Page 1 of 1

Sneak/Archer good for Morrowind?

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 8:51 pm
by Agent
Hey everyone. I just got Morrowind GOTY for my PC after my 360 red-ringed on me. I've always enjoyed playing the Thief/Assassin type characters but I'm not to sure if it works all that well. I assumed it worked great in Oblivion because it was a much more advanced game but since Morrowind is a few years old I'm not sure if the technology could actually make sneaking work effectively. Also, I've tried archers on Morrowind before and it seems like even if the arrows hit they never do damage. Dose anyone know if its fun to be a sneak/archer in Morrowind or will I just be screwing myself over if I try?

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 9:10 pm
by Sublymonal
Sneak is a nice skill, but it doesn't have much use in morrowind. You can't steal anything really good anyway. I like archery, but there comes a point where the bows are just too weak. Unless you make your own [I did, using the Widow Maker crossbow mod as the base item] that can rival the power of the more powerful swords, you will eventually get rid of the bow. The bows are very handy for dispatching those annoying cliff racers, and dealing damage without getting hurt yourself.

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 9:10 pm
by Caz
well it really depends on how good you are at it, i guess. if you start out with someone with archery as a major skill and possibly a race with a bonus then you won't have any problems. same goes for sneaking. it also helps to make sure your attributes go with your skills.

i don't know how well you know morrowind already, but these are things i go by:
if the skills are low at the beginning i wouldn't bother with them at all, but i find if you want to sneak well it has to at least be a minor skill, and the weapon skill should always be a major.

if you post you're stats it might be easier for people to give advice :wink:

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 1:29 am
by ragged-gothic
My experience, for whatever that’s worth to you, has been totally different. Every character I have ever created which focused on the sneak skill in some way found it extremely and repeatedly useful. Conversely, every time I’ve created a character which didn’t have sneak as a primary/secondary skill and which was also conscientiously developed, I have learned to regret it. I honestly cannot think of a single exception.

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 2:50 am
by Agent
Caz wrote:if you post you're stats it might be easier for people to give advice :wink:
Well mine isn't all that exciting. I've never been to good at making my own classes so I picked the pre-set one "Thief" so it has all of those skills. I picked a female Bosmer as my race so she has all the advantages of a wood elf. 15 to Marksmen, Athletics, Sneak, all that good stuff. I've tried it out so far and its really nice but I want to make the perfect sneaking character for morrowind. I really haven't had much experience with it so i just want to be sure I'm doing everything right.

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 4:54 am
by ragged-gothic
Agent wrote: Well mine isn't all that exciting. I've never been to good at making my own classes so I picked the pre-set one "Thief" so it has all of those skills. I picked a female Bosmer as my race so she has all the advantages of a wood elf. 15 to Marksmen, Athletics, Sneak, all that good stuff. I've tried it out so far and its really nice but I want to make the perfect sneaking character for morrowind. I really haven't had much experience with it so i just want to be sure I'm doing everything right.
You bring up a whole series of interesting points in this post, Agent. I hope that my response, which, I think, will speak more to the philosophy behind different directions in character creation, doesn’t stray too far from the more concrete concepts involved. (Things like, frex, “is agent a better stealth class than acrobat”, or “should one make sneak a major or minor skill for a custom character”.) I also hope that you, and others, might find something useful in my musings. :oops:

The first thing that leaps out at me from Agent’s post is the stated desire “to make the perfect sneaking character for morrowind.” The question of a “perfect morrowind character” of any sort is a difficult one to parse, since any character in morrowind will be doing many different sorts of things besides focusing whatever skill one seeks perfection at. Is a scout a better sneaking character than an acrobat...depends entirely on where one is planning on having that character do most of his/her adventuring, an urban or rural setting. And every morrowind character is almost certain to visit both in the course of their career.

