Valenwood villages - Comparison between 3E and 2E

A place to discuss and ask questions about anything related to the Elder Scrolls lore.
Post Reply
-Esh-
Layman
Layman
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon May 15, 2017 4:45 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, Online
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 0

Valenwood villages - Comparison between 3E and 2E

Post by -Esh- »

Hi all! I need help to achieve some consensus about how to treat minor settlements in Valenwood.
Green: obvious relationship.
Orange: probable relationship.
Red: possible relationship.
Hidden:
3E Archen Cormount = 2E Cormount - Same settlement.

3E Black Park = Black Vine Ruins are in front of the Baandari Trading Post. - QUESTION: That Colovian-style settlement could be named Black Park during the 3E, being the Trading Post and Black Park equivalent?

3E Cori Silmoor = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Velyn Harbor - QUESTION: Cori Silmoor and Velyn Harbor are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Velyn Harbor should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Cori Silmoor should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Cormeir Spring = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Brackenleaf - QUESTION: Cormeir Spring and Brackenleaf are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Brackenleaf should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Cormeir Spring should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Eagle Vale = no direct equivalent and no settlement nor ruins in its location by 2E - QUESTION Eagle Vale should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Ebon Ro = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Vinedusk Village - QUESTION: Ebon Ro and Vinedusk Village are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Vinedusk Village should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Ebon Ro should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Emperors Run = 2E Wilding Run - Same settlement, but renamed.

3E Glenpoint = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Tanglehaven - QUESTION: Glenpoint and Tanglehaven are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Tanglehaven should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Glenpoint should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Green Hall = 2E Green Hall (subzone) - QUESTION: Green Hall is a settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E in the so-called region? Or we should not treat Green Hall as a settlement at all?

3E Heimdar City = no direct equivalent and no settlement nor ruins in its location by 2E - QUESTION Heimdar City should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Karthdar Square = 2E Karthdar - Same settlement.

3E Longhaven = 2E Longhaven - Same settlement.

3E Longvale = 2E Valeguard - Same settlement but renamed.

3E Lynpan March = no direct equivalent and no settlement nor ruins in its location by 2E - QUESTION Lypan March should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Marbruk Field = 2E Marbruk - Same settlement.

3E Meadow Run = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Bloodtoil Valley - QUESTION: Meadow Run and Bloodtoil Valley are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Bloodtoil Valley should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Meadow Run should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Moonmont= 2E Moonmont - QUESTION: Moonmont is a settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E around or over the Anequinan ruins? Or we should treat Moonmont simply as an Anequinan ruin?

3E Stone Fell = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Willowgrove - QUESTION: Stone Fell and Willowgrove are the same settlement with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Willowgrove should be considered uninhabited by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Stone Fell should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Stonesquare = no direct equivalent, but same location as 3E Reman's Bluff and Online rocky terrain - QUESTION: Stonesquare and Reman's Bluff are the same settlement/fortification with different names or the two are unrelated? If the two are unrelated, Reman's Bluff should be considered unoccupied by the 3E? And, if the two are unrelated, Stonesquare should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

3E Tarlain Heights = 2E Tarlain Heights (subzone) - QUESTION: Tarlain Heights is a settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E in the so-called region? Or we should not treat Tarlain Heights as a settlement at all?

3E Thormar Keep = 2E Thormar - QUESTION: Thormar is a settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E around or over the Ayleid ruins? Or we should treat Thormar simply as an Ayleid ruin?

3E Vulkwasten Wood = 2E Vulkwasten - Same settlement.

3E Vullain Haven = 2E Dread Vullain - Same settlement.

3E Wasten Brukbrook = no direct equivalent and no settlement nor ruins in its location by 2E - QUESTION Wasten Brukbrook should be considered a new settlement founded after the 6th century of the 2E or not?

2E Greenhill = no direct equivalent in 3E map. Greenhill should be considered uninhabited by the 3E?

2E Fort Grimwatch = no direct equivalent in 3E map. Fort Grimwatch should be considered unoccupied by the 3E?


2E Bramblebreach = no direct equivalent in 3E map. Bramblebreach should be considered unoccupied by the 3E?

2E Diss = no direct equivalent in Online or Arena map. Seaside Sanctuary is located in the island in front of the supposed location of the settlement. Should Diss and Seaside Sanctuary be considered the same settlement with different names (probably Bosmer and Altmer versions)? Should we consider Diss and Seaside Sanctuary uninhabited by the 3E because there is no direct equivalent in Arena map?
Last edited by Aarah on Mon May 15, 2017 6:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
legoless
Global Wiki Admin
Global Wiki Admin
Posts: 2552
Joined: Sun Sep 13, 2009 2:02 pm
ES Games: All
Platform: PC, Switch
UESPoints: 420
Location: Ireland
Contact:

Re: Valenwood villages - Comparison between 3E and 2E

Post by legoless »

If this is in regards to the wiki, you might get a better reception here. I would say it's worth assuming that anything with a similar name has a relationship with the ESO settlements, while anything in the same location and no obvious ties should be considered a new (post-2E582), separate settlement.
Wiki admin. Contact me on my talk page or via PM.
-Esh-
Layman
Layman
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon May 15, 2017 4:45 pm
ES Games: Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, Online
Platform: PC
UESPoints: 0

Re: Valenwood villages - Comparison between 3E and 2E

Post by -Esh- »

Many thanks! I will post there :)
Post Reply