Page 1 of 2
Kvatch Challenge
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 1:52 am
by Ergukrael
Hey ya'll. Let's share ideas for completing the Battle for Kvatch without having ANY ally casualties.
The best I've been able to do so far was only two other survivors: Savlian Matius, who is a given, and Ilend Vonius. I was doing very well up until we crossed the castle courtyard. In that skirmish I lost 2 of the 3 Imperial Guards, plus Jesan Rilian. Then inside the castle, I lost my remaining Imperial Guard, Berich Inian, Merandil and Tierra.
One reason for the high mortality rate is that I went straight there from the IC, rather than detouring down to Bravil to buy ‘convalescence’. In hindsight I should have picked that up to heal up my allies between skirmishes.
Anyway, here’s my basic rules for the challenge:
1. Vanilla Ob. Official mods/expansions are okay, but no custom mods that affect game play.
2. No console cheats or bug exploitations.
3. Any other allies you bring with you (i.e. Mazoga) must also survive.
4. Difficulty must be left at 'default' (or harder).
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 1:55 am
by The Tourist
See that Difficulty Slider in the options? Well, make it go left. Like,
Fidel Castro left...
There. Problem solved.

Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:07 am
by Ergukrael
The Tourist wrote:See that Difficulty Slider in the options? Well, make it go left. Like,
Fidel Castro left...
There. Problem solved.

Fixed. See rule No. 4. (I've got no qualms about making it up as I go.)

Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:24 am
by The Tourist
Pah! I've always hated improv...
That really
was my solution though, and I have absolutely no qualms about dropping the difficulty after putting in as many hours as I had on Oblivion.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:38 am
by M1SSYF1V3
I lost.

Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:51 am
by Deandra
I did this before, and at lvl 20ish no less
It requires having a powerful ranged healing spell, preferrably one with a large radius as well, in addition to a powerful wide-area combo fire shield/shock shield spell (having master level alteration really comes in handy here). Also saving after every skirmish is a must.
So basically, you buff everyone, skirmish, heal, save, rinse and repeat. You must turn yourself into a human shield and throw yourself in between a monster and a guard that is taking hits. Since you will be busy healing guards and killing daedra, you won't have time to heal yourself, so make sure you come loaded with powerful magicka and healing potions. Shield potions for yourself also help.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 5:17 am
by Doctor Meaticus
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:04 am
by gregor
i went to do it with level one i believe and i got them all safelly in the castle, but then one room before the count they all died...
over the courtyard they all went for one creature and that creature (i think scamp) ran away. all this time i moved forward as i thought they are right behind me. my fights were tougher and tougher when finnaly i get some break and look arround and i see i am all alone. so i went back to see what is going on. i found them standing arround and chatting. Ugh!
then it all went well as i ran in front up until the last room where they thought running in front would be cool. so if i remmber everyone died there...
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 7:45 am
by weka
I did it about level 20, but I still lost one man. Had no healing spells for others though.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 7:52 am
by Logius
I always have Martin with me while doing this portion of the Kvatch quest, but unless I do it at low levels ( <10) no one except essentials ever survive. Even playing the part of the human shield, most of the time my "allies" end up hitting each other more than the enemies.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 10:41 am
by vondobeln
I always make sure I rest an hour after one stage has been cleard and BEFORE any of the NPC's enter the next stage. Then they will also get healed completely and so can enter the next stage with full health instead of being nearly dead (this seems to affect only NPC's that are in the same stage/room as you so resting in the chapel won't help the men waiting outside the castle gate e.g.). That usually helps a lot in keeping them alive. I usually manage to keep all of them alive on normal difficulty, but on 75% which I play now it's rather hard and I usually don't care unless too many get killed which makes the latter stages a lot harder. Other than that it's just F5 and F9 until you get it right.
vD
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:02 pm
by Kickass1337
I've lose only 1 Imperial Soldier, but other's survive. When i made this quest i was very high skilled, because i didn't finish Main Quest at the start. First i demoralize my soldiers, so they run to chapel and didn't fight, so they didn't die. Only 1 [&@%!] was killed by Fire ball. Than i own daedra's with Ice damage 50 points 50 ft. Easy one
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:20 pm
by Warlock
OMG I just tried this does it count if you paralyse your team mates? because I did, and I managed to complete the challenge with no dead teammates.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:58 pm
by weka
Kickass1337 wrote:... First i demoralize my soldiers, so they run to chapel and didn't fight...
Hey I like that idea! I think I might try that, Thanks Kick. I've thought of using Paralyze before, but never got around to trying that. Def pref this method though!

Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:55 pm
by Struck
Real problem with this is that there are quite a few people to keep alive...and all of em want some pieve of the action, so you could either be a human shield for some or hang back and heal...thats kinda the easier route...
you could go this route...which i prefer...though you can't keep an eye on the NPCs...
Summon a powerful daedra and do as much damage to the mobs as quick as possible...you can heal others in the process...just remember to save...
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 7:29 pm
by Caldyn_Blade
Anyway, here’s my basic rules for the challenge:
1. Vanilla Ob. Official mods/expansions are okay, but no custom mods that affect game play.
2. No console cheats or bug exploitations.
3. Any other allies you bring with you (i.e. Mazoga) must also survive.
4. Difficulty must be left at 'default' (or harder).
What about making 0 weight enchanted clothing items, then reverse pickpocketing the gear on them? Does this count as a cheat or bug?
Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 1:59 am
by Ergukrael
Caldyn_Blade wrote:Anyway, here’s my basic rules for the challenge:
1. Vanilla Ob. Official mods/expansions are okay, but no custom mods that affect game play.
2. No console cheats or bug exploitations.
3. Any other allies you bring with you (i.e. Mazoga) must also survive.
4. Difficulty must be left at 'default' (or harder).
What about making 0 weight enchanted clothing items, then reverse pickpocketing the gear on them? Does this count as a cheat or bug?
Actually, no. I wouldn't consider it to be cheating. I haven't tried it yet, myself. It strikes me that at lower levels it would be extremely difficult to pull off, as your sneak ability just isn't there yet.
Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 2:17 pm
by Paladin_Warrior
After one hassle after another with NPC's complaining to me that I've hit them (friendly fire, in the thick of the battle) I've decided to let as many of them die, and get out of my way, so that I can take care of business solo.
Is there any real benefit, reward or anything that comes if the majority survive?
Avoid the hassles - don't bother getting aid that turns out to be useless.
Note: 1st post of the day, after 2nd extra large coffee, so that might be tempering my response.

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 2:23 pm
by Caldyn_Blade
After one hassle after another with NPC's complaining to me that I've hit them (friendly fire, in the thick of the battle) I've decided to let as many of them die, and get out of my way, so that I can take care of business solo.
Have to say, I pretty much developed the same idea on these types of missions...they get in the way more than they help... If you could actually order them, that'd be another thing...but since they are so determined to rush in headfirst and die...I usually just let them do so after Kvatch.....

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 2:49 pm
by vondobeln
I would say that if you play on harder than normal difficulty you will be glad of their support in taking on the horde of daedras (especially if you arrive at Kvatch as a beginner magician or another "weak" character ) and then there's the satisfaction of succeeding in keeping avaryone alive, but other than that I don't know of any other benefits or rewards.
vD
Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 3:16 pm
by Sir Frederick Chook
I was AMAZED to finish that quest one time and find everyone had survived. I was playing a low level Nord battlemage, heavy armour, warhammer, default difficulty. I was a bit miffed, actually, as I was hoping for some of the Legionnaires' free steel-quality armour. My playstyle was just to rush the enemies and crush them with superior warhammery crushpower, then rest an hour to let everyone recuperate. Even Ilend Vonius survived!
Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 3:24 pm
by Caldyn_Blade
Well, everyone survived on my stab at it...except for the two I killed accidentally, lol...one of which was Ilend Vonius.
One other thing to try that fits the criteria... Have a few custom buff spells, cast them on the guys and use potions to restore magicka, then Charge!

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 3:39 pm
by Oathbreaker
Well, to be honest I haven't actively tried to keep EVERYONE alive yet. My first time playing the game before learning anything useful that would help me die less, I got stuck at the castle gate with scamps casting fireball at the legion soldiers and the town guards, lol. Once I finally figured out there was a compass thing at the bottom of the screen (I regret finding that... I really do) I figured out how to proceed, and when I entered the count's castle... a total of 3 people had died. This was at level 4 or 5 I believe.
I tried again with my redguard assassin character at level 17 (so far he's the most truly rp-ed character I've made so far), and there were so many frost atronachs and storm atronachs that have so much health that even with healing spells (why would an assassin heal soldiers? To raise their hopes of victory only to slay them as soon as they set foot in the castle of course.

) only 2 non-essentials survived no matter how many times I tried. Actually that was the ONLY time anyone non-essential survived.
I find that my well-leveled characters tend to cause mass death to the troops by the hands of the daedra. With my current character though I'm roleplaying him as though he DIDN'T start out in prison, and thus doesn't know anything about what's going on. By the time he does he should be a master of restoration and illusion, meaning I can paralyze, rally, demoralize, and heal to my heart's content. Actually I'm just gonna try doing a mass demoralize spell on the daedra and once they go off and running I plan on casting paralyze on every single guard that's alive with the intention of acting it out like they're so awestruck that the daedra are running away that they can't move.

That should help thin the herd so that more people can live.
Post Number 666, mwahahahaha!!!
Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2008 5:11 pm
by hypnotique1959
QUOTE:
Once I finally figured out there was a compass thing at the bottom of the screen (I regret finding that... I really do)
lol I forget about it all the time.....then i ask one of my kids what am I supposed to do and guess what the answer is??? Mom there is a compass on the screen .... USE it.

Ah well.
Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 1:40 am
by Ergukrael
Paladin_Warrior wrote:After one hassle after another with NPC's complaining to me that I've hit them (friendly fire, in the thick of the battle) I've decided to let as many of them die, and get out of my way, so that I can take care of business solo.
That's not very paladinish of you, Mr. Paladin.
Is there any real benefit, reward or anything that comes if the majority survive?
Nope. Just bragging rights and a clear conscience.