There a lots of different philosophies of character creation, and, because the advantages of class specialization really make most difference in the character’s early career (for instance, my recent over-matched, magic-specialized character; were he 10th, or even 5th level, he would probably have had abilities and spells to at least escape, if not triumph), there are lots of different strategies for maximizing the effectiveness of skills in character development. Here is an example: a character gains levels much more quickly (and so meets more dangerous foes more quickly) when (s)he develops skills that are on his/her primary and secondary lists. Once a character reaches a level of general functionality, it might be better in the long term to have the skills you are most interested in as miscellaneous, rather than primary or secondary! Counterintuitive? Maybe, but think for a second about this: If your 10th lvl character (magic or combat oriented in his/her earliest levels) decides to be come a stealth-master, you can have him train/practice stealth skills many, many times before going up in level, as miscellaneous skills don’t help leveling much. Not only will that character become a much better sneaker before (s)he becomes 11th level, chances are, when (s)he does level, (s)he’ll have put so much effort into stealth skills that the related stats will have a ×4 or ×5 bonus as well! Focusing this way, the character might sneak like a barrel of rocks rolling down hill at 2nd level, but might be as stealthy as any thief, scout or assassin in mid levels, and even be moreso as further levels accumulate. They will then face weaker ninja monkeys on their adventures and have a bonus of magical or combat skills to help them as well. The difference is whether one is playing for a shorter or longer term advantage. (And, there are probably counter arguments to this approach I also haven’t foreseen; such is the nature of morrowind.)

I understand Agent wanting “to be sure I'm doing everything right.” Unfortunately, when the game is as open, and has as many variable stratagems available, “right” quickly dissolves into tactical approach and even taste. I would, I suppose, advise to try different formulae and work out which works best for how you want to play the character, and when (in the character’s development) you think the character needs to, or ought to, focus on particular abilities.

Finally, just an observation on pre-set classes, as opposed to custom ones. One good compromise, I find, is to look at the pre-set classes first, think about which one you would like to play, and then look at all the skills. Decide if there is a skill, or a small number of skills that you think might be better suited to a pre-set class than have been awarded in the pre-set design, and make a custom class accordingly: an almost-thief, or an almost-mage, for example. You might, say, look at rogue and decide that speechcraft should be a major skill, not minor, or that rogues would be more effective with acrobatics or sneak among their preferred skills, rather than athletics. This way you can build a custom class that really does what you want it to do, without losing the helpful direction that using a pre-set class gives in character creation.

I hope that these ramblings have cleared some of the water, not just muddied it further. :?

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 5:31 am
by Brucinater
^^gothic, if you put all your paragraphs into a book, it would be like war and peace 0.o

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 5:43 am
by Agent
Thanks a lot gothic! Not only was that post really informative but I'll definitely be taking most, if not all of your points into consideration next time I try to make a Morrowind character. I guess you can't have a perfect character in Morrowind just as you couldn't in Oblivion. Morrowind just seemed like an incredibly broader and more robust challenge than Oblivion so I thought having the best possible sneak character would make the game a bit lighter on the shoulders, or even, less scarier (yeah, Morrowind actually gets pretty scary knowing it's not level-based).

I see your point in the custom character creation as well. I've tried before in Oblivion to make characters I liked by basing them on cretin pre-set classes but in the end I ended up getting bludgeoned in the head by Daedra maces and cooked up by spells far too quickly. Most likely due to my own error. Thanks a lot for the advice though. I'm sure I can cook up a great class in no time.

I'm really grateful for your response! It's definitely one of the most informative and well said responses I've ever read. I'll definitely keep this post in mind as I make my new character! Thanks again!

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 5:55 am
by ragged-gothic
Wow!
:oops: :oops: :oops:
What a generous, complementary response.
Thanks very much! :D :D :D

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 10:32 am
by KJR1012
Not sure that I can really add anything to ragged-gothic's post, but my last character was a Bosmeri archer-ranger, and she was a lot of fun to play.

I used several archery-based mods, including Area Effect Arrows, 100 Projectilie Store Chance, Nerena the Archer, Suran Archery Tradehouse, and Corv's Ultimate Ranger mod. Plus another one that I'm forgetting right now.

Having the ability to make your own bows and arrows was pretty neat.

