I am currently working on the above mentioned quest. I have already collected all the required ingredients and I am working on collecting the creatures. Now here is the problem I am a Lvl 30 and my mysticism is at 25. I bought the command creature up to lvl 2 for 30 seconds and when I try to get the bailwog to follow me the spell has no effect. Can anyone tell me why the spell isn't working, when that is the spell she recommends for the first creature?.
(this ought to be posted in the Oblivion Forum, don't worry, a mod will move it)
I don't have shivering isles, but I should think that the Baliwog that you mention is higher than level 2.
You'll need to train mysticism and get a better spell.
Isn't command creature an illusion spell? Any who the baliwog is almost definitely higher then level two and you have to factor in spell effectiveness as well.
Edit: Checked the wiki, a Venomous Baliwog which would be what you would face at your level is level 9 so you do indeed need a stronger spell.