mage vs warrior vs sneak
- GoatLiver
- Warder

- Posts: 554
- Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
- ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: PC
- Contact:
I've just read through this thread and I think that it is a bit one sided towards the mage. Heres my two cents (I'm new here so go easy) One thing I noticed would be that when you fortify a skill in oblivion you don't get the associated mastery perk that goes with that skill making it less useful than someone who actually has master level of that skill. Also people seem to think the mage has a very fast rate of fire (it sounds like its instant from reading other posts) but I've noticed that it takes a while to cast multiple spells.
In a fight between a mage and a warrior (as described in previous posts) I think the warrior would win, my reasons are as follows:
The fights described in previous posts give an unfair advantage to certain types, for example
I guess what I'm trying to say is that without using any skills from other classes at all the warrior is the strongest at combat, afterall he is the one designed for combat.
Sorry to drag on but another post on pg 7 also by Josjie had the stats of all three classes at level 10, but they were fairly inacurate as all classes had all their major skills at 100 which means they are all much higher than level 10. This does make a big difference to the fight as it would determine the health of each contender. For example at level 10 a warrior who started from level 1 with 65 endurance would have 100 endurance by level 7 and at lvl 10 would have 288hp (by my calculations, I hope they are right). However a mage starting with 40 endurance not being able to get more than a plus 1 boost to endurance through skill usage and probably not even taking this becasue he boosts his willpower and intelligence, would have only 116hp - less than half.
Ok I'll leave it there for now, not trying to upset anyone (especally you josjie, I only quoted you so many times because you seem to have made the most arguments for the mage.) just hoping I can shed light on a different point of view or something that you hadn't yet considered.
PS as for the stealth I think they are the weakest and would loose the battle but one of their strengths is that they are designed to be able to avoid a battle when they are out matched.
In a fight between a mage and a warrior (as described in previous posts) I think the warrior would win, my reasons are as follows:
The fights described in previous posts give an unfair advantage to certain types, for example
I think a fair fight would requre all classes to use only there major skills (not able to do anything that would earn them experience towards a skill that isn't a major skill) so this would mean no athletics for the mage, the mage can still walk but running is using athletics so would not be allowed for the mage. If the mage can't win without using athletics then he is weaker in my mind.josjie wrote:Rules:
- They are only allowed to use their major skills (except athletics), so their minor skills are still at 5
This particular strategy relies heavly on athletics which is a warrior skill only - boosting your speed and athletics is a magical effect but using that skill is still a warriors skill.josjie wrote:MAGE vs. WARRIOR
Mage will win because the Warrior has no ranged attacks.
Mage outruns the Warrior by boosting his Speed stats.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that without using any skills from other classes at all the warrior is the strongest at combat, afterall he is the one designed for combat.
My understanding of this would be that using/drinking a poison/potion gives you no experience towards alchemy therefore only the creation of a potion or eating a raw alchemy ingredient would be reseved for the mage.josjie wrote: The warrior/thief are not allowed to use potions/poisons, because alchemy is not their major skill.
Sorry to drag on but another post on pg 7 also by Josjie had the stats of all three classes at level 10, but they were fairly inacurate as all classes had all their major skills at 100 which means they are all much higher than level 10. This does make a big difference to the fight as it would determine the health of each contender. For example at level 10 a warrior who started from level 1 with 65 endurance would have 100 endurance by level 7 and at lvl 10 would have 288hp (by my calculations, I hope they are right). However a mage starting with 40 endurance not being able to get more than a plus 1 boost to endurance through skill usage and probably not even taking this becasue he boosts his willpower and intelligence, would have only 116hp - less than half.
Ok I'll leave it there for now, not trying to upset anyone (especally you josjie, I only quoted you so many times because you seem to have made the most arguments for the mage.) just hoping I can shed light on a different point of view or something that you hadn't yet considered.
