Repair hammer observation

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
User avatar
Flairinsich
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun May 24, 2009 3:52 am
ES Games: Morrowind and Oblivion
Platform: Pc and Xbox360
Status: im a dude
Location: Trollin the dungeon
Contact:

Post by Flairinsich »

But what he is saying is that when he went fast the hammers broke faster or meaning less hits per hammer but when he went slower he got more hits per hammer.
If somethign doesn't look right look at it again.

But if you do that you waste more of you life.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

Flairinsich wrote:But what he is saying is that when he went fast the hammers broke faster or meaning less hits per hammer but when he went slower he got more hits per hammer.
But how do we know that when can't provide the number of strikes? He could have made 32 strikes and lost 4 hammers he could also have made 67 strikes with 6.

Meaning the test has failed to provide.
Silkysmooth
Novice
Novice
Posts: 70
Joined: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:08 pm
Contact:

Post by Silkysmooth »

Kestral wrote:
Flairinsich wrote:But what he is saying is that when he went fast the hammers broke faster or meaning less hits per hammer but when he went slower he got more hits per hammer.
But how do we know that when can't provide the number of strikes? He could have made 32 strikes and lost 4 hammers he could also have made 67 strikes with 6.

Meaning the test has failed to provide.
Because no matter which method you are using it takes the same number of strikes to fully repair the same armor that has been damaged the same amount if in both cases your armorer is exactly the same.

if you have a sword that's damaged and has 50 percent of its health. Lets say at level 50 armorer it takes 10 strikes to fix it. No matter how many hammers he breaks no matter if he goes slow or fast that sword will always need ten strikes to fix from 50 percent health at level 50.

During then ten strikes he can break up to 10 hammers. 1 hammer per strike although that is highly unlikely. The hammer has no predetermined number of strikes in it before it breaks. Every time you strike you have a chance of breaking a hammer, that chance is determined mainly by your luck and armorer levels. With the same number of starting hammers and same equipment that needed the same number of strikes to fix and with the same stats, theoretically if the speed you strike the hammers doesn't weigh in to your chance of breaking the hammers than after using both methods you should have roughly the same amount of hammers to end. Since there was a big difference between the number of hammers left over after the same amount of strikes on the same gear with the same levels, it shows that the speed you strike does indeed play a factor in your chances of breaking a hammer.

But because their are other factors involved, repeat trials should be done and only then with consistent results would my theory be proven correct. His test only worked once which could have been luck.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

As I said, the test is still wrong.

He did not press the "A" button or "X" or left click the same amount of times. So, we cannot know how much. And, where is that proof to your statement?

I never said hammers had a number of strikes to them.
Silkysmooth
Novice
Novice
Posts: 70
Joined: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:08 pm
Contact:

Post by Silkysmooth »

From wiki on armorer
Your armorer skill level controls how many health points of damage you fix each time you use the skill:

Health_Repaired = Armorer_Skill + 3

This is the number of health points, not the percentage of damage, that is repaired. See Weapons and Armor for details on the total health of individual items, which allows conversion between health points and percentage.


There is a set amount of health repaired by each strike. If he was repairing the same exact gear two different times, both times would have yielding him pressing the A button or X or left click the exact same amount of times. Everything above is the control. The independent variable would be the speed of his clicking or pressing. The dependent variable would be the number of times the hammer breaks
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

Silkysmooth wrote:From wiki on armorer
Your armorer skill level controls how many health points of damage you fix each time you use the skill:

Health_Repaired = Armorer_Skill + 3

This is the number of health points, not the percentage of damage, that is repaired. See Weapons and Armor for details on the total health of individual items, which allows conversion between health points and percentage.


