Page 1 of 3

Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:13 pm
by Dogmantra
Which games do you think are over-rated and slash or under-rated?

Portal was just a teensy bit over-rated by the friend that persuaded me to buy it. 's my third favourite game, but it didn't blow my mind nearly as much as he (and half the internet) implied it would.

Over-rated: the Warcraft Series (not WoW). They're rather mediocre RTSes, but people go on about them like they're god's gift to gaming, which is complete rubbish, since god's gift to gaming is Morrowind.

Over-rated: Call of Duty. BLEH. Bland, uninspiring, hyper-realistic shooters. Ewwww...

Over-rated: Halo series. Sure, it's fun, but it doesn't deserve the hype.

Over-rated: Fable. I'd love to play the games Peter Molyneux says he'll make. I don't like playing the games he does make. He is personally responsable for making this game over-rated.

Under-rated: Gotcha Force. Second. Best. Game. Ever. I challenge you to find anyone who has ever heard of this game that you know personally. You'll find maybe one or two people. Received pretty bad reviews.

Under-rated: Wind Waker. 'twas better than Ocarina of Time, but people disliked it for some reason. Something about ships?

Under-rated: The Minish Cap. Excellent Zelda Game, and received some of the worst reviews of them all.

Under-rated: Mario Smash Football. I swear, everyone I know (and that includes online!) thinks Mario Strikers Charged is the first installment in the series. Just goes to show how little people hyped this rather excellent game up.

Feel free to completely refute these, and add your own!

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 1:26 pm
by Sonixboom
underrated- myth 2 soulblighter PPL NEED TO GET ON MY TRAIN!!!!

VERY UNDERRATED- Freedomfighters for the original xbox (great game, russian invade america)

overrated- WOW, warcraft, all those other crappy RTS's. most PS3 games

-Sonix

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 1:45 pm
by JamesF14
Over-rated : Treyarch call of duty 5 , Halo , Final Fantasy , Dragon ball

Under-rated : Spartan total warrior

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 3:14 pm
by videogmer314
Underrated: Golden Sun and Golden Sun: The Lost Age. Only one person I know (or used to, at least) had heard of these two games for the GBA before I showed it to him.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 3:22 pm
by Dragour
JamesF14 wrote:Under-rated : Spartan: Total Warrior
Actually no, this game isn't that great, sure I love it myself and the fighting is really fun but the story... there was seriously no thought put into the story at all, I felt ashamed to be a fan after I had passed the game and it seems more like God of War, except instead of fighting a few big enemies, you might heaps of smaller (humansize) enemies.

Overall, the game is fun but the story isn't worth acknowledging.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 3:55 pm
by JamesF14
I wasnt to bothered about the story because it was just a cheap kill-them-up (You can feel the Rome Total War in it)
but with modern games if the stories crap (Haze) i will not buy it because your paying £40 to £60 for it.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:19 pm
by Josjie
Over-rated:
Call of Duty series - unrealistic, linear, too easy, respawning enemies, arcade multiplayer... it's fun for a while but nothing more than that. And COD4/6 do not even look like "modern warfare".
GTA IV - great setting and graphics, very realistic... but San Andreas was more fun. It's a great game but not worth a score of 10 (IGN) IMO.
Empire: Total War - personally I like Medieval II and Rome more. IGN gives E:TW a 9.5 though. I would give it a 9.0.

Under-rated:
Fallout 3: The Pitt - even before I patched my game I never had any trouble with bugs or glitches while many game websites/magazines say The Pitt would've been a lot better if it weren't for the "massive amount of bugs".
Fallout 3: Mothership Zeta - press average of 6.6 and GameCritics.com gives it a 3.5/10! I agree that Mothership Zeta is quite linear and focuses heavily on combat but it's still a great add-on that also lasts beyond Mothership Zeta, thanks to the new perks and items. So a score of 7.5-8 would fit better IMO.
Fallout 3: Operation Anchorage - it's true that you cannot do the simulation again (although you can create a new character or reload a previous save), but the new items (Chinese Stealth Armor, Jingwei's Shocksword, Winterized T-51b Power Armor, Gauss Rifle) are extremely useful items that you'll have in your inventory for the rest of the game. I would even pay $10 just for those items. So calling Operation Anchorage the worsest DLC isn't true IMO and it deserves a 8.
Just Cause - it lacks variety but it's still a great game. I think it's worth more than a 6.8.

