Game "Holds your Hand"?

A place to discuss and ask questions about the fourth part of The Elder Scrolls series and its expansions
The Royal Druid
Novice
Novice
Posts: 52
Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2009 4:07 pm
Location: Sussex, England

Game "Holds your Hand"?

Post by The Royal Druid »

Don't you think Oblivion holds your hand a little too much?

One small complaint I have is that you never really think for yourself. If you are doing a "get the so-and-so item" quest then as soon as you have the item, a big message comes up and tells you.

Couldn't the game have been written so:

1/ The item itself is obvious that it's what you need (actually they often are)?
2/ That you are given a little intelligence. For example, in one mission you have to discover where someone has gone by searching their premises. You should have time to work out whether the item is "the one"? Not as soon as you find it be told that's it.

You don't really "discover" clues, you are led from one thing to another as they are signposted.
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

I see what you're saying.

In Morrowind the quests were not as obvious and i think a lot of people wasted time trying to remember names, places, etc which could be frustrating. So they put the marker in your hud and organised the quest journal so it's virtually impossible to 'lose your way'.

Oblivion has cleared up a lot of the quest/item frustration I felt with Mw, but i see how some might think they've gone too far. Perhaps the item marker might only work until you arrive at the building/dungeon it's supposed to be in, and then you're on your own (they do this with some Ob quests anyhow). And maybe if you know where an item is cos you put it somewhere, it could mark it on the map where you remember leaving it. But quest items can't be dropped so this issue is also sidestepped.

I suppose if you think your hand is being held by the game, the best thing is to do a quest without activating it. The map won't show you where to go and you can follow your wits.
User avatar
Apocalypse
Champion
Champion
Posts: 916
Joined: Mon Feb 18, 2008 7:10 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC
Status: Playing TES with my Horsemen
Location: Serbia

Post by Apocalypse »

If you're on the PC, the HUD can be disabled with the following console command:

Code: Select all

tm
Ry an kynd loria, la na vasha
Auran sou aran
Cactus
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1629
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:48 pm

Post by Cactus »

I think it should be
a) easily disabled in-game without having to "cheat" with the console
b) so that it only points towards things your character knows, ie: things you've learned in the game. Not just:

"I think he may have possibly, but I'm not entirely sure about this, gone north. Or west. Something"

<arrow appears pointing at the person's face>

That's 100% a quote taken directly from Vanilla Oblivion. >.>
DFS
<.<
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Post by Dark Spark »

I am so glad that I had forgotten completely about the Idiot Arrow during "Necromancer's Moon". I spent a long time searching all the shelves of the Mystic Archives for that book, both floors.

What was I doing? Playing the game, instead of being led around like a 5-year old in a kindergarten story circle (the game's rated 'M', give your audience some credit, Bethesda!).
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Alchemy Addict
Novice
Novice
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:37 am

Post by Alchemy Addict »

Hmm, perhaps one could gain self-control and direct one's eyes away from the Arrow :P

Or you could never open the quest things. Sometimes I pretend its not there.
Poisons and Potions... Its all good!
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Post by Dark Spark »

Unfortunately(?) with my super-keen sense of intuition, the moment I set eyes on the Idiot Arrow, I'm able to glean an astonishing amount of data from what is an otherwise innocuous display on a compass. Kind of like how I'm able to know a song is playing on a radio after hearing just the first two beats.
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Logius
Champion
Champion
Posts: 913
Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2007 11:30 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox 360
Location: I'm that noise you hear outside your window.

Post by Logius »

It does seem like they went from one extreme to another between the two games. But if you don't like the current system, it's easily avoidable without the use of the command console. For the last couple of years I've been getting around without the compass pointer by setting my Active Quest as the Nirnroot quest Sinderion gives you. If you have this as your Active Quest, no red marker will appear on your compass.

As for the messages that keep popping up and telling you where to go... you know you can skip past without reading them, right?