There is a set amount of health repaired by each strike. If he was repairing the same exact gear two different times, both times would have yielding him pressing the A button or X or left click the exact same amount of times. Everything above is the control. The independent variable would be the speed of his clicking or pressing. The dependent variable would be the number of times the hammer breaks
That still proves nothing, I never said that there was a fixed amount that how much health a hammer repairs. The problem is that we do not know how many times he pressed the button/clicked. Because of this, the test has failed. It's moot. Kaput. The number of press/clicks has to be the same before we can recognize it as proof. The speed has nothing to do with it.
Silkysmooth
Novice
Novice
Posts: 70
Joined: Sun Jun 07, 2009 7:08 pm
Contact:

Post by Silkysmooth »

IF he repaired the same set of gear to full health two different times both would require the same amount of pushes or clicks
User avatar
Darkheart
Novice
Novice
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2009 1:49 am

Post by Darkheart »

Argh, why is this such a problem?

If he broke six hammers with 67 strikes, then 67 strikes is what it would take to get the same piece of equipment up to full health. If he broke 4 hammers the second time, then he had to get 67 strikes in in order to break those 4 hammers.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

To settle this, I've found the setting that controls the repair menu.

It shows how much is repaired by your skill, breaking, etc. But, there is nothing in this script that says anything about quick multiple hammer strikes. There is nothing seemingly related to this, so, this ends this debate with proof from the Construction Set on a Vanilla Oblivion.esm file.

The repetition, and speed, in which you use repair hammers, has no effect, whatsoever.
User avatar
Flairinsich
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun May 24, 2009 3:52 am
ES Games: Morrowind and Oblivion
Platform: Pc and Xbox360
Status: im a dude
Location: Trollin the dungeon
Contact:

Post by Flairinsich »

well maybe it dose kinda like an Easter egg where its there but nothing in there says anything about it so it could be an easter egg but it also depends how many times he repeated the test if he did it lets say about 5 or 6 times and the results came pretty close it just might mean there might be something behind all of this.
If somethign doesn't look right look at it again.

But if you do that you waste more of you life.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

Flairinsich wrote:well maybe it dose kinda like an Easter egg where its there but nothing in there says anything about it so it could be an easter egg but it also depends how many times he repeated the test if he did it lets say about 5 or 6 times and the results came pretty close it just might mean there might be something behind all of this.
So you're saying that; there's an Easter egg in the files in which there's a feature not even scripted?
User avatar
Dragour
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1846
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2009 6:43 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY (1), Oblivion GOTY (2), Skyrim (3)
Platform: Pc (1), Xbox 360 (2, 3)
Location: New Zealand

Post by Dragour »

Kestral wrote:
Flairinsich wrote:well maybe it dose kinda like an Easter egg where its there but nothing in there says anything about it so it could be an easter egg but it also depends how many times he repeated the test if he did it lets say about 5 or 6 times and the results came pretty close it just might mean there might be something behind all of this.
So you're saying that; there's an Easter egg in the files in which there's a feature not even scripted?

Ok well I have heard some crazy things before, but no this ones deserves the trophy for first place :o
Image
User avatar
Flairinsich
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun May 24, 2009 3:52 am
ES Games: Morrowind and Oblivion
Platform: Pc and Xbox360
Status: im a dude
Location: Trollin the dungeon
Contact:

Post by Flairinsich »

Kestral wrote:
Flairinsich wrote:well maybe it dose kinda like an Easter egg where its there but nothing in there says anything about it so it could be an easter egg but it also depends how many times he repeated the test if he did it lets say about 5 or 6 times and the results came pretty close it just might mean there might be something behind all of this.
So you're saying that; there's an Easter egg in the files in which there's a feature not even scripted?
That could be,i mean they do it all the time in console games why not on PC.
If somethign doesn't look right look at it again.

