mage vs warrior vs sneak

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
Locked

who would win?

Mage
20
40%
Warrior
12
24%
Sneak
18
36%
 
Total votes: 50

The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

The Chad wrote:And moving out of the way isn't an option? Or circling the mage to confuse him and always be at his back attacking?
Ha! The Warrior isn't the bumb brute we think he is...
User avatar
Sanguine
Master
Master
Posts: 1031
Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 4:41 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Daggerfall
Platform: Xbox (Morrowind), PC(Oblivion)

Post by Sanguine »

The Chad wrote:
Sanguine wrote:First off I gave an alternative situation for him to use even without potion were waiting for magicka to regenrate wouldn't be a problem. And once again Mage's staff of Paralysis, stops the fighter dead in his tracks.
And moving out of the way isn't an option? Or circling the mage to confuse him and always be at his back attacking?
Possible but difficult as weapons and armor are heavy.
The Chad
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 172
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 9:40 pm

Post by The Chad »

Sanguine wrote:
The Chad wrote:
Sanguine wrote:First off I gave an alternative situation for him to use even without potion were waiting for magicka to regenrate wouldn't be a problem. And once again Mage's staff of Paralysis, stops the fighter dead in his tracks.
And moving out of the way isn't an option? Or circling the mage to confuse him and always be at his back attacking?
Possible but difficult as weapons and armor are heavy.
Maxed athletics and heavy armor(no encumberance from equipped heavy armor at all) tend to make them faster.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Aha! The Warrior might win!.... I said might. :|

But the Stealthy One is more cunning.
The Chad
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 172
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 9:40 pm

Post by The Chad »

The Ninja wrote:Aha! The Warrior might win!.... I said might. :|

But the Stealthy One is more cunning.
It'll be a tie. There is no clear cut winner. Each have a fair chance of winning.
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Possibly, but one has to win.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Possibly, but one has to win.
Hes saying its all chance/luck
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Maybe, but not likely. Out of all the matches and possibilites, the Mage and Stealthy One will beat he Warrior.
User avatar
Dragour
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1846
Joined: Sun Feb 01, 2009 6:43 am
ES Games: Morrowind GOTY (1), Oblivion GOTY (2), Skyrim (3)
Platform: Pc (1), Xbox 360 (2, 3)
Location: New Zealand

Post by Dragour »

In the end, it was entirely depended on the player which one won, a weak assasin with poor skills can defeat a high level warrior with maxed skills, same for the mage fighting other classes and the warrior fighting other classes, it is only the player's personal skill that counts, same when lock picking manually
Image
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Yes! I rock at picking locks!
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

Omg 13 pages.
It'll be a tie. There is no clear cut winner. Each have a fair chance of winning.
Why? If the Mage, Thief and Warrior are equally skilled and all level 10 and they are only allowed to use their major skills, the Mage will win, as I've said a dozen of times.

And I think it is fair if we create a new rule: only one full equipment set for every character. So no equipment swapping. That's more realistic too.
Maxed athletics and heavy armor(no encumberance from equipped heavy armor at all) tend to make them faster.
The Warrior only has 40 Speed. Athletics doesn't make you faster, it only affects your Fatigue regeneration.
And moving out of the way isn't an option? Or circling the mage to confuse him and always be at his back attacking?
Mage can boost his Speed skill as well / turn invisibile etc.
No, but moving quickly from cover (The columns) to cover when the Mage isn't looking is what I meant.
When he isn't looking? Wtf. Of course he's looking.
First off I gave an alternative situation for him to use even without potion were waiting for magicka to regenrate wouldn't be a problem. And once again Mage's staff of Paralysis, stops the fighter dead in his tracks.
Only the Mage is allowed to use potions. He cannot carry 1000000 of them, that would be unrealistic. But he'll have at least 20 Potions of Sorcery, Healing, Invisibility...
With 100 in hand-to-hand, you bet your arse he is. Sort of
Mage can run away.


The most fair situation for this discussion would be an 1 vs. 1 arena fight in the Imperial City Arena.
The Mage, Thief and Warrior are equally skilled and all level 10.
Rules:
- They are only allowed to use their major skills (except athletics), so their minor skills are still at 5
- They are only allowed to have one equipment set (perhaps 2 for the warrior?), because having 5 different cuirasses with enchantments would be unrealistic.
- The warrior and thief have no access to enchantig altars so they cannot enchant their own equipment. They have acces, though, (just like the mage) to level 10 items. So the thief can wear Mithril and the warrior can pick up items like Umbra armor.
- The warrior/thief are not allowed to use potions/poisons, because alchemy is not their major skill.
- The mage is allowed to turn invisible, but not to sneak.

