Page 1 of 3

If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 3:09 pm
by animesh1997
If you could change one thing about Oblivion then what would it be

personally I think that the deaths are a bit more realistic as in instead of going back they go towards the way you killed them and a slash or stab mark on where yo hit and blood coming out of the wound

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 4:13 pm
by Sonixboom
ya more realistic deaths...

I would like oblivion to NOT take place inside a cave/dungeon/tower, etc

like 90% of the game is in a cave :|

-Sonix

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 4:22 pm
by Josjie
One major overhaul:

The whole game is set in Middle-Earth instead of Cyrodiil :D. You can explore all of Middle-Earth's key locations: Mordor, the Mines of Moria, the Shire, Rivendell, Minas Tirith, the Grey Havens etc.
You play in first or third person and the Main Quest lets you help the fellowship of the ring in their quest. There are also many sidequests in which you help other important NPC's. The battles in the North (Battle for Middle-Earth 2) are split up in several very long sidequests (you can help the Dwarves and/or Elves). An evil ending is also possible and during the quests there are many choices to be made by the player.

Lord of the Rings: The White Council came close to this idea but was cancelled :(.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 4:43 pm
by animesh1997
Sonixboom wrote:ya more realistic deaths...

I would like oblivion to NOT take place inside a cave/dungeon/tower, etc

like 90% of the game is in a cave :|

-Sonix
excellent point, i mean couldn't there be a bit more to it than cave/mine quests but anyway the good thing on that is definately the loot

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 5:04 pm
by chromalfean
Josjie wrote:One major overhaul:

The whole game is set in Middle-Earth instead of Cyrodiil :D. You can explore all of Middle-Earth's key locations: Mordor, the Mines of Moria, the Shire, Rivendell, Minas Tirith, the Grey Havens etc.
You play in first or third person and the Main Quest lets you help the fellowship of the ring in their quest. There are also many sidequests in which you help other important NPC's. The battles in the North (Battle for Middle-Earth 2) are split up in several very long sidequests (you can help the Dwarves and/or Elves). An evil ending is also possible and during the quests there are many choices to be made by the player.

Lord of the Rings: The White Council came close to this idea but was cancelled :(.
please don't take this the wrong way. not trying to be a smart@$$, but aren't there already several games based on LotR?

I haven't personally played any of them, but how would this end up being any different than the ones already out there?

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 5:08 pm
by Generalno1
chromalfean wrote:
Josjie wrote:One major overhaul:

The whole game is set in Middle-Earth instead of Cyrodiil :D. You can explore all of Middle-Earth's key locations: Mordor, the Mines of Moria, the Shire, Rivendell, Minas Tirith, the Grey Havens etc.
You play in first or third person and the Main Quest lets you help the fellowship of the ring in their quest. There are also many sidequests in which you help other important NPC's. The battles in the North (Battle for Middle-Earth 2) are split up in several very long sidequests (you can help the Dwarves and/or Elves). An evil ending is also possible and during the quests there are many choices to be made by the player.

Lord of the Rings: The White Council came close to this idea but was cancelled :(.
please don't take this the wrong way. not trying to be a smart@$$, but aren't there already several games based on LotR?

I haven't personally played any of them, but how would this end up being any different than the ones already out there?
he means a Lotr role playing game,just as good and expansive as oblivion(right?)

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 5:26 pm
by The Tom
People react more to the fact that the unstoppable armies of Mehrunes Dagon are on their doorstep?

"Well, all our hope rests on an ex-con and the illegitimate son of the emperor, but I don't care. In fact, I think I'll be off to Anvil this weekend - I hear they have a special offer on Mazte."

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 6:57 pm
by Josjie
chromalfean wrote:
Josjie wrote:One major overhaul:

The whole game is set in Middle-Earth instead of Cyrodiil :D. You can explore all of Middle-Earth's key locations: Mordor, the Mines of Moria, the Shire, Rivendell, Minas Tirith, the Grey Havens etc.
You play in first or third person and the Main Quest lets you help the fellowship of the ring in their quest. There are also many sidequests in which you help other important NPC's. The battles in the North (Battle for Middle-Earth 2) are split up in several very long sidequests (you can help the Dwarves and/or Elves). An evil ending is also possible and during the quests there are many choices to be made by the player.

