Skyrim Vs. The Aldmeri Dominion
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 4:00 am
Could Skyrim Stand up to the Aldmeri Dominion?
Let me start out by saying this is a non-biased. I will only used well established fact and lore taken as canon as stated by USESP-Wiki. Now let’s get the ball rolling.
Part I - Military Might
The Empire
Although the size of an Imperial Legion is never given, it is safe to assume, however that a single legion could be comprised of approximately 5,000 soldiers as this was the size of the average Roman Legion., and as we all know the Imperial Legion was inspired by the Roman Legion. The number of Legions is not known, however they were numbered and the highest numbered legion was the 18th Legion which was mentioned in the book “The Infernal City.” With these numbers, a safe bet would be that the Imperial Legion is no smaller than 90,000 soldiers. This does not however include Naval Forces, which played a large part of the Great War.
The Aldmeri Dominion
Considering the Aldmeri Dominion was fought to a standstill during the Great War, it is safe to assume that the Empire and the Dominion are a relatively match for each other as far as military strength. It is likely that the Dominion has a larger Naval Force than the Empire due to it being a mostly coastal/Island Empire. This may give the Dominion an advantage at Sea,
The Stormcloaks
According to the USEP Wiki the entire population of Skyrim is 483. This is including all races and ages across the entire Province. By sheer weight of numbers even if Ulfric managed to rally the entire province together, the Aldmeri Dominion would obliterate them. However, this is from a game code perspective. If you looked at the game code for Oblivion or Morrowind, there are over 2,000 NPC’s total per game. It is highly unlikely that these are the actual populations of these provinces; otherwise a 90,000 solider strong army would be impossible. Skyrim, from a lore perspective could have a population of 20,000-25,000 as 2 entire Imperial Legions consisted solely of Nords, and Nords made up a considerable part of the entire Imperial Legions forces, so if Skyrim became Independent, a large majority of those Nords may fight for Skyrim instead of the Empire. However, Skyrim as little to no Naval force to speak of, making a direct attack on Summerset Isle suicidal.
Part 2 - Geography of Tamriel
Skyrim
Skyrim is surrounded by the Velothi Mountains to the East, The Druadach Mountains to the west, and the Jerall Mountains to the South. Only two passes exists through any of these mountains into the surrounding provinces. Dunmeth Pass leads through the Velothi Mountains into Morrowind (Which by the way is neutral in this conflict and unless the Dominion wants war with them too, they would most likely not send a significant force through) and the Pale Pass Connecting Skyrim to Cyrodiil (again, currently at peace, the Empire would not let a massive invasion force just waltz right through their heart). The Sea of Ghosts boarders Skyrim to the north and forms a barrier almost as impenetrable as the mountains, since that area of Skyrim is likely frozen year round due to the high latitude of Skyrim on Nirn; Making Ice sheets and Icebergs a permanent and dangerous obstacle for anyone traveling the Sea.
High Rock
With no direct pass into Skyrim, it is unlikely the Dominion would consider invading Skyrim through it. Plus, it is still part of the Empire, and it is unlikely the Empire would the Dominion just march an Invasion force inside their borders.
Hammerfell
Hammerfell would be a bad place to land any number of Aldmeri forces, as they would have to fight their way through the province to get to Skyrim, not to mention the Alik’r Dessert would be a major obstacle.
Morrowind
Currently, the Argonians control both Morrowind and Black Marsh, and with the eruption of Red Mountain, Most of Vvardenfell was left either uninhabitable or outright destroyed. This could allow for the Dominion to make use of the Dunmeth Pass, but this would risk a war with the Argonians, not to mention the length the supply lines would have to be.
Black Marsh
Inhabited by the Argonians, and comprised primarily of swamp, it would be a logistical nightmare to move troops through, not to mention risk of war with the Argonians.
Cyrodiil
Two-thirds of the Dominion already borders Cyrodiil to the South, and with the shorter supply lines by comparison, may be the only viable option for an invasion of Skyrim. However, Like High Rock, it is unlikely the Empire would sit back and let an invasion force walk right through the heart of the Empire to Skyrim.
The Sea of Ghosts
The Sea of Ghosts is up there with Cyrodiil as the only real viable location from which to invade Skyrim. Given the environmental barrier though, it could cost the Dominion many ships just getting there. Even then, the only 2 viable landing locations are Dawnstar and Solitude. Solitude, being the Capital of Skyrim, would like be more heavily defended than Dawnstar so it more likely the Dominion would invade from Dawnstar.
