History
Moderator: Tea Party Mods
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
Quite.
Try to do this quickly.
Genocide IS bad. But condemnation of a people for it is...quite the same. Genocide cannot be looked at as a single act destroying a civilizations reputation. It happens, one must look at the other factors. What did this civilization give to the world?
For a perfect modern example: The Nazis DID commit a horrid act of genocide, HOWEVER, they wrote the playbook for modern warfare. Saved countless soldiers lives with their military innovations. I am not sympathetic to the nazi cause, of course. This, however, is important to look at.
When you do look at such factors. The Romans become the good guys.
My interest in history? Military, primarily. I can look at a battle. I can tell you about everything that was a factor in the way it turned out. It's what I find interesting.
Try to do this quickly.
Genocide IS bad. But condemnation of a people for it is...quite the same. Genocide cannot be looked at as a single act destroying a civilizations reputation. It happens, one must look at the other factors. What did this civilization give to the world?
For a perfect modern example: The Nazis DID commit a horrid act of genocide, HOWEVER, they wrote the playbook for modern warfare. Saved countless soldiers lives with their military innovations. I am not sympathetic to the nazi cause, of course. This, however, is important to look at.
When you do look at such factors. The Romans become the good guys.
My interest in history? Military, primarily. I can look at a battle. I can tell you about everything that was a factor in the way it turned out. It's what I find interesting.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
The most obvious two, are the sheer number of the soviet soldiers and the lowered morale and ability of the primarily conscripted or untrained defenders of the city itself. The depleted Wehrmacht and SS regiments were not prepared for the force of the soviet army. The, primarily, old men and young boys of the other half of the defenders had either never seen battle, been trained, or were too old for what a battlefield required of them.
The Soviets also had a huge advantage in the number of armored vehicles, although this advantage was watered down due to the urban environment during most of the battle. The willingness of the soviets to execute every last German soldier in the city didn't help morale in the deeper sections.
The Germans were also relying on almost no supplies to face off against the well-armed, well-supplied, and veteran Red Army. The mobility, and incompetent decision making by the Germans didn't help their defense capability. The psychological factor for the Red Army soldiers, all of them wanted the Germans to pay. Russia has a history of uniting, regardless of political or economical strife, when the Motherland is threatened. The Great Patriotic War was no different. Almost every Russian soldier was going to fight, so they could see Germany fall. Or they would die trying.
None of this is all too important, except the first two. The battle was obviously a soviet win from the start. Nothing could stop the Red Army from taking Berlin. Nothing.
The Soviets also had a huge advantage in the number of armored vehicles, although this advantage was watered down due to the urban environment during most of the battle. The willingness of the soviets to execute every last German soldier in the city didn't help morale in the deeper sections.
The Germans were also relying on almost no supplies to face off against the well-armed, well-supplied, and veteran Red Army. The mobility, and incompetent decision making by the Germans didn't help their defense capability. The psychological factor for the Red Army soldiers, all of them wanted the Germans to pay. Russia has a history of uniting, regardless of political or economical strife, when the Motherland is threatened. The Great Patriotic War was no different. Almost every Russian soldier was going to fight, so they could see Germany fall. Or they would die trying.
None of this is all too important, except the first two. The battle was obviously a soviet win from the start. Nothing could stop the Red Army from taking Berlin. Nothing.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
- nyk45
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 6:47 pm
- Location: Dá-me a tua mão e vamos ser alguém.
- Contact:
On the original topic, my favorite Era was the first Imperialistic one.
Roman, Greek and all that.
That's why I love startegy games so much in the first place. That era got me started in loving history and all.
Recent history is kinda cool, but it nowhere near reached the interestingness of the Ancient times.
Roman, Greek and all that.
That's why I love startegy games so much in the first place. That era got me started in loving history and all.
Recent history is kinda cool, but it nowhere near reached the interestingness of the Ancient times.
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
Ok, Stalingrad.
The defenders of Stalingrad had several major advantages. One of the most important was the prepared state of the Red Army for the Russian winter. The Russian soldier were equipped to live through it, and be able to fight the enemy. The Germans were not so lucky. The cold incapacitated many Germans, and killed many as well. The Soviet showed exceptional use of force multiplication, some of the best in the last 1000-2000+ years. The use of snipers is probably the best, ever. It dropped German morale, disrupted their command, and destroyed their sense of security. It instilled fear in every German soldier with any brain.
