Page 1 of 1
Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:12 am
by Daemos Avetorii
Since my experience and knowledge about the game is still in it's infancy. (lol)
I've come to ask this question. Is it possible to join and/or work with the Thalmor?
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:14 am
by OblivionDuruza
Sadly, no, although there is one quest you can perform for them if you visit Markath. I wont give it all away for you though, just head on over and see if you can find them there.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:15 am
by Duderino Abides
Well, if you work with the empire, you're basically working with the Thalmor.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:16 am
by Pilaf The Defiler
Nah, not in the vanilla game. Maybe in a mod or expansion. Keep in mind what they represent, though. Their ultimate goals entail nothing short of the death of Man, of Man's gods and of the physical universe.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:16 am
by OblivionDuruza
Not exactly. The Empire is not under the Thalmor, and it has its own interests. The Empire doesn't even like the Thalmor. They may be under a great deal of pressure from the Thalmor, and yes, to RP a Thalmor agent it would probably be best to side with the Empire, for a number of reasons, but given the chance, the Empire would strike back against the Thalmor.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:17 am
by Daemos Avetorii
Duderino Abides wrote:Well, if you work with the empire, you're basically working with the Thalmor.
That is confusing me. Did the Thalmor not want the Empire destroyed? How can I facilitate that by "aiding" the Empire? o.o
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:18 am
by Daemos Avetorii
Thalmor are mostly Altmers right. If I play as Altmer, will that cause different dialog options if you speak to them?
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:20 am
by Duderino Abides
If the Empire goes against what the Thalmor want, it's bye bye to the Empire. They're in no position to fight the Aldmeri Dominion. That's why they signed the White-Gold Concordant in the first place.
The Empire couldn't even beat them when they had the Nords and Redguards on their side.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:20 am
by Arch-Mage Matt
Pilaf The Defiler wrote:Nah, not in the vanilla game. Maybe in a mod or expansion. Keep in mind what they represent, though. Their ultimate goals entail nothing short of the death of Man, of Man's gods and of the physical universe.
That's rather incorrect, the Thalmor want to live on Nirn as much as the next guy, I think.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:21 am
by OblivionDuruza
Playing as an Altmer actually does allow you to infiltrate the Thalmor Embassy more easily for the Main Quest, if you so choose. I think that's the most visible affect.
The Thalmor do wish to destroy the Empire of Men, however they are currently at piece after the Concordat of White-gold was signed. Now the Thalmor has a degree of free reign in the Empire, to stamp out Talos worship (while actually watching and gathering information, and elongating the Civil War).
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 3:00 am
by Will Zurmacht
Duderino Abides wrote:If the Empire goes against what the Thalmor want, it's bye bye to the Empire. They're in no position to fight the Aldmeri Dominion. That's why they signed the White-Gold Concordant in the first place.
The Empire couldn't even beat them when they had the Nords and Redguards on their side.
See
Battle of the Red Ring. The Empire fought the Dominion to a stalemate. The resulting treaty was somewhat damaging to the Empire, especially given the destruction of the Blades. But what are the odds that the Empire has made efforts in the intervening 20 years to develop other espionage capabilities? Talos worship was officially banned and Thalmor inquisitions installed in parts of the empire, but if Earth's history of persecuted religious groups is any guide, if Talos worshipers can develop a cult of martyrs, they will ultimately emerge stronger than before.
Arch-Mage Matt wrote:That's rather incorrect, the Thalmor want to live on Nirn as much as the next guy, I think.
Pilaf is referencing super-meta-lorey theories about Altmer theology, where Altmer (thus Thalmor) supposedly want to destroy Talos and Lorkhan because they limited the Altmeri gods by creating and/or sustaining Mundus/Nirn. So if Mundus/Nirn is destroyed the Altmeri star children can reunite with their god parents as pure spirit, unfettered by matter. Or something. I think it's a stretch to confidently claim that the Thalmor are driven by this impulse, given what we have available.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 5:09 am
by Dark Spark
It's Casablanca, except the Nazis are pretty skilled at throwing fire and lightning on Bogey's backside.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 5:12 am
by dtmwerks
Duderino Abides wrote:Well, if you work with the empire, you're basically working with the Thalmor.
Nope. Sounds like stormcloak propoganda to me. Let me try.
