Page 1 of 1
fire/schock/frost shield vs shield
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 4:49 pm
by XPredator 7
I don't get it, there's a sigil stone 20%shield and one 25% fire shield.
What's the point of taking the first one ?
For an example : you have 50 armor, you use :
shield sigil stone you have 60
fire shield sigil stone you have 62.5 and resist fire
Am i wrong here ?
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:31 pm
by akatosh
For an example : you have 50 armor, you use :
shield sigil stone you have 60
fire shield sigil stone you have 62.5 and resist fire
Should't it be:
you have 50 armor
shield SS: 70
fireshield SS: 75 + 25% resist fire?
In either way, the elemental shield SS is better than the shield SS.
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:39 pm
by Deandra
Akatosh is correct; shield effects are calculated additively instead of multiplicatively. And yes, elemental shield sigil stones are terrific. They are one of my favorite choices for armor/clothing enchantments.
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:45 pm
by akatosh
Yes they are awesome. I use those sigil stones on my daedric armor to get 85 armour rating while using claymores.
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 9:23 pm
by XPredator 7
why do neutral shield stones exist then ? At least give them more shield
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 9:31 pm
by Oathbreaker
They exist to add a greater selection of sigil stones. Since they're randomly generated when you pick them up, some players could go an entire game of closing gates without seeing a single elemental shield stone. Not likely, but possible. And considering not all players close all 60 gates, there's a very high probability that most players would only get one elemental shield stone, so the game basically balances itself out. And if you found a shield stone that adds 20 before you found an elemental shield stone that adds 25, wouldn't you be tempted to use it?
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 9:44 pm
by Deandra
Of course, if you don't mind metagaming, you can just quicksave your game before grabbing the stone, then reloading until you get the one you want.
why do neutral shield stones exist then ? At least give them more shield
Short answer: because the game isn't perfectly balanced. It's likely an oversight.
Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 9:48 pm
by Oathbreaker
Deandra wrote:Of course, if you don't mind metagaming, you can just quicksave your game before grabbing the stone, then reloading until you get the one you want.
Shhhhh, I didn't mention that for a reason.

Posted: Tue Mar 25, 2008 11:46 pm
by Dark Spark
I think it was a minor oversight on the programmers' part.
Resist Magic 20% — the catch-all resistance to all destructive spells cast at you. Resist Magic provides a wide spectrum of protection, so you don't want to make it too powerful lest it becomes a game-breaker.
Resist Fire 35% — now, a resistance to only one particular element is another story. You trade off increased protection from one form of attack by having no protection from any of the other elements. Fair trade, in a sense.
Now, what to do with Fire Shield? It provides protection from one element and adds armor. You don't want it as weak as Resist Magic 20 because it only protects from one element, not all three. You don't want it as strong as Resist Fire 35 because no one would choose it if they can get some armor protection as well. So, you compromise on the strength: Fire Shield 25%. Looks about right: it's between the low-strength omnipotency of Resist Magic and the high-strength esoteric defense of Resist Fire. All is well.
"But what about Shield?" asks some desk-monkey at Bethesda. Oh, Shield is a generic defense spell like Resist Magic, yeah? Then make the Shield stone as strong as the Resist Magic stone: 20%! We're done for the day, cheese for everyone!
Posted: Wed Mar 26, 2008 3:44 am
by Oathbreaker
Dark Spark wrote:I think it was a minor oversight on the programmers' part.
Resist Magic 20% — the catch-all resistance to all destructive spells cast at you. Resist Magic provides a wide spectrum of protection, so you don't want to make it too powerful lest it becomes a game-breaker.
Resist Fire 35% — now, a resistance to only one particular element is another story. You trade off increased protection from one form of attack by having no protection from any of the other elements. Fair trade, in a sense.
Now, what to do with Fire Shield? It provides protection from one element and adds armor. You don't want it as weak as Resist Magic 20 because it only protects from one element, not all three. You don't want it as strong as Resist Fire 35 because no one would choose it if they can get some armor protection as well. So, you compromise on the strength: Fire Shield 25%. Looks about right: it's between the low-strength omnipotency of Resist Magic and the high-strength esoteric defense of Resist Fire. All is well.
"But what about Shield?" asks some desk-monkey at Bethesda. Oh, Shield is a generic defense spell like Resist Magic, yeah? Then make the Shield stone as strong as the Resist Magic stone: 20%! We're done for the day, cheese for everyone!
What if some of us don't like cheese?

It would still be a party to we that don't like it.
(Dumb lazy oversights)
Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 8:05 am
by Maverick80
Sorry guys but I still don't get it. I keep reading everywhere that an elemental shield is better than a normal shield because element adds to both elemental resistence and armor rating, whereas shield only adds to armor rating.
It would be great if that was indeed the case but I do not see this happening in my game. If I enchant a ring or piece of clothing with, for instance, a 10% fire shield and wear this item I do not see any change in armor rating at all. I just see the 10% fire shield in my active effects.
Am I doing something wrong or was this same kind of bug that everybody was happy that existed but might be corrected in one of the unofficial patches that I do indeed have installed (next to many other mods).
Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 7:37 pm
by Zetal
Screenshot.
Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 8:00 pm
by Alien
Maverick80 wrote:Sorry guys but I still don't get it. I keep reading everywhere that an elemental shield is better than a normal shield because element adds to both elemental resistence and armor rating, whereas shield only adds to armor rating.
It would be great if that was indeed the case but I do not see this happening in my game. If I enchant a ring or piece of clothing with, for instance, a 10% fire shield and wear this item I do not see any change in armor rating at all. I just see the 10% fire shield in my active effects.
Am I doing something wrong or was this same kind of bug that everybody was happy that existed but might be corrected in one of the unofficial patches that I do indeed have installed (next to many other mods).
It's a bug, try equiping it, then go to your armor rating. If you equip then exit the inventory, then it won't show it adding anything to your armor.
Posted: Sat Jul 19, 2008 7:27 am
by Maverick80
found out what the problem was. I was confusing "resist fire"with "fire shield". The former indeed does not add to armor while the latter does.