Most Unforgivable Crime

Moderator: Tea Party Mods

Which is Unforgivable?

Pre-Meditated Murder
0
No votes
Torture
3
10%
Sexual Assault
2
7%
War Crimes
2
7%
Animal Abusement
2
7%
Sexual Assault of a minor
6
20%
Mass Murder
1
3%
A Combination of Any of the Above
14
47%
 
Total votes: 30

User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

they are all unforgivable unless the victims can forgive (difficult if the only victim is dead). This has happened in some cases though, where the family of murder victims have forgiven the killer.

It's not really about whether I can forgive these crimes, I have never had to deal with them personally so all i have is an opinion based on what i can imagine (I'm not in the position to offer forgiveness unless i have been harmed in some way).
Our social biases make some of the crimes seem worse than others, eg paedophilia is probably the biggest taboo of our age but you could argue that taking someones life away forever might be 'more unforgivable'.

I think every one of these crimes can destroy a life, and that really is the unforgivable part of it.
User avatar
Chaos the N'wah
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1555
Joined: Wed Mar 19, 2008 3:25 am
Status: Always lurking
Location: Tenmar Forest

Post by Chaos the N'wah »

I think in the end the real question to pose is this:
What do you think is worse? taking a life/lives or living a life of prolonged horror
User avatar
crack398
Novice
Novice
Posts: 80
Joined: Sat May 17, 2008 8:16 am
UESPoints: 0
Contact:

Post by crack398 »

leroybrown wrote:
crack398 wrote: [OFF TOPIC]
the 2 smartest animals on earth are
1. Human
2.Pigs, suprised?
I'm pretty sure monkeys are smarter than pigs.
The King wrote:I'm pretty sure dolphins are also smarter than pigs.
scientist measure IQ or how smart an animal is by measuring the size of the brain, the bigger the brain the smarter they are, and pigs have the biggest brains besides humans.

anyway back on topic
ChaosDawn wrote:I think in the end the real question to pose is this:
What do you think is worse? taking a life/lives or living a life of prolonged horror
that is a much clearer question imo
PS3 user--------PSN = crack398

Urge to kill 69%

98% of forumers say fast travel ruins Oblivion. Put this in your signature if you're one of the 2% who realize it's optional.
User avatar
Dark Lord Cam
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
Status: Watching. Always Watching.

Post by Dark Lord Cam »

crack398 wrote: [OFF TOPIC]

The King wrote:I'm pretty sure dolphins are also smarter than pigs.
scientist measure IQ or how smart an animal is by measuring the size of the brain, the bigger the brain the smarter they are, and pigs have the biggest brains besides humans.

anyway back on topic


if it were true then we would be the slaves of whales

NOW BACK ON TOPIC!
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

time to lock this, derailment is confirmed

:?:
User avatar
Blue the Thief
Warder
Warder
Posts: 559
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 5:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena
Platform: Xbox 360, and I may be getting a PC soon
Status: Injecting my eyes with weapons-grade adorableness
Location: "I come from a land down under, Where beer does flow and men chunder"

Post by Blue the Thief »

^I disagree.

I think, that there all as unforgiveable as each other.
ImageAh yes, "Signatures"Image
User avatar
Тeatime
Warder
Warder
Posts: 547
Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 9:01 am
Platform: PC

Post by Тeatime »

All of the above are considered wrong by society, true. At the same time I cannot help but seeing how the people committing these acts could justify several of them. Also, I must disagree with Blue, they're not all unforgivable.

Murder can easily be justified in a scenario where the taking of one or several lives leads to the preservation of a greater number than those lost. It's consequential ethics, the ends justify the means. Is it forgiveable? Yes, if you had the freedom of choice I'd say it's less forgiveable not to kill and hence let more lives be lost. The same scenario is applicable to the question of torture. Principally causing suffering is wrong but when this suffering can prevent a greater suffering it is easy to see how it can be justified.

As for forgiving, who is it really that's supposed to be doing the forgiving? If me, then you'll find that I can be very forgiving. If the person committing the act really believes it's justified and that he's acting morally I could not blame him. Note that I'm not saying it is any less wrong just because I could bring myself to forgive. For the one committing the act to forgive himself that belief of justification must remain firm. If he/she knew it was wrong she/he should not be capable of forgiving him/herself. For the victim to forgive his/her tormentor he would have to possess understanding of whatever justification existed. Without justification in the mind of those committing these acts there can be no forgiving.

As for sexual assault, of any kind, and animal abusiveness I find it hard to think of a scenario where it could be forgiven. Actually, that's a lie. I can think of such far too easily but what's really disturbing is that they're not particularly far-fetched or unrealistic... I probably shouldn't say any more on that subject though.

