Page 1 of 4

Oblivion best game ever?

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 4:38 pm
by bas237
Is Oblivion the best game ever?
Sure, it has some negative aspects. The graphics aren't outstanding, but still good for a game that is two years old.
And maybe the game is quite straight forward and maybe the AI isn't perfect, but what the hell, I've never seen such a realistic Medieval-look-a-like fantasy world in a game before.
Oblivion is the only game I've played for more then 1000 hours and the only game of which I've bought every guide/special edition box set/expansion packs/add-ons/etc.

So even with the fun I've had with games like Red Alert 2, Age of Empires II, Rome Total War and Battlefield 2 in my mind, I think this is the best game ever.
But what is your opinion?

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 4:45 pm
by Dunmer
I do think Oblivion is the best game ever. I have had it since it was released, and I still haven't got bored of it.

It's great!!!

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 4:52 pm
by Oathbreaker
I don't think it's the best game ever and here's why:

Final Fantasy VII

'nuff said.

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 5:25 pm
by weka
Best Game Ever!! :D

For me it's cause of the freedom. That and picking flowers!! :wink: :lol:

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 5:50 pm
by Dogmantra
Nope. It's good but not lore-friendly or anything really. I like to think of it as a seperate series, rather than in the same series as Morrowind.

The reason it's not the best game ever:

1. No multiplayer (even a 2-player co-op would be nice)
2. Morrowind.

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 6:04 pm
by bas237
When you compare vanilla Oblivion to Morrowind, Morrowind is better in some parts, like the variation in the landscape, but SI takes that aspect away.
Oblivion has better graphics, better sound, a better fighting system and the world is much more realistic. It's also a more modern RPG, which indeed is something you either like or hate.
Morrowind has more guilds and the main quest is better then the main quest in Oblivion, but even though Oblivion has only four guilds, the DB is so good that I don't really matter.
But it's your opinion.

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 6:24 pm
by Vesna
Reason it will soon not be the best game ever: Final Fantasy XIII is being released.

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 10:17 pm
by Dogmantra
basleijser wrote:a better fighting system
That is a load of rubbish, Morrowind has the better fighting system, or at least in my opinion.

Posted: Sun Apr 13, 2008 10:33 pm
by Fiar
No, while I'm in love with the TES series and Oblivion is an AWESOME game. I feel that it isn't the best, other games are coming, or are already out that have beat it out. For instance I think Fable 2 will beat it. RPG wise yes it's the best so far. Overall wise....no I have games that tie with it. As for games I own that beat it, I'll get back to you on that seeing as I ever have thought of it.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 1:11 am
by Ergukrael
weka wrote:Best Game Ever!! :D

For me it's cause of the freedom. That and picking flowers!! :wink: :lol:
I'd say the best "of its kind". And I like how with the PC version, we have modding options allowing some of the more creative players out there to share their tweaks with the rest of us.

Speaking of which, "Harvest Flora" by XmirroR is excellent if you like to pick flowers.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 6:13 am
by gregor
Plenty of good games out there... depends on what you are looking for. more story? other's have it. More variety in landscape, others have it.

I would say it is a descent game and it deserved that game of the year title it got.

but then you have Morrowind and like some said Finaly fantasy. i also hear Gothic is quite OK.

Then you have smaller but also interesting Arx Fatalis - where oyu can actually kill every one and still finish the main quest. Also it has an interesting way you do magic and the effects are way cooller than in Oblivion (despite being older game). And speaking of which it's not really propper to compare Oblivion with for example Ultima Underworld 1 & 2 which at the time had the best graphics. UW2 needed for the time staggering 16 MB of hard disk and 2 MB of RAM to run. But you could actually drop the object from the inventory, something we haven't seen in Morrowind.

Then we have the leveling system, which wasn't really done good in Oblivion. The game "punishes" you with stronger enemies if you use/increase speachcraft or mercantilism too much. WTF?!

All it all Oblivion is a very good game, but not really best game ever. i would put it in top 5 RPG games.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:12 am
by Doctor Meaticus
This game is great. I've had it for almost 2 years, and I aint bored yet. I've played some good games - Assassin's Creed, Dead Rising, Gears of War... the list goes on. But seriously, Oblivion takes the cake. All of the cake. That's how great it is. I probably wouldn't have considered it the best game until a few months ago, when for the first time, I stood on Dive Rock and just admired the hugeness of the game. There's not many other games in which you can do that - just stand and admire the entire game world.

