Page 1 of 1

PC vs. Xbox 360 vs. PS3 versions of oblivion

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:45 pm
by cptkrunch1
CONSOLE WAR....kinda I am seeing what versions of oblivion are more popular I have the Xbox 360 version which unlike the computer has pretty much no lag but doesnt have all the cool mods like th PC or the PS3 which comes with the nights of the nine and some other extras but the xbox 360 version has all the same OFFICIAL mods but no user created ones like the PC vote now!!!

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:54 pm
by Warlock
Personally I prefer the Xbox 360 version simply because you don't have the choice to use cheats if the going gets tough making it more thrilling :)

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:55 pm
by Caldyn_Blade
Well, I'm on the 360, but I'd like to have a PC capable of running it and the mods... I use my home PC for work occassionally too (and college), so never really needed much "oomph" out of it before...so never bothered going the high end route...

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:56 pm
by cptkrunch1
Amen brotha Amen

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 6:57 pm
by Sevis
PC, simply because I have nothing else, and running on PC lets me use mods and console.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 7:04 pm
by Caldyn_Blade
I'm pretty sure I'd have to rip off my ~ key if I had it on PC, hehe.... :D
Temptation would be too great...

Took me enough willpower to limit my duping to only ingredients and nonmagical arrows...and that's only for my own ingame convenience (as no fun playing a farmer or marathon shopper)

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 7:16 pm
by Bear
Welcome to the forums cptkrunch. I have a very personal reason for disliking this thread from the very start, but as long as everyone is civil about it; I'll be ok.

I have never tried anything but PC and other than the official DLC's; I have not modded my game in anyway, nor used the ~ key for anything. I have collected paint brushes but never actually used them, and I've never duped anything.

Boring right? Yeah, I know!! :lol:

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 8:30 pm
by Davesmason
Warlock wrote:Personally I prefer the Xbox 360 version simply because you don't have the choice to use cheats if the going gets tough making it more thrilling :)
Personally I dont call it cheating =P

I completed the main storyline on the 360 + a lot of the side quests. Now I liven things up with the PC version and the console. Not just to spawn myself endless riches, but to tweak how I play the game and what I am able to do for better and worse. =)

PC rules, ok? =P

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 8:40 pm
by Deathmist
This topic is pointless, the way you worded it is provoking a flame war.

Of course the PC version is the best! And it is very obvious that the PS3 is the worse (no mods or good DLC). I think you should have changed it to "what version of Oblivion do you own". Because people will most likely choose what version they own.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 9:12 pm
by Paladin_Warrior
A Flame War? Good! It's time to purge the Sanctuary! ;-)

---

But, this is a useless thread, simply because it's been done...time, after bloody boring time....in other threads.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 9:24 pm
by Codex
Paladin_Warrior wrote:A Flame War? Good! It's time to purge the Sanctuary! ;-)

---

But, this is a useless thread, simply because it's been done...time, after bloody boring time....in other threads.
And with the exact same outcome. Play nice, or it the thread will be locked.

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 9:39 pm
by Paladin_Warrior
How can anyone take a smiling Yeti seriously? ;-)

Just kiddin'.... your point is well taken. :-)

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 10:21 pm
by The Tourist
All I'm packing is some uncut sense... so kick back and be (slightly) educated... :roll:

Pros:
PC: it can be run the smoothest, its graphical identity can be tweaked and boosted, plus the whole mod-community thing. able to utilize multiple control methods.

360: plain old vanilla flavoured, utilizing the slickest joypad created by man or mer. SI, Knights, and all the main DLC's are just a click away from perfect compatibility and ease of use.

PS3: as the 360 version, but with greatly improved loading, and - I believe - less frame rate issues.

Cons:
PC: it can be the best of the best - and also the worst of the worst (how it looks, and how it runs). Hardware compatibility issues and general computer reliability leaves it wide open for by far the greatest potential for crash-chaos, slowdown, poor v-syncing etc.

360: 'HDD not required', for the central game - means it suffers, by far, the (consistetly) worst with regards to loading, becuase it reads direct from the disc, and enforces no buffering or writing to the HDD to speed things up. (SI needs the HDD to run, tho). No mods.