The points I'm trying to make is that you shouldn't really generalize in these matter. To say that murder is automatically wrong and unforgivable just doesn't work, it can very well be both justified and forgiven. You should never jump to such conclusions without thinking things through though. If you just try to understand the minds behind “wrongs” in our society you just might find that things are a bit more complicated than they'd seem and maybe you'll find that the world is more frightening that you thought but trust me, if you choose to understand it just might bring you a little more peace of mind, something which a lot of people really seem to be lacking these days.

Forgiving really is a strange thing, personally I'd rather forgive than harbour resentment and whatnot. All in all it doesn't have to mean I approve or support what the person has done, I just made the choice.
User avatar
Blue the Thief
Warder
Warder
Posts: 559
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 5:43 am
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena
Platform: Xbox 360, and I may be getting a PC soon
Status: Injecting my eyes with weapons-grade adorableness
Location: "I come from a land down under, Where beer does flow and men chunder"

Post by Blue the Thief »

Fair enough, while I don't agree with much you said, to each his own, I guess.

But, I'm not the "Very forgiving" type, so that might be why.
ImageAh yes, "Signatures"Image
leroybrown
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 201
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 10:59 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: awesome
UESPoints: 14

Post by leroybrown »

Mrs T wrote:*Pure genius text wall*
This is one of those few times i feel completely in sync with what someone posted. You are a genius little missy.
Mrs T wrote: Forgiving really is a strange thing, personally I'd rather forgive than harbour resentment and whatnot.
Id like to say one thing ive discovered about forgiveness. I am probably going to butcher the way i feel about it because ive never been very good with words, but ill try.

I dont necessarily view forgiveness as a matter of right and wrong, that meaning if you choose to forgive someone or not is your choice, there is no right or wrong in that decision. Forgiveness is not about the other person, its about yourself, its almost a selfish decision to forgive somebody if theyve wronged you.

If you do forgive someone youve made the decision to completely drop what ever wrong deed theyve done from your thought process and move on with your life. You are deciding that person has no influence on you and you are rendering them powerless. Youre taking the power from them so that you arent their little puppet on strings, RATM has an excellent lyrics that could apply here but theres a bit of profanity im afraid.

The hard thing is the forgiving itself. Thats something that has to be learned. You havent forgiven someone if youre still thinking about how angry something/someone makes you.

That is somewhat of a generalization, if someone has done something like burn your house to the ground, then you make sure they go to jail, but after that you have to forgive them or youre only screwing yourself over.

Hopefully you guys get my little philosophy and i didnt butcher it too bad.
User avatar
Тeatime
Warder
Warder
Posts: 547
Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 9:01 am
Platform: PC

Post by Тeatime »

leroybrown wrote:
Mrs T wrote:*Pure genius text wall*
This is one of those few times I feel completely in sync with what someone posted. You are a genius little missy.
Thank you, I'm sure. But tis just the truth, nothing more.
leroybrown wrote:*Brick wall*
We're quite in sync it'd seem. ^.^
Agreeably you shouldn't be overly forgiving, i.e the house burning example, but one of the things I cannot stand is those people who can't let the little things go or just decide to be [&@%!] off instead of even just talking to the person they feel have wronged them. Can't they see that the one they're hurting the most is themselves? :shock:
User avatar
The Most Unholy
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics

Post by The Most Unholy »

Mrs T wrote:All of the above are considered wrong by society, true. At the same time I cannot help but seeing how the people committing these acts could justify several of them. Also, I must disagree with Blue, they're not all unforgivable.

Murder can easily be justified in a scenario where the taking of one or several lives leads to the preservation of a greater number than those lost. It's consequential ethics, the ends justify the means. Is it forgiveable? Yes, if you had the freedom of choice I'd say it's less forgiveable not to kill and hence let more lives be lost. The same scenario is applicable to the question of torture. Principally causing suffering is wrong but when this suffering can prevent a greater suffering it is easy to see how it can be justified.

As for forgiving, who is it really that's supposed to be doing the forgiving? If me, then you'll find that I can be very forgiving. If the person committing the act really believes it's justified and that he's acting morally I could not blame him. Note that I'm not saying it is any less wrong just because I could bring myself to forgive. For the one committing the act to forgive himself that belief of justification must remain firm. If he/she knew it was wrong she/he should not be capable of forgiving him/herself. For the victim to forgive his/her tormentor he would have to possess understanding of whatever justification existed. Without justification in the mind of those committing these acts there can be no forgiving.

