.

Oblivion was released on March 20, 2006 and Fallout 3 on October 31, 2008. Releasing a game near the end of the year is always riskful. Fallout 3 sold over 610.000 units in the first month though and I think that's why it has made a bigger impact than Oblivion. Not to mention Fallout 3 is an action game with guns while Oblivion is a fantasy game with swords and magic. Guns are more popular than fantasy I think ;).

Oblivion and Morrowind are hardcore RPG's (Morrowind even more than Oblivion), with their own history and lore. Fallout 3 is a bit more casual, has better graphics and the setting is great.

While I agree that you can easily spent hundreds of hours in Oblivion and Morrowind, Fallout 3 is meant for creating several characters instead of just one. Bethesda wants you to create a neutral, evil and good character and to try out all the different choices during quests (destroying Megaton or not, etc.).
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
nyk45
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by nyk45 »

Josjie wrote:Not to mention Fallout 3 is an action game with guns while Oblivion is a fantasy game with swords and magic. Guns are more popular than fantasy I think ;).

Oblivion and Morrowind are hardcore RPG's (Morrowind even more than Oblivion), with their own history and lore. Fallout 3 is a bit more casual, has better graphics and the setting is great.

While I agree that you can easily spent hundreds of hours in Oblivion and Morrowind, Fallout 3 is meant for creating several characters instead of just one. Bethesda wants you to create a neutral, evil and good character and to try out all the different choices during quests (destroying Megaton or not, etc.).

Indeed so @ all three paragraphs, except a part of the third.

I think swords and magic are more for the hardcore RPGamers. Guns are for both the hardcore and the 'softcore', or mainstream. Oblivion is a much more niche game. Same with Morrowind.

Regarding Fallout being meant for different characters more than Oblivion, I disagree. Even if you pick Big Guns instead of Small Guns or Energy Guns, the gameplay is pretty much the same, you just change the kind of weapons you have. It only goes through a makeover if you go Melee or Unarmed, but that just makes two 'gameplays', really. I do agree with the quest part, there are many more choices, and you need to make new characters to try them all out, unless you spend half your playtime saving and loading and doing it all again. While Oblivion doesn't have as much choice during quests, it still holds quite some, and there are like what, 5 times as many quests? Probably more, but it doesn't matter. My point is, the quest system isn't as robust as Fallout's, but doing ALL quests in Oblivion differently takes you hundreds of hours, where in F3 you can do all quests in under 30 hours without rushing (if you don't go around exploring with no purpose). With that said, Oblivion's quests still don't make you go and make new characters just to try different play-throughs. On the other hand, your characters vary a lot more, but it's probably because of the setting. You can have a mage, a swordsman, a marskman, a fist-fighter, a healer, a necromancer and so on. To add on that, the gameplay also changes between those classes, so there are many more classes, and they are all very different.

To sum it up, I think Fallout's setting is much more appealing to more people, and its replay value is based on choices during quests and the karma system, while Oblivion appeals to a shorter number of players and its replay value consists of different gameplay for different characters.
Image
Thus, He saith: To Nine Thousand... and Beyond!
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Dogmantra »

Josjie wrote:The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion is still quite popular and has sold many copies :D.
's why it's over-rated.
BANG → !
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Josjie »

nyk45 wrote:Indeed so @ all three paragraphs, except a part of the third.

I think swords and magic are more for the hardcore RPGamers. Guns are for both the hardcore and the 'softcore', or mainstream. Oblivion is a much more niche game. Same with Morrowind.

Regarding Fallout being meant for different characters more than Oblivion, I disagree. Even if you pick Big Guns instead of Small Guns or Energy Guns, the gameplay is pretty much the same, you just change the kind of weapons you have. It only goes through a makeover if you go Melee or Unarmed, but that just makes two 'gameplays', really. I do agree with the quest part, there are many more choices, and you need to make new characters to try them all out, unless you spend half your playtime saving and loading and doing it all again. While Oblivion doesn't have as much choice during quests, it still holds quite some, and there are like what, 5 times as many quests? Probably more, but it doesn't matter. My point is, the quest system isn't as robust as Fallout's, but doing ALL quests in Oblivion differently takes you hundreds of hours, where in F3 you can do all quests in under 30 hours without rushing (if you don't go around exploring with no purpose). With that said, Oblivion's quests still don't make you go and make new characters just to try different play-throughs. On the other hand, your characters vary a lot more, but it's probably because of the setting. You can have a mage, a swordsman, a marskman, a fist-fighter, a healer, a necromancer and so on. To add on that, the gameplay also changes between those classes, so there are many more classes, and they are all very different.

