Page 1 of 1

100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 6:31 pm
by Kwil
Hey I have an accumulated amount of 100% reflect through constant effect items, but some spells are still affecting me. Is this a glitch or is it by design?

Items I'm using:
Robe of drake's pride 25%
Darksun shield 20%
Wraithguard 20%
helm of white graff (sp?) 10%
Marara's ring 20%

And

Custom ring 2%
Custom amulet 2%
custom skirt 1%

or

Dagger of symachus (or something like that) 10%

Both elemental and magicka based spells get through sometimes. I'm not sure what's going on because everything adds up to 100%, unless it behaves like spell absorption which I've read that it's not supposed to. Any help or insight would be appreciated. Thanks!

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 9:16 pm
by dem
I learned something from uesp wiki after you posted. I looked up under spell effects and learned that they must have a reflect of their own. They cast, you reflect it back and then it is reflected it back to you!

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 9:37 pm
by Dean
dem wrote:I learned something from uesp wiki after you posted. I looked up under spell effects and learned that they must have a reflect of their own. They cast, you reflect it back and then it is reflected it back to you!
Not possible, a spell can only be reflected once. So if a casters spell is reflected they will get hurt no matter what.

Also I am not sure what is going on here, I'm guessing you already tried to unequip everything? and have you made sure that you haven't added up the values of your reflect equipment wrongly?

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 10:27 pm
by Venger
dem wrote:They cast, you reflect it back and then it is reflected it back to you!
Drat! I was really looking forward to playing Fire ball tennis with a high level mage. :Angry:

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 10:46 pm
by Dean
Scozzar wrote:Why dont you make an absorb magicka rather than deflect? I think thats a good idea
I'm guessing since he has gone through the trouble to collect the items necessary to gain 100% reflect, absorb is kind of out of the question. Why spend your energy killing if your enemies do it for you? :wink:

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 10:52 pm
by kertaw48
Erm... reflect doesn't stack together...
If you have several CE Reflect items it will calculate each one seperately...
Only the Royal Signet Ring can give you complete Reflect...

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2010 11:02 pm
by dem
http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Morrowind:Reflect

This is where I got the info about it being reflected back. If it is not right we need to correct it. It is the 4th bullet.

edit: OK, I read this more slowly and more carefully. What it said was that if you cast a spell it can be reflected back and your %100 reflect won't help you.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:18 am
by Dean
kertaw48 wrote:Erm... reflect doesn't stack together...
If you have several CE Reflect items it will calculate each one seperately...
Only the Royal Signet Ring can give you complete Reflect...
I did not know this, I always thought everything in the game stacked together. Why would this be any different?

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:28 am
by Vivec's Tears
Uh, from the wiki:
Unlike Spell Absorption, separate instances of reflect are additive. As such, 100% reflect can be created through using multiple items at the same time. Also, this means that more than 100% reflect does not have any extra value.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:30 am
by Dean
Vivec's Tears wrote:Uh, from the wiki:
Unlike Spell Absorption, separate instances of reflect are additive. As such, 100% reflect can be created through using multiple items at the same time. Also, this means that more than 100% reflect does not have any extra value.
Knew it! I thought I smelt something odd and it weren't Scozzar. :lol:

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:37 am
by Vivec's Tears
I think the OP's problem is that the spells that effect him are cast by someone with their own Reflect, and they reflect back to him.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:40 am
by Dean
Vivec's Tears wrote:I think the OP's problem is that the spells that effect him are cast by someone with their own Reflect, and they reflect back to him.
As I said earlier it is not possible, the spell can only be reflected by one creature and after that it can get through anything.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 2:55 am
by Dean
Scozzar wrote:I am so confused :? :? :? :?
Okay look at it this way: If I was to cast a fireball at a scamp and we both had reflect at 100%.

I cast my fireball which hits the scamp,
The Scamps reflect stops the fireball from hurting it,
The reflect spell also turns the fireball into a reflect penetrating missile,
The fireball is then reflected back at me,
I get hit by the fireball and take damage.

That should be easy enough to comprehend.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 4:02 am
by Vivec's Tears
Newsound wrote:
Vivec's Tears wrote:I think the OP's problem is that the spells that effect him are cast by someone with their own Reflect, and they reflect back to him.
As I said earlier it is not possible, the spell can only be reflected by one creature and after that it can get through anything.
I'M SO CONFUSED TOO xD

What I *meant* was that the OP casts at someone who has reflect and they reflect back to him. :lol:

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 4:11 am
by dem
Not to beat a dead horse but in the disscussion section of http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Morrowind:Reflect There is some debate as to if you are vulnerable to an AOE spell that is reflected back but you are too close. i wonder if the author is being hit by that.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 1:12 pm
by Vivec's Tears
A really easy way to solve this would be to
Cast a spell at King Helseth. I'm up for it if no one else is.

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 7:46 pm
by Nucleon
I can relate to this. I had a character that had like 97% spell absorption. Yet, when I face the Crimson Plague lich in the enclosed tomb, about three out of four of its destruction spells affected me. I remember being white with rage after this.

(I still killed the wretched thing, thought :Twisted Evil: )

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2010 10:47 pm
by Kwil
Okay, so let me shed some more light on this. I've tried unequipping all of the enchanted items and putting them back on. No luck. And yes, the values add up to 100%. Uesp even says that reflect functions like resist magicka, where the values add up and are not counted as separate instances like spell absorption, unless that's false.

So when I finally obtained all of those items, I went into dagoth ur thinking I could be totally invulnerable to magic and then I find out that an ash goul's shock spell is only being reflected about 50% or less of the time. Same thing with Dagoth ur: his damage health spell gets through sometimes as well. These are the only enemies I've faced so far with all these items equipped, so that's why I mention them. Oh yeah, I have 100% resist magicka that I tried taking off in case it was interfering, and it didn't do anything.

My only conclusion is that uesp is wrong and that reflect actually behaves like spell absorption. Will anyone with a pc confirm this? Will someone add those items through the console, go to an ash goul or dagoth ur, and see if it works for them? If the 100% reflect works for you then it's probably just the xbox version or my saved game that has this problem.

Also, I have 50% spell absorption in effect all the time (sign of atronach) incase that has anything to do with it... Oh and I don't want to kill helseth. Alright I think I'm done posting, I don't want to waste anymore time with this. But if anyone can confirm anything or debunk uesp's description, that would be good to know. I'll be back to check this from time to time. Thanks again

Re: 100% reflect not working!

Posted: Thu Jul 22, 2010 9:24 pm
by Milder Despues
Also, I have 50% spell absorption in effect all the time (sign of atronach) incase that has anything to do with it...
I think that before the game checks if spells are reflected, it checks if they are absorbed. Which would explain why half the spells get through.

But I also think that if they are not absorbed, the game also tests to se if they are reflected, which puts you back in square 1. And you would probably have noticed that they weren't reflected but absorbed, but maybe worth a double check?