So yeah, in my opinion, Oblivion is the greatest game ever made. The only true downside was body physics. I hated it when you butchered and then watched them literally 'float' to the ground.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 7:35 am
by WGalczak
Maybe I'm an old, creaky gray-haired man, but all I see listed here are modern games. Oblivion is a great game with a lot of content. Oblivion is very buggy, the models are very "clashy" and it isn't optimized very well. The leveling system is horrid. The game is beautiful, however I believe it isn't the best game ever. In terms of AMOUNT OF CONTENT it's up there with San Andreas and those sort of games. Deus Ex is easily the best game, ever,... ever. There's a lot of older games that are as good as oblivion in the "suck-you-in" element. For the sort of person that STARTED on an Xbox, perhaps this is the best game ever for them.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:31 am
by Matti1
If we speak about RPG's, Oblivion is de best game. (personal opinion). No RPG can match oblivion on the pc. The Freedom, non-linear gameplay, superior graphics, lots of quest, The endless option for the look of your character, the battle experience. I'm think I've played more than 1000 hours, and I'm still not bored.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 8:32 am
by Ravey
My favourite game is still Little Big Adventure 2. 8)

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 9:27 am
by Oathbreaker
gregor wrote:...but then you have Morrowind and like some said Finaly fantasy. i also hear Gothic is quite OK.

-----------------------------v----------------------------

All it all Oblivion is a very good game, but not really best game ever. i would put it in top 5 RPG games.
So.. if you say Final Fantasy is better than Oblivion... that kind of takes up a good 12+ spaces... (Include X-2, Tactics, Tactics Advance, Chronicles and Crystal Chronicles and that makes 17)... How is Ob still in the top 5? :?

Anyway, lol... sorry, that just caught my attention. But as for combat... if they applied more of Morrowind's combat (certainly not the "if your sword goes straight through the creature you still missed" aspect), but maybe a greater variety of what you could do with the weapons... being able to make normal strikes more powerful instead of resorting to slower power attacks... etc etc. Morrowind and Oblivion kind of even out in terms of combat system. Morrowind had much greater depth of story and lore, and had they made Morrowind to see off farther in the distance (I saw somewhere someone actually managed to put together what landscapes would actually look like without the fog-out effect... not sure if there's a mod for it or not though) then it would make it even more fantastic.

As for gameplay... it actually is very linear... maybe not in your options, but once you choose an option, it's a straight line from there on. (i.e. guilds) In Morrowind, you still had options within the guild that far outmatch the freedom of Oblivion. (Where the hell is Tourist? He could do this way better than me) Oblivion certainly isn't a bad game, but though they made it good, they left out every aspect that would've made it perfect.

Oh, and the thing about SI taking away Morrowind's claim to greater landscape variations... how does that work? SI is composed of two different landscapes. Sure there are variations in colors all over the place, but that's just how the individual landscape was made. There's still only two landscapes you can choose from there. (Although the progression of the Greymarch adds the whole Crystal Obelisk thing going on... the only place it really affects is that small outskirt town that you enter SI from, and that goes back to normal once you beat Jyggalag) Morrowind still had much greater variety.

But that's just between those two games... and neither Oblivion nor Morrowind has any type of character development aside from your own single character. Sure a character you do a quest for might in some way be affected by what you did for them (or to them), but does it show from then on? Can you tell they made the change? (In Morrowind there are a couple instances when you can, but compared to the population of Vvardenfell, it's kind of insignificant) And your character doesn't develop at all unless you hardcore roleplay him/her out. The only development is with your stats. Games like Final Fantasy utterly wipe the floor with Oblivion in this department.

Oh back to the combat system... of any game I've played with a free-ish combat system such as Oblivion, Assassin's Creed did it best (certainly not perfect, but it was more varied than Oblivion and loads more precise than Morrowind).