PS as for the stealth I think they are the weakest and would loose the battle but one of their strengths is that they are designed to be able to avoid a battle when they are out matched.
If your on PC this MIGHT apply (thought it seems kind of ridiculus) but on console you cant walkGoatLiver wrote:I think a fair fight would requre all classes to use only there major skills (not able to do anything that would earn them experience towards a skill that isn't a major skill) so this would mean no athletics for the mage, the mage can still walk but running is using athletics so would not be allowed for the mage. If the mage can't win without using athletics then he is weaker in my mind.josjie wrote:Rules:
- They are only allowed to use their major skills (except athletics), so their minor skills are still at 5
But overall that was great post, just thought id mention a few things
@Liver:
The biggest problem I see with your argument is that you're drastically restricting the mage class in preference to the warrior. If you say you just absolutely can't use any non-mage skills, it's like telling the mage to fight with his hands tied. It's also a bit ridiculous to say he can't even run. Mage or not, a mage is going to run, there's no reason he couldn't/shouldn't logically aside from how Bethesda set up skill sets. Besides, athletics isn't really a combat skill and isn't going to give any drastic edge over any other class.
This also restricts the mage in that a large selection of spells suddenly become off limits. Why be able to cast a Fortify Blade spell if you aren't allowed to use blade? However, even given that limit I'm pretty confident that a skilled mage could take on a warrior. Their weapons won't be that good if they're destroyed with a spell or if their choice weapon skill is suddenly drained to 0.
As for casting speed, it's not instant at all, however it's a lot faster than anything else. The only really comparable skill would be marksman which requires you to pull out your bow then knock an arrow. With magic you just hit the button and the spell is on it's way. Given a simple "wild west" scenario the mage would "outdraw" the archer any day.
The biggest problem I see with your argument is that you're drastically restricting the mage class in preference to the warrior. If you say you just absolutely can't use any non-mage skills, it's like telling the mage to fight with his hands tied. It's also a bit ridiculous to say he can't even run. Mage or not, a mage is going to run, there's no reason he couldn't/shouldn't logically aside from how Bethesda set up skill sets. Besides, athletics isn't really a combat skill and isn't going to give any drastic edge over any other class.
This also restricts the mage in that a large selection of spells suddenly become off limits. Why be able to cast a Fortify Blade spell if you aren't allowed to use blade? However, even given that limit I'm pretty confident that a skilled mage could take on a warrior. Their weapons won't be that good if they're destroyed with a spell or if their choice weapon skill is suddenly drained to 0.
As for casting speed, it's not instant at all, however it's a lot faster than anything else. The only really comparable skill would be marksman which requires you to pull out your bow then knock an arrow. With magic you just hit the button and the spell is on it's way. Given a simple "wild west" scenario the mage would "outdraw" the archer any day.
- Josjie
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1749
- Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
- Platform: PC
- UESPoints: 500
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
@GoatLiver,
You don't upset me
especially because I've got an answer ready.
Behold...
And what about running while sneaking?
Athletics does say something about your movement speed, but so does Speed. Athletics governs fatigue regeneration, which means that the Warrior can regenerate his fatigue quicker because his Athletics skill is higher.
Your fatigue also decreases from attacking. Based on your argument, the mage and thief wouldn't be allowed to attack because that would decrease their fatigue, which is bound to the Athletics skill.
The reason that I said: "The Mage/Thief are allowed to use Athletics", is because their Athletics skill will increase during this battle. Although it'll only be like 7-8 at the end of the battle, while the Warrior has a 100 Athletics skill.
After a Thief has done his sneak attack, he must escape (sneak away) and prepare another attack. But the Warrior can constantly attack with his sword/warhammer.
Again, the most important effect of Athletics is your Fatigue regeneration rate. The Mage can boost his Speed attribute to 100, leave his Athletics skill at 5 and still outrun the Warrior.
Now, you say that the Warrior and Thief are allowed to use potions/eating raw ingredients, even though Alchemy is a skill from the mage class.