To sum it up, I think Fallout's setting is much more appealing to more people, and its replay value is based on choices during quests and the karma system, while Oblivion appeals to a shorter number of players and its replay value consists of different gameplay for different characters.
Your tagged skills aren't important in Fallout 3 ;).
It's true that you can be a necromancer, healer, scout, acrobat, assassin, mage, battlemage etc. in Oblivion but in the end everyone uses either stealth, combat, magic or a combination of these. Most level 50 characters have powerful enchanted armor and/or custom created spells. To complete all the quests in Oblivion, you have to be both evil and good. You'll take the role of a thief, assassin, fighter and a mage.
So being a jack-of-all-trades is even a requirement to achieve 100% completion in Oblivion.

Oblivion has more quests but most of these quests follow the default RPG pattern: "Go to location X and get item Y" or "Kill X for me". The quests in FO3 have more variety, take more time to complete and there are more choices.
What choices does Oblivion offer? You can go for the bonuses during the DB quests or not. You can call for aid at every city during the "Aid for Bruma" quest or none at all. That's it.
And let's not forget the five DLC's for Fallout 3 :D. They add more variety and new quests to the mix ;).

I agree that there's a bit more to do in Oblivion. But I've already fallen in love with Fallout 3 :D. The graphics, the setting, the enemies, V.A.T.S., the storyline, the weapons, playing with a female character :mrgreen:, the excellent mods.... I like it even more than Oblivion.

To be short: I think Fallout 3 is under-rated and deserves a 10.0 but that's my opinion :lol:. Morrowind is under-rated as well and Oblivion is perhaps slightly over-rated. Vanilla Oblivion isn't that good, it's 100x better with the Shivering Isles, DLC's, KotN and a bunch of mods :D.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
ace62394
Master
Master
Posts: 1470
Joined: Fri Jan 26, 2007 6:20 pm

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by ace62394 »

If you ask me, no game on earth deserves a perfect score, unless it can make me sandwiches, do the dishes, and walk the dog.
User avatar
nyk45
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by nyk45 »

ace62394 wrote:If you ask me, no game on earth deserves a perfect score, unless it can make me sandwiches, do the dishes, and walk the dog.
Well, if you literally live in your computer, get The Sims.
Image
Thus, He saith: To Nine Thousand... and Beyond!
Vivec's Tears
Master
Master
Posts: 1253
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm
ES Games: Morrowind GotY
Platform: Pee See
Status: 50% complete
Location: With Mad Dog and the Companion Cube

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Vivec's Tears »

nyk45 wrote:
ace62394 wrote:If you ask me, no game on earth deserves a perfect score, unless it can make me sandwiches, do the dishes, and walk the dog.
Well, if you literally live in your computer, get The Sims.
The Sims 1. The best game. What other game has itself in it? :mrgreen:
Image
Spoiler:
Ratwar wrote:Brains......
Brains......




Livers.......
Sleeper of House Dagoth
Galvanized Gordon Freeman of the VGCC
User avatar
ace62394
Master
Master
Posts: 1470
Joined: Fri Jan 26, 2007 6:20 pm

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by ace62394 »

nyk45 wrote:
ace62394 wrote:If you ask me, no game on earth deserves a perfect score, unless it can make me sandwiches, do the dishes, and walk the dog.
Well, if you literally live in your computer, get The Sims.
Haha, very funny. I meant in real life, anyways.
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Dark Spark »

Why would a video game do your chores? Wouldn't it be easier to get a trained chimp?

If I had the best game in the world, having it take out the trash would not be the first thing to come in mind. Nor the second thing.
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Josjie »

A score of 10.0 isn't "a perfect score". That's a very common mistake.

One could argue that giving a game the perfect score means that:
- it's the best game that has ever been created.
- it's the best game that'll ever be created.
- you can play it forever without getting bored.
- everyone likes it and gets addicted to it.

This is impossible, however.

When a game gets a 10/10 it's simply a great game. GTA IV got a 10/10 on IGN. I think GTA IV is over-rated but you can still argue that such a realistic city hasn't been done before. The graphics, setting, replay value, length of the game itself, soundtrack, multiplayer, gameplay etc. were all great.

That's why games like Bioshock and Fallout 3 have scored a 10/10 on some websites.