Aside from these, the Russians also had a few more advantages. Many were not only fighting to defend the Motherland, but their home. Many of these soldiers came from Stalingrad, and would rather die than see it fall. The Russians also had a constant supply of reinforcements from across the Volga. Soviet high command during the battle was, brilliant, to say the least. Brutal, but efficient and effective, nonetheless. The quantity of soviet weaponry, particularly tanks and other vehicles, gave them an advantage as the Germans couldn't match their numbers. No matter how good the tank is, being outnumbered 6+ to 1 is what decides that fight.
The smaller factors also made a difference. Legendary places like Pavlov's house and the simple fact that the Soviet had superior weaponry in some cases, helped turn the tide. For example, many of the men were hunters or farmers, which meant crack shots most of the time.
As for the Ardennes Offensive.
This battle was significant because it was the last offensive the Germans would mount before the end of the war. The Germans plan was a good one, in theory. They would come in through the dense, deep Ardennes forest. Assumed impenetrable by the Allies, Hitler believed. He would thrust through, and take the allied armies by surprise, no doubt.
What Hitler failed to remember, was he had done this once before, during the invasion of France. The British had made the same mistake Hitler hoped the allies would make again. They entrenched to the North, both assuming the Ardennes impenetrable by armor, and assuming the Germans would take the historic route of hooking south through Belgium to attack France. So Hitler punched through the Ardennes and destroyed the British defenders, and took France with minimal opposition.
This time around, the allies expected this to happen. They fortified the Ardennes and deployed in and around the forest. When Hitler's surprise attack came, no one was surprised but him. He never expected them to defend it so readily, so he went on with it anyway. The 'Bulge' is a large portion of the allied lines that were forced backward by the Germans, while the surrounding areas held firm, creating a bulge in the lines.
One important area of fighting was the junction city of Bastogne. If the Germans captured it, the entire front could be decimated, and all that had been worked for since the Invasion of Normandy could be lost, along with the war in the west. Regiments of the 101st held that city, while surrounded by the Germans until Patton's army could break through, and end the fighting in Bastogne.
The defenders of Stalingrad had several major advantages. One of the most important was the prepared state of the Red Army for the Russian winter. The Russian soldier were equipped to live through it, and be able to fight the enemy. The Germans were not so lucky. The cold incapacitated many Germans, and killed many as well. The Soviet showed exceptional use of force multiplication, some of the best in the last 1000-2000+ years. The use of snipers is probably the best, ever. It dropped German morale, disrupted their command, and destroyed their sense of security. It instilled fear in every German soldier with any brain.
Aside from these, the Russians also had a few more advantages. Many were not only fighting to defend the Motherland, but their home. Many of these soldiers came from Stalingrad, and would rather die than see it fall. The Russians also had a constant supply of reinforcements from across the Volga. Soviet high command during the battle was, brilliant, to say the least. Brutal, but efficient and effective, nonetheless. The quantity of soviet weaponry, particularly tanks and other vehicles, gave them an advantage as the Germans couldn't match their numbers. No matter how good the tank is, being outnumbered 6+ to 1 is what decides that fight.
The smaller factors also made a difference. Legendary places like Pavlov's house and the simple fact that the Soviet had superior weaponry in some cases, helped turn the tide. For example, many of the men were hunters or farmers, which meant crack shots most of the time.
As for the Ardennes Offensive.
This battle was significant because it was the last offensive the Germans would mount before the end of the war. The Germans plan was a good one, in theory. They would come in through the dense, deep Ardennes forest. Assumed impenetrable by the Allies, Hitler believed. He would thrust through, and take the allied armies by surprise, no doubt.
What Hitler failed to remember, was he had done this once before, during the invasion of France. The British had made the same mistake Hitler hoped the allies would make again. They entrenched to the North, both assuming the Ardennes impenetrable by armor, and assuming the Germans would take the historic route of hooking south through Belgium to attack France. So Hitler punched through the Ardennes and destroyed the British defenders, and took France with minimal opposition.
This time around, the allies expected this to happen. They fortified the Ardennes and deployed in and around the forest. When Hitler's surprise attack came, no one was surprised but him. He never expected them to defend it so readily, so he went on with it anyway. The 'Bulge' is a large portion of the allied lines that were forced backward by the Germans, while the surrounding areas held firm, creating a bulge in the lines.
One important area of fighting was the junction city of Bastogne. If the Germans captured it, the entire front could be decimated, and all that had been worked for since the Invasion of Normandy could be lost, along with the war in the west. Regiments of the 101st held that city, while surrounded by the Germans until Patton's army could break through, and end the fighting in Bastogne.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
-
Amnea
- Layman