But I presumed that they don't go to sleep so they won't level up after level 10.
Having a level 40 Warrior, Mage and Thief fighting each other would be urnealistic and unfair, because a level 40 character has also raised other attributes/skills. And the Warrior gets more advantages after level 10 than the Mage/Thief (because his Endurance attribute is higher).

You don't upset me
Behold...
Athletics isn't the same as using your ability to run. Every character can run, and it would be unfair to say that the Thief is not allowed to run. This would mean that the Thief has 100 Speed, but he's not allowed to run. That's just... stupid.he fights described in previous posts give an unfair advantage to certain types, for example
josjie wrote:
Rules:
- They are only allowed to use their major skills (except athletics), so their minor skills are still at 5
I think a fair fight would requre all classes to use only there major skills (not able to do anything that would earn them experience towards a skill that isn't a major skill) so this would mean no athletics for the mage, the mage can still walk but running is using athletics so would not be allowed for the mage. If the mage can't win without using athletics then he is weaker in my mind.
And what about running while sneaking?
Athletics does say something about your movement speed, but so does Speed. Athletics governs fatigue regeneration, which means that the Warrior can regenerate his fatigue quicker because his Athletics skill is higher.
Your fatigue also decreases from attacking. Based on your argument, the mage and thief wouldn't be allowed to attack because that would decrease their fatigue, which is bound to the Athletics skill.
The reason that I said: "The Mage/Thief are allowed to use Athletics", is because their Athletics skill will increase during this battle. Although it'll only be like 7-8 at the end of the battle, while the Warrior has a 100 Athletics skill.
It depends what you use as a description for "combat". But the Thief is better at dealing out damage than the Warrior. The Thief can do a stealth attack with x6 damage. The Warrior is more designed for taking damage (he has much health) and dealing out damage over a longer time.josjie wrote:
MAGE vs. WARRIOR
Mage will win because the Warrior has no ranged attacks.
Mage outruns the Warrior by boosting his Speed stats.
This particular strategy relies heavly on athletics which is a warrior skill only - boosting your speed and athletics is a magical effect but using that skill is still a warriors skill.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that without using any skills from other classes at all the warrior is the strongest at combat, afterall he is the one designed for combat.
After a Thief has done his sneak attack, he must escape (sneak away) and prepare another attack. But the Warrior can constantly attack with his sword/warhammer.
Again, the most important effect of Athletics is your Fatigue regeneration rate. The Mage can boost his Speed attribute to 100, leave his Athletics skill at 5 and still outrun the Warrior.
First, you say that the Mage/Thief may not run because Athletics is a skill that only the Warrior has and may use.josjie wrote:
The warrior/thief are not allowed to use potions/poisons, because alchemy is not their major skill.
My understanding of this would be that using/drinking a poison/potion gives you no experience towards alchemy therefore only the creation of a potion or eating a raw alchemy ingredient would be reseved for the mage.
Now, you say that the Warrior and Thief are allowed to use potions/eating raw ingredients, even though Alchemy is a skill from the mage class.
Their skills are all at 100 because that makes a more fair fight.orry to drag on but another post on pg 7 also by Josjie had the stats of all three classes at level 10, but they were fairly inacurate as all classes had all their major skills at 100 which means they are all much higher than level 10. This does make a big difference to the fight as it would determine the health of each contender. For example at level 10 a warrior who started from level 1 with 65 endurance would have 100 endurance by level 7 and at lvl 10 would have 288hp (by my calculations, I hope they are right). However a mage starting with 40 endurance not being able to get more than a plus 1 boost to endurance through skill usage and probably not even taking this becasue he boosts his willpower and intelligence, would have only 116hp - less than half.
But I presumed that they don't go to sleep so they won't level up after level 10.
Having a level 40 Warrior, Mage and Thief fighting each other would be urnealistic and unfair, because a level 40 character has also raised other attributes/skills. And the Warrior gets more advantages after level 10 than the Mage/Thief (because his Endurance attribute is higher).
