I. More realism:
1.) Make plants and environments interactive
-- If you walk through grass, it should bend, wave, and otherwise react accordingly.
-- If you walk into/through shrubs and bushes, they should snap and crack.
-- Brushing against leaves should invoke some action on their part (e.g. the limb of a small tree might be bent as it catches on your arm, then swing back sharply, the way it would in real life).
-- If you swing your sword at plants, their leaves/branches should fall off.
-- If you hit a tree, its bark should bear appropriate marks (slashes from swords, nicks and holes from arrows).
-- Plants should be able to catch on fire and maybe even be destructible.
-- If a slope is steep, the player should adapt (lean forward, use hands if necessary).
-- Maybe even be able to scale certain walls and cliff faces or climb trees.
2.) Show the effects of time and action
-- Armor and weapons should rust and degrade as they progress into disrepair.
-- The player should get cuts, bruises, scars, etc (which could all go away after sleep, magic, food, a potion, etc).
-- All attacks should have a physical effect (e.g. slash marks on shields, wounds on enemies -- and friends -- spell damage, and maybe even crippled or lost limbs).
-- Hair should grow, environments should change (e.g. wooden structures may become dusty in dry seasons or swell up in wet times; water levels should rise and fall by season, lakes should freeze in winter).
-- Maybe towns could even change, both on their own and as results of your actions. In a prospering town, citizens might buy more expensive clothes and furnishings for their homes, stores might sell more rare/valuable items, new quests might open up, etc).
3.) Believable characters
-- More voice actors so there is more variety/personality in characters.
-- More "passing dialogue" options (i.e. the things NPCs say to you in passing -- they should be more accurate and varied so the world is more believable).
-- Better expressions (eyes need LIFE, more emphasis on realistic and appropriate expressions).
-- Work on lip syncing.
-- When characters go about their daily routines, make them seem like they're doing stuff. Show them actually physically doing things like yardwork, shopping, eating, etc.
4.) Travel
-- Revamp fast travel. A LOT. Make it so that the only way to fast travel is to pay someone to take you from town to town (like someone who owns a wagon or something). You can't just go anywhere on the map; you may only fast travel to designated rest stops located at all major towns and a few select places of interest.
-- To compensate, make fast realtime transport a viable alternative. Make speed spells more accessible or horse travel more beneficial (i.e. easier to maneuver and a bit faster in general). Add other means of conveyance such as rafts down rivers or new mounts.
II. More customization:
1.) Character customization
-- Make a more extensive and intuitive customization pallet. Fallout 3's is nice but not as in-depth as I'd like to see. Focus on eyes and hair, two features which tend to make or break realism in character design these days. If any of you have played FIFA 09, it has an awesome player creator. Mass Effect's is also pretty good.
-- GIVE LIFE TO THE EYES.
-- Make the hair look like ACTUAL HAIR (Fallout did a good job with this but it could still be much better). [Watch the trailer for "I am Alive" and you will see some real good video game hair...]
-- Allow for a degree of body customization. I know that too much variety would mean every piece of clothing/armor would have to be retooled for every possible body type, but I'm sure some sort of compromise could be met. Maybe have some sliders for muscle toning, tattoos (tasteful ones), scars, etc. (Height/weight modifiers would be AWESOME but are probably way too much to ask for...)
-- Make the "human" races really be human-like in a very real way.
-- Make other races LESS human-like / more distinct.
-- Add a race or two if possible.
2.) Clothing customization
-- Let me go to a tailor and start with a base outfit, then choose a fabric, color scheme, and modify the outfit to my liking (sleeve length, frills, layers, collars, etc). Allow players to make shirts, coats, and pants; maybe even hats, gloves, and boots).
3.) House customization
-- Nothing like the Sims or anything, but it would be nice to be able to buy a couch or bed or something... Maybe have a little garden in the yard, a fence, a fountain... Just to make my house ... well, MY house.
4.) Weapon customization
-- Let me give my Daedric sword a Ruby-encrusted handle, embed diamonds into the blade, etc ... maybe enchant it so that the blade is always on fire or made out of ice (i.e. it is the shape of a Daedric sword but it would be transparent and would have the texture/appearance of an ice sword).