- Posts: 1
- Joined: Fri Sep 04, 2009 6:46 pm
- ES Games: oblivian
- Platform: xbox360
- Status: On this
- Location: Scotland
Re:
the romans by alot of historians are classed as stupid people who elimanted clever societes because of their milatery qausing some technolgys not to be rediscoverd till the age of enlightment.leroybrown wrote:I read a lot of US history not so much out of interest more so out of the fact that i feel obligated. It is fairly interesting too, it dosnt bore me really.
Aztecs were pretty cool i like the mayans more though personally. Lately ive been getting into the history of china. My favorite history subject by far would have to be ancient egypt. Its just so effing fascinating i could go on and on.
EDIT:Oh yeah and i think its a given that the romans were ridiculously awesome. One of these days i want to read more into german history because of my family lineage.
Theirs also the english who made the modern world with the empire but commit genocides on people in their own country.The Most Unholy wrote:Quite.
Try to do this quickly.
Genocide IS bad. But condemnation of a people for it is...quite the same. Genocide cannot be looked at as a single act destroying a civilizations reputation. It happens, one must look at the other factors. What did this civilization give to the world?
For a perfect modern example: The Nazis DID commit a horrid act of genocide, HOWEVER, they wrote the playbook for modern warfare. Saved countless soldiers lives with their military innovations. I am not sympathetic to the nazi cause, of course. This, however, is important to look at.
When you do look at such factors. The Romans become the good guys.
My interest in history? Military, primarily. I can look at a battle. I can tell you about everything that was a factor in the way it turned out. It's what I find interesting.
Last edited by Codex on Sat Sep 05, 2009 2:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Please don't double post. Use the "Edit" button instead.
Reason: Please don't double post. Use the "Edit" button instead.
Dont be sillie
- The King
- Master

- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
- ES Games: Obliwind.
- Platform: Game Cube 360
- Location: Texas
Re: History
Wow. We have some violent folks here. I prefer to study the.....peaceful side of history. Sure there was a lot of war and bloodshed. But I like looking at ancient government policies, political ideas, rights movements, ancient culture. I don't care how this guy and that guy killed the other guy, I wanna know how they looked at life, and wrote laws accordingly.
P.S. Yes, I love law.
P.S. Yes, I love law.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
sorry king, their isnt a peaceful side.The King wrote:Wow. We have some violent folks here. I prefer to study the.....peaceful side of history. Sure there was a lot of war and bloodshed. But I like looking at ancient government policies, political ideas, rights movements, ancient culture. I don't care how this guy and that guy killed the other guy, I wanna know how they looked at life, and wrote laws accordingly.
P.S. Yes, I love law.
at some point or other every civilization or tribe has gone to war.
oh and laws sometimes lead to revolutions 8D
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
Re: History
Laws, philosophies, culture. All of it stems from violence. War is the lifeblood of humanity. Without it, we would advance little if at all past a bunch of people in smalll communities far away from each other.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
- The King
- Master

- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
- ES Games: Obliwind.
- Platform: Game Cube 360
- Location: Texas
Re: History
Yes, there is a peaceful side of history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_RomanaDark Lord wrote:sorry king, their isnt a peaceful side.The King wrote:Wow. We have some violent folks here. I prefer to study the.....peaceful side of history. Sure there was a lot of war and bloodshed. But I like looking at ancient government policies, political ideas, rights movements, ancient culture. I don't care how this guy and that guy killed the other guy, I wanna know how they looked at life, and wrote laws accordingly.
P.S. Yes, I love law.
at some point or other every civilization or tribe has gone to war.
oh and laws sometimes lead to revolutions 8D
The link above just pointed to it. 207 years of peace. No war. Obviously there was crime, but no large scale, or even small scale battle. That's what I like to learn about. What about how the Egyptians buried their kings? How is that violent. You mean to say that every period of time has violence, but there are times that even when there is violence one place, there is peace in another. I like to learn about the other place, the one with peace. Its fine that you enjoy that side of history, I just don't particularly fancy the violent side.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
peace for rome you meanThe King wrote:Yes, there is a peaceful side of history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_RomanaDark Lord wrote:sorry king, their isnt a peaceful side.The King wrote:Wow. We have some violent folks here. I prefer to study the.....peaceful side of history. Sure there was a lot of war and bloodshed. But I like looking at ancient government policies, political ideas, rights movements, ancient culture. I don't care how this guy and that guy killed the other guy, I wanna know how they looked at life, and wrote laws accordingly.
P.S. Yes, I love law.
at some point or other every civilization or tribe has gone to war.
oh and laws sometimes lead to revolutions 8D
The link above just pointed to it. 207 years of peace. No war. Obviously there was crime, but no large scale, or even small scale battle. That's what I like to learn about. What about how the Egyptians buried their kings? How is that violent. You mean to say that every period of time has violence, but there are times that even when there is violence one place, there is peace in another. I like to learn about the other place, the one with peace. Its fine that you enjoy that side of history, I just don't particularly fancy the violent side.
other nations still had their wars.
and drake is right.
violent conflict has helped humanity advance greatly, from planes to penicillin to the birth of nations.
i mean, the internet was invented by the military
Re: History
I fixed your post to make it more accurate.Dark Lord wrote:i mean, the internet was invented bythe militaryAl Gore
-
Vivec's Tears
- Master

- Posts: 1253
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind GotY
- Platform: Pee See
- Status: 50% complete
- Location: With Mad Dog and the Companion Cube
Re: History
In reply to the precious (omg why did I type precious? And why the hobo did I not delete it after I typed it?) previous comments about Rome, they were equally bad and good. I recently listened into a lecture about ancient Rome. They "took things from other civilizations and made it Roman." Ancient Fistory rules. 

Spoiler:
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
(QUITE FUNNY CACTUS)Cactus wrote:I fixed your post to make it more accurate.Dark Lord wrote:i mean, the internet was invented bythe militaryAl Gore
i guess you never heard of ARPANET
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARPANET
Re: History
Dark Lord wrote:i guess you never heard of ARPANET![]()
Not by name, but I am familiar with the history of the innerwebz.
- The King
- Master