Hold block while castingAlso people seem to think the mage has a very fast rate of fire (it sounds like its instant from reading other posts) but I've noticed that it takes a while to cast multiple spells.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
- AzNmamba
- Novice

- Posts: 76
- Joined: Sat Apr 04, 2009 8:29 pm
- ES Games: Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: PS3
- Location: Garden Grove, California, USA
but, then how do thieves and warriors restore their health? they already can't use restore health spells, but now they cant even use restore health potions?there is something called: a store (OMG!)josjie wrote:
The warrior/thief are not allowed to use potions/poisons, because alchemy is not their major skill.
First, you say that the Mage/Thief may not run because Athletics is a skill that only the Warrior has and may use.
Now, you say that the Warrior and Thief are allowed to use potions/eating raw ingredients, even though Alchemy is a skill from the mage class
- Josjie
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1749
- Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
- Platform: PC
- UESPoints: 500
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Forgot to say that 
If Mages and Thieves are allowed to run, I think it is fair to say that Thieves and Warriors are allowed to eat raw ingredients and use potions/poisons. Mages still have an advantage over them regarding Alchemy because their ingredients will have more effects and they can create (stronger) potions.
I think we now got a fair situation.
And I still think that the Mage will win. He simply unequips every weapon he has, blocks with his fists, and then casts spells. Casting spells while blocking is much faster.
So you can cast fireballs and shockwaves at a very high speed at your enemy.
Mage will defeat Warrior because the Warrior has no ranged attack.
Mage will defeat Thief because the ranged attack of the Mage is quicker.
If Mages and Thieves are allowed to run, I think it is fair to say that Thieves and Warriors are allowed to eat raw ingredients and use potions/poisons. Mages still have an advantage over them regarding Alchemy because their ingredients will have more effects and they can create (stronger) potions.
I think we now got a fair situation.
And I still think that the Mage will win. He simply unequips every weapon he has, blocks with his fists, and then casts spells. Casting spells while blocking is much faster.
So you can cast fireballs and shockwaves at a very high speed at your enemy.
Mage will defeat Warrior because the Warrior has no ranged attack.
Mage will defeat Thief because the ranged attack of the Mage is quicker.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
I think were all forgetting one of the mages best skills, illusion. He can turn invisible and pop up behind you with a strong destruction touch spell with a paralyze spell. for example shock damage 100pts 1 sec on touch / paralyze 1 sec on touch
just repeateadly cast this ands there nothing the oppenent can do.
just repeateadly cast this ands there nothing the oppenent can do.
- Josjie
- Grand Master

- Posts: 1749
- Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
- ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
- Platform: PC
- UESPoints: 500
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
And the Mage can use Alteration to get the same armor rating as the Warrior.
or use Restoration to increase any of his attributes/skills/resistances.
or use Mysticism to see where his enemy is (Detect Life).
or use Illusion to turn invisible.
or use Destruction for powerful spells.
or create powerful potions/poisons.
or use Restoration to increase any of his attributes/skills/resistances.
or use Mysticism to see where his enemy is (Detect Life).
or use Illusion to turn invisible.
or use Destruction for powerful spells.