Part 3 – Climate and Fighting Conditions
The Climate of the Dominion consists of the Tropical Summerset Isle, the warm rainforests of Valenwood, and the harsh desserts of Elswyer. Skyrim is a cold and bitter. The Aldmeri troops are used to fighting in the temperate climate of Cyrodiil. If you look at the way Napoleon fought in Russia, more of his men froze and starved to death than were killed by Russians. The Stormcloaks could employ a similar strategy to the Russians and let a cold Skyrim winter freeze out the Dominion.
However the reverse is true of the Nords of Skyrim. They would suffer in the same way as the Confederate troops did in the American Civil War. They wore Wool and Cotton Clothing in a climate that was too hot for such clothing and many suffered and died from heat exhaustion and dehydration.
Part 4 – Defending Skyrim
Invasion from Dawnstar
Let’s say the Dominion invaded from the Sea of Ghost into Dawnstar, They would obviously be met with opposition by the Stormcloaks, but they would only have 2 places they could really go. The path to Winterhold is blocked by mountains, they pass south to Whiterun is a bottleneck, and the way west runs into the swamps outside of Morthal, where re-enforcements from Solitude could pin the Dominions Troops against the Sea.
Invasion from Solitude
While it would be easier to avoid ice invading from Solitude, the Dominions troops would have nowhere to go except through the marshes outside of Morthal, as going east would funnel them toward Whiterun and Windhelm, where soldiers from those cities could pin them in the mountains. Solitude would be much harder to capture than Dawnstar to begin with as it lies on the edge of a cliff, and the Dominion could only attack it from the south.
Part 5 – Wild Cards
The Dragonborn
The Dragonborn is by far the wildest of the Wild cards. It is completely up to the player has to whom he/she would support. However if the Dragonborn was on the Stormcloaks side, he/she could be a game changer.
The Greybeards
The Greybeards vow never to interfere, especially in war and politics. However if the Dominion threatened them it is unlikely they would let themselves be destroyed.
The College of Winterhold
Like the Greybeards, they rarely interfere with politics or war, however if they fell under attack by the Dominion, they would most certainty retaliate.
Conclusion
Given the statements above, It is quite clear that although Skyrim may be capable of defending itself against the Aldmeri Dominion, it is unlikely they would be able to muster the strength needed to destroy the Dominion as Ulfric claims.
Let me start out by saying this is a non-biased. I will only used well established fact and lore taken as canon as stated by USESP-Wiki. Now let’s get the ball rolling.
Part I - Military Might
The Empire
Although the size of an Imperial Legion is never given, it is safe to assume, however that a single legion could be comprised of approximately 5,000 soldiers as this was the size of the average Roman Legion., and as we all know the Imperial Legion was inspired by the Roman Legion. The number of Legions is not known, however they were numbered and the highest numbered legion was the 18th Legion which was mentioned in the book “The Infernal City.” With these numbers, a safe bet would be that the Imperial Legion is no smaller than 90,000 soldiers. This does not however include Naval Forces, which played a large part of the Great War.
The Aldmeri Dominion
Considering the Aldmeri Dominion was fought to a standstill during the Great War, it is safe to assume that the Empire and the Dominion are a relatively match for each other as far as military strength. It is likely that the Dominion has a larger Naval Force than the Empire due to it being a mostly coastal/Island Empire. This may give the Dominion an advantage at Sea,
The Stormcloaks
According to the USEP Wiki the entire population of Skyrim is 483. This is including all races and ages across the entire Province. By sheer weight of numbers even if Ulfric managed to rally the entire province together, the Aldmeri Dominion would obliterate them. However, this is from a game code perspective. If you looked at the game code for Oblivion or Morrowind, there are over 2,000 NPC’s total per game. It is highly unlikely that these are the actual populations of these provinces; otherwise a 90,000 solider strong army would be impossible. Skyrim, from a lore perspective could have a population of 20,000-25,000 as 2 entire Imperial Legions consisted solely of Nords, and Nords made up a considerable part of the entire Imperial Legions forces, so if Skyrim became Independent, a large majority of those Nords may fight for Skyrim instead of the Empire. However, Skyrim as little to no Naval force to speak of, making a direct attack on Summerset Isle suicidal.