By using these two methods, it shouldn't be an issue. While some people may have "moral objections" with having to circumvent these things, that's more of a personal problem and not really related to the game itself. So, in other words, if you don't like it, there're easy and entirely non-obtrusive ways around it.
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

you have to won der about the marker. i mean here is how a lot of quests go:

Quest giver: There was a misterious powerfull weapon that existed in the old days. Mayne have tried to found it and it is believe it is lost forwever. However there are roumors that it could be in <insert dungeon name here>.

Player: <insert dungeon name here>?

Quest giver: yes, and old lost fort. here let me mark in on your map.

Then once oyu get there the misterious, supper hidden weapon no one can find will pop up in your hud with the arrow pointing to where it is.

Player should say: huh if it's so easy to find it then why not get it yourself. you obviously know where it is there is no mistery here...

I mean this is a bit ridiculous. What they could have done is mark a larger area on the map. and then you would explore within that area to find the right ruin. the ruin could be vaguely discribed. however i see the problem here since many people don't like to read the jurnal or listen to the quest giver.

The interesting ques tis when you search for those ayleid statues. however the problem is that there are no roumours or clues in game to give out the location of them so they only way to find them is to visit all the ruins (loooooong) or find a list of ruins that have it online.

Oh and speaking of Morrowind - there was a huge problem with quests because location there were too vague as well as sometimes completelly wrongly described. so searching for certain location or item was really horrible.

Then again if the old dwemer puzzle box is lost it means "no one" can find it so far and doesn't mean that when you enter the ruin you are already supposed to know where it is.
Aendra
Journeyman
Journeyman
Posts: 204
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:22 am
ES Games: Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim
Platform: PC

Post by Aendra »

I had one quest (part of the MQ cause I skipped a step and had to do it again) told me to hunt down two people...there was no map marker, and whenever I asked someone about them they said "I trust you can sort things out, so I actually had to hunt for them :? no holding hands there..
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

In Morrowind, if you want the game to hold your hand a bit more, you have to search the internet.
In Oblivion, if you want the game to hold your hand a bit less, you simply use a console command, ignore the marker or have a different quest as your active quest.

So I think this is a positive change.
User avatar
gregor
Champion
Champion
Posts: 806
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 12:26 pm

Post by gregor »

josjie wrote: In Oblivion, if you want the game to hold your hand a bit less, you simply use a console command,

Not available on consoles.
ignore the marker
Ignore? how?
or have a different quest as your active quest.
yes all these might work but that's not the point the point is how the game is made not how you can mod it or change it so it's not made like it is.
And if you don't use tzhe marker then whewre are the clues to find what you are supposed to find? should you spend days finding the darn ruin or what? you never thought of that did you? try disabling it without knowing where things lie.

game is not made for that.

Now let's not compare it to morrowind - compare it to Ultima underworld or for example where space is so much smaller yet you need to eplore so much on your own to solve the puzzle or quest.

In obLivion there is one quest where you need to find that pass. at leats there are clues and i kind of found it interesting trying to find the cave. the joy was much bigger when i found it.
User avatar
Valus
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 1:23 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox, Xbox 360, PC
Status: Ostensible
Location: Front Royal, VA

Post by Valus »

gregor wrote:
josjie wrote: In Oblivion, if you want the game to hold your hand a bit less, you simply use a console command,

Not available on consoles.
I know, those PC players have that console thing so they can do whatever they want, I've always wanted to see the coctesting hall.
ignore the marker
Ignore? how?
Uh...not looking at it? It's not that hard if you have an HD TV
Image
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

yes all these might work but that's not the point the point is how the game is made not how you can mod it or change it so it's not made like it is.
And if you don't use tzhe marker then whewre are the clues to find what you are supposed to find? should you spend days finding the darn ruin or what? you never thought of that did you? try disabling it without knowing where things lie.

game is not made for that.
Why not? This is a role-playing game! You may decide what you do and at what time. You can spend 100's of hours walking around in your cell and not even consider escaping by following the emperor and those three Blades. It's boring, but if you want to do that, it's possible.