But if you do that you waste more of you life.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

Flairinsich wrote:
Kestral wrote:
Flairinsich wrote:well maybe it dose kinda like an Easter egg where its there but nothing in there says anything about it so it could be an easter egg but it also depends how many times he repeated the test if he did it lets say about 5 or 6 times and the results came pretty close it just might mean there might be something behind all of this.
So you're saying that; there's an Easter egg in the files in which there's a feature not even scripted?
That could be,i mean they do it all the time in console games why not on PC.
For a feature to exist, it needs to be scripted. The Console versions and the PC version barely differ, except for a few things. (Like settings to get the platform being run on, the type of controls, etc.) I believe that there is a developer's console (~ additem F 999, stuff) on the console versions, but we can't access it.
User avatar
Flairinsich
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun May 24, 2009 3:52 am
ES Games: Morrowind and Oblivion
Platform: Pc and Xbox360
Status: im a dude
Location: Trollin the dungeon
Contact:

Post by Flairinsich »

well if its not that then what is it.Do you have your own reason why his test worked out.
If somethign doesn't look right look at it again.

But if you do that you waste more of you life.
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

Flairinsich wrote:well if its not that then what is it.Do you have your own reason why his test worked out.
The test didn't prove anything.
I've gone into the game itself and looked at it. There was nothing regarding the frequency of the uses of hammers. Plain and simple. So, there is nothing to further prove, or refute, if it's in the Vanilla game, why try to refute it in the first place?
User avatar
Aces Andre
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:17 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Location: Norway

Post by Aces Andre »

Just to point out the very obvious: The test, while valid, needs to run a huge amount of times to establish a trend. One test of this nature is considered insufficient data and can be put down as a chance/random occurrence.

Personally I believe what Kestral says, seeing as there would have to be scripting for any effect like this to work.
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Post by Dark Spark »

It would be a question of whether or not a rapidly delivered set of inputs accesses the same dice roll to qualify an event, which hinges on the issue of the frequency of a dice roll.
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Aces Andre
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 9:17 pm
ES Games: Oblivion
Platform: PC
Location: Norway

Post by Aces Andre »

Dark Spark wrote:It would be a question of whether or not a rapidly delivered set of inputs accesses the same dice roll to qualify an event, which hinges on the issue of the frequency of a dice roll.
This just jumped way beyond my understanding :P

Surely they would have ensured the use of a separate dice roll per strike with a hammer? And if it could use the same dice roll because of speed, surely a human being can't push the button faster than a computer can make a dice roll calculation?
urthdigger
Master
Master
Posts: 1086
Joined: Wed Aug 20, 2008 2:21 pm

Post by urthdigger »

Well, a dice roll calculation isn't truly random, but rather an algorithm to determine a seemingly random number by processing a given seed value. Typically this is done using the system clock, whose values change faster than one could request dice rolls. Though, if instead of using the smallest increment of time, it instead used the time as displayed, i.e. down to the seconds, or any other value that could conceivably be changed less often than a button could be pressed, then conceivably it would cause it to generate the same value every single time. However, just about anything that uses random values in a computer uses the system time or other similarly rapid changing value.

So, in short, technically possible, but you'd have to be a retard to code it that way.
“Fine day” said the young man.

“Gods!” hollered Zaki, sending the young man flying with a well-placed punch, and dashing away.
Image
User avatar
Kaelan Corvinus
Master
Master
Posts: 1152
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:11 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Creeping into your bedroom when you are sleeping, just to taste your blood.

Post by Kaelan Corvinus »

In true meaning, nothing man-made can ever be truly Random, by its definition.

Random means no set scale with no set number value.

No computer can truly process this equation, because Random has too much uncontrolled uncertainity in it.

For anything to be scripted by a computer or anything man-made, it must first understand the concept of Infinity, or no end.

For a computer, this concept is as foreign as the concept of emotion.

The uncertainty factor, if you will.

For a computer to script a truly random number, it would have to be able to compute the equation of Infinity x Infinity.
No computer can TRULY do this.
All computers have to have an equation with certain numbers to go by.
These numbers are usually so large that it seems to be a Random generation to the naked eye.

The point of all of this is to show that computers, no matter how powerful, cannot generate a TRULY Random number.

If they could, then you would be walking into the territory of AI.

Which at this point in time, is not possible.