You can't look in the future. If you really like a game and have a feeling that it's worth a 10, and it's better than anything that has been released in the past 1-2 years, you give it a 10.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
Coulsonji
Master
Master
Posts: 1128
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2007 9:58 am
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: Xbox 360
Location: The Great Down Under
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Coulsonji »

GTA 4 Disappointed me a LOT. I had played San Andreas and Saints Row 1 and 2 and was expecting something similar. The story was amazing though. And it had hookers...
I have 2 words to say to you! I can't count!!!
User avatar
ace62394
Master
Master
Posts: 1470
Joined: Fri Jan 26, 2007 6:20 pm

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by ace62394 »

I've noticed that katanas are quite over-rated in many modifiable games. Oblivion and Fallout 3 come to mind.
User avatar
Agares
Novice
Novice
Posts: 59
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:53 pm
ES Games: 'bout all of 'em
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: You wear the Shadows well!
Location: Virginia

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Agares »

Oh Boy, here we go!


my theory on the "WoW is the greatest game ever!!!1111oneoneone!" theory is that it uses a primal system of rewards and punishments that equate to a similarity to real-life drug use. you start out, you level up! "hey! that was fun!" you say, but next time it takes a little more, got to stay challenging right? you level up a few more times and after awhile you've built up a small amount of goodies: a nice piece of armor or a magical weapon. but remember, you gotta' keep leveling up if you wanna be the best! keep at it "it seems tough, but it'll pay off!" you say to yourself. eventually, you're knee-deep in RedBull cans and your brain can't handle it all. "gotta do a little more, just need to get better". Like a cheap high, it takes more and more of the drug to get the same buzz.

Thank You! World of Warcraft!
"The Worlds #1 Online Abstinence Program!"

to stay on-topic, I think that people under-rate the Dungeons and Dragons franchise as a whole, not realizing that most elements of today's RPG's come from its system.

AND WE AREN'T ALL NERDS! :x
User avatar
Dogmantra
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1518
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 6:19 pm
ES Games: Yes
Platform: 9¾ leaving in 5 minutes.
Status: Listening to They Might Be Giants
Location: With Uncle Crassius and the Companion Cube
Contact:

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Dogmantra »

Agares wrote:AND WE AREN'T ALL NERDS! :x
I am!
BANG → !
User avatar
Agares
Novice
Novice
Posts: 59
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:53 pm
ES Games: 'bout all of 'em
Platform: Xbox 360
Status: You wear the Shadows well!
Location: Virginia

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Agares »

I consider myself more of a Hypercritical Musician...
User avatar
ace62394
Master
Master
Posts: 1470
Joined: Fri Jan 26, 2007 6:20 pm

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by ace62394 »

I consider myself a geek...
User avatar
JamesF14
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 161
Joined: Tue Sep 15, 2009 6:43 pm
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: PS3

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by JamesF14 »

Most people on online rpg's just power-game the whole way through. I find them really boring :? .
Rock The Casbah
User avatar
dag71
Novice
Novice
Posts: 57
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 1:53 am
ES Games: Oblivion GOTY
Platform: Xbox 360

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by dag71 »

Overrated: Mass effect, sure its a good game but not a super great game

underrated: Legaia 2 duel saga, zoids legacy
Want a salad? Order extra onions.
User avatar
The Number None
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2009 2:13 pm
ES Games: Morrowind
Platform: PC
Status: Dazed and confused
Location: Gothenburg, Sweden

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by The Number None »

Are the Sims games even rated enough to be called under-rated? I thought only 14 year old girls played those games.

OnT: Fallout 3, TES4 Oblivion and basically all awesome games that are not quite as awesome as Morrowind is OVER-RATED!

Under-rated: TES3: Morrowind!
She used to baby me, I was her baby doll. I used to chase her around, she was my basketball.
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by Cactus »

Stoner wrote:Are the Sims games even rated enough to be called under-rated? I thought only 14 year old girls played those games.
I really should ban you for that. I'll have you know I'm a 25-year old guy and I love the Sims games. Not just "The Sims" but SimCity, Streets of SimCity, SimCopter, SimTower.. all the Sim games. They're brilliant and I own most of them, including all The Sims games (1-3) and expansions to date.
User avatar
The Number None
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 108
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2009 2:13 pm
ES Games: Morrowind
Platform: PC
Status: Dazed and confused
Location: Gothenburg, Sweden

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Post by The Number None »

Cactus wrote:
Stoner wrote:Are the Sims games even rated enough to be called under-rated? I thought only 14 year old girls played those games.
I really should ban you for that. I'll have you know I'm a 25-year old guy and I love the Sims games. Not just "The Sims" but SimCity, Streets of SimCity, SimCopter, SimTower.. all the Sim games. They're brilliant and I own most of them, including all The Sims games (1-3) and expansions to date.
Hey, I said "I thought". ;)

There are surely other people playing it aswell, 25-year old girls, 25-year old gay guys. The list goes on...

Please don't ban me!!! :P
She used to baby me, I was her baby doll. I used to chase her around, she was my basketball.
Locked