I also think Gamespot underrates a lot of games. Half-Life 2 gets a 9.2 for example while it gets a 9.7 on IGN.com (and it deserves a 10 more than GTAIV IMO!!).
Gamespot gives Fallout 3 a 9.0 while IGN gives it a 9.6.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:26 pm
by JamesF14
I agree with your views on GTA IV. The character was crap to. Who wants to play an Eastern European illegal immigrant?

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 7:18 pm
by Josjie
Dogmantra wrote:Over-rated: Halo series. Sure, it's fun, but it doesn't deserve the hype.
Agreed :D. That's why Metroid Prime > Halo.
Sonixboom wrote: overrated- WOW, warcraft, all those other crappy RTS's
Have you even played Warcraft III? Or any of those other games?

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:15 pm
by ace62394
Over-Rated: Console-only games that us PC gamers want :Angry:
Over-Rated: Modern Warfare 2. CoD4 was fun, until you got to level 55. Then you can start all over again, which is the funnest thing evar!
Over-Rated: Halo 2 and 3. Halo 2 is the birth of trash-talking, and Halo 3's strong point is the Forge, but everything else is just silly.
Over-Rated: Too Human. All that advertising for naught.
Over-Rated: The Beatles Rock Band. Only about 40 of the Beatles' 200+ songs. Why? DLC, of course :Angry:

Under-Rated: VALVe games on consoles. Some of the greatest games made, and all but two of my friends have heard of them. :(
Under-Rated: Spore. I find it very fun, even if some review sites call it redundant.
Under-Rated: TES series. Same reason as VALVe games :(

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:32 pm
by Dogmantra
ace62394 wrote:Under-Rated: VALVe games on consoles. Some of the greatest games made, and all but two of my friends have heard of them. :(
They stink. VALVe aren't very good for console support. TF2 hasn't even had any of the class updates!

And I think Half Life 2 is just a tad over-rated. Same as Portal in that it's still a game I really enjoy, but it's not god's gift to gaming.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:48 pm
by Josjie
Dogmantra wrote:
ace62394 wrote:Under-Rated: VALVe games on consoles. Some of the greatest games made, and all but two of my friends have heard of them. :(
They stink. VALVe aren't very good for console support. TF2 hasn't even had any of the class updates!

And I think Half Life 2 is just a tad over-rated. Same as Portal in that it's still a game I really enjoy, but it's not god's gift to gaming.
Half-Life 2 over-rated? It's the best game that has ever been made! It's the only perfect game IMO. I can't think of anything that could've improved Half-Life 2. The soundtrack, the graphics, the setting, the characters, the weapons... it's all perfect! Half-Life 2 was released in 2004 and I still think it's one of the best looking games ever and it has better graphics IMO than games like Timeshift, Gears of War, Call of Duty 4....

It's a first-person shooter but while you can finish COD4 in a few hours, Half-Life 2 actually takes quite a long time to complete. The storyline is amazing, it's impossible not to fall in love with Alyx, Dog is the best robot ever, experimenting with the Gravity Gun is a lot of fun... nothing beats the Ravenholm level, a bunch of zombies and a Gravity Gun :mrgreen:.

Just my opinion of course ;) but I can't wait for Episode Three :D

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:54 pm
by Dogmantra
Josjie wrote:Half-Life 2 over-rated? It's the best game that has ever been made!
Everyone's entitled to an opinion, of course. That doesn't mean it's right.
:P

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:02 pm
by Josjie
Yup that's why I added this line:
Josjie wrote:Just my opinion of course ;) but I can't wait for Episode Three :D

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:08 pm
by r  
Giants - Citizen Kabuto is one of the most underrated games ever, and it's quite old so by now will be abandonware or cost about £1.

It's a vibrant, fast-paced and hugely entertaining action adventure which had so many great ideas in it - being able to play as an enormous monster who could kill things simply by stepping on them or picking them up and throwing them for miles, ballistic weapons that simply required one to aim at where you wanted the projectile to land as opposed to having to worry about such troublesome things as trajectory, base-building in a game of this nature and the easiest way of commanding friendly NPC followers ever - you shoot at something, and they all do too. There's even a few racing segments where you're on some sort of mythical King Canute-style jetski, and the most effective way to win is to use rockets to take out everyone else whilst welding your foot to the throttle and shouting "POWER!" a lot. That's what racing games should be about.