Lord of the Rings: The White Council came close to this idea but was cancelled :(.
please don't take this the wrong way. not trying to be a smart@$$, but aren't there already several games based on LotR?

I haven't personally played any of them, but how would this end up being any different than the ones already out there?
I've played every LOTR available I think ;).

There's the Battle for Middle-Earth series, which are great (real-time strategy), especially BFME2. It's a shame there are no signs of BFME3 :(.

Then there are the official movie games: The Fellowship of the Ring (decent), Two Towers (great) and Return of the King (awesome!! one of the best games ever!!).
But those are action adventures.

Finally there's Lord of the Rings Online, which I don't like at all. The fact that every place is crowded with hundreds of people with nicknames like "EliteDragonSlayer" and "Pwnzer4life" takes away the fun of the game and the unique LOTR setting for me.

So there's no singleplayer RPG game.

More info on the White Council game: [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_White_Council/url]

There's a chance it will be released some day but I don't think that's going to happen :(.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:29 pm
by chromalfean
Josjie wrote: Finally there's Lord of the Rings Online, which I don't like at all. The fact that every place is crowded with hundreds of people with nicknames like "EliteDragonSlayer" and "Pwnzer4life" takes away the fun of the game and the unique LOTR setting for me.

So there's no singleplayer RPG game.
... rofl ... never played any of the LotR titles myself, but I thought there was at least one RPG. kinda dumb that there's not considering that's basically the whole appeal of the story, but ... guess the MMO is what I was thinking of, and after playing WoW for a short time myself, I totally understand what you mean ...

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:13 pm
by azuarc
Oh man, where to start? Oblivion's an awesome game, but it's a proven psychological fact that the more realistic things become, the more people complain about the lack of realism. That probably extends to awesomeness, as well.


* The game isn't 100% scaled to your level. Enemies don't have to be static, but maybe they start at a level of X, and gain the equivalent of half a level when you do. You catch up and pass eventually, so the world doesn't flat-line, but it also doesn't mirror you.
* More present-day development. How is it that every province, including Cyrodiil, has a scant smattering of towns, very few farms, and then a ridiculously massive wilderness in-between? Obviously it *was* once very developed if they have all these abandoned forts all over the place.
* More specific objectives. (In other words, more quests.) It feels like there's a ton of quests when you first start off, but ultimately there aren't THAT many things to do. There should be more quests, and they should be contingent on your progress in the game -- and not strictly in terms of moving up in a guild. The game is wonderful in the sense of giving you freedom to move around, and I appreciate the non-descript dungeons, but I like going into dungeons with a purpose...maybe more locations that aren't subterranean "dungeons?"
* More realistic UI when the PC is behaving erratically (according to societal norms.) I mean, if I pick the lock on your house, and you see me, are you simply going to tell me "I think you should leave" and shrug it off when I go? Moreso, are you going to shrug it off if I run to your second floor instead? And if you chase me out into the street with a knife, do you anticipate the guards will kill you for it?...If you were a notorious bandit and chased someone out of your lair to the outskirts of a town, would you follow them into sight of the guards?
* Weapons and armor should weigh less, and progressively better equipment should not be heavier than starting equipment. I can carry mountains of other stuff on my encumbrance, but heaven help me if I find a pair of valuable two-handed swords. Weapons, especially swords, grossly outweigh what they should compared to other items.
* More random cash items. If I can't carry the weapons and armor to sell, then I'd like to find other things that are meaningful, like Welkynd stones.
* A better spell design system. If I understand how to make light, as I get better with alteration, my light should get better on its own unless I choose not to make it stronger. Rather than "designing" spells for great gobs of cash, and then having old spells clog up your spellbook, you should learn general spell concepts under one tab, and then make quickspells from them that you can easily throw away when they become less meaningful.
* Less difference between a character that begins as a spellcaster and one that doesn't -- a character that doesn't gear itself for magic will never get a good magicka total, but one that does can ultimately do all the same things that the mundane character can, plus cast a barrage of arcana. I remember initially thinking "eh, 50 magic points isn't that big a deal. Why would I take the Mage?"
* Armor that helps against magical effects. Yes, eventually you start getting magical items that have effects like "Resist Fire 20%," but at level 10, I would much rather fight a couple strong warriors than a pair of spellcasters simply because I can fend off the warriors.
* Merchants that sell stuff. I mean yeah, the merchants have a supply of things, but I don't believe I've ever really spent money on anything but Repair Hammers. Their inventory STINKS for adventurers. There is basically never a point where merchants offer expensive items worth buying.
* Enchanted items without charges. I mean, weapons with on-strike effects are cool, but I don't want to mess around with recharging it. I understand if it's a staff, but I have to do the same for an axe? Can I just get a weaker passive effect? We aren't all soul trappers that carry about Azura's Star.
* Spellcasters and magic options outside the mages guild -- they are sorely lacking. There should be actual drawbacks to joining certain factions and a reason to not be in the mages guild...and I should be able to make spells or get enchantments without going through the first 7 MG quests (or getting an add-on that can no longer be downloaded.)
* More cool unique items.
* A bounty system that makes sense. If I kill someone in two blows, I get a bounty. If I hit someone, run away from them into the street, and let the guards kill them, I get a very minor bounty, and I can go back and loot their body. Plus the guards somehow know exactly which items are considered stolen and take those from me.
* Non-specific items should not be regarded as stolen. Maybe for a limited period of time, but after 24 hours, is anyone going to recognize that apple, or even that mortar & pestle? Finding a fence is a nuisance, and is a perk only available to members of the thieves guild. Even other shady merchants won't buy stolen items!
* A leveling system that doesn't overtly punish you for the way you play the game.
* More factions, perhaps even opposing factions like the three houses in Morrowind.
* Cliff racers! (OK, not really.)