So if you want to search for yourself for a certain cave, don't look at the quest marker or set a different quest as your active quest.

So "should you spend days finding the darn ruin", YES, if that's what you want. But if you don't, the game gives you enough hints and that marker to help you on your way.

In Morrowind, you had to "spend days finding the darn ruin". If you didn't want to search that long, you had to find a guide on the internet.

So because of that, the system in Oblivion is better, well, in my opinion it is :)
Not available on consoles.
Yeah but on the PS3 or Xbox360 you can also select a different active quest or ignore the marker.
The Royal Druid
Novice
Novice
Posts: 52
Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2009 4:07 pm
Location: Sussex, England

Post by The Royal Druid »

I think people have mostly got caught up with the compass/map markers.

I don't actually have a problem with these, they show you where you need to go, which can be very helpful.

I am talking about how every time you do a quest it is signposted as soon as you have found what you're looking for or what the next task is to complete the quest.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

So last night, I did the "Sins of the Father" quest. I was told I would probably recognise the item as soon as I saw it as it wasn't something ogres would have. I didn't need to, as soon as I picked it up I was told by the game this was it - if it was that recognisable surely I shouldn't have needed to be told that?

I think one of the few times this doesn't happen is in "Canvas the Castle" where it doesn't say how you're doing until you've interviewed everybody, then it says you should look for clues.

But the "Canvas the Castle" throws up another minor problem I have with some of the quests; despite the open nature of the game you cannot discover clues until you have interviewed everyone. So you might see the paint on the carpet, you may discover the strange painting, etc., but unless everyone has been interviewed the game won't "see" these.
User avatar
Dark Spark
Undecided
Undecided
Posts: 4746
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 1:37 am
ES Games: Oblivion (SI); Skyrim (DB)
Platform: XBox
Status: Reality and I aren't on speaking terms right now
Other Profiles: DarkSpark135
UESPoints: 5
Location: Edge of the world and all Western civilization

Post by Dark Spark »

It was easy to figure out who stole the painting from the interviews alone, but the game forces you to do this whole dog-n-pony show with the clues before you can make your accusation.

The Rosethorn Cache is an example of subtley gone wrong. The clue left behind in the Long Forgotten Note does nothing to tell you where the treasure is hidden, and wouldn't have helped the person to whom it was first addressed, either. Whether or not you figured out the riddle's answer, you still had to do a top-to-bottom search of the house to notice something out-of-place.
Baurus: Our job is to get the Emperor out of situations like this. Though I'll admit, things aren't going exactly to plan.

Casandra: At the moment, the deadliest weapon at my disposal is a goblin's head on a stick. I'd be worried if this was the plan.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

... or you just read the location of it in the official game guide :P
User avatar
Valus
Warder
Warder
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 1:23 am
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion GOTY, Skyrim
Platform: Xbox, Xbox 360, PC
Status: Ostensible
Location: Front Royal, VA

Post by Valus »

... or the UESP wiki page :P
Image
User avatar
The Edgy Redguard
Champion
Champion
Posts: 849
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 10:05 pm
ES Games: Skyrim, Oblivion GOTY, Morrowind GOTY, Redguard, Daggerfall, Arena
Platform: PC
Status: Is actually back this time...
Location: Canada,Eh?

Post by The Edgy Redguard »

Logius wrote:It does seem like they went from one extreme to another between the two games. But if you don't like the current system, it's easily avoidable without the use of the command console. For the last couple of years I've been getting around without the compass pointer by setting my Active Quest as the Nirnroot quest Sinderion gives you. If you have this as your Active Quest, no red marker will appear on your compass.

As for the messages that keep popping up and telling you where to go... you know you can skip past without reading them, right?