Part 2 - Geography of Tamriel
Skyrim
Skyrim is surrounded by the Velothi Mountains to the East, The Druadach Mountains to the west, and the Jerall Mountains to the South. Only two passes exists through any of these mountains into the surrounding provinces. Dunmeth Pass leads through the Velothi Mountains into Morrowind (Which by the way is neutral in this conflict and unless the Dominion wants war with them too, they would most likely not send a significant force through) and the Pale Pass Connecting Skyrim to Cyrodiil (again, currently at peace, the Empire would not let a massive invasion force just waltz right through their heart). The Sea of Ghosts boarders Skyrim to the north and forms a barrier almost as impenetrable as the mountains, since that area of Skyrim is likely frozen year round due to the high latitude of Skyrim on Nirn; Making Ice sheets and Icebergs a permanent and dangerous obstacle for anyone traveling the Sea.
High Rock
With no direct pass into Skyrim, it is unlikely the Dominion would consider invading Skyrim through it. Plus, it is still part of the Empire, and it is unlikely the Empire would the Dominion just march an Invasion force inside their borders.
Hammerfell
Hammerfell would be a bad place to land any number of Aldmeri forces, as they would have to fight their way through the province to get to Skyrim, not to mention the Alik’r Dessert would be a major obstacle.
Morrowind
Currently, the Argonians control both Morrowind and Black Marsh, and with the eruption of Red Mountain, Most of Vvardenfell was left either uninhabitable or outright destroyed. This could allow for the Dominion to make use of the Dunmeth Pass, but this would risk a war with the Argonians, not to mention the length the supply lines would have to be.
Black Marsh
Inhabited by the Argonians, and comprised primarily of swamp, it would be a logistical nightmare to move troops through, not to mention risk of war with the Argonians.
Cyrodiil
Two-thirds of the Dominion already borders Cyrodiil to the South, and with the shorter supply lines by comparison, may be the only viable option for an invasion of Skyrim. However, Like High Rock, it is unlikely the Empire would sit back and let an invasion force walk right through the heart of the Empire to Skyrim.
The Sea of Ghosts
The Sea of Ghosts is up there with Cyrodiil as the only real viable location from which to invade Skyrim. Given the environmental barrier though, it could cost the Dominion many ships just getting there. Even then, the only 2 viable landing locations are Dawnstar and Solitude. Solitude, being the Capital of Skyrim, would like be more heavily defended than Dawnstar so it more likely the Dominion would invade from Dawnstar.
Part 3 – Climate and Fighting Conditions
The Climate of the Dominion consists of the Tropical Summerset Isle, the warm rainforests of Valenwood, and the harsh desserts of Elswyer. Skyrim is a cold and bitter. The Aldmeri troops are used to fighting in the temperate climate of Cyrodiil. If you look at the way Napoleon fought in Russia, more of his men froze and starved to death than were killed by Russians. The Stormcloaks could employ a similar strategy to the Russians and let a cold Skyrim winter freeze out the Dominion.
However the reverse is true of the Nords of Skyrim. They would suffer in the same way as the Confederate troops did in the American Civil War. They wore Wool and Cotton Clothing in a climate that was too hot for such clothing and many suffered and died from heat exhaustion and dehydration.
Part 4 – Defending Skyrim
Invasion from Dawnstar
Let’s say the Dominion invaded from the Sea of Ghost into Dawnstar, They would obviously be met with opposition by the Stormcloaks, but they would only have 2 places they could really go. The path to Winterhold is blocked by mountains, they pass south to Whiterun is a bottleneck, and the way west runs into the swamps outside of Morthal, where re-enforcements from Solitude could pin the Dominions Troops against the Sea.
Invasion from Solitude
While it would be easier to avoid ice invading from Solitude, the Dominions troops would have nowhere to go except through the marshes outside of Morthal, as going east would funnel them toward Whiterun and Windhelm, where soldiers from those cities could pin them in the mountains. Solitude would be much harder to capture than Dawnstar to begin with as it lies on the edge of a cliff, and the Dominion could only attack it from the south.
Part 5 – Wild Cards
The Dragonborn
The Dragonborn is by far the wildest of the Wild cards. It is completely up to the player has to whom he/she would support. However if the Dragonborn was on the Stormcloaks side, he/she could be a game changer.
The Greybeards
The Greybeards vow never to interfere, especially in war and politics. However if the Dominion threatened them it is unlikely they would let themselves be destroyed.
The College of Winterhold
Like the Greybeards, they rarely interfere with politics or war, however if they fell under attack by the Dominion, they would most certainty retaliate.
Conclusion
Given the statements above, It is quite clear that although Skyrim may be capable of defending itself against the Aldmeri Dominion, it is unlikely they would be able to muster the strength needed to destroy the Dominion as Ulfric claims.