Page 1 of 2

What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:03 pm
by Frogmander
So, I think I finally figured out what is missing from Oblivion in Skyrim..

NPC emotions.

In Oblivion, NPCs were always smiling or you could hear it in their voice if they were happy. Or they would be frowning and talking in a rude tone if they were mad.
In Skyrim, the most emotional NPC (Cicero) barely even smiles, he talks high pitched and dances around, but if you look at his face it is still fairly stale.
Even the guards are like this..
In Oblivion: STOP RIGHT THERE CRIMINAL SCUM! ITS ALL OVER LAWBREAKER! PAY THE COURT A FINE AND SERVE YOUR SENTENCE, YOUR STOLEN GOODS ARE NOW FORFEIT -looks very mad-
In Skyrim: No lollygaggin' -can't even see face because of mask every guard has-

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:07 pm
by Evil-i
"Let me guess....Someone stole your sweetroll."

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:08 pm
by Dirty Spaceman
That's just one of the things from Oblivion that's missing in Skyrim (at least, from what I've heard - I've sadly never played Oblivion). And it's very true. I'll be in a conversation with someone, and although they'll sometimes shift around or cross their arms or something, their expression never changes. I've had people yelling, or whispering, or worrying, or talking sadly, and their expression always stays neutral. That isn't something that can just be fixed in a DLC or patch either. We'll need to wait for the next TES game to see if Bethesda fixes it.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:11 pm
by Frogmander
Basically what Abrad said, the world could be ending around them and their expression NEVER changes.

Honestly I prefered how in Oblivion time would freeze when talking to an NPC, it was kind of funny to see people in the background looking at you for ten minutes while you talk XD

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:14 pm
by Dirty Spaceman
Frogmander wrote:the world could be ending around them and their expression NEVER changes.
Actually, one time I was talking to the Boethiah Cult leader, who kept on calmly talking to me while a dragon attacked all of her fellow cultists in the background. It was incredibly hilarious actually. Luckily, the dragon ignored both of us.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:17 pm
by Frogmander
EpicAbrad wrote:
Frogmander wrote:the world could be ending around them and their expression NEVER changes.
Actually, one time I was talking to the Boethiah Cult leader, who kept on calmly talking to me while a dragon attacked all of her fellow cultists in the background. It was incredibly hilarious actually. Luckily, the dragon ignored both of us.
Wow.. XD

Another thing I honestly miss is the class system. I think it felt good building your character and seeing all the stats. Skyrims "Look to the stars" method is neat and all but it just feels like something anyone could do, imo Oblivion made you feel like a legend or something in the fact you chose all this stuff XD

I highly recommend you play it since you haven't

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu May 03, 2012 11:23 pm
by Dirty Spaceman
Frogmander wrote:Wow.. XD

Another thing I honestly miss is the class system. I think it felt good building your character and seeing all the stats. Skyrims "Look to the stars" method is neat and all but it just feels like something anyone could do, imo Oblivion made you feel like a legend or something in the fact you chose all this stuff XD

I highly recommend you play it since you haven't
I was thinking of getting it in fact, and probably will to pass the time until the Skyrim DLC comes out and get a better feel for the lore. And although I haven't played it, Oblivion's stat-attribute-class system was more realistic - in real life, for example, if you spend the first 20 years of your life studying hard in school and learning academically, you won't be able to suddenly become a world-class athlete if you randomly decide to pick up a sport. Bethesda probably got rid of classes because they felt it was too limiting, but the Skyrim system is, well, too "un-limiting."

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Fri May 04, 2012 12:00 am
by SajuukKhar
EpicAbrad wrote:I was thinking of getting it in fact, and probably will to pass the time until the Skyrim DLC comes out and get a better feel for the lore. And although I haven't played it, Oblivion's stat-attribute-class system was more realistic - in real life, for example, if you spend the first 20 years of your life studying hard in school and learning academically, you won't be able to suddenly become a world-class athlete if you randomly decide to pick up a sport. Bethesda probably got rid of classes because they felt it was too limiting, but the Skyrim system is, well, too "un-limiting."
The attribute system also has a nasty side-effect of making all high level characters almost exactly the same.

In Morrowind and Oblivion characters started off unique but became the same

In Skyrim everyone starts off the same but become unique.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Fri May 04, 2012 2:03 am
by Pilaf The Defiler
You know, in a video game that's more cinematic and linear it's a lot easier to display those sorts of emotions on NPCs. The main selling point of the Elder Scrolls thus far has been the huge, open world. With that many things going on all the time in the engine, some things have to be sacrificed and complex NPC emotions is one of them.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Fri May 04, 2012 2:45 am
by Frogmander
SajuukKhar wrote:
EpicAbrad wrote:I was thinking of getting it in fact, and probably will to pass the time until the Skyrim DLC comes out and get a better feel for the lore. And although I haven't played it, Oblivion's stat-attribute-class system was more realistic - in real life, for example, if you spend the first 20 years of your life studying hard in school and learning academically, you won't be able to suddenly become a world-class athlete if you randomly decide to pick up a sport. Bethesda probably got rid of classes because they felt it was too limiting, but the Skyrim system is, well, too "un-limiting."
The attribute system also has a nasty side-effect of making all high level characters almost exactly the same.