or create powerful potions/poisons.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
- Blue the Thief
- Warder

- Posts: 559
- Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 5:43 am
- ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena
- Platform: Xbox 360, and I may be getting a PC soon
- Status: Injecting my eyes with weapons-grade adorableness
- Location: "I come from a land down under, Where beer does flow and men chunder"
- GoatLiver
- Warder

- Posts: 554
- Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
- ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: PC
- Contact:
Ok well thats a custom spell right, if your allowing custom stuff in the fight theres no reason the warrior couldn't have his own custom enchanted weapons and armour. The actual process of enchanting requires no magical skills at all and people who cannot enter the arcane university can use the alters in frostcrag spire. I don't think it should be included because then it truns into an argument of who has the best equipment not the best skills. Also when you attack from using invisibility you're nolonger invisible and if by chance were to miss you become vunrable. However relying on someone missing does put you at a huge disadvantage. If the warrior were to complete Malacath's shrine quest he would have the Volendrung weapon which has a paralize effect. When I go into a cave with vampires they usually go invisible but if I just swing wildly I usually have a good chance to hit them.gibson wrote:I think were all forgetting one of the mages best skills, illusion. He can turn invisible and pop up behind you with a strong destruction touch spell with a paralyze spell. for example shock damage 100pts 1 sec on touch / paralyze 1 sec on touch
What I was trying to say about alchemy was that creating a potion uses your alchemy skill, but drinking one doesnot, therefore all classes should be able to drink them in battle but only the mage can bring his custom potions. I don't think saying drinking potions is a fair trade off for full use of athletics skill, which clearly has a different meaning on the console version than the pc version, I didn't realise there was no option for run or walk. If we were allowing all classes the run ability does this mean we also alow all classes the acrobatics ability as they seem to go hand in hand? If so it would seem we were allowing the mage two skills not from his class and no-one can use any skills from the mages class. What about greater and lesser powers for example if a warrior was born under the sign of the lord, can he use the blood of the north power to regenerate 90 points of health whenever he wants, it only costs 50 magika which even a level one orc would have. The battle between the warrior and the mage that you describle would have the mage running backwards away from the warrior shooting fireballs at him (which everyone knows are fairly easy to dodge) but any damage he does could be restored by either potion or lesser power. Were would it end, maybe when they run into a unicorn with 100% resist magic and normal weapons reasonable attack and good speed and they both eventually get killed by it...loljosjie wrote:If Mages and Thieves are allowed to run, I think it is fair to say that Thieves and Warriors are allowed to eat raw ingredients and use potions/poisons. Mages still have an advantage over them regarding Alchemy because their ingredients will have more effects and they can create (stronger) potions.
I think we now got a fair situation.
And I still think that the Mage will win. He simply unequips every weapon he has, blocks with his fists, and then casts spells. Casting spells while blocking is much faster.
So you can cast fireballs and shockwaves at a very high speed at your enemy.
Mage will defeat Warrior because the Warrior has no ranged attack.
Mage will defeat Thief because the ranged attack of the Mage is quicker.
I didn't really like the sneak system in oblivion it seems impossible to actually sneak away and become re-hidden once some one sees you. For Example my character is a wood elf with assassin class and has sneak as a mojor skill, I'm not heaps high level but I was going through the imperial city pick pocketing rich npc's and one of them caught me and I was chased all over the city by the guards. I found that everytime i go around a corner and it was obvious no-one could actually see me, if I tried to go back into sneak mode and hide behind a box or something and wait for the guards to pass, they would run around the corner and just no were I was trying to hide. Even when I ran into the sewers they still followed me and always knew exactly were I was. Hopefully they can make the stealth system in elder scrolls V alot better. That said I think the stealth carachter is only good (in combat) for a one hit kill which he seems to only get against the unsuspecting mage, but the warrior is usually protected by his heavy armor.josjie wrote:It depends what you use as a description for "combat". But the Thief is better at dealing out damage than the Warrior. The Thief can do a stealth attack with x6 damage. The Warrior is more designed for taking damage (he has much health) and dealing out damage over a longer time.
After a Thief has done his sneak attack, he must escape (sneak away) and prepare another attack. But the Warrior can constantly attack with his sword/warhammer.
In terms of answering the original question, mage vs warrior vs sneak who would win? I think it mostly depends on what skill set and usage of skills you allow each to use. If it is solely your skill class and depending on your definition of the athletics and alchemy skills I still lean towards the warrior.