As for sexual assault, of any kind, and animal abusiveness I find it hard to think of a scenario where it could be forgiven. Actually, that's a lie. I can think of such far too easily but what's really disturbing is that they're not particularly far-fetched or unrealistic... I probably shouldn't say any more on that subject though.

The points I'm trying to make is that you shouldn't really generalize in these matter. To say that murder is automatically wrong and unforgivable just doesn't work, it can very well be both justified and forgiven. You should never jump to such conclusions without thinking things through though. If you just try to understand the minds behind “wrongs” in our society you just might find that things are a bit more complicated than they'd seem and maybe you'll find that the world is more frightening that you thought but trust me, if you choose to understand it just might bring you a little more peace of mind, something which a lot of people really seem to be lacking these days.

Forgiving really is a strange thing, personally I'd rather forgive than harbour resentment and whatnot. All in all it doesn't have to mean I approve or support what the person has done, I just made the choice.
Umm, awesome? Just awesome post.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
User avatar
WolfGang IceEye
Champion
Champion
Posts: 922
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 8:36 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Mother Russia *Cheers*

Post by WolfGang IceEye »

War-crimes are ,in my opinion, are the worst type of crime you can commit. I have been going through changes with my views on the Russian military (Subliminal advertisement is great!) and I have come to a conclusion... Every soldier has there own reason for fighting some were drafted and are fighting for survival, some are fighting for a loved one, others are trying to protect their country but in the end, no matter what they are fighting for, are the same. But to continue on with why my theory about war crimes...War crimes are hardly ever the soldiers fault, they are mostly from a commanding officer or crooked general. So in the end it is mass murder and misleading.
User avatar
The Most Unholy
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics

Post by The Most Unholy »

I think many people here are confusing 'war crimes' with 'crimes against humanity' they are two entirely separate things. (Not you wolfgang, you got it right) "War crimes - crimes committed against an enemy, prisoners of war, or subjects in wartime that violate international agreements. "
"Crimes against humanity - a crime or series of crimes, such as genocide, directed against a large group because of race, religion, country of origin, or other reason unconnected with any individual's responsibility for having committed a criminal act. "

Anyway, soldiers in almost all cases really can't be held responsible, because they either do it so they don't get killed by the CO who ordered it, or they are mentally unstable due to possible shellshock or trauma. Some just hated the enemy, some were justified in what was done. The Russians had every right to treat the Germans the way they were treated after Barbarossa. Considering the Germans killed thousands of Russian civilians and executed prisoners of war on sight, I'd say it was a fair trade. They had to be held accountable, WWII wasn't a war for the Germans, but a crusade. One that most of their soldiers believed in. Trial and jury just doesn't cut it in these cases. They needed to pay the consequences of what they did. Humans may have rights, but they must respect the rights of others to maintain their own, in my opinion.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
User avatar
ArotosMarkos
Warder
Warder
Posts: 503
Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2007 10:13 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: U.E.S.P.F.G.E.P.O. Station

Post by ArotosMarkos »

I think it's all a matter of personal preference.
Some of us love animals; others loathe them.
I find it hard to think of things like animal abuse and sexual assault as anywhere the same caliber as murder in the first degree.

My reasoning? Animals are just...animals. I'm not saying I support animal abuse, but it just doesn't phase me. I feel those that purposely harm animals for reasons other than sport and the such (hunting, a little forceful farming, that is all fine by my standards), but for someone to beat a dog if not training it is a little...eh.

Sexual assault is a serious offense, and it can leave some scarred, but it's...not murder.
Tell me, everyone, would you rather be raped or killed?
The answer is obvious.

What I consider to be unforgivable is the murder of a celebrity that is so...benign.

John Lennon, for example, wanted NOTHING but to entertain men and women alike with his music, for his music to MEAN something for the world, peace and love for everyone...He had no REASON to be shot. He did nothing but good for the world.
The man who shot him destroyed a symbol of hope for millions and essentially soiled the world just a little more.

Whatever, though...'tis just my two cents.
I missed it here.
User avatar
Sheepbiter
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 159
Joined: Sun Nov 23, 2008 7:54 pm
ES Games: Oblivion, Morrowind, Arena and Daggerfall
Platform: PC
Status: Menacing with Spikes of Ebony
Location: Lisnaskea

Post by Sheepbiter »

Animal cruelty and child abuse. I point out that i would willingly break my vow of pacifism when it comes to either of those two.
The Endar Scrolls IV : Oblivious.
User avatar
The King
Master
Master
Posts: 1006
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 1:55 am
ES Games: Obliwind.
Platform: Game Cube 360
Location: Texas

Post by The King »