In Morrowind and Oblivion characters started off unique but became the same

In Skyrim everyone starts off the same but become unique.
That explains it, I roll a lot of low level characters, I don't usually get to high level XD


Pilaf The Defiler wrote:You know, in a video game that's more cinematic and linear it's a lot easier to display those sorts of emotions on NPCs. The main selling point of the Elder Scrolls thus far has been the huge, open world. With that many things going on all the time in the engine, some things have to be sacrificed and complex NPC emotions is one of them.
How do emotions make it linear? You can still tell by what they are saying and minorly how they are saying it (no where near oblivions) what the emotion is meant to be. It doesn't really make it linear, not sure how that is linear.

New engine = You can't make an NPC smile? The logic in this is extremely flawed. Making an NPC smile is not complex.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 12:36 am
by Pandamatak
Well disposition as a whole has basically been removed, so you can go a long way at proving that point and many others related to how the depth of characters in general has become more black and white in Skyrim (a given character either likes you, doesn't, or does not care).

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 8:39 pm
by Pilaf The Defiler
Frogmander wrote:
Pilaf The Defiler wrote:You know, in a video game that's more cinematic and linear it's a lot easier to display those sorts of emotions on NPCs. The main selling point of the Elder Scrolls thus far has been the huge, open world. With that many things going on all the time in the engine, some things have to be sacrificed and complex NPC emotions is one of them.

How do emotions make it linear?
You can still tell by what they are saying and minorly how they are saying it (no where near oblivions) what the emotion is meant to be. It doesn't really make it linear, not sure how that is linear.

New engine = You can't make an NPC smile? The logic in this is extremely flawed. Making an NPC smile is not complex.

Reading comprehension. I didn't say "emotions make it linear." I said that when designing a linear game, there's more programming time left for things like complex facial animations and such. Those games tend to be smaller, with fewer estimated play hours. Skyrim's team spend the bulk of their time designing a huge world and hundreds of quests to go into it. At the end of the day, certain details are up in the air. I guess from a developer stance, it was considered but dropped in favor of focusing on the open world element. You could have your cake and eat it too, I guess. It's theoretically possible, but usually when you decide to do one thing you're deciding not to do another, and Skyrim turned out to be a pretty fine RPG in the end.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 11:12 pm
by Frogmander
Pilaf The Defiler wrote:
Frogmander wrote:
Pilaf The Defiler wrote:You know, in a video game that's more cinematic and linear it's a lot easier to display those sorts of emotions on NPCs. The main selling point of the Elder Scrolls thus far has been the huge, open world. With that many things going on all the time in the engine, some things have to be sacrificed and complex NPC emotions is one of them.

How do emotions make it linear?
You can still tell by what they are saying and minorly how they are saying it (no where near oblivions) what the emotion is meant to be. It doesn't really make it linear, not sure how that is linear.

New engine = You can't make an NPC smile? The logic in this is extremely flawed. Making an NPC smile is not complex.

Reading comprehension. I didn't say "emotions make it linear." I said that when designing a linear game, there's more programming time left for things like complex facial animations and such. Those games tend to be smaller, with fewer estimated play hours. Skyrim's team spend the bulk of their time designing a huge world and hundreds of quests to go into it. At the end of the day, certain details are up in the air. I guess from a developer stance, it was considered but dropped in favor of focusing on the open world element. You could have your cake and eat it too, I guess. It's theoretically possible, but usually when you decide to do one thing you're deciding not to do another, and Skyrim turned out to be a pretty fine RPG in the end.
Because making an NPC smile is VERY difficult.

And Oblivion was extremely linear, that's why all the NPCs had emotions, because the game was linear.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sat May 05, 2012 11:42 pm
by Belgarion98
Let's not forget to take into account the environment of Skyrim: harsh. These people probably never smile, and perhaps Bethesda meant it this way, because they are in such a brutal place. Remember the words of Maramal:
"The people of Skyrim are hardy, and Marriage is not that common". Maybe this is the reason their facial expression changes? Either that or they're just badasses.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 12:15 am
by Frogmander
Belgarion98 wrote:Let's not forget to take into account the environment of Skyrim: harsh. These people probably never smile, and perhaps Bethesda meant it this way, because they are in such a brutal place. Remember the words of Maramal:
"The people of Skyrim are hardy, and Marriage is not that common". Maybe this is the reason their facial expression changes? Either that or they're just badasses.
Even NPCs in oblivion had an expression for that, take martin for example during the whole kvatch thing, his expression seemed "distressed" or "sad". The NPCs in skyrim dont smile, dont frown, dont look distressed, they just plain dont look anything. Hell half the NPCs you can't even see their face and all look the same (guards..)