- Posts: 1006
- Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
- ES Games: Obliwind.
- Platform: Game Cube 360
- Location: Texas
Re: History
Pencillin wasn't created by war. It was an accident. When Sir Alexander Fleming left a petri dish filled with bacteria unattended.Dark Lord wrote:
peace for rome you mean
other nations still had their wars.
and drake is right.
violent conflict has helped humanity advance greatly, from planes to penicillin to the birth of nations.
i mean, the internet was invented by the military
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
not created but most widely used.The King wrote:Pencillin wasn't created by war. It was an accident. When Sir Alexander Fleming left a petri dish filled with bacteria unattended.Dark Lord wrote:
peace for rome you mean
other nations still had their wars.
and drake is right.
violent conflict has helped humanity advance greatly, from planes to penicillin to the birth of nations.
i mean, the internet was invented by the military
its the military that used it more than anyone else and pretty much tested it for public use.
here is a list of things created by the military http://military.discovery.com/tv/backya ... p-ten.html
- Kestral
- Grand Master

- Posts: 2970
- Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
- ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
- Platform: PC
- Status: [&@%!]
Re: History
I speak for everyone when I say, thank you Military.Dark Lord wrote:not created but most widely used.The King wrote:Pencillin wasn't created by war. It was an accident. When Sir Alexander Fleming left a petri dish filled with bacteria unattended.Dark Lord wrote:
peace for rome you mean
other nations still had their wars.
and drake is right.
violent conflict has helped humanity advance greatly, from planes to penicillin to the birth of nations.
i mean, the internet was invented by the military :P
its the military that used it more than anyone else and pretty much tested it for public use.
here is a list of things created by the military http://military.discovery.com/tv/backya ... p-ten.html
- Maxrebo
- Journeyman

- Posts: 285
- Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2009 8:04 pm
- ES Games: Arena-Beaten,Daggerfall-Beaten,Battlespire-beaten,Redguard-Still haven't Beaten,Morrowind GOTY-beaten,OblivionGOTY-beaten,Skyrim and its DLC Xbox360-Beaten,ESO-Beaten except DLC(PS4)
- Platform: PC,PS4,Xbox One
- Location: Rhode Island
Re: History
Going back to the orignal topic my favorite areas of history are egyptian,greek,roman,other middle eastern powers,india,chinese,japanese,european history all together,american with out right wing propganda, and most of all japanese.
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
Re: History
On Pax Romana: "Despite the term, the period was not without armed conflict, as Emperors frequently had to quell rebellions. Additionally, both border skirmishes and Roman wars of conquest happened during this period. Trajan embarked on a series of campaigns against the Parthians during his reign and Marcus Aurelius spent almost the entire last decade of his rule fighting against the Germanic tribes."
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
i hate it when i forget facts like those 8DThe Most Unholy wrote:On Pax Romana: "Despite the term, the period was not without armed conflict, as Emperors frequently had to quell rebellions. Additionally, both border skirmishes and Roman wars of conquest happened during this period. Trajan embarked on a series of campaigns against the Parthians during his reign and Marcus Aurelius spent almost the entire last decade of his rule fighting against the Germanic tribes."
heck, it was Buddhist monks that invented kung fu and even created ninjas in japan.
war is everywhere.
- The Most Unholy
- Warder

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
- Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics
Re: History
Did you know a battle was the reason for Rome's survival over the long period it lasted? Battle of teutoburg forest, ladies and gents. Kept the Roman empire from too heavily overextending it's borders, and saved it from further disasters.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
- Dark Lord Cam
- Warder

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
- Status: Watching. Always Watching.
Re: History
for a while <.<The Most Unholy wrote:Did you know a battle was the reason for Rome's survival over the long period it lasted? Battle of teutoburg forest, ladies and gents. Kept the Roman empire from too heavily overextending it's borders, and saved it from further disasters.
- Dragour
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1846
- Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2009 6:43 am
- ES Games: Morrowind GOTY (1), Oblivion GOTY (2), Skyrim (3)
- Platform: Pc (1), Xbox 360 (2, 3)
- Location: New Zealand
Re: History
To start a new debate (a clean controlled argument) which subject shall be touch... select a region of the world, a time period and we shall go from there!

