Immortal NPC wrote:I'm pretty sure, (don't hold me to it though) that if you just stand there and do nothing, letting him paralyze you-- he tries to cast a worm thrall spell, which is counteracted by the colossal soul gem. BUT, if you start attacking him before he casts the spell (like a smart person) you can kill him without using the gem and cause Traven to die in vain (should've just trusted you to kill him anyway... jerk. lol)
No, I did it without the Colossal Black Soul Gem, and he tried to cast the Worm Thrall-spell but nothing happened. So it doesn't matter at all if you have taken the gem or not. There's just the repercussions that if you don't take it it'll disappear with Traven's body, if you take it it'll remain in your inventory forever.