By using these two methods, it shouldn't be an issue. While some people may have "moral objections" with having to circumvent these things, that's more of a personal problem and not really related to the game itself. So, in other words, if you don't like it, there're easy and entirely non-obtrusive ways around it.
That is the Same Method i've been using for over a year now. I find the Arena quest tends to work just as well.
The Royal Druid
Novice
Novice
Posts: 52
Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2009 4:07 pm
Location: Sussex, England

Post by The Royal Druid »

josjie wrote:... or you just read the location of it in the official game guide :P
Yes, you can just read the location, but you still have to play through the quest in sequence.
User avatar
Josjie
Grand Master
Grand Master
Posts: 1749
Joined: Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:21 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 500
Location: The Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Josjie »

Yeah well I pick up the note ran down to my basement and then I'm done. Shortest quest ever, took me about 30 seconds.
User avatar
christylynne
Associate
Associate
Posts: 16
Joined: Thu Mar 19, 2009 8:19 am
UESPoints: 0
Location: California

Post by christylynne »

Dark Spark wrote:I am so glad that I had forgotten completely about the Idiot Arrow during "Necromancer's Moon". I spent a long time searching all the shelves of the Mystic Archives for that book, both floors.

What was I doing? Playing the game, instead of being led around like a 5-year old in a kindergarten story circle (the game's rated 'M', give your audience some credit, Bethesda!).
Yeah, although the "Idiot Arrow" is helpful on the big map, I'd much rather thoroughly explore a dungeon to find what I'm looking for instead of being lead straight to it. I find that I get lazy and miss out on a lot of important loot (ie. Master Alchemy Aparatus) I'm still looking!
User avatar
Kaelan Corvinus
Master
Master
Posts: 1152
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:11 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Creeping into your bedroom when you are sleeping, just to taste your blood.

Post by Kaelan Corvinus »

My complaint about this is that you cant turn off the indicator on the Xbox 360 version. At least, I dont think you can.
--Earth! That's right! I liked Earth. Got these boots on Earth. Listen, don't tell the girl about what happened, cause if you do...I'll tear out your speen! Thanks, buddy...like those jammys!--
President of the Galaxy
User avatar
Mattbott
The New Number Two
The New Number Two
Posts: 2325
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 2:33 pm
ES Games: Mw, Ob, Sk
Status: embellishing my headcanon
UESPoints: 1

Post by Mattbott »

you can highlight a different quest as your current one or just have no quest active. Or ignore the compass. Or place a strip of post-it on your monitor/tv where the compass is, drawing a skull and crossbones for effect if you like.

I never worried too much about the compass thing, having spent days wandering aimlessly round red mountain in Mw looking for some crypt or searching for some obscure ashlander name who i have to visit in a hut somewhere in the grazelands. So i am happy enough to be shown where to go. I often play games when relaxing (which may mean i am tired or even a little drunk), so it's nice to be reminded where i'm going, for when i wasn't paying attention or popped out of the room

But the map marker usually disappears for quests where you have to hunt people, once you are close enough
User avatar
Kaelan Corvinus
Master
Master
Posts: 1152
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 5:11 pm
UESPoints: 0
Location: Creeping into your bedroom when you are sleeping, just to taste your blood.

Post by Kaelan Corvinus »

Mattbott wrote:you can highlight a different quest as your current one or just have no quest active. Or ignore the compass. Or place a strip of post-it on your monitor/tv where the compass is, drawing a skull and crossbones for effect if you like.

I never worried too much about the compass thing, having spent days wandering aimlessly round red mountain in Mw looking for some crypt or searching for some obscure ashlander name who i have to visit in a hut somewhere in the grazelands. So i am happy enough to be shown where to go. I often play games when relaxing (which may mean i am tired or even a little drunk), so it's nice to be reminded where i'm going, for when i wasn't paying attention or popped out of the room

But the map marker usually disappears for quests where you have to hunt people, once you are close enough
I dont have that much self-control. Id end up ripping the sticky note off and setting fire to it.......and dance naked around it while it burned!!!! :Twisted Evil: :Twisted Evil:
--Earth! That's right! I liked Earth. Got these boots on Earth. Listen, don't tell the girl about what happened, cause if you do...I'll tear out your speen! Thanks, buddy...like those jammys!--
President of the Galaxy
Locked