Alright, I should stop ranting. I could add tons of little things to this list, and my goal isn't to just complain about the game. Tons of these things are covered by mods. But these are all things I'd like to see in a future ES game. If I could make one change

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 12:18 am
by potato
A leveling system similar to M&M 6-8. Thats pretty much all. There are several other minor flaws, but nothing like the leveling.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 11:28 am
by chromalfean
same here ... the entire leveled/leveling system ... it's broken ... badly ... actually, two things 'cause so is the AI ... "radiant"? really? seems pretty dull ... all my so-called "followers" ... do everything EXCEPT "follow" ... there's a hundred other games out there with better AI and some of them are much older games than oblivion ... what would help most would be able to set levels like in several of the superhero-genre games (Marvel X-Men Legends, Ultimate Alliance, etc.) like "defensive/agressive" modes, if not the ability to actually issue commands like in some of the (much) older Mechwarrior series ("attack my target", "defend", "group", etc.). just a few minor mods, tweaks and improvements such as those would have made a whole world of difference in the feel of the gameplay ...

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 5:25 pm
by JamesF14
I totally agree with Josjie. Thats why I avoid MMORPG's or whatever. People on them just powergame the whole way through and call you a noob because your a beginner. I might cry if TES 5 is a online/computer game :) .

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 6:37 pm
by Josjie
JamesF14 wrote:I totally agree with Josjie. Thats why I avoid MMORPG's or whatever. People on them just powergame the whole way through and call you a noob because your a beginner. I might cry if TES 5 is a online/computer game :) .
Exactly. In single-player RPG's, like Dragon Age Origins, Fallout 3, Morrowind and Oblivion, you are the hero. You can do whatever you want, whenever you want. You can save the whole world.

In a MMORPG all places are crowded with people. The major city has hundreds of players with their nickname floating above their head.

The whole LOTR setting is gone. And Guild Wars and WoW are not very immersive IMO. It's hard to enjoy the story when you know there are millions of players completing the same quest as you.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:39 pm
by cmk420
too many loading screens

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2009 11:49 pm
by Avian
Stealth kills. A trained assassin should be able to sneak up on an unsuspecting person and kill him in one shot without raising an alarm. None of this 6X damage and getting a bounty crap.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 1:44 am
by chromalfean
assassin's creed? ... anybody?

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 4:28 am
by EndfinityJon
I'm really surprised that no one has said anything about character customization.