Yeah that is a very valid point but every character in the game also starts with a basic restore health spell and for that matter a basic fire ball spell and there is no reason not to use that in a fight either.Cactus wrote:It's also a bit ridiculous to say he can't even run. Mage or not, a mage is going to run, there's no reason he couldn't/shouldn't logically aside from how Bethesda set up skill sets.
Well that would take a truly skillful mage who has a good understanding of battle and an ability to read the fight and predict what his opponent will do. But if he is matched with a warrior of an equal battle knowledge or experiance then it would not be fair to assume the warrior would just run straight at the mage and not stand back trying to dodge avoid the mages ranged spells. This would eventually lead to a tie and the mage would run after running out of restore magika potions (especially if his birthsign is the atronach) and it would be the warriors turn to chase him.Cactus wrote:However, even given that limit I'm pretty confident that a skilled mage could take on a warrior. Their weapons won't be that good if they're destroyed with a spell or if their choice weapon skill is suddenly drained to 0.
Perhaps we could say that its not so much about the skills you have, but about how you use what you have. I'll give you a lore based example like what you would read in a skill book but made up by me...and with many flaws. Here goes, A master thief and a master warrior are one day engaged in conversation when the warrior makes the claim that he is the greatest warrior ever to have lived can can defeat anyone in battle. The master thief thinks to himself for a minute before saying "Maybe any other warrior but my friend if we were to fight I garentee I would win". The warrior so angered by this outrageous accusation sid to him "Then draw your sword".
"Wait" says the thief, "if two masters like us are going to battle it should be in the arena with hundreds of paying spectators". The warrior laughed and said "Very well if you want to embaress yourself in front of everyone then thats fine with me, this way everyone will know I'm the greatest".
So the match was organised for the next day to take place in the imperial arena first fight in the morning. The warrior went off to practice but the master thief had a plan. That night under the cover of darkness when everyone was asleep he broke into the warriors room and stole all his weapons, armor and gold selling them to a friend in the infamous thieves guild. But he wasn't done there, he was the master thief and so broke into every shop in the city and stole every single piece of armor and every blade, axe and hammer in the whole city selling it all to the thieves giuld for a lot of gold. The next day the warrior awoke to find all his weapons, armor and gold were gone. He raced down to the blacksmith explaining his situation and demanded a weapon but the blacksmith said "Even if you pay me back double I cannot give you a weapon, all mine were stolen last night and it would take days to forge a new blade".
Infriated he made his way to the arena. When it was time to fight he burst out onto the arena battle ground with no weapon and no armor. He looked across the field and saw his opponent the master thief with a shiny new and very expencive looking ebony bow across his shoulders. He shouted out "It doesn't matter I'm going to tear you apart with my own two hands!" The thief smiled and muttered to himself "You won't make it hlafway across the field". So it was and the master warrior lay dead in the middle of the arena with nothing but an arrow sticking from his back. The master thief took his winings and like all great thieves he simply vanished and was never heard from again.
Sorry for writing a small novel and going off topic but I felt it was needed.
The only problem with your logic is everything depends on the warrior getting the first hit and being able to catch the mage. All it takes for the warrior to be down is a paralyze 2 seconds in 10ft spell on target. I agree with you that the warrior could enchant his weapon though.GoatLiver wrote:Ok well thats a custom spell right, if your allowing custom stuff in the fight theres no reason the warrior couldn't have his own custom enchanted weapons and armour. The actual process of enchanting requires no magical skills at all and people who cannot enter the arcane university can use the alters in frostcrag spire. I don't think it should be included because then it truns into an argument of who has the best equipment not the best skills. Also when you attack from using invisibility you're nolonger invisible and if by chance were to miss you become vunrable. However relying on someone missing does put you at a huge disadvantage. If the warrior were to complete Malacath's shrine quest he would have the Volendrung weapon which has a paralize effect. When I go into a cave with vampires they usually go invisible but if I just swing wildly I usually have a good chance to hit them.gibson wrote:I think were all forgetting one of the mages best skills, illusion. He can turn invisible and pop up behind you with a strong destruction touch spell with a paralyze spell. for example shock damage 100pts 1 sec on touch / paralyze 1 sec on touch
They're not mages - they might not know how to.GoatLiver wrote:Yeah that is a very valid point but every character in the game also starts with a basic restore health spell and for that matter a basic fire ball spell and there is no reason not to use that in a fight either.Cactus wrote:It's also a bit ridiculous to say he can't even run. Mage or not, a mage is going to run, there's no reason he couldn't/shouldn't logically aside from how Bethesda set up skill sets.
