Page 1 of 3
What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 7:13 pm
by Daemos Avetorii
I'm curious
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 7:16 pm
by Norroen Dyrd
If you don't mind my interfering, I think you should make more pol options, like "Pure Combat", or "Combat/Magic" or "Magic/Stealth", etc. Because even if you are a pure warrior who hasn't cast a spell in his life, you still need potions to heal yourself - and Alchemy is magic!
I myself tend to go for Combat/Magic, but this playthrough I'm trying Magic/Stealth.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 7:18 pm
by LP Gibson
Norroen Dyrd wrote:If you don't mind my interfering, I think you should make more pol options, like "Pure Combat", or "Combat/Magic" or "Magic/Stealth", etc. Because even if you are a pure warrior who hasn't cast a spell in his life, you still need potions to heal yourself - and Alchemy is magic!
I myself tend to go for Combat/Magic, but this playthrough I'm trying Magic/Stealth.
I call shenanigans, a warrior who uses potions isn't combat/magic, just a combat.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 7:24 pm
by Norroen Dyrd
LP Gibson wrote:Norroen Dyrd wrote:If you don't mind my interfering, I think you should make more pol options, like "Pure Combat", or "Combat/Magic" or "Magic/Stealth", etc. Because even if you are a pure warrior who hasn't cast a spell in his life, you still need potions to heal yourself - and Alchemy is magic!
I myself tend to go for Combat/Magic, but this playthrough I'm trying Magic/Stealth.
I call shenanigans, a warrior who uses potions isn't combat/magic, just a combat.
Oh, sorry, I guess I was just being nerdish. But still warriors and rogues can use magic for backup, and mages can use combat to slice their stunned opponents to pieces.

Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 7:32 pm
by Daemos Avetorii
fixed poll options >> so much for pure combat or magic or stealth x.x
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 8:15 pm
by KrisCrash
Currently doing a combat/magic sort of deal
All my previous ones have generally been stealth/combat. But mowing through Daedra with 10pts shock damage on touch is kinda intriguing.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 8:30 pm
by BFG
I'm focusing on all three.

Seriously though, methinks the strongest character is able to adapt to any of those types of combat. My character routinely encounters enemies that are immune to magic or are too strong for a full-on confrontation, so being able to switch gears is a necessity.
And yes, focusing on all three is different than not focusing at all!
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 8:36 pm
by Backfire
Because even if you are a pure warrior who hasn't cast a spell in his life, you still need potions to heal yourself - and Alchemy is magic!
I also call shenanigans. I voted myself as Stealth only, even though Illusion is one of my major skills and I have Alchemy for a minor. Seven out of my ten skills are Stealth with one Strength skill and two Magic. If one of the three dominates your skills, then vote for that.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 8:48 pm
by Rose of Sithis
I tend to use all three. My character can be sneaky when she needs to, doesn't mind swinging a giant hammer around, and she appreciates being able to heal herself and set people on fire, too.

Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 9:14 pm
by Elune
I think being Combat/Magic or Stealth/Magic is better determined by how much you use spells, not how many major skills you have as magic.
A Warrior who used Restoration spells all the time but nothing else could easily be considered Combat/Magic even if Restoration is the only branch of magic she uses.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 9:31 pm
by LP Gibson
Brainstorm wrote:I think being Combat/Magic or Stealth/Magic is better determined by how much you use spells, not how many major skills you have as magic.
A Warrior who used Restoration spells all the time but nothing else could easily be considered Combat/Magic even if Restoration is the only branch of magic she uses.
In my opinion, to put magic in your "path" it should to be used offensively. Just sayin'..

Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 10:09 pm
by Elune
LP Gibson wrote:Brainstorm wrote:I think being Combat/Magic or Stealth/Magic is better determined by how much you use spells, not how many major skills you have as magic.
A Warrior who used Restoration spells all the time but nothing else could easily be considered Combat/Magic even if Restoration is the only branch of magic she uses.
In my opinion, to put magic in your "path" it should to be used offensively. Just sayin'..

Spells be be just as effective used defensively though. Reflect Damage is a Defensive spell, but you can use it to kill melee attackers (for one example).
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 10:20 pm
by Prophet
BFG wrote:I'm focusing on all three.

Seriously though, methinks the strongest character is able to adapt to any of those types of combat. My character routinely encounters enemies that are immune to magic or are too strong for a full-on confrontation, so being able to switch gears is a necessity.
And yes, focusing on all three is different than not focusing at all!
I have to agree with this one. I use all three skills equally. I don't roleplay as others do, I just always try and make sure my character is competent in everything, that way I am completely flexible. One small example: even though I make an effort to never run out of lockpicks, I still always purchase the strongest available unlock spells just in case.
That said, I chose magic because out of the three classes it is the most versatile.

Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 10:49 pm
by LP Gibson
Brainstorm wrote:LP Gibson wrote:Brainstorm wrote:I think being Combat/Magic or Stealth/Magic is better determined by how much you use spells, not how many major skills you have as magic.
A Warrior who used Restoration spells all the time but nothing else could easily be considered Combat/Magic even if Restoration is the only branch of magic she uses.
In my opinion, to put magic in your "path" it should to be used offensively. Just sayin'..

Spells be be just as effective used defensively though. Reflect Damage is a Defensive spell, but you can use it to kill melee attackers (for one example).
Very true.. but i'm pretty sure the only way to cast reflect damage is from a birthsign, and theres no way to cast a reflect spell. Unless you count potions and scrolls as spells.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 11:51 pm
by Backfire
A problem with hybridization's that, instead of being really good at one technique, you'd be mediocre at a few or all of them. In the former, you can manipulate your strategy to fit your style; in the latter, no matter what you do, there's no distinctly good option.
Also, your attribute multipliers when leveling would theoretically be spread out. So, again, you'd have decently ranked attributes instead of one; two; or three really, really high ones. Think of it like a contest. Would you want to win the gold in one event, or win the bronze in, like, five events?
That's the cumulative effect, where the more is the better. The threshold effect is where, once something's beyond a certain point, its effectiveness stays the same. Attributes are cumulative until you reach 100, then its threshold (they can't be raised anymore, so raising the skills that up the multiplier becomes useless in that regard). It's hard to describe unless I go on a long tirade.
Just focus on one thing and get really, really good at it versus splitting your focus / time / resources on several. Of course, that's one way of playing it. Some situations allow for some people to do really well when they hybridize. Morrowind, being as complex as it is, can really go either way: pure or hybrid. Personally, however, I always recommend not hybridizing a character (in any game / situation, not just Morrowind or Oblivion) because hybridization takes a lot of prior knowledge of the game and a lot of know how of how to do it right.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 4:53 am
by Nucleon
I've got three characters running right now.
My most advanced one, my main one, is stealth/combat, with a hefty doe of magic due to her being high level. I guess that Stealth/Combat is what feels most natural to me.
The least advanced one is more purely stealth, being an archer and all.
But my middle one is the one that satisfies me most to date, and the one that is beginning to break my Stealth addiction; She is Magic/Combat, and with her things seem easier than how they have been with my main one (who trailblazed the game for the two others).
A pure combat character doesn't interest me - too dull. I also tend to play dual or tri-class characters.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 5:12 am
by Backfire
I'd agree about the pure combat build. I can see it being amusing for a little while but when s**t hits the fan, you're going to need something to get you out of a jam, and you can't whack all your problems away. Role-playing-wise, pure combat blows. The Nerevarine's not going to be a knight on steroids.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 7:46 am
by Elune
Backfire wrote:I'd agree about the pure combat build. I can see it being amusing for a little while but when s**t hits the fan, you're going to need something to get you out of a jam, and you can't whack all your problems away.
What, I've never been unable to whack all my problems away.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 8:12 am
by Hunter22
I always always always seem to play a stealth combat guy...
I have tried many different characters but it always comes back to this guy.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 12:38 pm
by KrisCrash
I agree with Brainstorm. Just work on your weapon skills, your endurance and strength, and you CAN whack away your problems.
The weakest pure build is probably Stealth, if they are defenceless in open combat - Magic and Combat types do not suffer this weakness.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 6:17 pm
by Backfire
What, I've never been unable to whack all my problems away.
You
can be if all your problems are
unwhackable!
The weakest pure build is probably Stealth, if they are defenceless in open combat
That's one reason why I use Illusion with my stealth. Blind, Sanctuary, Paralyze, Silence, Sound, etc. They can't hit you. Not to mention that your Agility's high.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 7:17 pm
by KrisCrash
Oblivion doesn't have unwhackable problems, save for oddities like Mehrunes Dagon.
It's a game equally playable with brute force or strategical finesse.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 8:42 pm
by Backfire
I've always wanted to make a brute force character. The problem with a lot of the races when you try to do that, though, is that they get bonuses in, like, three to five weapons, which is a waste considering that you should only work on one, and maybe even two if you can strategically work that out.
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 8:53 pm
by undead182
im combat stealth...ussualy my charecters are stealth with 90% of my combat sneak bow shots and some sword. that charecter im using now is stealth with marksman and blunt...haha i always wanted to try a blunt charecter and I REALLY ENJOY SMACKING PEOPLE WITH BIG HAMMERS
Re: What is your path, Combat, Magic, or Stealth
Posted: Wed Jul 21, 2010 8:58 pm
by Backfire
I've always thought of blunt weapons as one of the worst killing options. I'm talking realistically, not in-game. A sword kills much quicker and effectively-er, and a bow-n-arrow can take your victim out from a distance in one clean shot. A blunt weapon'd take a while; make a lot of noise (due to the screams); and would leave a big, bloody mess. It's just not my thing lol