It's also one of the few genuinely funny games I've ever played, most of the main characters being a group of Cockney space marines who shout things like "Oi, pub! Top!". This is my favourite quote:

"Here we are, Blind Man's Volcano"
"Er... Yan... There is no volcano"
"What do you expect? The poor man was blind!"

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:09 pm
by Fiar
ace62394 wrote:Over-Rated: Console-only games that us PC gamers want :Angry:
Under-Rated: TES series. Same reason as VALVe games :(
First one goes both ways, I want Crysis on the 360, and you want whatever game it is on the Xbox/PS3/Wii on the PC.

Second one I disagree with, the TES series is well acknowledged. If anything it is in the middle, so it's actually fine.

To stay on-topic.

Over-rated: Call of Duty:4 is the only one I like, but all tend to take place in WWII and it's gotten real old.

Under-rated: Legend of Dragoon: Game was pretty good on the PS1, I think it's sequel worthy.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:55 pm
by ace62394
FireAcolyte wrote:First one goes both ways, I want Crysis on the 360, and you want whatever game it is on the Xbox/PS3/Wii on the PC.
I want GoW2 and Uncharted 2 on the PC. Also, you may want to watch this video.
FireAcolyte wrote:Second one I disagree with, the TES series is well acknowledged. If anything it is in the middle, so it's actually fine.
Compare the amount of console gamers that have one of the "mainstream" games to the amount of console gamers that have ANY TES game.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:08 pm
by Vivec's Tears
Overrated:

WoW

Fallout

The Sims 2

Underrated:

The Sims 1

Morrowind

Diner Dash ( :shock: :oops: )

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:56 pm
by Kestral
FireAcolyte wrote:
ace62394 wrote:Over-Rated: Console-only games that us PC gamers want :Angry:
Under-Rated: TES series. Same reason as VALVe games :(
First one goes both ways, I want Crysis on the 360, and you want whatever game it is on the Xbox/PS3/Wii on the PC.
You guys can't handle Crysis!

...No really, I don't think even the PS3 can handle Crysis.

Over-Rated:
ODST, Halo 3, CoD WaW

Under-Rated:
JSRF, ES Series, AOM (+TT), AOE (2-3)

The ES series is not widely acknowledged, ask 10 random people in your daily life that aren't friends or family what Oblivion is, if yes, ask what Morrowind is.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:08 pm
by ace62394
Kestral wrote:...No really, I don't think even the PS3 can handle Crysis.
Both the 360 and the PS3 have 256MB of VRAM. This means shorter draw distance, less high-res textures, and not as much overall detail.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:13 pm
by Vivec's Tears
Kestral wrote: AOM (+TT),
Ah, too true. It is definitely underrated. As is Black and White.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 1:34 am
by Fiar
ace62394 wrote:
FireAcolyte wrote:First one goes both ways, I want Crysis on the 360, and you want whatever game it is on the Xbox/PS3/Wii on the PC.
I want GoW2 and Uncharted 2 on the PC. Also, you may want to watch this video.
FireAcolyte wrote:Second one I disagree with, the TES series is well acknowledged. If anything it is in the middle, so it's actually fine.
Compare the amount of console gamers that have one of the "mainstream" games to the amount of console gamers that have ANY TES game.
Very nice video, I take it back then, we are getting Crysis. But you will be getting GoW2, they released Gears 1 to the PC and they will do so with Gears 2.

As for TES, if I were to look at my friends list on the 360, I'm sure more than half would have it. Any gamer I talked to in my school has heard about, or played an Elder Scrolls game.

They are well acknowledged and popular, though who knows, maybe I tend to have friends who know it or play it unknowingly to myself.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 3:43 am
by ace62394
I wish my school was like yours :(

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 5:28 am
by Coulsonji
I read in a 360 magazine that Crysis might be released on the consoles. Obviously the graphics would have to be turned down. A lot.

I LOVE Call of Duty 4! I think it met the hype and more. The Halo series has always had too much hype, but I still enjoy them nonetheless.

Kung fu Chaos for the original xbox was underrated so bad. And Shrek 2 the game.

Re: Over-rated and slash or under-rated games!

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 6:33 am
by Josjie
Vivec's Tears wrote:Overrated:

WoW

Fallout

The Sims 2

Underrated:

The Sims 1

Morrowind

Diner Dash ( :shock: :oops: )
I agree that Morrowind is under-rated. Press average: 8.8 on IGN.com (IGN gives it a 9.4).

But Fallout over-rated? Which Fallout game do you mean?