For me (and I know this doesn't apply to everyone), I think customization is one of the coolest and most immersive things in games. For a game this expansive, time-consuming, and rich, I really am disappointed in the character customization. The amount of races and classes are fine, I wouldn't change a thing. I'm talking more about visual customization; starting with the facial and body sliders. Face it, the sliders for creating your character are very poor. I don't think they're effective, and half the time I have no clue what's being changed. If I'm going to spend 60+ hours with a game, I want to LOVE the way I look, I want to be proud of my character.

Speaking of the look. I'm a VERY disappointed in the amount of base weaponry and armor. There's only a HANDFUL of unique weapon looks in the whole game. The rest of the weapons are either the standard 8 or 9 ranging from Iron to Daedric. Does this not make anyone else upset? Same thing applies with the armor, there's a few different ones for heavy or light, but there's still less than 15 total types of armor. If we could expand the amount of base weapons and armor in the next Elder Scrolls game, I would be overjoyed!

I would also like options for coloring clothing, weapons, and armor. This would be so cool if in loot you could find different color dyes or cloth and you could take these in town to the armorer and get your stuff dyed. If this could happen, imagine the possibilities with unique looks! Everyone would feel unique, my character would look completely different than yours instead of us both wearing generic glass armor and wielding Daedric longswords.

I really hope this is seen by someone at Bethesda and I really hope other people here share my sentiments.

~Jon

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 11:26 am
by chromalfean
guys, please forgive me for saying so, but much of what you're asking for has already been done and provided for you in one form or another. you really should check out some of the available resources. granted, if you play xbox 360 or ps3, you're stuck, but personally, I think I'd prefer a console because of my "purist" attitude and limited computing resources. I don't and won't use mods for any reason, ever. main reason is they are usually fanboy-based and actually end up unbalancing the original game that the designers envisioned, more than they serve to balance it.

I've already posted this in another thread, "but have to admit ... not a big fan of aftermarket mods, mostly because they install what I consider "insanity gear", like the reported one-shot, insta-kill arrow, or "vanity mods" found in OOO", so if "vanity mods" or "insanity-gear" one-shot, insta-kills are what you're after, then you should probably check them out, because they're already out there. OOO reportedly adds dozens, if not hundreds of new armor and weapon types, or else go play assassin's creed or some other such non-sense.

that's not the focus of this rpg, and personally, I think you're missing the point of playing an rpg. you might be a trained assassin, but you're (character is) still a first level n00b. you might successfully sneak up on an opponent, and even backstab, but at first level, #1) you're using cheap gear, #2) in the case of NPCs, you're possibly trying to penetrate armor, #3) being "new" at the game and not a "seasoned veteran" or "old-hand", you might be nervous and flinch or miss a vital spot/target, etc., #4) in the case of creatures, you might not be familiar with their anatomy and have to actually guess where to strike for max. damage, and God forbid you should actually guess wrong.

like the poster in one of the previously mentioned threads, I'm more of a "substance-over-style" type. I'd much rather have a game equal in depth and scope to morrowind. frankly, there was a lot of hype to oblivion, mostly due to beautiful rendering and other audiovisual multimedia performance resulting in a more immersive experience. unfortunately, for me, oblivion might have succeeded in some of those areas, but failed to deliver the "goods".

to me, they sacrificed content resources for performance resources. not a good trade in my book. especially considering I don't get either, playing the game on a bare-bones system at the "low" video setting for any sort of playable experience. think I'd much rather have a console so at least I'd have matching hardware to enjoy what the game does have to offer. played morrowind goty on the xbox and enjoyed it immensly, so I'm about to break down and get myself a 360 for Christmas.

as for game balance? I think the game system is already unbalanced enough as it is, especially considering my low-level mage with his apprentice-level destruction can already pretty much one-shot just about anything up to around level 8 or so, and put most fighters and thieves to shame. if they change anything, they should balance magic more with combat and stealth. fighters (!) should have the magic resistance. not the mages themselves. first, magic shouldn't bypass armor. second, endurance should provide some magic resistance, much like willpower did in morrowind. a key point the devs neglected on oblivion, replacing it with magicka regen, which is fine, but give fighters some kind of defense and edge to use! hence, endurance-based magic resistance.

