Mattbott wrote:I voted Oblivion cos i spent way more time playing it. Morrowind is a better game but less accessible for many reasons. If they forgot about TES5 and just remade morrowind with up to date graphics, updates tes mechanics (tweaked skills, character generation etc) and ai, they would have a hit which would bury Oblivion and i don't think many people would notice, let alone mind. There's something very classic-epic-fantasy about a baddie who lives inside a volcano in an isolated and beleagered land which needs to be united to defeat him, and they executed this plotline very well.
I'd consider Far Cry 2 a much more immersive and in depth shooting-rpg-style-game experience than fallout, even tho there's no 'roleplaying' in it as such. And when i play far cry, i'm pretty much doing the same thing as in FO3: get mission from A, go to B, scope the area and decide the best tools for the job, etc. Which kind of pinpoints what rpgs are about, really. Variety.
anyhow, I am looking forward to TES5 and will be interested in what they do with FO4 and fallout vegas. Maybe they can include a multiplayer aspect to fallout? That might be what it needs to fill it out a bit experience wise, and we'd get a chance to do a bit of gaming together

IMO Fallout 3 has much more variety than Oblivion. In Oblivion, every Oblivion plane and dungeon looks the same. Every chapel, city, yes even every Khajiit, Argonian or High Elf, look almost exactly the same. I don't know if you have any of the DLC's for Fallout 3 but they're totally different. Mothership Zeta resembles nothing of Point Lookout, for example. Operation Anchorage takes place during the winter and reminded me of Battlefield 2142, The Pitt has a working Steel Mill with awesome animations and features a city full of slaves and Raiders, Broken Steel has a large Air Force Base that hasn't been seen in previous DLC's or Fallout 3 itself, Point Lookout reminded me of the Shivering Isles and brings survival horror to Fallout 3 and Mothership Zeta takes place in an alien ship and looks very futuristic.
And the vanilla Fallout 3 game also has a lot of variety. Megaton, Rivet City and Big Town look totally different. No dungeon looks the same. You could say that the metro tunnels are quite similar but there aren't that many of them and they are connected under D.C.
You've got Dunwich Building, the several Vaults, Minefield, Andale, D.C., the Washington Monument, the Death Claw Sanctuary, Raven Rock.....
Anyway, I still haven't decided where I'm going to vote for. Will it be Oblivion or Fallout 3?
As I said, Fallout 3 has more variety than Oblivion IMO. It also has a bigger replay value. There's much more to do in Oblivion though.
In Fallout 3, after 80 hours or so, I've achieved 100% completion (all DLC's completed, all quests completed, all Bobbleheads, all SPECIAL stats and skills maxed, all Unique items found, all unmarked quests completed).
In Oblivion, I still haven't reached 100% completion after 200 hours of playing time. Creating your own spells, enchanting your own weapons and clearing out dungeons remains fun forever. Enemies respawn every three days so you can come back to any dungeon you want. And there are a lot of them. While Fallout 3 has but a few dungeons (some Vaults, the Metro Tunnel system and a few caves like the Death Claw Sanctuary), Oblivion has dozens of caves, fortresses and mines.
There are 62 Oblivion gates to close and much more quests than in Fallout 3. And let us not forget the guilds! And there's the Arena, Shivering Isles, Knights of the Nine, the Daedric Quest, dozens of Miscellaneous quests... and there are more houses, more NPC's, more cities, a bigger world, horses....
And exploring is more fun in Oblivion IMO. You can use a horse (Shadowmere) and go wherever you want. Fallout 3 has many obstacles that are standing in your way (huge piles of rubbish) and you can't use a mount, which means you've got to walk and that takes more time.
Fallout 3 has guns on the other hand, better graphics, very good DLC's, a better levelling system (IMO) and sneaking is more fun.
So I still can't decide

.