PS3: came out last, and still apparently lacks one or two DLC's, and has to put up with Sony's controller - which, once you get used to it, is adequate. No mods.

So I say? Whichever version you use is the best.

Personally, running games on Vista makes me want to cry quietly in a darkened corner, and I bought a 360 for the Halo/Oblivion combination (the same combination that made me get the original Xbox; Halo/Morrowind). And I'm primarily a console gamer (the 360 joypad counts big for me), who doesn't really care about mods.

Perfection
If Oblivion could be run on the PS3 (reliable, powerful, QUIETER.. ), with the 360 joypad and a full compliment of DLC's and a few user mods? Then sign me up.

Posted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 2:26 am
by Chrodar
The Tourist wrote:All I'm packing is some uncut sense... so kick back and be (slightly) educated... :roll:

Pros:
PC: it can be run the smoothest, its graphical identity can be tweaked and boosted, plus the whole mod-community thing. able to utilize multiple control methods.

360: plain old vanilla flavoured, utilizing the slickest joypad created by man or mer. SI, Knights, and all the main DLC's are just a click away from perfect compatibility and ease of use.

PS3: as the 360 version, but with greatly improved loading, and - I believe - less frame rate issues.

Cons:
PC: it can be the best of the best - and also the worst of the worst (how it looks, and how it runs). Hardware compatibility issues and general computer reliability leaves it wide open for by far the greatest potential for crash-chaos, slowdown, poor v-syncing etc.

360: 'HDD not required', for the central game - means it suffers, by far, the (consistetly) worst with regards to loading, becuase it reads direct from the disc, and enforces no buffering or writing to the HDD to speed things up. (SI needs the HDD to run, tho). No mods.

PS3: came out last, and still apparently lacks one or two DLC's, and has to put up with Sony's controller - which, once you get used to it, is adequate. No mods.

So I say? Whichever version you use is the best.

Personally, running games on Vista makes me want to cry quietly in a darkened corner, and I bought a 360 for the Halo/Oblivion combination (the same combination that made me get the original Xbox; Halo/Morrowind). And I'm primarily a console gamer (the 360 joypad counts big for me), who doesn't really care about mods.

Perfection
If Oblivion could be run on the PS3 (reliable, powerful, QUIETER.. ), with the 360 joypad and a full compliment of DLC's and a few user mods? Then sign me up.
YES YES YES!!!! :D

I hate how each console is superior in it's own way, it leaves us hangin, but to have one over the other PC is best if you have a fairly new computer. I played the 360 version and it lags like hell and glitches. I currently play on PS3. It runs great and loads quick, but once you really really get into the game your going to want the PC's capabilities.

Posted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 11:45 am
by xenolion
Well I have the PS3 version which is the best for me. I am afraid to DL stuff to my computer, so the Mods really are a mute point for me.

Plus the game looks better in 1080I on my TV than on my PC anyday!!

I can see why people would like the PC version though, more game to play.

Posted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 6:32 pm
by cptkrunch1
Deathmist wrote:This topic is pointless, the way you worded it is provoking a flame war.

Of course the PC version is the best! And it is very obvious that the PS3 is the worse (no mods or good DLC). I think you should have changed it to "what version of Oblivion do you own". Because people will most likely choose what version they own.
I want to start a war I think it would be intresting spice it up a little and I agree the PC probally is the best for mods and veriety of play and more freedom and yes the PS3 does suck I own the 360 version and I like but I chose the PC but good idea I think i will make a new topic

Posted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:33 pm
by Codex
cptkrunch1 wrote:
Deathmist wrote:This topic is pointless, the way you worded it is provoking a flame war.

Of course the PC version is the best! And it is very obvious that the PS3 is the worse (no mods or good DLC). I think you should have changed it to "what version of Oblivion do you own". Because people will most likely choose what version they own.
I want to start a war I think it would be intresting spice it up a little and I agree the PC probally is the best for mods and veriety of play and more freedom and yes the PS3 does suck I own the 360 version and I like but I chose the PC but good idea I think i will make a new topic
Oh please!

From the rules:
Console Wars - Console wars do nothing but make people argue with each other and don't provide any helpful information about the games. So just try not to argue about which console is better. It never stays civil when fanboys square off.
And try using some periods once in a while. Makes it easier for everyone to read.