In my opinion (as biased as it may or may not be), Star Ocean 2 has one of the greatest RPG combat systems ever created. And in terms of character development, even though the ending scripts are very similar to eachother, the developers showed that you could develop relationships between your characters that had lasting effects for the rest of their lives. 81 endings is nothing to cough at.

Anyways, I still say Final Fantasy VII is the greatest game ever created (if for no other reason than it's story and plot). And the only games that really come close are Valkyrie Profile (the original I actually consider equal with FFVII, but not the PSP version or 2) Kingdom Hearts (on equal footing with the other FF's besides VII), Star Ocean 2, Fable, KOTOR/Jade Empire, and Morrowind (I haven't played Arena or Daggerfall, so I can't judge them, and though I'd say Assassin's Creed came much closer than Oblivion, the tweaking required would take a lot of time-- even though there's not much to be done to make it perfect, just time consuming to develop-- and thus it's on about equal footing as Oblivion). The reason why I include Fable is because it would have taken the cake altogether, but the developer left out too much and slightly screwed up how a couple things were implemented. Fable 2 claims to have all those fixes and more though, so here's hoping. Oh, and I almost forgot... not many people will agree with this, but the Xenosaga series (aside from the voice changes they made in 2... grrr...) was also very good in my opinion. Ugh... and now the memories come flooding back.... the Jak and Daxter series (not the Daxter game on the PSP), Devil May Cry series, the FIRST Summoner game, and Valkyrie Profile 2 (if you can appreciate the story and ignore the minor gameplay flaws) are all also very good. And please say MMO's are left out of this discussion... that's another two paragraphs at least....

On a final note... Deus Ex rocked... if only the sequal lived up to its predecessor. (I still don't think it's the best though)

(I'm sorry for the long-winded judgmentalness but sometimes I just can't help myself)

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:26 am
by Dogmantra
Doctor Meaticus wrote:There's not many other games in which you can do that - just stand and admire the entire game world.
*COUGH* Morrowind *cough*

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:28 am
by Ravey
All games have gameplay, but not every game has a story - So you really have to judge them seperately. Similarly, you can't really compare genres... You can't say the best game is for example, an RPG, there are a lot of gamers who don't like RPGs at all. Anyone's opinion is always going to be subjective based on their own experiences, no one has played every game and there is always a bias towards games they've played affected by the range of games they've played, favourite genre, their age, the time period, etc.

If there was a best game, it would probably be something generic that everyone would enjoy - At the same time it probably wouldn't be everyone's favourite game because the point is that gamers explore genres to get more of what they like to play...

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:36 am
by Dogmantra
Ravey wrote:something generic that everyone would enjoy
Er... scrabble?

Officially, the best Nintendo game ever is LoZ Ocarina of Time but I don't like it as much as the game that came (I think) 3rd... so there's always going to be disagreement. As for the best game I've played, well, most games I play are RPGs so out of them, I'd have to say Morrowind, the Lionheart, then Oblivion

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:42 am
by gregor
Ravey wrote: If there was a best game, it would probably be something generic that everyone would enjoy - At the same time it probably wouldn't be everyone's favourite game because the point is that gamers explore genres to get more of what they like to play...
yeah, such as Pong or Space invaders. :) No matter how old they are, they are still fun to play with. Or if you are into strategy - chess is a good way to consume some free time...

Uf as for RPG how did we forget Diablo 2? - still played on the net and LAN parties after all these years since it came out...
So.. if you say Final Fantasy is better than Oblivion... that kind of takes up a good 12+ spaces... (Include X-2, Tactics, Tactics Advance, Chronicles and Crystal Chronicles and that makes 17)... How is Ob still in the top 5?
you are talking about a series, while i was talking about games mentioned in posts before mine.

i never played the other ones you mentioned, so i am not able to put them in my list which just shows how different experience people have. for example i didn't have the time to play any latest games due to the studies. i did play some old games back when i was in Highschool. it's a long time ago now and i probably have completely different list as a result.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:43 am
by bas237
gregor wrote:Plenty of good games out there... depends on what you are looking for. more story? other's have it. More variety in landscape, others have it.

I would say it is a descent game and it deserved that game of the year title it got.

but then you have Morrowind and like some said Finaly fantasy. i also hear Gothic is quite OK.