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 10:34 am
by r  
^ I had a similar character, ie a Bosmer ranger/archer, who was excellent fun. Marksman is a very good skill once you train it high enough - under 50 it's a bit unreliable but once you're over 50 and have a decent bow you can start nailing Cliff Racers from 500 yards away which is one of life's most satisfying things.

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 10:43 pm
by ragged-gothic
Just one more point to add: I don’t know if others have experienced this, but I have found that aiming slightly above one’s target with marksman weapons makes generally for a more accurate shot than placing the cross-hairs directly on the thing one is shooting at. I’ve noticed this with both bows and crossbows.

Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 12:48 am
by Agent
ragged-gothic wrote:Just one more point to add: I don’t know if others have experienced this, but I have found that aiming slightly above one’s target with marksman weapons makes generally for a more accurate shot than placing the cross-hairs directly on the thing one is shooting at. I’ve noticed this with both bows and crossbows.
I've noticed this too. I've just been wondering even if arrows clearly hit their target, why don't they do damage? I'm positive I'm hitting them. Maybe it's only because I'm using Chitin Bows and Arrows. I'm sure I'll find a solution.

Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 4:26 am
by Brucinater
It's one of the crappy parts of morrowinds fighting system, half the time you don't do damage when you directly hit it. It gets easier as your skills get higher.

Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 8:29 am
by KJR1012
ragged-gothic wrote:Just one more point to add: I don’t know if others have experienced this, but I have found that aiming slightly above one’s target with marksman weapons makes generally for a more accurate shot than placing the cross-hairs directly on the thing one is shooting at. I’ve noticed this with both bows and crossbows.
Yeah, that's a little physics put into the game. Heavier arrows drop faster than lighter ones, but you only see a real difference at long ranges. If you're on uneven ground (your target is uphill or downhill of you), you'll need to adjust more. I've also found that aiming a hair to the right of the target helps, too.

With thrown weapons, you need to aim well above the target at longer ranges.

Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:38 am
by r  
ragged-gothic wrote:Just one more point to add: I don’t know if others have experienced this, but I have found that aiming slightly above one’s target with marksman weapons makes generally for a more accurate shot than placing the cross-hairs directly on the thing one is shooting at. I’ve noticed this with both bows and crossbows.
Well yes, that's the basic principle of ballistics. Also crossbow bolts plummet after about 50 yards because traditionally crossbows are short-range weapons.

Posted: Fri Apr 25, 2008 9:53 am
by nordicay
On the usefulness of sneak & marksman:
LOL This latest chacter of mine took out an ascended sleeper while she was level 2, using sneak & marksman. I fired at him across a ravine while in constant sneak mode, he never could find me, though I give it to him, he tried (assuming ascended sleepers are he's.... a bit difficult to tell, really).

I always play a bosmer, with marksman being at least a minor skill. Sneak I usually don't take as a major or minor... I use it often enough that it will cause my characters to level up too fast.

Anyway, I love killing from afar... no damage to take, no armor to repair afterwards. Once you're good enough at it (my experience has been level 30 minimum), you can take out enemies as they run up to you, long before they ever become a threat... or at elast do them serious damage that a single blow in contact melee will drop them for good.

Sneak I use pretty much whenever I'm in hostile territory... it allows my character that chance mentioned above to drop the enemy before they even see you coming. Another thing I tend to do (when sneak is high enough) is sneak right up to an enemy, take myself off sneak and immediately engage the NPC in conversation... lol it's good practice for your speechcraft skills, and who cares if their disposition drops to 0? They're going to attack you as soon as you exit the conversation anyway, whether or not you bring their disposition up to 100. Plus, you get to have interesting conversations with things like Dagoth's that way.

I disagree with the comment about there not being anything good to steal with a high sneak skill... I've stolen a master's albemic? (the item Big Helend asks you to find for a quest, can't recall now which alchemy apparatus it is) from a shop, with both the shop owner & guard standing right next to me... never detected :D Now, THAT is a rush.... it's all about the sleight of hand (and timing, of course!)