Page 1 of 2

Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 2:48 pm
by ShadowScaleIV
Hey I'm making a new warrior character and was wondering which of the Weapon classes to make as my major group. What do you guys prefer when killing things and what do you find easiest and most effective to use: Blade, Blunt or Marksman?

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 3:10 pm
by Norroen Dyrd
For me personally, Marksman is the less convenient type of attack. I find it not as effective for ranged attacks as, say, Destruction magic. But that's just me. I am not really into these skill statistic things. I choose weapons according to roleplay, is all. :)

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 6:04 pm
by Lindai
Blade.
The best weapons in the game are blades. Umbra,Goldbrand,Sword of the Crusader,Mehrunes Razor,Bound Sword and plenty more.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 6:13 pm
by AeraDunmerMoon
I dunno, I prefer Marksman. There's something oddly satisfying about being across an Ayleid Hall and shooting down a skeleton. Never even get touched. Plus you can recollect the arrows, and if you get to Apprentice level, it doesn't fatigue you the slightest. At Journeyman you even zoom in. Destruction magic doesn't do that, and it's a mite harder to aim. Plus, magic doesn't get bonuses from sneaking.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 6:26 pm
by Lindai
But in all honestly,Marksman not on par with the other weapon classes. If it had the 6x bonus that melee weapons have,then it would be truly something. Also, a Warrior based character tends not to sneak and use the bow.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 6:41 pm
by AeraDunmerMoon
Ah, true, true. A warrior would probably be better suited to a Blade.
I don't really care about being on par with other weapons. I can kill stuff with a single arrow and taunt their dead body. What do I have to complain about? As opposed to blades, where one runs the risk of being knocked down, stupid shields getting in the way, the buddies than gang up from behind...
Nah, i still like Marksman better.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 7:13 pm
by Jeff
Daedric Bow 21 & Daedric Arrow 20 = 41
Daedric Longsword = 24
Daedric War Axe = 22
Daedric Mace = 24
Daedric Battle Axe = 26
Daedric 2-H Sword = 26
Daedric 2-H Warhammer = 28

For Unenchanted Weapons, The Bow and Arrow are best for Max Damage, non-sneak, by 13-19 points.

Daedric Bow & Arrow x3 = 123
Daedric Longsword x6 = 144

For Unenchanted Weapons, the Daedric Longsword is best for Sneak Attacks by 21 points.


- - - - - - - - - - -

Bow of the Inferno 20 + 20 Fire Damage & Arrow of the Inferno 20 + 20 Fire Damage = 80
Longsword of the Inferno 22 + 20 Fire Damage = 42

Enchanted, the Bow and Arrow combination will be almost double damage at 38 points, for standard, non-sneak attacks.

Keep in mind that Magic Damage does not count in the x3 or x6, for sneak attacks.

Inferno Daedric Bow and Arrow = 163
Inferno Daedric Longsword = 164
Goldbrand = 172

...so, the Bow and Arrow are only 1 point shy of the Longsword, if they are Enchanted. (9 points less than Goldbrand)

Keep in mind, that you can not sneak attack with 2-handed weapons (which is why I didn't compare them).

- - - - - - - - - -

It is all a matter of the right tool for the Job.

You have to choose what is right for the Character that you are playing, and how you have fun playing. There is nothing to say that you can not use an Enchanted Bow and Arrow, with Poison for a Ranged Sneak Attack, then blast them with a spell as you close, and then finish them off with your Melee weapon... except your Roleplay.

As for what I prefer to use: It all depends on what Role I give my Character. I change it up, so that it is different, and I don't get bored playing the same way... but I also give myself the options to use whatever is right for the current situation... or have something else to fall back on. Unless I have a roleplay, that prohibits the use of Magic, or Poison, or Edged Weapons.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 8:12 pm
by Shadow
I'm really for the Blunt skill. Axes and Warhammers make a great job of killing people. In your inventory I recommend you have a one-handed Axe, then a Warhammer. That's what I usually have. Axe for short, low leveled enemies, Warhammer for those more fearful opponents.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Mar 18, 2011 9:43 pm
by Rose of Sithis
I used to prefer Blade, but then I started using Marksman and never looked back. You can do a lot of damage with ranged sneak attacks, especially if you use poison.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 12:13 am
by lostlast
I always use and prefer blade. I need to give marksman a go. I think it's the whole having to be sneaky that throws me off it. I prefer to charge in guns blazing. Well in TES case, swords swinging.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 2:30 am
by Offtopic
Question: On the Wiki when it says speed what does that mean? A weapon speed of 1.0= how many hits per second??