If you work with the stormcloaks, you're basically working with terrorists and racists.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 12:06 pm
by Lord Elvewyn
dtmwerks wrote:Duderino Abides wrote:Well, if you work with the empire, you're basically working with the Thalmor.
Nope. Sounds like stormcloak propoganda to me. Let me try.
If you work with the stormcloaks, you're basically working with terrorists and racists.
Actually you're serving the Thalmor as well. Shattering the Empire into pieces means that when the Thalmor return to conquer there won't be a unified force to defend mankind. Skyrim could even be an Altmer ruled territory. If a Voice challenge is a legal way to get the crown and the player is Altmer and the most powerful voice user ever ... There's also the fact that if you complete the
Oh, I imagine High Rock would drop out of the Empire simply because it's physically split from the Empire in that event.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 2:47 pm
by Pilaf The Defiler
Will Zurmacht wrote:Duderino Abides wrote:If the Empire goes against what the Thalmor want, it's bye bye to the Empire. They're in no position to fight the Aldmeri Dominion. That's why they signed the White-Gold Concordant in the first place.
The Empire couldn't even beat them when they had the Nords and Redguards on their side.
See
Battle of the Red Ring. The Empire fought the Dominion to a stalemate. The resulting treaty was somewhat damaging to the Empire, especially given the destruction of the Blades. But what are the odds that the Empire has made efforts in the intervening 20 years to develop other espionage capabilities? Talos worship was officially banned and Thalmor inquisitions installed in parts of the empire, but if Earth's history of persecuted religious groups is any guide, if Talos worshipers can develop a cult of martyrs, they will ultimately emerge stronger than before.
Arch-Mage Matt wrote:That's rather incorrect, the Thalmor want to live on Nirn as much as the next guy, I think.
Pilaf is referencing super-meta-lorey theories about Altmer theology, where Altmer (thus Thalmor) supposedly want to destroy Talos and Lorkhan because they limited the Altmeri gods by creating and/or sustaining Mundus/Nirn. So if Mundus/Nirn is destroyed the Altmeri star children can reunite with their god parents as pure spirit, unfettered by matter. Or something. I think it's a stretch to confidently claim that the Thalmor are driven by this impulse, given what we have available.
If they're a continuation of the Aldmeri Dominion as described in earlier texts, then yes that is their penultimate goal, and they're using all their "allies" as puppets, especially the Imperials. It's not really a fringe theory. It's the foundation of orthodox Aldmeri religion. They see Lorkhan's actions as a curse, whereas the man races (and the Dunmer) see it as a gift. Remember that in Elven tradition it was their chief Auriel who tore Lorkhan's heart from his chest. It differs a lot from the human traditions that Shor willingly sacrificed himself so that mortals may live. It's a fundamental ideological split. The Aldmeri see man as "bringing Sithis into every quarter."
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 3:33 pm
by vickstick
It think no matter what you do in this game, you'll be helping the Thalmor, whether you like it or not.
Although the 'we want to destroy the entire world'-theory does sound appealing, I'm not really buying it. How would the Thalmor destroy the world by conquering it?
I think their motives are very mundane, and their politics are brilliant. I heard they know about scheming in High Rock, but these guys are geniuses!
Their whole 'foreign policy' department is bent on further destabilising the Empire to completely conquer it.
1. They forced most of the concessions of land from Hammerfell. This [&@%!] the Redguards off, and they secede. Although still not many Redguards will be loyal to the High Elves, the Redguards seem to blame the Empire mostly. They feel betrayed. One province down, 3 to go!
2. Banning the worship of Talos upsets about everyone in the Empire. But Talos was a Nord, and the Nords of Skyrim don't take kindly to their man-god being taken down. So pretty much half of the Nords want to secede from the Empire.
4. The Thalmor soldiers are apparently allowed to just walk in, and they even get a couple of fortresses. How would you defeat these guys if you allow 'em to build fortresses in the middle of your territory on strategic locations? Also, the Thalmor are everywhere! The 'Inquisition' rewards you for ratting people out, and the Thalmor can find out where the weak spots in the Empire are.
5. They're at liberty to arrest pretty much whoever they want to under the pretenses of being a Talos worshipper. This way they can root out Blades, other spies, political opponents, etc.
If you ask me, no matter who you're helping, the Empire's toast and you just aided the Thalmor.
I'll give you an example:
And choosing between Empire and Stormcloacks is like American politics:
you can vote for only two sides, which are basically copies of each other.