Warrior has 100 Strength, 100 Endurance and 59 Luck.
Thief has 100 Agility, 100 Speed and 64 Luck.
Mage has 100 Intelligence, 100 Willpower and 59 Luck.
See page 3 or something for a complete lay-out of their attributes and stats (birthsigns...).

MAGE vs. WARRIOR
Mage will win because the Warrior has no ranged attacks.
Mage outruns the Warrior by boosting his Speed stats.

MAGE vs. THIEF
The Thief can only use his bow to attack and can use no poisons. He can sneak and wear equipment that makes him partly invisible.
The Mage will turn invisible, use a detect life spell, summon a creature, boost his health and speed, avoid the arrows the thief shoot at him and spam back fireballs and shockwaves. Those are quicker and stronger than arrows to the Mage will easily win.
The only thing the Thief has are:
Light Armor, Sneak, Marksman and Acrobatics.
So he can jump around (Mage can boost his Acrobatics skill too), sneak (but the Mage will detect him), use his bow (but spells are faster) and wear Light Armor (which the mage can disintegrate).
So the Mage will win.

The Mage is the only character who can boost all his stats/skills/attributes. He's a Mage, Warrior and Thief in one. He can act based on the situation, he has countless of options. And yes, it would be realistic if the Mage has 100 spells. Why not? He has access to the spellmaking altar, so he would be stupid not to create lots of spells.
The Warrior can buy the most expensive equipment and the Thief too.

Again, I prefer the Thief over the Mage, but there's just no denying that the Mage will win in this situation.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

we had this discussion many times when I played D&D. The test was how good these characters were in adventuring situations rather than fighting each other. Cos when you fight each other one on one, who decides the circumstances wherein you meet? A mages fireball can reach a warrior with a bow out in the open, a dark forest can hide a backstabbing thief, the mage is dead as soon as he's toe to toe with the fighter in a small space.

A lot depended on the level of the character. At low level the fighter is best survivor. The thief is second, and mage weakest cos magic is weak at low level.

Mid level, the mage gets some tasty spells, with great damage and very useful applications but the fighter really comes into his own and is still the backbone of the party. The thief is still the weakest in a fight but has tactical uses that can't be replicated.

At high level the thief can kill with a backstab and disappear. But if confronted by someting big will have to withdraw, he's still the weakest in most respects. The fighter can take on armies but his function now is to keep the attention away from the mage who now can summon up humungous death magic. The mage is powerful enough to end any fight straight away but needs the support of the warrriors.

The lesson is, a balanced party includes all three types (you'd get a cleric in there for healing, too). Although the thief is of dubious value 90% of the time, he'll be absolutely vital 10% of the time, so as long as he gets stuck in and doesn't annoy the party, he will be valued. The backbone of the party is always the warrior, but he can be left stranded if a door needs unlocking or a problem arises that only magic can solve. The mage is the special element who needs protecting long enough to do his stuff, which usually swings the balance in the party's favour. However on his own, the mage is lost where the thief and fighter can at least look after themselves in their different ways.

This party analogy can be applied to any Oblivion character. The strange thing about Oblivion, though is that because it's a 1player game and the world is essentially designed for only 1 hero - you - it doesn't matter what type of character you play cos the game is balanced to allow all characters to play. Oblivion characters start off as 40% jack of all trades, and 60% potential for specialism so it's quite difficult to make a character with the strengths and weaknesses of a true specialist (the best i came up with was my magic only no armour or weapons of any sort ever atronarch)

For instance, health depends on you endurance, not your class. A mage can get his endurance up to 100 as quickly as any warrior, which negates a big mage weakness. An oblivion character can have a bit of everything (eg a mage can have a high endurance, wear armour and use a sword and a warrior can be a master spellcaster) to fill in gaps, but the character you decide to play essentially determines the sort of challenges you would like to experience.
At the end of the day, Oblivion is a fighting game, more or less everything you do is based aroung killing things and stealing their loot.

In Oblivion I found that pure mages were the most challenging to play, then sneaky characters, with the warriors being the best survivors.