Thank God for that! Any of you guys ever seen the Terminator movies.
:lol:
--Earth! That's right! I liked Earth. Got these boots on Earth. Listen, don't tell the girl about what happened, cause if you do...I'll tear out your speen! Thanks, buddy...like those jammys!--
President of the Galaxy
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

i have tested it now on the 360, it does seem to work better when you go slower.

I used two sets of 50 hammers on the same character reloaded, and again with two separate 50 hammer characters with different repair skills (on 2 separate saves). The character with the lesser repair skill used the 'slow' method.
Luckily many of my mid- to high-level characters have collected repair hammers. My equipment was damaged to zero by attacking and then ignoring summoned 120 second duration seducers and flesh atronarchs, and 60 sec saints, as well as miscellaneous summoned creatures. I'm sure spells and items can be used to destroy armour but i wanted to do this with physical damage.
The two sets of results suggest hammers behave the same no matter which character you use, although the higher your repair skill the greater the amount repaired by each ding with the hammer and the less repair fails. My identical save characters have 90 repair, the second quick test has 80 and the second slow test has 55 repair.
Damaging all of the equipment took ages, repairing tests were relatively painless.
'Slow' was 1 hit per second, fast was spamming as fast as possible, or 4-5 times a second when my finger got tired. With the fast method I didn't notice a difference between the spamming rate and the 5 per second rate, but as dark spark suggests there might be one or many thresholds of input delivery qualification and ascertaining what they are is well beyond my capability.
There was no pause in the repair test once started, luckily i had enough broken equipment and all hammers were used up even with the 125% perk for experts.

The same character results were around 43% better on the slow count and around 29% better for the different characters (the average brought down by the character with the lesser repair skill but still better than expected).
All test groups of hammers had 'good runs' where they did a lot of repairing for no breakages, and 'bad runs' where they broke consecutively, but the slow method was noticeably more effective. The 55 repair could only go to 100% repair, but the others could repair to 125%.

But really the only way to definitively test this would be with thousands of hammers, but i don't think anyone would think this issue that important.

would they..

:discouraging frown:

I think the developers may have put this in to increase immersion. Blacksmithing is a job done with a steady, rhythmic motion, not by frantically walloping things.
They also put 'realistic' delays in other parts of the game, eg the casting of spells from magic items (in Morrowind this was very rapid fire) and the speed of weapon strikes to a lesser extent. :)
User avatar
Kaelan Corvinus
Master
Master
Posts: 1152
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:11 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Creeping into your bedroom when you are sleeping, just to taste your blood.

Post by Kaelan Corvinus »

Thank you, Mattbot.

Now, if you try to convince Kestral of this, good luck to you.
He won't take anything or anyone on faith or their word, which is sad when you think about it.
--Earth! That's right! I liked Earth. Got these boots on Earth. Listen, don't tell the girl about what happened, cause if you do...I'll tear out your speen! Thanks, buddy...like those jammys!--
President of the Galaxy
User avatar
Symmachus
Warder
Warder
Posts: 494
Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 2:29 pm

Post by Symmachus »

wow... i would never think of doing that.

course my characters all either dont use armour or pay to get it fixed, so i never questioned the skill like that. its quite interesting.
@Zachariel009 in Elder Scrolls Online, PC NA. My primary house is open to the public!
User avatar
Kaelan Corvinus
Master
Master
Posts: 1152
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:11 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Creeping into your bedroom when you are sleeping, just to taste your blood.

Post by Kaelan Corvinus »

Here's my final take on this issue.

If you think that going slower when repairing helps you out, then by all means, no one has the right to tell you not to do it.

If you think it doesnt matter then, by all means, it shouldn't matter.

Personally though, ever since my little experiment with the hammers, Ive been going slow on using the hammers, and I know that it works for me, because Im buying less hammers.

But whatever melts you butter is fine by me.

There. Done.
--Earth! That's right! I liked Earth. Got these boots on Earth. Listen, don't tell the girl about what happened, cause if you do...I'll tear out your speen! Thanks, buddy...like those jammys!--
President of the Galaxy
Locked