Too me, animals don't qualify on the same level as humans. They can't think, love,read,write or do anything civilized. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying we should all have a dog beating party, I'm just saying that they don't have the rights humans do.
"I have never killed a man, but I have read many obituaries with great pleasure."- Clarence Darrow

"An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind."- Mohandas Ghandi
User avatar
WolfGang IceEye
Champion
Champion
Posts: 922
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 8:36 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Mother Russia *Cheers*

Post by WolfGang IceEye »

The King wrote:Too me, animals don't qualify on the same level as humans. They can't think, love,read,write or do anything civilized. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying we should all have a dog beating party, I'm just saying that they don't have the rights humans do.
Exactly. If a human was being skinned underneath my porch it would have a greater effect on me then if it was a deer.
User avatar
Dark Lord Cam
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
Status: Watching. Always Watching.

Post by Dark Lord Cam »

The King wrote:Too me, animals don't qualify on the same level as humans. They can't think, love,read,write or do anything civilized. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying we should all have a dog beating party, I'm just saying that they don't have the rights humans do.
animals do think

how else do you think wolves and lions coordinate to catch prey?

and they do love

alpha males in packs have been known to howl all night and day if their mate dies

same with cats and dogs
they will cry out pretty loudly if their kittens or cubs die

and chimps can be taught to communicate using sign language
they can also be taught math and some are even able to read certain symbols on computer screens

and elephants have been known to stop at the skeletons of their dead and remain quiet for long periods of time

as if they are mourning

an elephant that has seen a human kill its kind will remember it and will be pretty hostile to any humans it sees in the future

in my opinion
humans are a bit more uncivilized than the animals are
you never hear about a wolf committing genocide do you?
User avatar
The Most Unholy
Warder
Warder
Posts: 437
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:19 am
Status: Spreading the Thermodynamics

Post by The Most Unholy »

Humans are, as they say, advanced to a fault. We are able to grasp the idea of genocide and commit it.
Lieutenant of DHC. UESP Rock Star.
User avatar
WolfGang IceEye
Champion
Champion
Posts: 922
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 8:36 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Mother Russia *Cheers*

Post by WolfGang IceEye »

I like to think that humanity is better than that, there are monsters out there that seek out and commit genocide while others wish to make the world a better place. Now which one seems more accessible in your eyes? Also you can't compare humans to other animals we are to different the are actual genetic code is more advanced and refined than that of other mammals.
User avatar
Dark Lord Cam
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
Status: Watching. Always Watching.

Post by Dark Lord Cam »

you must remember that that was something said by another human

its mostly a bit of opinion
we are smarter than animals but we are not stronger or faster than most of them

our genetic code isnt better
we are just smarter

but that doesnt mean that animals are stupid

animals have the same rights we do
they are like children who dont know right from wrong

so we must protect them from abuse
User avatar
WolfGang IceEye
Champion
Champion
Posts: 922
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 8:36 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Mother Russia *Cheers*

Post by WolfGang IceEye »

Why should we have to protect something that is stronger and faster than us? They are also not like children, children (well the ones I know) know what right and wrong is. So I disagree.
User avatar
Dark Lord Cam
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 3:15 am
Status: Watching. Always Watching.

Post by Dark Lord Cam »

WolfGang IceEye wrote:Why should we have to protect something that is stronger and faster than us? They are also not like children, children (well the ones I know) know what right and wrong is. So I disagree.
think about it
humans are smart enough to fix their own mistakes
and we made a very big one

the animals cant protect themselves so we have to

animal abuse is something i hate
i hate it as much as i hate murder
User avatar
WolfGang IceEye
Champion
Champion
Posts: 922
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2008 8:36 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Mother Russia *Cheers*

Post by WolfGang IceEye »

(I am loving this discussion dark lord you really know how to spark a intelligent conversation :) )

A few questions:
What was humanities great mistake?
Who said that animals can't protect themselves?
You hate animal abuse as much as you hate murder? Why?
User avatar
Kestral
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 2970
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 12:41 am
ES Games: All of them (ESO is not ES)
Platform: PC
Status: [&@%!]

Post by Kestral »

WolfGang IceEye wrote:(I am loving this discussion dark lord you really know how to spark a intelligent conversation :) )

A few questions:
What was humanities great mistake?
Who said that animals can't protect themselves?
You hate animal abuse as much as you hate murder? Why?
If I may butt in....

1) Falls to opinion.
2) They can, like spider's have fans and orangutans climb trees.
3) Its more hardwired in people. If you have a cat as a child, a small child, and you liked that cat, every time you see an act of abuse against an animal you think "That could've been my cat."
Locked