I suppose if you made up a character with just 1 type of skill (magic or stealth or combat) and never used any from the other two groups (as far as possible) you would have a good indication of which was 'better' for your style. Has anyone else done this yet?
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

I'm going to double post cos that was too long. We can settle this once and for all:

make up a 'truly' specialised character of each type (the only skills to be improved are your 7 major relevant stealth/magic/combat). Then choose a level at which to be tested, I would suggest 15th - 20th level to allow true strengths to develop.
Anyone can use scrolls, enchanted items and found potions. Mages can obviously use their own potions/poisons. Fighters and thieves must avoid using charged items cos they replicate wizard effects, wizards can only use bound weapons and armour. No one can use powers from stones, orrery or other quests although racial stuff is allowed for anyone

Then put your characters through some trials. I suggest these might include:

Umbra defeated (no camping atop any pillars)

The infiltration of the mythic dawn quest, up to you whether you do it with or without equipment. Extra points without, though

Close 5 Oblivion gates, this would be done by locating them first then fast travelling to each as they were closed to avoid wandering monsters

the various daedric quests have a lot of good variety as well

the arena

any more suggestions? Do them on normal difficulty, if your character dies then the trial is over and go onto the next one
User avatar
Blue the Thief
Warder
Warder
Posts: 559
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 5:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena
Platform: Xbox 360, and I may be getting a PC soon
Status: Injecting my eyes with weapons-grade adorableness
Location: "I come from a land down under, Where beer does flow and men chunder"

Post by Blue the Thief »

I remember a ayled ruin with lots of trolls somewhere on the south of the map, could be a nice challege :?

Keeping up with M'Aig on his little jog. :P

Dungon Diving Marathon: no resting, completed when you die. scored by how many dungon's you completed, you can sell loot, but no buying, you can only use what you find. :Twisted Evil: (Done this before, its hard.)

Imperial Legion Masscare: Kill as many Legion guards as you can. no leaving the city, but you can replace you weapons and armour from the bodies of the guards (Or anyone else who trys to be a hero) Starts in the market district.

Goblin war: Get all the totems, set up shop somewhere, and defend. 8)

Thats all I can think of right now.
ImageAh yes, "Signatures"Image
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

Mattbott wrote:I'm going to double post cos that was too long. We can settle this once and for all:

make up a 'truly' specialised character of each type (the only skills to be improved are your 7 major relevant stealth/magic/combat). Then choose a level at which to be tested, I would suggest 15th - 20th level to allow true strengths to develop.
Anyone can use scrolls, enchanted items and found potions. Mages can obviously use their own potions/poisons. Fighters and thieves must avoid using charged items cos they replicate wizard effects, wizards can only use bound weapons and armour. No one can use powers from stones, orrery or other quests although racial stuff is allowed for anyone

Then put your characters through some trials. I suggest these might include:

Umbra defeated (no camping atop any pillars)

The infiltration of the mythic dawn quest, up to you whether you do it with or without equipment. Extra points without, though

Close 5 Oblivion gates, this would be done by locating them first then fast travelling to each as they were closed to avoid wandering monsters

the various daedric quests have a lot of good variety as well

the arena

any more suggestions? Do them on normal difficulty, if your character dies then the trial is over and go onto the next one
Now that's something different. Instead of a battle against each other, you let them do challenges.
But how are you gonna test this out?

And I don't think it is fair. The battle against Umbra might be hard for a Thief, because you don't have much space to run around, it's just a room with one exit.

Same for Oblivion Gates. Warriors can hack&slash themselves through the dark corridors and Oblivion Plane Towers, Mages might have a harder time but can use On Touch spells and Thieves who use a bow are the weakest again.

And, most importantly: how are you gonna test this out and who is gonna do that?
What's the use of it? It's not like the result will be: "Thief is better than the Mage", because it all depends on the situation.
If the Mage stands in a room with no exit and the Thief on a balcony above, the Thief will win.
If the Mage and Thief face off in the IC Arena, the Mage will win.

As you said, Oblivion is a singleplayer game. Even if you create a pure mage character, it won't be a pure mage anymore after a few hours of playing time. You will increase your Athletics and Acrobatics skill, perhaps put some points into Endurance.
And in the end, all level 50 characters with 100+ playing time can use stealth, combat or magic whenever they want.