III. More freedom:
1.) Let me do more with what I have
-- Let me use a knife as a weapon, for example.
-- Let players be creative with items, especially generic things like garden tools (let people use them to maintain their yards) and paintbrushes (maybe I could equip the brush and use it on an easel to "make" a painting, which I could [try to] sell...?).
-- Let me buy more buildings -- hell, let me become so rich and powerful that I can overthrow a count and take over his castle (and subsequently, the town over which he reigns).
-- Let me control a business and hire a worker or two so I have a steady income.
2.) Give us more to explore
-- Let us climb walls if there are ledges to grab.
-- Make some small holes/crevasses and the like through which players could crawl if they are able to spot them.
-- Let us sail in a ship, maybe even have battles on the ocean with rival factions.
-- Reward people for being adventurous (experience bonuses for discovering certain locations, valuable/rare/unique items in hard-to-find, secluded areas of the map, etc).
3.) More weapons, armor, and magic.
-- Let me get some ninja armor and some ninja stars.
-- Throwing knives, javelins, crossbows for ranged attacks.
-- More unique items (but make them even more difficult to find, and make each one truly special).
-- New enchantments (or old ones revived, heh).
-- Make high-levelled armor truly awesome. Daedric was pretty much the only really cool-looking armor that was worth using in Oblivion...
IV. More immersion
1.) Make me FEEL for my character (and for other characters)
-- Make pain evident and real.
-- Give some burden to decisions.
-- Make the evil characters truly, sickeningly, brutally evil. There were some sick freaks in the other Elder Scrolls games, but no one really made me feel like they were all too vile. I want my guildmaster to make me DESPISE the leader of our enemy.
2.) Make more factions and guilds with fascinating storylines and sidequests.
-- Include warring factions and the ability to join either side and even become a double agent.
V. Miscellaneous/Extra Ideas and Afterthoughts
-- Wet clothing: If it rains or snows (or if I swim in a lake), my hair and clothes should look (and seem) wet. Hair should be heavier and stuck in strands. Clothes should also sag heavily and stick to the skin. (See Uncharted: Drake's Fortune.)
-- Weather physics: Rain should not go through overhangs (awnings above doorways, horse stables, etc). Rain should not always come straight down; it should vary based on the wind. There should be more snow and maybe hail. Wind should be present and maybe have an effect on ranged attacks or ease of movement. Maybe there could be spells to create more wind or nullify existing wind patterns. Also, waves should vary and actually physically hit shorelines (i.e. sand might be pulled or displaced by waves when they break).
-- Fluid animations: We spend a lot of time customizing our characters. Why? SO THAT WE CAN SEE THEM, FEEL THEM, AND BE THEM. I know first-person is better for fighting and arguably more immersive, but third-person is good for surveying your surroundings and just to admire your character. They should work A LOT on third-person models. Make jumping, running, swimming, and attacking animations more realistic and fluid. Make the characters react to things around them (i.e. plant-life, weapons, walls, etc: if I tell my guy to walk into a wall, he should reach out and push against it with his arm, not glide on the ground while his legs perpetually move back and forth. Think "Assassin's Creed," where the character detects objects and reacts to them).
-- Varied landscaping: Have different types of rocks for different regions. Different types of trees (dense patches of towering evergreens in deep forests, scatterings of oak, spruce, yew, etc. on hillsides...). Different ground textures, shrubbery, grasses, etc.
-- More quests: Different outcomes based on character choices, more challenges (mental, physical, psychological, emotional). Maybe some risk/reward situations.
-- Dual Wielding: Pretty self-explanatory. Only with certain small items (Daggers, throwing knives, scimitars, short swords...).
-- More "unlogged quests" / treasure hunts: These are always engaging, fun, and rewarding. Maybe even some randomly generated events such as chancing upon the recently-ravaged corpse of an unfortunate traveler with a note lying nearby (or on his person), which, upon reading, would [eventually] lead you on a mini-adventure.
-- Special moves on certain weapons: e.g. An instant kill assassination move with a dagger (IF UNDETECTED) or an execution move on an unconscious (sleeping, drained of fatigue) creature/NPC.
If this looks familiar to anyone, it's because I posted this on IGN's boards a day or two ago. I'll probably edit this with more ideas soon.
PS: First post