- GoatLiver
- Warder

- Posts: 554
- Joined: Sun Apr 19, 2009 2:54 am
- ES Games: Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
- Platform: PC
- Contact:
Seriously how much magika would a spell like that cost? and it would require a high illusion skill.gibson wrote:The only problem with your logic is everything depends on the warrior getting the first hit and being able to catch the mage. All it takes for the warrior to be down is a paralyze 2 seconds in 10ft spell on target. I agree with you that the warrior could enchant his weapon though.
What if it were the blood of the north power, then its more like an ability rather than a skill.Yoshi wrote:They're not mages - they might not know how to.
it only costs 42 magicka at 100 illusion, and requires level 75 LOL.GoatLiver wrote:Seriously how much magika would a spell like that cost? and it would require a high illusion skill.gibson wrote:The only problem with your logic is everything depends on the warrior getting the first hit and being able to catch the mage. All it takes for the warrior to be down is a paralyze 2 seconds in 10ft spell on target. I agree with you that the warrior could enchant his weapon though.
Nope, It's a lesser power. You can use it all the time.Yoshi wrote:You can only use Blood of The North once per day.GoatLiver wrote:What if it were the blood of the north power, then its more like an ability rather than a skill.Yoshi wrote:They're not mages - they might not know how to.
Doin my own, thang, and if you got a problem with that
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
Then the nina go bang, bang, and I'll be everywhere on the map - but
I rep that West
I think there are a lot of other factors that aren't being taken into account. What race are we talking about, for example? I mean, an Orc warrior vs Mage isn't as easy for the Mage as a Nord warrior vs Mage. The Orc would be resistant to the magic and take less damage, possibly leading to victory another wouldn't achieve.
As for enchantments, I don't think a warrior SHOULD be able to custom enchant armor. The only way to access enchanting without joining the Mages Guild is Frostcrag and if we're going to be so strict on the classes, I don't think a warrior or thief should have access to it. However, previously enchanted items found in the game would be accessible, I would think. This would mean, tied in with my argument above, that an Orc warrior could easily be completely immune to magic without once stepping in front of an enchanting alter. Not to mention all classes have access to Sigil Stones.
As for enchantments, I don't think a warrior SHOULD be able to custom enchant armor. The only way to access enchanting without joining the Mages Guild is Frostcrag and if we're going to be so strict on the classes, I don't think a warrior or thief should have access to it. However, previously enchanted items found in the game would be accessible, I would think. This would mean, tied in with my argument above, that an Orc warrior could easily be completely immune to magic without once stepping in front of an enchanting alter. Not to mention all classes have access to Sigil Stones.
What else can a warrior do beside run at you.. there to easy to spot when there sneaking.COL1N995 wrote:Why do people keep on completely ruling out warriors??? There are so many types of warrior characters you would need have a fight between them to put in the mage v sneak v warrior. The warriors most of you are thinkin about are the "me want cookie" kind of warriors
Also, the argument is which pure class would win. However, as I said before I think race can have a lot of influence here. Hell, a Breton warrior would fair pretty well against a Mage.COL1N995 wrote:Why do people keep on completely ruling out warriors??? There are so many types of warrior characters you would need have a fight between them to put in the mage v sneak v warrior. The warriors most of you are thinkin about are the "me want cookie" kind of warriors

Ah yes, "Signatures"