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 2:02 am
by DarkEastwood
Inactually have seen people react to my actions (facially). Like when I approached the lady with the Marks of Dibella, I could definetly see the embarassment in her face. It may not be as drastic and crazy as Oblivions but its certainly existent.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 2:33 am
by Gideon Dragontongue
The other thing is that's totally something I could see being added in a patch or DLC, it's not impossible that they might add if everyone wants it.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 5:31 pm
by Voice of the North
Well, its just my opinion but I think Oblivion was the worst of the Elder Scrolls games.
I mean, its a good game. But the atmosphere is gone after visiting every area. You know, its all the same after a few hours.
The only places that feel really different than others are the colovian highlands and the jerall/Valus mountains.
Sancre Tor in the evening, with the sunset behind imperial city and that feeling of.. autumn?^^ Or the Valus mountains, with the wild valley in front of it. Thats the only places I still could explore countless hours. Everything else is good, but I cant stay there long, its not as unique.


To the "feelings" of NPCs - the smiling in Oblivion was a little too crazy. When I think about it all the emotions of the characters were either crazy or not there, I think in Skyrim they're going a better road, although everyone seems sad.
Maybe It's just the enviroment that makes me feel so - Oblivion is colourful, happy and a little bit too nice, Skyrim is rough and everybody seems tired of the dangers.

I mean, if the NPCs aren't overreacting or completely stone-faced, than its the gameworld that makes you think they feel sad, happy or whatsoever.
In Morrowind there was nearly no voice acting and old graphics, but it still felt lonely, lost and sad - and that was reflected by the NPCs.
But at least the companions could be much more emotional. And to certain events, such as
Spoiler:
Kodlaks Burial in
"Purity of revenge" or the main quest, there should be more feeling in the NPCs.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Mon Jun 04, 2012 4:18 am
by Dunmer999
I didn't really care for Oblivion's emotion, because I always had to look at it standing chest to chest with the person I'm talking to.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Mon Jun 04, 2012 3:58 pm
by christine
Dunmer999 wrote:I didn't really care for Oblivion's emotion, because I always had to look at it standing chest to chest with the person I'm talking to.
Yeah, it had quite a bad case of "close talking" going on: I eventually altered the config stuff to distance the NPCs a bit in the dialogue menus.

The almost total lack of emotions in Skyrim's NPCs also bothers me, though. Some of Oblivion's weren't very subtly done, but at least they were there; occasionally you do see the odd not-very-convincing smile or snarl in Skyrim, but the expressions are far too static. It doesn't help that everyone sounds perpetually [&@%!] off or "serious business" at all times. I think I saw this coming based on the recent Fallouts but I hadn't expected it to be quite as severe as it is: at least there, the voice acting compensated somewhat for the rather static faces.

Worst of all is the player character who also has the same unwelcome carry-over from FO3/NV in that they're totally static and completely oblivious to their surroundings: I do like to play in third person occasionally and it does seem a bit wrong that there's no reaction at all. At least in Oblivion the PC showed some reaction to what was going on, looking at people and other things that were passing by and often showing some sort of emotional response, but the mannequin-like unresponsiveness in Skyrim is a bit of a downer.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Tue Jun 05, 2012 4:13 am
by Pancake
After playing a whole lot of Skyrim. I've come to appreciate the beauty that is "freeze-time" conversation style of Oblivion. Can't believe I'm in love with rumours about mudcrab and nasty goblin. I like seeing NPC faces even the adoring fan, although ,zooming out the conversation camera angle a little bit, like fallout 3, won't hurt.

Radiant AI is awesome.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Tue Jun 05, 2012 2:19 pm
by Yaije
Frogmander wrote: Because making an NPC smile is VERY difficult.

And Oblivion was extremely linear, that's why all the NPCs had emotions, because the game was linear.
Wait what?

Elderscroll and linear don't often go in the same sentence unless there's a "not" immediately separating them paired with and "is" in the order of "is not".

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Tue Jun 05, 2012 2:46 pm
by Belthazor
Yaije wrote:
Frogmander wrote: Because making an NPC smile is VERY difficult.

And Oblivion was extremely linear, that's why all the NPCs had emotions, because the game was linear.
Wait what?

Elderscroll and linear don't often go in the same sentence unless there's a "not" immediately separating them paired with and "is" in the order of "is not".
Sarcasm FTW! ;)

P.S.:
Although I have to say that there is still a lot of linearity in TES games. Sure, you can do whatever you want, whenever you want. But rarely however you want. It's a rare occasion that you have options and different possible outcomes for a quest.

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:40 am
by Hissien
Oblvion is my favorite of them, but it was my first.

I miss the spell altars and also I miss the quests that seemed more personal.

Mazoga the orc reminds me of this, she expressed emotion and I wanted to help her regardless of reward. And I freaked out when she died and used the staff of worms to bring her to leyawiin where I buried her in the undercroft. :/

Re: What I realized was missing from Oblivion

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 11:18 pm
by Theificka
necro-posting here