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 2:39 am
by Arch-Mage Matt
Offtopic wrote:Question: On the Wiki when it says speed what does that mean? A weapon speed of 1.0= how many hits per second??

The more speed the faster you can swing the weapon. A dagger has a high speed and warhammers have low speed, for example.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 3:15 am
by butterslug
Blade all the way, but I'm a sneaky creeper dealing long head shots with the bow.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 3:23 am
by Offtopic
Arch-Mage Matt wrote:
Offtopic wrote:Question: On the Wiki when it says speed what does that mean? A weapon speed of 1.0= how many hits per second??

The more speed the faster you can swing the weapon. A dagger has a high speed and warhammers have low speed, for example.
Yes but how fast do the numbers represent.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 3:32 am
by zzfallens
definitely blade. warhammers are to slow and bows need arrows and they are only long ranged

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 7:05 am
by Dark Spark
Marksman is the skill of choice for a Stealth-based character relying on Sneak and Agility to attack from a crouch. It stems from one obvious fact: an archer shoots just as quickly from the sneaking crouch as they do standing up.

Users of a melee skill do not have that advantage— sneak attacks are always slower.

If you can count on your armor to reduce damage, you don't need the risk of a ranged attack. Go for the Blunt/Blade debate instead.

If you like to have use stealth as a defense— this means the ability to remain undetected even after the first arrow hits the mark (which is possible, given enough Sneak/Agility)— then Marksman works beautifully.

The key question: are you going to wait until you see the whites of their eyes, or not?

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 3:59 pm
by born2beagator
Blade.

But get marksman to at least journeyman level so you can zoom. After you fire an arrow, keep holding zoom and use destruction spells, it will stay zoomed while firing the spells.

Hatred's soul+zoom+shock spells+slow deadra=dead deadra 8)

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 5:26 pm
by MARS
I usually combine Blade with Marksman on my usual Stealth-Mage characters but lately I've been preferring blades. Blades are faster and lighter than blunts.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sat Mar 19, 2011 7:58 pm
by Doctor Meaticus
Okay. Go and choose your big ol' axes, maces and claymores. Just means you'll be looking like a human pincushion by the time you reach me. On top of this, I can dance out of the way of your slow attacks, staying just out of your reach and sticking an extra arrow in you from time to time until your dead at my feet.

Today's question... is the Marksman skill really a bad choice? You be the judge, my friend.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2011 5:46 am
by Dark Spark
Doctor Meaticus wrote:Okay. Go and choose your big ol' axes, maces and claymores. Just means you'll be looking like a human pincushion by the time you reach me. On top of this, I can dance out of the way of your slow attacks, staying just out of your reach and sticking an extra arrow in you from time to time until your dead at my feet.
Sadly, your point is based on a game that doesn't exist— an Oblivion MMORPG.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2011 6:37 am
by RatKiller
Blade is the "easiest and most effective to use", but for me personally, marksman is more challenging and the most fun. I love using sneak with poisons, and for stronger enemies conjuration is your best friend. You can fire arrow after arrow into an enemy while he's busy swinging away at your atronach.

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 1:33 pm
by Hadrianus
Norroen Dyrd wrote:For me personally, Marksman is the less convenient type of attack. I find it not as effective for ranged attacks as, say, Destruction magic. But that's just me. I am not really into these skill statistic things. I choose weapons according to roleplay, is all. :)
Ditto :P

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Fri Apr 15, 2011 10:41 pm
by Scout
I prefer marksman. I like sneaking around dungeons better than just charging through. Though I'm currently having problems when they don't die straight off and charge at me :shock: I need to train my blade.

I like blade as long as I have a good block to go with it. I didn't really see the use of a decent block skill until recently. It just makes fights so much easier.

I've never really liked blunt weapons. To big, slow, heavy... Nah, not my thing. I'd rather kill from afar. My aim's good enough that I'll hit you 90% of the time :Twisted Evil:

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 6:03 pm
by Samaelthedestroyer
Swords on average do less damage than blunts (although the strongest weapon in the game is a blade) but are faster. Marksmen if more for stealth characters, but its all up to what you want in the end

Re: Blade or Blunt ( or Marksman)

Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2011 6:04 pm
by Wolfie
Samaelthedestroyer wrote:Swords on average do less damage than blunts (although the strongest weapon in the game is a blade) but are faster. Marksmen if more for stealth characters, but its all up to what you want in the end
really? i was under the impression that blade and blunt both shared that