and stealth, well, that could use some tweaking as well. first, if you're going to use a leveling system, use it to progressively level damage multipliers so a thief can keep up with the combat curve, and provide a few moments of that ever-so-satisfying feeling you get when you actually DO get an insta-kill, not to mention keeping the adrenaline up not actually KNOWING if you can take your target or not! I'd stay glued to the edge of my seat not actually knowing whether I can drop somebody in sneak mode or not, and likewise knowing that if I DON'T, they're likely to turn around and maul my face.

unfortunately, now (and this is the old-timer in me coming out) all these kids want everything just handed to them, which is why we end up here with redundant, stupid questions being asked that can be found and are answered in several resources, like (OMG!) the GAME MANUAL (of all places, never would have thought to look there for an answer to my question!), because it's just easier to get on the forum and ask my stupid question and let the world know how friggin' lazy I am than to actually go read and research my topic, and the marketing guys at these game design companies recognize that fact and cater to it for their parents hard-earned cash, which is why we have things like "in-game tutorials".

so where exactly is the fun in that? no wonder these kids are bored ... and we call it ADHD? I'd prefer and welcome the challenge of knowing that the brute my mage is about to blast might shrug off my spell and proceed to kick the crap out of me, or a stealth-type could be lurking in the shadows sizing up my throat for a garrote neck-tie so I have to use spells like detect life. it would make me think, and keep me thinking about alternates, back-up plans and contingincies. make sure I have a way out if (and when) it all goes south and all hell breaks loose. even better yet (and I've said this before too), have my opponents and enemy spell-casters able to use detect life to find me if I'm running around stealthed (chameleon/invis).

give some actual purpose to a spell AND close up a long-standing loophole and known break in the game system from previous games (morrowind)? omg! what a concept! but please stop pining and whining about how your character looks, or the fact that your "trained" first level n00b assassin can't one-shot everything in the game, especially if (and when) there are mods and other resources available to add those things if that's the sort of play experience you're after and enjoy, but are simply too lazy to go and look for them yourselves, or even other games out there available that cater to what you're looking for in a game. maybe you're just playing the wrong game! so sorry for yet ANOTHER wall of text, but just needed to get that off my chest ...

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 5:43 pm
by azuarc
wow, uh...nice rant there. I'll agree with you a little about the physical character customization since the only time I see my character is when I have the inventory window open. I don't find the game enjoyable to play in third person view, so it's not like I can watch my character. However, for the part of your post that relates things to kids who want things handed to them, I think you were a little overboard.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:08 pm
by Koneira
You think its ADHD? You must be freaking kidding me. For starters you dont have a clue what ADHD, its nothing to do with lazyness or anything alike that. Anyone can be lazy.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:33 pm
by chromalfean
for what it's worth, I see it more as a sign of the times that we live in a culture based on instant gratification. there are very few real challenges left, which is why I like trying to challenge myself through gaming. what surprises me are posts from people struggling with such a simple game to master (which was my first let-down). what frustrates me are posts and questions about armor, weapons and/or skills, etc. that are all covered quickly and easily with a little simple effort and light reading of the game's manual and/or wiki, so yes, this is just laziness. what else would you call it?

edit

don't want this to go off-topic, so let's just leave it there. have plenty of experience with the rest, so if anyone feels the need for further discussion, feel free to PM me.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:41 pm
by Koneira
I would call it.........Lazyness.
Thats what it is. Nothing else. So how about you read what ADHD is before you start calling lazy people it.

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:47 pm
by chromalfean
edit

dude, I have plenty of experience with ADHD and what it is (and isn't). your needle is stuck and you apparently completely misread my post or missed my point, so before you take something I posted out of context and twist it around into something I didn't post so you can bristle with antagonism, take your meds and maybe go back and try rereading it again, eh?

Re: If You Could Change Any One Thing About Oblivion?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 6:49 pm
by Koneira
You called them ADHD which is nonsense. You asked me what else you should call them and i told you lazyness.
I think i understood your post alright.

But yes, lets not go off topic.