In Skyrim, you can choose between the Klu Klux Klan and the Spanish Inquisition. Nice.
EDIT:
You don't join the Spanish Inquisition, so maybe joining the Legion is best to preserve stability in the Empire should the Thalmor choose to attack again.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 4:20 pm
by Will Zurmacht
vickstick wrote:4. The Thalmor soldiers are apparently allowed to just walk in, and they even get a couple of fortresses. How would you defeat these guys if you allow 'em to build fortresses in the middle of your territory on strategic locations? Also, the Thalmor are everywhere! The 'Inquisition' rewards you for ratting people out, and the Thalmor can find out where the weak spots in the Empire are.
5. They're at liberty to arrest pretty much whoever they want to under the pretenses of being a Talos worshipper. This way they can root out Blades, other spies, political opponents, etc.
4. We mostly see Thalmor Justiciars (inquisitors and bounty hunters), not proper army troops, wandering the hills and dales of Skyrim. There is no indication that Aldmeri
garrisons are allowed in Skyrim, except to protect the embassy and at a fortress/jail likely ceded to the Thalmor by the Legion. You mention the mission to rescue the Grey-Mane from said fortress, but remember how the Aldmeri soldier at the front gate mentions he would let a prisoner go at the request of the Legion? These bellicose foreigners are not free to do whatever they want in the province.
5. We simply don't know the details of the agreement that let Thalmor inquisitors into the provinces. Even if we knew the exact wording of the WGC, the terms or the enforcement may have changed in the interim.
And regarding the fate of Talos worship, what about Hammerfell? I'm no Hammerfell lore expert, but since they are one of the only provinces that is totally Thalmor free, wouldn't the area become a magnet for religious refugees, priests of Talos, etc.?
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 4:38 pm
by Daemos Avetorii
The Thalmor are my kind of guys. The fiery destruction of the empire has always been high on my agenda.
I kinda hope there will be an expansion pack or something in wich you can join the Thalmor and eradicate the Empire. No more bounties for me because all the Imperial Guards will be dead.
It will be a catastrophic battle. Heads on stakes will stretch from daggerfall to cheydinhal.
Mountains of skulls everywhere. And rivers turning to a torrent from blood. I like.

Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2011 8:32 am
by Lord Elvewyn
Will Zurmacht wrote:
4. We mostly see Thalmor Justiciars (inquisitors and bounty hunters), not proper army troops, wandering the hills and dales of Skyrim. There is no indication that Aldmeri garrisons are allowed in Skyrim, except to protect the embassy and at a fortress/jail likely ceded to the Thalmor by the Legion. You mention the mission to rescue the Grey-Mane from said fortress, but remember how the Aldmeri soldier at the front gate mentions he would let a prisoner go at the request of the Legion? These bellicose foreigners are not free to do whatever they want in the province.
5. We simply don't know the details of the agreement that let Thalmor inquisitors into the provinces. Even if we knew the exact wording of the WGC, the terms or the enforcement may have changed in the interim.
And regarding the fate of Talos worship, what about Hammerfell? I'm no Hammerfell lore expert, but since they are one of the only provinces that is totally Thalmor free, wouldn't the area become a magnet for religious refugees, priests of Talos, etc.?
#4 True they say they require a legion order, but can the legion actually give that order? Perhaps it's merely a way for the Thalmor to get a civilian to blame the legion for yet another problem. I'm not aware of any way in the game to actually rescue him that doesn't involve ignoring the Thalmor.
#5 No not really. Consider the Night of Green Fire (4E42). Thalmor mages just razed the dissident quarter - no survivors. Only chance for the refugees would be to go under and avoid notice.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Mon Nov 28, 2011 2:47 pm
by Will Zurmacht
Thanks for that lead about the Night of Green Fire Elvewyn. Do you have any more information about it? Are there in game sources? What was the response from Hammerfell's leaders? At the time of Skyrim we're 150 years after the Night of Green Fire, Talos worship has been banned Empire-wide, and the Second Treaty of Stros M'kai has forced the withdrawal of Aldmeri forces from Hammerfell. So I think the dynamic could be much different now with respect to refugees who want to find asylum there.
Re: Stoopid question about thalmor
Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2011 5:29 am
by Dark Spark
In a few missives I seen from the bodies of Thalmor agents, they understand that many of their unoffical missions are illegal and those agents should not expect to get any help from the Legion if something should go wrong.