So I still don't see the use of this thread. If Oblivion would be a MMORPG, ok, but I'm still surprised that this thread has reached over 10 pages.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

finally i think we're nearly at a conclusion to this business, thanks to josjie's last post


i don't really see the point of the argument either, but having experienced it before wanted to put my thruppence in.

No, there is no way to really test this out, it is a pointless argument (not discussion) cos really it is about what type of character you like to play, not which character is actually will 'win'.

This thread reminds me of those 'this race is best' type topics which were all mercilessly hunted down and locked by moderators.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

Mattbott wrote:finally i think we're nearly at a conclusion to this business, thanks to josjie's last post


i don't really see the point of the argument either, but having experienced it before wanted to put my thruppence in.

No, there is no way to really test this out, it is a pointless argument (not discussion) cos really it is about what type of character you like to play, not which character is actually will 'win'.

This thread reminds me of those 'this race is best' type topics which were all mercilessly hunted down and locked by moderators.
Agree 100% :D

Or those topics called "Breton vs. High Elf" which can be found on almost every Oblivion forum on the internet.

To avoid much longer useless discussion, why don't we lock this topic?
"Not all those who wander are lost"
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

josjie wrote:
Maxed athletics and heavy armor(no encumberance from equipped heavy armor at all) tend to make them faster.
The Warrior only has 40 Speed. Athletics doesn't make you faster, it only affects your Fatigue regeneration.
Heck yes it affects your speed!
No, but moving quickly from cover (The columns) to cover when the Mage isn't looking is what I meant.
josjie wrote: When he isn't looking? Wtf. Of course he's looking.
Not when he is turning around constantly trying to find me. :P Just when he looks the other way, I'll switch pillars.
Last edited by The Ninja on Fri Apr 24, 2009 1:18 am, edited 1 time in total.
RestlessChicken
Novice
Novice
Posts: 74
Joined: Sun Apr 05, 2009 4:05 pm

Post by RestlessChicken »

you kids need to get out more.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

The Ninja wrote:
josjie wrote:
Maxed athletics and heavy armor(no encumberance from equipped heavy armor at all) tend to make them faster.
The Warrior only has 40 Speed. Athletics doesn't make you faster, it only affects your Fatigue regeneration.
Heck yes it affects your speed!
No, but moving quickly from cover (The columns) to cover when the Mage isn't looking is what I meant.
josjie wrote: When he isn't looking? Wtf. Of course he's looking.
Not when he is turning around constantly trying to find me. :P Just when he looks the other way, I'll switch pillars.
We really better lock this topic ;)

It'd be a stupid mage if he just turns around trying to find you. A good mage would summon a creature, turn invisible, fortify his speed and health and run around even faster, then cast detect life, appear right behind the thief, use some restore magicka potions and then a very nasty on touch spell.
"Not all those who wander are lost"
User avatar
Blue the Thief
Warder
Warder
Posts: 559
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 5:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena
Platform: Xbox 360, and I may be getting a PC soon
Status: Injecting my eyes with weapons-grade adorableness
Location: "I come from a land down under, Where beer does flow and men chunder"

Post by Blue the Thief »

My Dungon Diving Marathon challenge stands :P

It be a good way to test the differant characters out, if they all did the same dungons.
ImageAh yes, "Signatures"Image
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

Which the ninj- oh, sorry, Stealthy One could dodge quickly or jump away from using Acrobatics.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:Which the ninj- oh, sorry, Stealthy One could dodge quickly or jump away from using Acrobatics.
Stop, for gods sake we all get it, the stealthy one will beat anything and is faster then the speed of light :roll:
The Ninja
Warder
Warder
Posts: 510
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 3:12 am

Post by The Ninja »

No, but IF there is an invisibility spell, the next thing you do cancels it. Therefore allowing the Stealthy One to see and escape and/or try to escape to the best of his being, which I think would be Acrobatics since it is a Stealth skill... And the characters ahve 100 on all their oriented skills.
gibson
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 256
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 4:29 pm

Post by gibson »

The Ninja wrote:No, but IF there is an invisibility spell, the next thing you do cancels it. Therefore allowing the Stealthy One to see and escape and/or try to escape to the best of his being, which I think would be Acrobatics since it is a Stealth skill... And the characters ahve 100 on all their oriented skills.
Ok what about 100% chameleon spell
Locked