Then you have smaller but also interesting Arx Fatalis - where oyu can actually kill every one and still finish the main quest. Also it has an interesting way you do magic and the effects are way cooller than in Oblivion (despite being older game). And speaking of which it's not really propper to compare Oblivion with for example Ultima Underworld 1 & 2 which at the time had the best graphics. UW2 needed for the time staggering 16 MB of hard disk and 2 MB of RAM to run. But you could actually drop the object from the inventory, something we haven't seen in Morrowind.

Then we have the leveling system, which wasn't really done good in Oblivion. The game "punishes" you with stronger enemies if you use/increase speachcraft or mercantilism too much. WTF?!

All it all Oblivion is a very good game, but not really best game ever. i would put it in top 5 RPG games.
Oblivion only "punishes" you with having Speechcraft/Mercantile as major skills if it are the only skills you're using. But you've got to choose 7 major skills so you can use Blade/Blunt/Marksman/Hand2Hand as well and that will increase your Strength and thus makes you stronger.
So it's completely your fault and not Bethesda's if you get owned when only using Speech/Merc. It's realistic.

And sure you can say things like "Crysis has better graphics", "World of Warcraft has more quests", "Fable 2 has a better story", but then you're comparing the negative aspects of Oblivion to the positive ones of other games, which is not fair.
You must compare the entire game with another one.
For example: Gothic 3 is nice, but it has loads of bugs and you don't have as many options as in Oblivion (for example: you can't create your own character, you've got to play with a default one).

Because saying that other games have better spells than Oblivion doesn't mean the entire game is better.
And what do you want to do? Do you want to play over 10 games just because one of its features is better then Oblivion? So you play WoW for the quests, Gothic 3 for the enemies, Morrowind for the landscape, Fable II for the story and so on??

I think Oblivion is the best game ever because when you compare it to other games, it has more points in which it is better then points in which is it worser.
And sure there will be new games in the future that are better then Oblivion, but right now, I think Oblivion is the best we've seen until now.
For the RPG section, sure, for all the games that has ever been released, perhaps.
But hey, it's only my opinion. You may have another one.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 10:59 am
by Oathbreaker
I get what you're saying about comparing the negative of one game to the good of the other, but you did that yourself just now by saying Gothic doesn't have as many options as Oblivion. When people compare games to decide which they like best, there has to be that kind of give and take. You choose the game you like better overall, but you don't choose the other because of the negatives it has.

Oblivion is an all around good game... it's just not great.

Oh... and yeah... I'm one of those people that plays all the different games for what they have to offer that I like. I have lots more free time than should be possible due to my college homework and whatnot, so I tend to use all of it that I have when I'm not hanging with people to play them. When I feel like slashing things up with lots of action-y style, I throw in something like Devil May Cry, when I want to have a good story told to me, I throw in something like Final Fantasy, and when I want to appease my OCD-ish tendencies of perfectionism, I toss in Morrowind or Oblivion. (or load my "perfect" saves from other games and go all out making sure I've done absolutely everything I possibly can as early as I possibly can)

I really wanna see one of Tourist's walls of criticisms of Oblivion... lol.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 2:09 pm
by bas237
You think it's just not great.

I think it is great because of how the game is overall.

But for the rest I've got to agree with you.

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 2:45 pm
by Struck
Yep best game...love it....its free and its huge and takes time...great game

Sure theres some things i would like to change...multi-player for example...mods for PS3...and change/fix a few bugs...get better steering on teh horse etc

It will still be best game on the list if Bethesda make TES V...and not have it as an MMORPG

But scratching all those things...I sure dam hell love that game :D...and this forum ofc

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2008 3:46 pm
by The Tourist
Ah.. how could I miss an opportunity to come down on Oblivion! :D

No, of course it's not the best game ever. Best First-Person Role Player? Obviously, because it had the biggest budget, and a long lineage of titles from which to develop/evolve from.

As far as iconic impact goes? FFVII takes the crown.
As far as actual quality, verve, imagination, perfection of game-engine? Only one game stands head-and-shoulders above all else; Half-Life 2...

...oh, and of course hardcore-MW has training-wheels-Ob beaten on multiple fronts, so Ob's not even the most accomplished game in the TES series.