Page 1 of 1

Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 11:13 pm
by bryanmichael11
I was wondering because I somewhat think they are, but I want to know about others' opinions.

Re: Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 11:17 pm
by Dean
Why do you think they are exactly?

I tend to not use them because I don't mind enduring the beginnings, but I do like the option of variation and they can be absolutely brilliant for in-game role-playing which is a nice bonus.

Re: Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Wed Oct 20, 2010 11:43 pm
by bryanmichael11
Newsound wrote:Why do you think they are exactly?

I tend to not use them because I don't mind enduring the beginnings, but I do like the option of variation and they can be absolutely brilliant for in-game role-playing which is a nice bonus.
I feel like I'm not playing the game the way it was supposed to be played. I know that the game is supposed to be played the way the player wants it to be played, but I can't help feeling like I'm doing something wrong when I play with those mods. I do like them, though. I just don't use them. Almost all of my mods add things into the game, but don't change something already there.

Re: Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 8:28 pm
by Shadow
bryanmichael11 wrote:
Newsound wrote:Why do you think they are exactly?

I tend to not use them because I don't mind enduring the beginnings, but I do like the option of variation and they can be absolutely brilliant for in-game role-playing which is a nice bonus.
I feel like I'm not playing the game the way it was supposed to be played. I know that the game is supposed to be played the way the player wants it to be played, but I can't help feeling like I'm doing something wrong when I play with those mods. I do like them, though. I just don't use them. Almost all of my mods add things into the game, but don't change something already there.
That's a good point there.
Although, like you siad, it's how to the player wants to play it, but they do also add immersion, say you never want to be a jailbird etc.
Hehe. Bird is the word.

Re: Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 11:01 pm
by Sawses
My opinion on alternate starts -and cheating in particular- is that it is a matter of perspective. I define cheating as giving myself an unfair advantage, which usually means an overpowered weapon or a nice house that contains any vanilla or modded items that I could not get at my own level. (This includes the modded items because usually they have equivalent items in vanilla.)

I view alternate starts as a way to avoid the tedious beginning. Usually, I have an alternate start that gives me a few starting items, but less than is usually earned in the tutorial, so that I have no more or less advantage, only less wasted time. Some would say that even modding the game at all is cheating, or that using the console to fix a bug is cheating.

If you hate the tutorial but want to make new characters, either make a save at the end of the sewer, or use a balanced alternate start. For roleplaying purposes, there are several nice ones at TESnexus.

Re: Do you think Alternative Start mods are a way of cheating?

Posted: Fri Oct 22, 2010 7:36 pm
by bryanmichael11
Very good point Sawses. I may start using an alt start mod because, like you said, it doesn't necessarily give you an advantage. In fact, it gives you a disadvantage without all the loot to sell. Plus, I've played the tutorial many times in the last four and a half years, so I think I can say I deserve to have a shorter start (seriously, I've played the tutorial probably about a hundred or more times). Thank you for the votes so far people, but I'll still see what others have to say.